Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Emergency departments”

Wednesday 27 October 2010 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 151 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

151 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Item 3 on our agenda is a section 23 report on emergency departments. We have with us Dr Kevin Woods, director general health and chief executive of the national health service in Scotland; Derek Feeley, director of health care policy and strategy with the Scottish Government; and Dr Bill Morrison, who is a consultant in emergency medicine with NHS Tayside. I apologise for any inconvenience caused by the considerable delay in starting this item. We had a useful session with a witness in relation to another item on our agenda.Dr Woods, do you wish to say anything in introduction?

Dr Kevin Woods Scottish Government Director General Health and NHS Scotland
link

I have two or three points. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to contribute to your discussions.I am pleased that the Auditor General’s report highlights high levels of patient satisfaction with emergency care services in Scotland. About 80 per cent of patients rated their care as excellent or very good, which is good news. We are also pleased that the report made positive comments on the performance of the Scottish Ambulance Service and NHS 24, both of which have delivered significant improvements in recent years, as the committee knows. One point that the report makes that we agree with very much is about the need to ensure that all components of the emergency care services work well together. No doubt, we will talk about that later.My final point, which is not covered explicitly in the Audit Scotland report but which is important, is simply that emergency services obviously have to accommodate significant short-term pressures at different times of the year, such as Christmas, new year and Easter, and I believe that in Scotland we have got much better at planning for those occasions. Of course, emergency services, of their nature, must be ready to respond to the unexpected, and health services in Scotland have a good track record on that. The evidence that I cite on that relates to the pandemic challenge that we had last year, when NHS 24 played an important role in ensuring that no undue pressure was put on emergency departments. However, as ever, there is much to do. We welcome the opportunity to tell you about the action that we are taking.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You mentioned several facets of emergency services, including the Scottish Ambulance Service. Recently, there have been a couple of incidents of failures of control rooms, leading to the resilience facility having to kick in. On at least one occasion, calls were handled by a control room in Belfast. Obviously, it is a worry that, on one occasion, all the control rooms went down. I am not sure whether, on the second occasion, all the control rooms went down or just some of them, but there has been more than one incident in which ambulance control rooms have gone down. Clearly, the Scottish Ambulance Service is an important part of the emergency services. What caused that problem and what has been done to ensure that it does not happen again?

Dr Woods
link

The problems were to do with telecommunications systems. The arrangements that you describe are the standard arrangements that apply to ensure continuity of service. The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing gave a full statement to Parliament on the background to the occasion to which you refer. The detail is in that statement. Obviously, the Scottish Ambulance Service has been working with its telecommunications contractors to ensure that any underlying issues are addressed. I am happy to give the committee an update on the action that has been taken.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But it has happened on more than one occasion.

Dr Woods
link

There was another occasion recently, but I would need to check whether it was the same problem or a slightly different one.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I did not suggest that it was the same problem, but control centres for the Scottish Ambulance Service have been down on more than one occasion.

Dr Woods
link

On the second occasion, only one centre was affected.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Good morning, Dr Woods. Perhaps I should congratulate you on your new appointment with the health service in New Zealand.

Dr Woods
link

Thank you.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to ask about increasing demand for the emergency services, and inappropriate attendances. The auditor general’s report shows that there has been a substantial rise in unplanned attendances at emergency departments. It also shows that 9,500 people who called an ambulance and arrived at the emergency department were not treated, presumably because they did not want to wait or they were not that unwell. Inappropriate call-outs are a tremendous drain on resources.Part of the problem might be a level of public ignorance about what is an appropriate level of treatment, or people not accessing out-of-hours general practitioner care, or calling NHS 24 and not getting a response, or waiting a long time for a call back. What is the Scottish Government doing to manage down the number of inappropriate attendances and ensure that there is a proper focus on services that are more relevant to people’s needs?

Dr Woods
link

As you say, the situation is quite complex; many factors are at work. It is important to set a bit of context around the increase in numbers, which is just under 10 per cent over a decade, which is an average of 1 per cent per year. Nonetheless, it is a rising pressure on emergency departments.There are several reasons for the situation. For instance, the population is ageing—we have talked about that many times. People are living longer with long-term conditions, and when some of those conditions are exacerbated people might seek help from the Ambulance Service and emergency departments. Of course, many people self-refer to those services.We are trying to dissect the problems, to understand their components and to design solutions to them. For instance, one of the concerns raised by the ageing of the population is multiple admissions of older people. That is where our work on anticipatory care, risk prediction and advance arrangements is important—we have talked about that at the committee before.More generally, on self-referral, we ran the know who to turn to pilot in Grampian, which was intended to explore how we can provide better information to the public to—Interruption.I am sorry, is there a problem?

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We thought that there was a problem with your microphone, but it is still on.

