Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

"The Gathering 2009"

Wednesday 27 October 2010 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 344 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

344 contributions · showing 1–200
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Agenda item 2 is the section 23 report, “The Gathering 2009”. I remind members that the liquidation procedures are still on-going and that the points that we discussed previously about sub judice still apply, so members will have to exercise their discretion on that, as advised by the Presiding Officer.Our witness today is Mr Norman Springford, the former chair of Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd, known as DEMA. Mr Springford, thank you very much for making yourself available to the committee. We are particularly interested to hear your perspective on some of the events that unfolded. Before we ask questions, is there anything that you would like to say to us on the record?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, there is nothing yet. I await questions with interest.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Concern has been expressed about the way in which the matter has developed. I do not know whether you have followed any of the evidence that has been given to the committee so far, but it has emerged in that evidence that there was an expectation on the part of the Scottish Government—officials and ministers—that the City of Edinburgh Council and DEMA would take on liability for the debt.It would also appear that the press release that was issued in the name of the City of Edinburgh Council was written by Government officials and given to the council, which contributed its own comments. After that was issued, the council decided that it could not take over The Gathering 2009 Ltd and that it would not take responsibility for any of the liabilities and for payment to the creditors.As chairman of the organisation that was intended to take on responsibility for all those liabilities, you are a key figure in those events. When did you first become aware that DEMA was emerging as a vehicle for purchasing the company and taking over responsibilities?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

It is a two-part answer. First, about a day before the press release, I received a call from Dave Anderson, the director of economic development at the City of Edinburgh Council. He imparted to me that the council had been approached by the Scottish Government, which had identified DEMA—if I can call it that rather than use its full title—as a suitable vehicle for promoting a future event. As a result, a discussion took place about whether DEMA would be in a position to accept that appointment.It was decided that that was something that Edinburgh should support, given its likely economic benefits to the city. At no time was it suggested that DEMA would be obligated for the payment of any debt that The Gathering 2009 Ltd had incurred. Dave Anderson and I were clear on that point. There was never any mention of that. The only mention was in the press release, of which I received a copy on 14 October.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So you became aware of what was emerging only the day before the press release came out.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

As far as I am aware, it happened reasonably quickly. The approach was possibly made at a late date. As I say, I received a telephone call. I cannot recollect the exact date, but I am pretty certain that it was 13 October.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

And at that point there were no discussions about the council or DEMA taking responsibility for the creditors.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

None at all. The only condition or caveat that was put upon it was that DEMA may need to be aware of the obligations for the running of the future event and would therefore be obligated to produce a business plan, which was clearly in everyone’s interest.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

And, to the best of your recollection, Mr Anderson similarly was of a view that there would be no responsibility for the creditors.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Nothing came up in the conversation, which would indicate to me that Dave Anderson was not aware of it. Otherwise, he would have mentioned it.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

When the press release was issued the following day, what was your reaction when you saw the terms?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I have had the opportunity to look at the notes that I made at the time of the press release. A copy of the press release was sent to me by e-mail at about 20 past 4 on 14 October. I was asked specifically to comment on the comment in the press release that was being attributed to me, and I sent back a response 10 minutes later saying that I was fine with that.However, having read the press release, I must admit that I was surprised that a phrase had been slipped in to the effect that DEMA would accept the creditors’ obligations. That was a surprise, but, given that the press release had been, in effect, raised by the City of Edinburgh Council on behalf of DEMA, my view was that the matter had been agreed prior to my involvement.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So, subsequently, when the City of Edinburgh Council decided not to proceed, it was a further surprise to you that the council seemed to have agreed but had then come to the conclusion that it could not take it on, which was more in line with what you originally thought was being discussed.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

My view was quite clear. DEMA Ltd has a separate legal persona and we had a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the company. My immediate reaction was that DEMA was not in a position to take over those liabilities. How the matter was going to be resolved between the Scottish Government and the City of Edinburgh Council was a matter for themselves. My view, as interim chair at that time, was quite clear, and the other board members were of the same view when I consulted them. We could not assume the responsibility—it would have been illegal for us to do so and we had no funds to do so.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You attempted to speak to other members of DEMA to ascertain their views.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Yes. I did a ring round and spoke to every director bar one, who was on holiday, and the chief executive of DEMA, Kenneth Wardrop, who was on holiday in Morocco. Those were the only two whom I did not consult; the rest were aware of the potential press release and were supportive of the concept of DEMA, although the financial aspects had to be resolved.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You are quite clear that at no point had there been any discussion of DEMA taking on any of the responsibility for the creditors of the company.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Not with me, if I can put it that way. I had no knowledge of that. My position was immediately stated and became a subject of perhaps some annoyance or embarrassment, as I was vehemently opposed to the idea that we could accept those responsibilities.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Who were the officials who supported you in your work at DEMA?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

