5. To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Government plans to give local authorities a one-year budget only. (S3F-2654)
Official Report · Chamber
Local Authority Budgets
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 2
- Alex Salmond SNP 2
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
5 contributions5. To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Government plans to give local authorities a one-year budget only. (S3F-2654)
By 18 November, we will submit for parliamentary scrutiny and subsequent approval a balanced budget, as we must, for the Scottish Government as a whole for 2011-12. That will include the total funding allocation for local government and will be accompanied by an explanation of our priorities for future years.
It is clear that in future years the Treasury’s block grant to Scotland will come nowhere close to providing the spending power that is needed to provide vital public services in the way in which they have been provided. As far as possible, we must protect users of services from those cuts in spending. Consequently, we are committed to reform across the Scottish public sector. As members know, recently I announced the establishment of a commission on the future delivery of public services, to be chaired by Campbell Christie, which will provide advice on the options and approaches. We expect the commission to report by next summer. If the present Administration is returned in May 2011, it will be our intention, in the light of the commission’s report, to provide for parliamentary scrutiny in September 2011 detailed spending plans for the years 2012-13 to 2014-15.
It is clear that in future years the Treasury’s block grant to Scotland will come nowhere close to providing the spending power that is needed to provide vital public services in the way in which they have been provided. As far as possible, we must protect users of services from those cuts in spending. Consequently, we are committed to reform across the Scottish public sector. As members know, recently I announced the establishment of a commission on the future delivery of public services, to be chaired by Campbell Christie, which will provide advice on the options and approaches. We expect the commission to report by next summer. If the present Administration is returned in May 2011, it will be our intention, in the light of the commission’s report, to provide for parliamentary scrutiny in September 2011 detailed spending plans for the years 2012-13 to 2014-15.
I thank the First Minister for confirming that that will be the case. Is he aware that today’s edition of The Herald includes a letter from the COSLA president, Councillor Watters, who has written in to express his frustration that the First Minister continues
“to tout the fallacy that”
he
“can deliver a council tax freeze”,
because the fact is that he
“simply can’t and it is outrageous that”
he continues
“to mislead the public.”
Councillor Watters also says that the First Minister was being “disrespectful” to councillors and “ultimately ineffectual”.
Does the First Minister agree that, given the level of cuts that local government faces, offering it a one-year budget is not good enough, especially when he sees fit to make two-year promises on its behalf? Why does his Government continue to refuse to come forward with budgets? Will he come forward with longer funding proposals, or will he persist in riding roughshod over local government and continue to tout his fallacies, his fibs and his falsehoods?
“to tout the fallacy that”
he
“can deliver a council tax freeze”,
because the fact is that he
“simply can’t and it is outrageous that”
he continues
“to mislead the public.”
Councillor Watters also says that the First Minister was being “disrespectful” to councillors and “ultimately ineffectual”.
Does the First Minister agree that, given the level of cuts that local government faces, offering it a one-year budget is not good enough, especially when he sees fit to make two-year promises on its behalf? Why does his Government continue to refuse to come forward with budgets? Will he come forward with longer funding proposals, or will he persist in riding roughshod over local government and continue to tout his fallacies, his fibs and his falsehoods?
I remind Michael McMahon that this Administration has delivered a council tax freeze in Scotland over the past three years, which has resulted in an average saving of £200 for every household in East Lothian, to take an area of Scotland at random.
I know that the Labour Party has not fully decided what its attitude to the council tax freeze is. I draw Michael McMahon’s attention to two developments. On 17 August, the Daily Record, which usually has a reasonable idea of the Labour Party’s approach, stated:
“Labour leader Iain Gray demands end to council tax freeze”.
On the “Politics Show” on 24 October, Iain Gray stated:
“Well, we’ve never been against freezing the council tax.”
Before Michael McMahon tries to evaluate SNP policy, perhaps he should consult and find out which of the schizophrenic Iain Grays will decide on Labour’s approach to the council tax.
Finally, I hope that Michael McMahon has seen the document that is before me, which states on page 22:
“Scottish Labour believes that the fairest approach is to have a basket of taxes.”
There will not just be big increases in council taxes—there will be a basket of taxes. We look forward to hearing the member explain to the people of Scotland the range of that basket case of Labour taxes.
I know that the Labour Party has not fully decided what its attitude to the council tax freeze is. I draw Michael McMahon’s attention to two developments. On 17 August, the Daily Record, which usually has a reasonable idea of the Labour Party’s approach, stated:
“Labour leader Iain Gray demands end to council tax freeze”.
On the “Politics Show” on 24 October, Iain Gray stated:
“Well, we’ve never been against freezing the council tax.”
Before Michael McMahon tries to evaluate SNP policy, perhaps he should consult and find out which of the schizophrenic Iain Grays will decide on Labour’s approach to the council tax.
Finally, I hope that Michael McMahon has seen the document that is before me, which states on page 22:
“Scottish Labour believes that the fairest approach is to have a basket of taxes.”
There will not just be big increases in council taxes—there will be a basket of taxes. We look forward to hearing the member explain to the people of Scotland the range of that basket case of Labour taxes.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
I will wish to study the Official Report of the final part of Mr McMahon’s question. Members should be very careful about how they address one another in the chamber. Words such as “falsehoods” and “fibs” need to be very carefully put in context—as do descriptions of other members as being possibly “schizophrenic”.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Oct 2010 →- Support for Business Debate · 69
- Renewable Energy Debate · 84
- Public Expenditure Reduction Questions · 5
- Inveramsay Bridge Questions · 11
- Carbon Trust (Agricultural Sector) Questions · 4
- Bervie Braes Questions · 6
- “The role of boards” (Audit Scotland Report) Questions · 4
- Broadband Services Questions · 6
- Gourock to Dunoon Ferry Service Tender Questions · 5
- Glasgow City Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Defence Spending Reduction First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Local Authority Budgets First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Obesity and Diabetes First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Gaelic (Adult Learning) Questions · 4
- Scots Language Questions · 4
- Roman Heritage (Economic Benefits) Questions · 6
- Creative Scotland Questions · 4
- Theatre Questions · 8
- Creative Scotland Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Sculpture Workshop Questions · 5
- Museums Questions · 7
- Built Heritage Questions · 4
- Scottish Education Quality and Improvement Agency Questions · 6
- Curriculum for Excellence (Implementation) Questions · 4
- Further Education Colleges (Funding) Questions · 7
- Clackmannanshire Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Newly Qualified Teachers (Employment) Questions · 6
- City of Glasgow College Merger (Engineering) Questions · 4
- Further and Higher Education (Range, Quality and Relevance) Questions · 6
- Carers and Young Carers Strategy Debate · 32
- Strategic Defence and Security Review Statement · 29
- Presiding Officer’s Ruling Procedure · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 17
- Communication Support Needs (Young Offenders) Members’ business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.