Dr Woods
link

The pilot was intended to explore how we could communicate more effectively with the public about when to use NHS 24, when to call an ambulance and when to go to the emergency department. From that pilot, we have developed a set of resources that all NHS boards can use, and we have provided them with a small amount of funding for that.Beyond that, we have developed initiatives in the Ambulance Service such as see and treat, where the ambulance will go out to a call but instead of transporting the patient to the hospital the ambulance staff will deal with the complaint there and then, and that will be the end of the encounter. We have been expanding that. Also, within accident and emergency departments, we have increasingly been co-locating primary care out-of-hours services.We have tried to dissect the problem and put in place a range of appropriate responses. Perhaps Dr Morrison would like to say a bit more about his experience in Tayside.11:30

Dr Bill Morrison NHS Tayside
link

The specific problem group that you are talking about—the people who come by ambulance and fail to stay—is a worry. There is also a group of people who self-present and do not stay, although that does not have the same financial implications. It is difficult to come up with a common factor, and I do not think that there is one.The know who to turn to campaign is useful. A lot of people know the messages already, but they can be reinforced, and we in the emergency services—the emergency departments, NHS 24 and the Ambulance Service—need to reinforce them to the public. There has been a tendency in the past to accept such behaviour and not to indicate to individuals that they have used a service inappropriately. We have a terrific responsibility to reinforce the messages. We cannot tell or advise them to behave in a certain way yet, when they do not do that, simply accept it. We do not have to accept it, and there is a big educational message to send out.Of the group that you are talking about, some leave as soon as they find out that the waiting time will be prolonged, some are removed by police, some cause difficulty and some get an element of treatment. I think that if you tracked the figures you would find that quite a number of the individuals get some form of assessment by the triage nurse at the first point of contact, find out how long they are likely to wait and then decide that it is no longer an emergency. If we can have one influence on the issue, it is through education and reinforcing the messages. The financial implications are not small.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Thank you, that is very helpful. Managing public expectations and ensuring that people have the right information are clearly a work in progress.Are you confident that there is enough capacity in minor injury units, GP out-of-hours services and NHS 24 to cope with the demand if we shift people away from inappropriate attendance at emergency departments?

Dr Woods
link

I will comment, and Dr Morrison might then add a bit more.One encouraging thing is the way in which NHS 24 and the Ambulance Service have not only sustained but improved their performance in the face of some increasing demand. They have got very good at matching their staffing and resource availability with peaks in demand, particularly, as I mentioned in my opening comments, at Christmas, new year and Easter. That is important and, to a degree, we can give you reassurance on that point, but it is obviously something that we need to keep under review. I will let Dr Morrison speak more specifically about emergency departments.

Dr Morrison
link

One message that comes across is that attendances are increasing. If all attendance for treatment at an emergency department is legitimate, nobody will complain, but there is a group of people who tend to use emergency departments for primary care purposes. We cannot give them the best primary care—that obviously comes from primary care services—and we need to look at shifting the balance.Is there enough capacity? Yes, I think that there is. Could we improve the way that care is provided? Yes, I think that we could. There have been well-documented problems with NHS 24 since its inception. Things have undoubtedly got better, but the links and communication could be improved. There are times, particularly at the weekends, when individuals turn up at the emergency department saying that they have called NHS 24 and are waiting on a call back. If we scratch below the surface, we sometimes find that they are being a little economical with the truth, but it undoubtedly happens.The capacity exists, but we need to handle it a bit better. I am very keen to discuss and work towards reducing some of the heat on emergency departments in any way we can, and I do not think that my colleagues in primary care or NHS 24 have any difficulty with that. They would be willing to look at how they can accommodate more.Finally, it is a law of nature that the path of least resistance will be followed. If someone can choose between accessing the system through an open door with a guarantee of being seen within four hours or accessing the system by making a phone call, waiting for a call back and then having to go elsewhere for an appointment—perhaps during daytime hours during the week, and perhaps having to phone up for an appointment and being unable to get through—it is clear which path they will follow. A piece of work needs to be done to equalise that access. We have an ever-open door that people come through—sometimes appropriately, sometimes not. Access to primary care, out of hours and within hours, could be improved.

Dr Woods
link

We are about to publish some guidance that has been agreed with the Royal College of General Practitioners on the issue of access that Dr Morrison has described, which we would be happy to share with the committee.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I would like to pursue that point. I take what Dr Morrison says about the path of least resistance, but what efforts have been made to quantify how much of an issue the difficulty in accessing GP out-of-hours services is in relation to accident and emergency departments? Anecdotally, most of us can share experiences of difficulty not just in accessing emergency services but in trying to use out-of-hours services. I wonder whether, because we are making it increasingly difficult for people to access out-of-hours services, more members of the public are doing what Dr Morrison suggests and going to accident and emergency departments because it is easier and sometimes quicker to get a service there. Has that been quantified? What steps have been taken to resolve the issue by reconfiguring out-of-hours services?

Derek Feeley Scottish Government Healthcare Policy and Strategy Directorate
link

We have done some significant survey work, particularly in Glasgow and Lothian, on what drives those behaviours—why people attend accident and emergency departments. The survey has found that the reasons for that are related to people’s perception of the seriousness of their injuries, especially if they think that they might need an X-ray. Their proximity to the accident and emergency department is also a factor, as is people’s perceived convenience—the attractiveness of the four-hour wait limit. There is also an issue around the age profile in that the people who self-refer to A and E tend to be younger. Only the convenience factor relates to your point about the relationship between access to out-of-hours services—and primary care more generally—and people’s tendency to attend A and E departments.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

How significant, in numerical or percentage terms, is the impact on the emergency services of people’s problem in accessing out-of-hours services? In essence, I am asking whether we now make it too difficult for people to access out-of-hours services, with consequences for the emergency services.

Dr Woods
link

The NHS 24 response times are very good—that is the performance point that I am talking about. The point that I think you are pursuing is about onward referral of patients by NHS 24 if the clinical judgment—and it is a clinical judgment—is that the person would benefit either from a telephone conversation with someone in one of the out-of-hours centres or from visiting a centre. We have improved that response but, as Dr Morrison said earlier, although it is quite good in the out-of-hours period, there may be issues about urgent access to general practice services within hours, which is where the guidance that has been agreed with the RCGP becomes important. I think that that is the point that you are pursuing.

Dr Morrison
link

I do not think that it is particularly an out-of-hours problem. The situation may even be better than is imagined. I probably gave the wrong slant on the problem, in that I failed to list the work that I am involved in to sort out the issues. I would not underplay our role in emergency departments. For far too long, we have taken an almost submissive attitude in saying, “Well, you are here.” We have not reinforced education messages, and we have a big role to play in that.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

The work that Derek Feeley referred to, regarding self-referral, showed that proximity and deprivation play a significant part in determining the levels of self-referral. You spoke about the Grampian pilot. Was it targeted? Have any pilots been targeted on areas of deprivation that are in close proximity to an emergency department? If not, would it be worth targeting those areas where there are significantly higher self-referral rates?

Dr Woods
link

I understand that the Grampian pilot was not targeted. It was about trying to demonstrate whether it was a viable approach and it demonstrated that it was. We have provided boards with the materials and the wherewithal, if you like, to judge the best way to use them. If they took the view on the basis of their local data that the focus should be on the areas that you suggested, they have materials that could be tailored to enable them to do just what you described.

Derek Feeley Scottish Government Healthcare Policy and Strategy Directorate
link

I can add that a useful thing that they did in Grampian—and this partially answers your question—was that they used the leaflet to reinforce the messages that Dr Morrison was talking about earlier. If someone attended—you are right that people from relatively deprived areas tend to attend more—they were handed a copy of the leaflet to make sure that they were aware of the situation. There was that subsequent reinforcement.Glasgow is about to kick off their know who to turn to campaign and I am sure that they will use their health news as well as the local newspapers to get the message out.

Dr Morrison
link

Part of the emergency access delivery team work towards target 10 of the health improvement, efficiency, access and treatment targets—or HEAT 10—is to encourage and give guidance to emergency departments on feeding back to general practices. The data collection means that we can now report back to GPs about attendances from their practice area, which gives practices across the board, regardless of deprivation, information on attendance by their patients. If there is overuse or inappropriate use of emergency services, the GPs are in a position to do something about it. That is another example of better communication.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

When you say that you are able to provide those data, do you provide them on request or are they provided as a matter of course?

Dr Morrison
link

We are in transition, but in Tayside we are providing those data automatically to practices with which we have been in discussion and that have requested them. That is being done automatically, and the idea is that it will be rolled out throughout the country.

Dr Woods
link

In the past, we have talked about the integrated resource framework. The provision of such data is part of the dialogue about giving people an overview of the way in which patients are using services and the cost consequences of those decisions.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Page 7 of the report states:“The services provided by each emergency department vary across Scotland and this can be confusing for patients and staff”.In your experience, are staff confused by what services they should be providing? Is there a particular problem with agency staff, who might work for a couple of different health boards? What can we do to tackle the situation if that is the case? Is there any point in standardising the services provided by emergency departments across Scotland?

Dr Woods
link

The point that the Audit Scotland report was making is that, as we have expanded the range of responses to unscheduled care needs with the development of NHS 24, minor injuries units and so on, people might have become uncertain about which route they should take. That takes us back to programmes such as know who to turn to. As you have drawn attention to paragraph 10 on page 7, I assure the committee that there is absolute operational clarity in the Ambulance Service, for example, about where to take individual patients. That is always being updated throughout the day to ensure that people are taken to the right place. There is clarity. The report was making the point that there is now a more varied landscape and the health service needs to respond to that by providing more information, a point that we accept entirely because of what we have been saying.11:45

Bill Kidd SNP Glasgow
link

Dr Morrison spoke earlier about triage. I have worked in the admin or reception areas of hospital accident and emergency departments and I know that triage is an extremely important tool for differentiating between the different levels of illness that people present at A and E departments. The report says—and I know that this is a fact—that“Not all patients are triaged, for example at busy times staff may see and treat patients without triage.”For all that see and treat is also used as a tool, triaging really can ensure a flow of patients under the four-hour waiting time and remove quite a number of the patients who really do not need to be at A and E before they get through to see medical staff.To what degree are hospitals being not only encouraged but made to ensure that triaging is available at all A and Es and, as far as possible, at all times?

Dr Morrison
link

I understand that the situation has changed over the past few years. Triage used to be an absolute given—and it is still very much up there. Then the principle of streaming came along. I was rather confused by that at first. It is triage by another name, but it also means that patients who can be dealt with very quickly by see and treat are put in that category. We used to have the Manchester five triage categories, which were very formal, but there is now some flexibility. However, all patients are seen by a nurse at an early point and allocated a priority. Occasionally that will mean a rapid turnaround and we might have staff who are dealing entirely with see and treat for cases that can be dealt with quickly. We still have a standard that says that, after the patient registers, they should be seen by the nurse as the first point of contact within 10 minutes. That still holds. So, triage is still there. It is a bit of a red herring to say that not everyone goes through it, because everyone goes through the point of first assessment. We have altered the language a little bit, which might be confusing, but the principle is still there.

Bill Kidd SNP Glasgow
link

Is that 10-minute requirement now a standard pattern in hospitals?

Dr Morrison
link

It is not a standard that we have been told to adhere to. Guidelines were put in place, principally by the College of Emergency Medicine, but we are not in a tick-box situation. We monitor to see whether we are reaching the standards, but we do not report on that at the moment.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

The report identifies a number of key areas. The issue that I want to focus on is the appropriate location of accident and emergency departments, which is obviously part of the wider community debate about treatment in Scotland.However, I want first to refer to a point about benchmarking in the briefing that we have received. There is a comment about what quality of care you would receive at an emergency department. The understandable assumption among the public would be that, in extremis, you are presented to an emergency unit that will have a range of skills to address the problem. My hunch is that I am not convinced that that range of skills will always be there, given the European working time directive and the range of clinical experience of staff present at any given time. When I read about how we benchmark, I was concerned about there being disconnection in that regard.What are the historical reasons for where we have emergency units? I remember coming across papers eight years ago when I was involved in the Executive about a pretty dramatic shift—they did not even relate to the units that ended up being contentious in 2006-07—and a significant reduction in emergency units in Scotland. Given that senior professional clinicians were discussing those points—the papers were essentially clinical papers—do those views and concerns about how best to locate such units still exist?

Dr Woods
link

I will kick off and then I will ask Mr Feeley to comment on the locational points that you raise, because the work that was done in the context of the Kerr report, which Mr Feeley supported, is relevant.On quality indicators, benchmarking and other such issues, the Audit Scotland report has been produced before we have the benefit of the work that ISD Scotland has done recently to build an indicator set and before the College of Emergency Medicine, whose Scottish board Dr Morrison chairs, has taken such work further. We are committed to building that range of indicators on quality and so on to complement the four-hour target. That target is an important feature of a quality service, but we want to supplement it with other indicators.I invite Mr Feeley to talk a little about the spectrum of emergency services and their location.

Derek Feeley Scottish Government Healthcare Policy and Strategy Directorate
link

As we have considered the issue over time, we have focused deliberately on the whole range of unscheduled care services, because our belief was and is that considering emergency departments in isolation does not recognise the interdependencies that Dr Woods spoke about. That is why, when we worked on the Kerr report, which has informed thinking ever since, we identified four levels of unscheduled care, from community-provided services such as GP out-of-hours provision all the way through to level 4—the highest level of trauma-type services—which we recognised that only a limited number of places should provide. It is now for boards to take that planning guidance, recognise the range of services and ensure that they have facilities in their communities to provide such services to local populations.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

I remember reading a long time ago the Scottish trauma audit group reports about the primary importance of paramedic intervention. Many of us have personal experiences of reasonable proximity to A and E units, but the reality is that the work that is needed to make someone survive is probably best done by properly qualified paramedics who have the resources to intervene in such extreme cases.Such services were a contentious political issue in 2007 between the previous and the current Administrations. That was a key defining political debate, which is understandable, because the public have a strong attachment to using such facilities in an extreme situation and to the quality of care that is available. However, I have read stuff that says that people do not receive care where they think that they will get it—they will probably receive care in another hospital. How do we reconcile that? It strikes me that there are strong political imperatives on such issues from the public and from statements that have been made in the Parliament. If we have a fixed view and do not have a more open debate, where do we go on the issues?

Dr Woods
link

Mr Feeley described a framework in which such discussions can take place. I will shortly draw in Dr Morrison to say a little about trauma.It is important to differentiate between patient groups. The needs of surgical patients, medical patients and trauma patients might be better served in different places. The framework is intended to enable boards to think their way through that set of issues.You made a good point when you referred to STAG’s work on the role of paramedics. In recent years, the use of paramedics on front-line ambulances has expanded substantially. That is transforming the Ambulance Service from a transport service into an outreach clinical service.That is important, but it prompts me to say that we have a dedicated, publicly funded air ambulance service in Scotland. Scotland is unusual in the United Kingdom in having such a publicly funded service, which we have been developing with our emergency medical retrieval service. It is clear that the notion of fixed locations is important, but the other services that we have put in place are also important components of the ability to move patients to where they can get the best possible care.Dr Morrison will comment specifically on trauma.

Dr Morrison
link

The question is interesting. I imagine myself asking members how we will sort things out, as it is clear that the public want teaching hospitals on their doorsteps, but we will never have that. Therefore, services must be tiered, as has been illustrated. If we started with a blank sheet of paper in Scotland, we certainly would not end up with the distribution of services that we now have. The point is made in the report that the services have evolved over time.We need to accept that some centralisation of services is needed. Other approaches are not affordable and could not be staffed. Let us take trauma as an example. When STAG was first formed many years ago and started to show the deficiencies in trauma care, we had a number of hospitals that were no better than a western film set. Their front doors looked great, but there was nothing behind them. We have moved on, and we now have a system that involves the air ambulance service and local organisations in which patients with severe injuries will be taken to hospitals that can deal with them, but we will never have such hospitals on every street corner. We must accept that we must get the pre-hospital care right and the paramedics trained to a level at which they can look out for the As, Bs and Cs, so that we can get patients to the nearest appropriate facility, which may not always be two miles away.

Dr Woods
link

The general principle is that, where there is a clear evidence base that patients can benefit from a concentration of services, we will concentrate services because we know how important local access is for most services that people want. It is about how things are balanced. The evidence evolves over time, of course. People who have suffered a particular form of heart attack that paramedics can detect at the scene will be taken directly to a hospital at which coronary intervention can take place, rather than to an A and E department just down the road, as there are better outcomes for such patients as a result of concentrating services in that hospital. Dr Morrison may be better placed than I am to comment on that matter. The debate on that has to be balanced.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

The role of paramedics was mentioned. I have seen an imaginative and innovative approach taken in recent years in Renfrewshire. A paramedic on a motorbike has located himself for part of the day near my constituency office. Such an approach is fantastic. The speed of response to an emergency call is critical in some cases and a person on a motorbike who sits waiting for calls to come in can cover quite a wide area. A rapid response can mean the difference between life and death: the motorbike may be able to get to the person in time and they will decide which hospital the person needs to go to. Dr Woods spoke about that. The ambulance service is to be commended on the excellent and imaginative work that it is doing, in which I wish it well.I do not think that we got an answer to Frank McAveety’s question whether clinicians and professionals think that A and E services are properly located and distributed. What are the professionals’ views on that?12:00

Dr Morrison
link

The word “professionals” encompasses a large group, and there will be different views within that group. We have been down this road before with Lanarkshire and Ayrshire. In those cases, even within the clinical groupings, there were differing views about whether there should be closures, centralisation, rationalisation and so on. However, I also accept that, at the moment, the landscape is such that we have what we have and that it will stay like that. I can speak only for myself, but I have an overall view of emergency medicine and I think that we need some further form of centralisation. That view is based on the fact that I am not sure that we can guarantee the services that we would want to be able to deliver to the biggest group of patients unless we can provide senior medical cover on a 24-hour basis. I do not think that there is a possibility of doing that in all the units that we are currently trying to staff. That does not mean that I think that there should be closures; it means that we should try to fine tune the level of service that we have in certain units.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Earlier, you said that there was a need to centralise services because the current situation is unaffordable. However, you have now expanded your view to say that you have concerns about the fact that we cannot guarantee services unless there is 24-hour cover from senior medical people. You are expressing financial worries, but you seem also now to be expressing medical concerns about the current situation.

Dr Morrison
link

I am not sure that we can separate the two. You have all seen the report, which shows that a lot of injuries that come to A and E departments are towards the minor end of the spectrum—although that is a dangerous word to use—but also that some significantly ill and injured people come to A and E departments. We do not know when they will come, but we know that their conditions are no respecters of a 9-to-5 routine. Therefore, it is folly to suggest that we should have consultants present between 9 and 5 but have a junior doctor on duty at 2 in the morning. I have worked shifts during all the time for which I have been a consultant, and I have a firm belief that shifts are the way in which the service should be organised. We need to do that because people get ill and injured at any time. However, at the moment, we do not have the level of senior staff to enable us to do that in every hospital in Scotland that has a full A and E service.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Are you concerned that, as a consequence, the individuals who need the service will not have adequate access to the necessary level of medical expertise?

Dr Morrison
link

In short, yes. We do our best to provide the cover but, sometimes, that cover might not be provided by someone who is as experienced as we would like them to be.

Dr Woods
link

Just to reiterate a point, it is important to differentiate between types of patient in this debate. The evidence base for the benefit in outcome terms will vary according to the type of patient. It is not a simple either/or situation. The area is complex and the evidence base is quite contested. The Government believes strongly that people value timely local access, and that is supported by the report. However, we must not lose sight of the fact that there must also be access to safe and high-quality services that deliver the outcomes that we want for everyone.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

I have a question about trends that relates to what the convener asked about earlier. The number of people who present to A and E has gone up 10 per cent in 10 years to roughly 1,500,000. The table on page 16 of the report suggests that half of the current presentations are for minor illnesses and so on. Was that the position 10 years ago, as far as you know? Is there an increasing trend for minor presentations?

Dr Woods
link

I will defer to Dr Morrison, although I speculate that there has probably been a similar mix over that period.The report says that the number of patients here has gone up by about 10 per cent, as you say. It is reported that the figure has gone up by 43 per cent in England, and we are intrigued by that. One of our objectives is to ensure that people are using A and E departments more appropriately. We want to understand that difference rather better.Dr Morrison is better placed to talk about the long-term trend.

Dr Morrison
link

I do not think that the case mix has changed significantly. I have some issues with the description of up to 50 per cent of patients presenting “minor injury or illness”. That is a dangerous description. Frequently, conditions can be described as minor only in retrospect. Even if something is minor, that does not mean that it is inappropriate for it to be presented at an A and E department. I would prefer to talk about things in terms of need, urgency and emergency. You will find that those departments are more responsive—they have to be responsive according to a timescale that might not apply in other services.I do not think that the case mix has changed too much and I am slightly concerned about the figure that has been cited. We have done some work on this recently in Tayside. We have a system whereby, if somebody turns up in an A and E department with things that they have had for longer than three days, they are highlighted at triage to see whether it would be better to redirect them elsewhere. However, that applies to only 7 per cent of our attendances, so I am not sure how to rationalise a figure of 50 per cent. Cases might be minor, and the total might be 50 per cent, but most of the patients concerned still need to be there.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

According to the table on page 16, the hospital in my constituency, Crosshouse, has about 60 per cent—two thirds—of presentations admitted or referred. I do not know whether that is bad news or good news. Is it bad news in the respect that there are more cases requiring admission being presented at Crosshouse, or are more people using the accident and emergency service more appropriately in my area? It is hard to know which it is.

Dr Morrison
link

I can answer that with some degree of accuracy. Crosshouse operates a system whereby all patients come in through the emergency department. If someone has been seen by a general practitioner and has been referred for admission, for medicine, surgery or whatever, they will touch base in the A and E department, and they will be recorded as an emergency department attendance. In contrast, at Ninewells, if a GP has referred someone, we take the view that the GP knows that patient well, so they should go direct to a bed, rather than waiting on a trolley. Those patients go direct—they do not touch base in the A and E department, and they are not recorded as an emergency department attendance. There is also a default whereby, if the ambulance crew feel that the person needs immediate attention, they will come to A and E.That illustrates the difficulty with comparing different units. We work in different ways, and there could be good local reasons for it. Anyway, that would certainly explain the figures for Crosshouse.

Dr Woods
link

Increasingly, direct admission to medical or surgical beds by GPs is the trend.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

That is helpful to know, as it explains some of the reasons why there are such variations in the data. I am reassured by your response in relation to Crosshouse. Thank you for that.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I am slightly confused about nomenclature. Are “A and E unit” and “emergency department” interchangeable?

Dr Morrison
link

No.

Dr Morrison
link

Emergency departments are A and E departments. During my career, they have been casualty departments and A and E departments, and now they are emergency departments. Do not ask me to explain why they have changed.

Dr Morrison
link

Those three are the same but an AMU—acute medical unit—is not the same as an emergency department. An acute medical unit is the next stage. If you have been seen by a GP who feels that you need to be admitted, or if you have been seen in an emergency department and it is deemed that you need in-patient care, you go to the acute medical unit.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Let us forget about the acute medical unit for a minute. A and E units, as we used to call them, or A and E departments, are now called emergency departments.

Dr Morrison
link

Yes. Sorry—I misheard you.

Dr Morrison
link

The decision was made about three or four years ago by the College of Emergency Medicine. I am not entirely sure that I can explain why, but it brings us more into line with practice in the United States and mainland Europe. It was felt that the word “accident” was not necessary.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Florence Nightingale.

Dr Woods
link

Casualty, I suspect.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Burke and Hare used to deal with it.Dr Woods, when did you become director general of health? I have forgotten.

Dr Woods
link

2005.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Which department were you in when Andy Kerr was the Minister for Health and Community Care?

Dr Woods
link

I was in the same job that I am in now.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

That is what I mean. You were in the same job, so you advised Andy Kerr on the proposed closure of the A and E units at Monklands and Ayr. Is that right?

Dr Woods
link

Since my appointment, I have advised all ministers on a wide variety of issues.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

My understanding is that you advised him to close the units on the basis that, as we heard from Frank McAveety and Dr Morrison, centralisation was necessary to provide the highest level of qualified consultants, but you later advised a new minister to keep them open. How do you reconcile that?

Dr Woods
link

Let me say a couple of things, if I may, convener. There are a number of former ministers on the committee who will know the conventions around what civil servants or public servants will say about the advice that they may have given to ministers at any particular time, but the reconciliation is really quite straightforward, in that I am a civil servant—a public servant—and I am employed to provide the best advice that I can to ministers and to implement and work within the policy framework that ministers adopt. I have no difficulty with that. If ministers come with a policy proposal, my colleagues and I will give them advice, but ministers will make decisions and we will work within the policy framework that is adopted. I do not see any inconsistency in that.

Dr Woods
link

Thank you.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I note what you say about giving advice depending on the policy objective of ministers, but your professional opinion and professional advice on the best configuration of accident and emergency units has stayed consistent.

Dr Woods
link

The point that I am making—I was trying to explain this previously—is that the question of the balance between local access and the concentration of services is quite a complex and vexed one. The evidence base is contested, it is not always clear and it evolves. One has to consider all these issues in the context of ministers’ policy preferences. That is all that I can say.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Absolutely. But—

Dr Woods
link

Perhaps, minister.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But, clearly, new ministers came in post-2007 with a very clear policy objective and I understand absolutely that it is your job to give advice with respect to the policy objective. However, the situation prior to 2007 was that the minister did not have a policy objective as such; the minister was responding to the professional advice that was developing and was being given and was politically trying to ensure that resources were used in a way that reflected the best professional and medical advice. I presume that the professional and medical advice that you gave to the minister prior to 2007, to which the minister responded, stayed consistent post-2007, when you gave advice to the new minister about the best configuration of services, regardless of the political priorities of the minister at that time. Is that the case? That is the question that I am asking you.12:15

Dr Woods
link

The point that needs to be added is that a further step was introduced after 2007, which was the independent scrutiny of board proposals. You will remember that, in the case of Lanarkshire and Ayr, an extensive process was bound up with that. That independent scrutiny shed further light on the evidence base. To that extent, new considerations emerged from the evidence base, which would no doubt have informed the advice that ministers were given and the decisions that they took.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Had you taken steps to get independent scrutiny prior to 2007, the advice that you gave to the minister, to which the minister responded, might have been different.

Dr Woods
link

It might have been, but that is a hypothetical question.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

If such scrutiny was so valuable post-2007, why did you not take steps to obtain it prior to 2007 to help the minister, who was responding to the professional advice that was given to him?

Dr Woods
link

The context for the advice that was given at that time was the Kerr report, to which Mr Feeley referred. When the new Government came into office, it pledged to continue with the services at Ayr and Monklands, and it asked for the independent scrutiny process to be undertaken. As I said, policy and evidence emerge constantly. In 2007, as a result of the independent scrutiny process, further evidence was put on the table that I am not sure was necessarily there in quite the same way prior to 2005, but Mr Feeley could comment—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But we are not talking just about the situation prior to 2005. It still applied in January 2007. Why was that advice and information not given to the minister then? Was it just that you had not thought about it?

Dr Woods
link

No, the point that I am making—within the bounds of the conventions on what we discuss in relation to such matters—is that there was a policy framework and a set of evidence that informed the decisions that were taken at that time. The new Government came in and pledged to introduce a process of independent scrutiny, which produced some further information and evidence, in the light of which new decisions were taken.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We have a situation in which politicians in the incoming Government thought that independent evidence would be good. The independent evidence that was obtained was so valuable that it changed the situation, but none of the professionals at a senior level who gave advice to ministers prior to 2007 thought about obtaining such evidence.

Dr Woods
link

I think that it is fair to say that the evidence base was contested prior to 2007.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

No, I am talking about the people who gave advice to the minister. Did you contest that evidence base?

Dr Woods
link

Obviously, we evaluate the evidence and information that are available. That is part of the normal business of government.

Derek Feeley Scottish Government Healthcare Policy and Strategy Directorate
link

If you look back to the Kerr report, you will see that there is a huge amount of uncertainty about the relationship between volume and outcome that drives many of the issues to do with the centralisation and location of services. That was the case then and it is still the case. As Dr Woods has recognised, the position evolves.You will also see that the Kerr report stresses the need to balance the clinical perspective and the public perspective. We had ways of establishing a public perspective in 2005. Independent scrutiny reinforced—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Forgive me, but I am not talking about the controversy and the different arguments, which you say have always existed. I accept that. I am talking about a situation in which, prior to 2007, the minister responded to the advice that officials gave about what was the best framework. He did not come in with a manifesto commitment about how services should be reconfigured but responded to the professional advice to which the two of you were central. You say that, post-2007, with the independent scrutiny, new information came to light that changed that. I am not talking about the controversy and the different views that have existed. I am talking about your views and your advice and how that could have shifted so substantially. Did it shift or has it remained consistent? I am not asking you to tell me what the advice was. I am merely asking you whether your opinion and your advice have remained consistent.

Dr Woods
link

What has remained consistent is that we have sought to give ministers the best advice that we can give with the information that is at our disposal at the particular moment in time. The fact is that that might change, but the consistency comes from giving ministers the best advice that we can with the information that we have.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

What changed, then, between January 2007 and September 2007, in terms of the best information?

Dr Woods
link

I am not sure what the significance of the September date is, unless it coincides—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

By September, the view was that there should be independent scrutiny and new information would eventually come to light, but in January you had a different view. At that time, you were telling the minister that this was the best way to structure emergency services. I am asking you what changed, from your perspective. Leaving the politicians aside, because I am just talking about the professionals, what changed in the intervening months?

Dr Woods
link

I am not sure that we can entirely divorce the politicians from the issue, because the change of Government came with a commitment to introduce independent scrutiny, and it was—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

No, no. I am not talking about that, Dr Woods. I am talking about the advice and whether it remained consistent. Politicians have the right to make such a commitment. I am not contesting that. I am asking you about the advice that was given by key people—by you and Mr Feeley—who were central to policy evolution at the beginning of 2007. I am asking you whether your advice remain consistent, because we clearly came to a different conclusion.

Dr Woods
link

My point, without getting into details of the advice that may have been given to ministers at any particular time, is that we have given, with the information available to us, the best advice that we could give at each and every one of those points.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

What advice became available that was not available before May 2007 and which changed your opinion and your advice?

Dr Woods
link

I think the important point is what information became available that informed ministers’ decisions, and it is all set out in the independent scrutiny panel report. It related to things such as a commentary on the workforce and staffing issues that had been quite a controversial feature of the proposals prior to 2007.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I am not talking about that, Dr Woods. I am talking about the opinion of yourself and Mr Feeley. What information was available to you that changed the advice that you gave? I am not asking about the advice. What information became available?

Dr Woods
link

I am saying that the detail of that—I am having some difficulty remembering all of it because it was some time ago—is in the independent scrutiny panel report, and a lot of it related to commentaries on the workforce issues, which had been a major driver of some of the proposals in both Lanarkshire and Ayrshire. Part of the commentary in the report was on that, so that matter, for instance, would have been part of it. There was also quite a lot in the report on the rather complex question of volume and outcome, which is a debate that continues to be unresolved.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But should not that information have been given to ministers prior to 2007?

Dr Woods
link

Information was given—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Specifically on that?

Dr Woods
link

It is quite difficult to deal with the question in terms of the convention of what was said. I come back to my point that the information that would have been used would have been the best information and advice that was available to us and hence to ministers at that time. That is the consistent position.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Clearly we are not going to get much further with this.

Dr Morrison
link

I think that I might have started all this off. I have a certain interest in this matter in that I was nominated although not selected to be on the independent scrutiny panel, and my memory suggests that the outcome of the panel was that it could find no evidence to support the changes that had previously been proposed. That is not the same as finding evidence to suggest that a different direction should have been taken—and, in saying that, I hold my hands up as one of the specialists and clinicians who might have been involved in giving advice on this matter.I do not think that there is a yes or no to this question. I have given my opinion as to the direction in which things should go, but it would not be too difficult for the committee to go out and find someone with a different opinion. I do not think that there is any precedent or evidence base that suggests that policy needs to go in the direction of either centralisation or localisation alone. It is not that simple.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I accept that 100 per cent and I know that, as the argument progressed, different opinions were expressed. I am simply trying to find out whether the key people who advised ministers on policy—and, indeed, were largely responsible for the evolution of the policy, as it was not in the manifesto—gave consistent advice all the way through the process. Clearly, I am not going to get an answer to that question.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

My understanding from the responses to this section of questions is that the evidence that was not available to the health secretary before 2007 became available from the independent scrutiny panel, which was established by the current health secretary. Was there anything to prevent the previous health secretary from putting in place such a panel to come up with that evidence?

Dr Woods
link

Not in principle.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But the point brings me back to the questions that I have just asked. I commend Nicola Sturgeon on introducing the independent scrutiny panel—fair play to her—but clearly it had not dawned on the people who gave the previous health minister advice that other information existed that could have changed the situation. Either he was given bad advice or your views have not changed and have remained consistent.

Dr Woods
link

The context was that the Kerr report had been produced and ministers had embraced its intentions in a publication entitled “Delivering for Health”. The boards were asked to go away and look not just at A and E but at their whole range of services. They did so and came up with proposals. At that time, there was no independent scrutiny process and, as they are to this day, boards were responsible for analysing and reviewing services and running consultation and engagement events. You will recall that in the heat of these controversies much concern was expressed about the quality of engagement and consultation processes throughout the health service, not just in Ayrshire and Lanarkshire, and as a result independent scrutiny was introduced and the Scottish health council was created to provide an independent commentary on the work that boards carry out. All of that became available after 2007. The quantity and nature of evidence that has been available to the present set of ministers is different from that which was available to previous ministers.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Dr Woods, do you remember who the MP for Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley was at the time?

Dr Woods
link

I believe it was you.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Indeed it was. Do you remember that member’s strong representations to the health minister and the First Minister against the closure of the A and E unit?12:30

Dr Woods
link

It is much to my regret that I do not remember your specific representation, but I am sure that it was clear and to the point.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Indeed. Do you remember that the then health minister—aside from the fact that he told me that the health board, which was full of experts and consultants, had recommended the closure—was advised by his civil servants that it was the right thing to do?

Dr Woods
link

I do not remember that specific conversation. I am not sure that I should comment on a discussion that may have taken place between a minister and a fellow member.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Was Kerr independent? I mean Professor Kerr, not Andy Kerr.

Dr Woods
link

Yes, I believe he was. It is important not to personalise the report: although his name is associated with it, the report was the creation of an extensive process of engagement and dialogue in consultation. Mr Feeley was the secretary to the group that was involved, which contained very able and committed people. I am sure that Professor Kerr was independent and that he dealt with the issue in the most objective way that he could.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Absolutely—I agree. So how do he and his group differ from the independent scrutiny panel?

Dr Woods
link

The process moved on. The Kerr group was considering not the specific proposals but the generality of the policy. The independent scrutiny panel was examining the specific proposals. Kerr was, if you like, a commentary to inform decision making on the specific proposals that the boards had created, which was a rather different context.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

But each was independent. It must be an enviable position to be able to make those recommendations and not have to bear any of the responsibility, as that rests with ministers. You get paid a great deal more than ministers for that privilege.

Dr Woods
link

You have referred to the fact that I will be moving on in the near future. It is not only enviable to be able to occupy a position like this and make a contribution but a real privilege. I have always believed that it is my job to give ministers the very best advice that I can, given the circumstances, the policy framework and the evidence that is available at the time. That is what I believe my colleagues in the Scottish Government do, and we have a strong set of values to ensure that that is the case. I am sure that there are people around this table who have occupied ministerial positions in the Government, and I hope that they recognise that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I have one final question. Are you aware of staff concerns that patients are being moved out of emergency departments or discharged to avoid breaching the four-hour target?

Dr Woods
link

You ask whether we are aware of staff concerns. We are aware of what is in the report with regard to the staff survey. However, we believe that the staff survey should be treated with a degree of caution; I would be happy to give the committee a note on that. It uses a comparatively small sample, and the responses disproportionately represent a group of staff who are not clinically responsible for admissions.The point I really want to get across is that we are very clear that there is no place for what might be called gaming to meet the target. We do not accept that. We believe—Dr Morrison can speak about this more fully than I can—that the decision to admit is a very important clinical decision, and such clinical considerations should come first, because the decision involves the risk assessment of individual patients.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Without going into too much detail because of the time, I think that you are saying that the practice of moving people just to meet the four-hour target is not happening.

Dr Woods
link

I am saying that if it did happen, we would not consider it to be acceptable. Dr Morrison can tell you whether or not it is happening.

Dr Morrison
link

I have no evidence—none whatsoever—that it is happening.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Just to come in on the previous discussion, I feel as though we have drifted slightly—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

If we have drifted, we are not going back.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

I think that is a wee bit unfair, convener. We have spent 45 minutes asking about 20 questions on a matter that is outside the scope of the committee.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I am convening the meeting. We have moved on. You said that we have drifted, so I am not drifting back. I will leave it at that.I thank Dr Woods, Mr Feeley and Dr Morrison for their contributions.I wish you well in your new post, Dr Woods; it is an exciting opportunity for you to move to New Zealand. I thank you not only for giving evidence today but for giving us informed, robust and sometimes extremely persuasive evidence on a number of occasions about some of the issues that affect the health service in Scotland. You have much to be proud of in terms of your personal contribution and the contribution of your colleagues. I wish you well in your new appointment, as I know other members do. Scotland’s loss is New Zealand’s gain.

Dr Woods
link

Thank you very much, convener. It has been a real privilege to occupy this post. Public Audit Committees are not the sort of thing that people say they enjoy, but the exchanges have been free and frank, and I am sure that they will serve me well in New Zealand. I am very grateful for your good wishes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We will now move into private session.12:36 Meeting continued in private until 12:44.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 344
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 151

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.