You will appreciate that DEMA was a public-private sector corporation—quite a laudable one, I might add—and the City of Edinburgh Council had decided to put a majority of the funding into it. The council had seconded a number of employees, the lead being Kenneth Wardrop. In my view, he is currently doing a sterling job within DEMA in promoting this for the city. He was the main official who was seconded from the council, and there was back-up from public relations, marketing and various other employees.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

He was on holiday in Morocco.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

He was in Morocco at the time and was, therefore, I presume, not consulted on the content of the press release.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I presume that, had he been consulted on something so significant as taking on substantial liabilities, he would have spoken to you. As well as Mr Wardrop, was there anyone on the official side who may have been involved in discussions about taking on the debt?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Not at that particular time. We are talking about the immediate time up to the issuing of the press release, and the only people who were likely to have been aware of it in advance were Mr Dave Anderson, probably Councillor Tom Buchanan, who was a director of DEMA, and Greg Ward, the head of economic development at the City of Edinburgh Council. Those are the only ones who I believe would have been involved in the process.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Was Councillor Buchanan one of the people to whom you spoke?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I did not need to, since Mr Anderson reports to Mr Buchanan. It seemed logical that the approach was made through Councillor Tom Buchanan, from the Scottish Government.09:45

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So a public statement was made about a substantial commitment, but neither the chair of DEMA nor the senior officers who support the board members were aware of it. It was clear from the press release from the Scottish Government—which was written by the Scottish Government, but issued on behalf of the City of Edinburgh Council—that there would be a responsibility on DEMA. At that point, what did you do?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I was faced with the difficulty that DEMA was a public-private corporation. It was a separate legal entity, and I was the chair, but—without being too rude about it—the funding was the council’s; it was their ball.My view was that if a decision had been made outwith DEMA that the funding for the history of The Gathering 2009 Ltd would be dealt with, it was not a matter for my attention. My main concern was to ensure that DEMA was not placed in an impossible position, as it would have been if it had accepted those obligations without recompense from someone else.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

If Edinburgh wanted to take on the responsibility, that was a matter for the City of Edinburgh Council, but you were clear that, as chairman of DEMA, there was no way that you would be involved in DEMA taking on any responsibility.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

We could not do so; there were insufficient funds. We would have been happy to make the payments or whatever, but we were in a position in which assurances of funding would be insufficient. I needed written assurances that funding would be provided.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

How did events develop once you became aware of what was happening? Whom did you speak to?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

The press stated that the obligations were being met by DEMA. It then caused some embarrassment when I immediately reported that DEMA could not accept that liability.At that point, we discussed with officials various ways of trying to ensure that the creditors would be paid. I think that everyone at the City of Edinburgh Council was keen to find a way in which the creditors could be paid, as it was only right that they should be paid if possible. Various discussions took place over a number of days—within a fortnight of the press release being issued—to try to ensure that some conclusion could be reached that would allow the creditors to be paid and the company to be taken over or bought over by DEMA.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Good morning, Mr Springford. It might be helpful for the committee if you could explain the constitution and the set-up of DEMA. It is a limited company; I take it that it is, in effect, an arm’s-length wholly owned subsidiary of the council.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

It goes back to the City of Edinburgh Council’s laudable intention that the public and private sectors could co-operate to the benefit of the city. I still strongly believe that to be the case.The council set aside a certain amount of funding: it was circa £1.5 million, and the council contributed 95 per cent or more at that time. A company limited by guarantee—Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd—was set up as a separate legal entity, and six original directors were appointed. That included two from the public sector—Councillor Buchanan and Kenneth Wardrop—and four private sector members, including me.The articles of association allowed the six directors to co-opt two further directors to the board, which was done by 21 October 2009. The articles then allowed the original members—or shareholders, if you want to call them that—to appoint a further four directors to the company.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Who were the members of the company?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

The members of the company were those who had been involved in an initial steering group to discuss DEMA, such as the Edinburgh business assembly and the University of Edinburgh. There were about 10 financial contributors.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You mentioned Mr Wardrop, who was the chief executive. Were there other employees?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, there were no employees. DEMA did not employ anyone. Vacancies were filled by City of Edinburgh Council employees who were seconded to assist the process, because that is what they had been doing prior to the creation of DEMA.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

May we have the names of the four other directors and the two who were subsequently appointed by 20 October?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

From the private sector, there was Alan Johnston, Derek McCulloch, the solicitor in the city, Graham Birse, who is probably known for being with the Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce, and myself. Part of DEMA’s articles was that the council could nominate an official, and Councillor Tom Buchanan was chosen. Kenneth Wardrop was acting chief executive of the company in any event; he was a director. Those were the six.With regard to the two co-opted members, the purpose of DEMA was to integrate the target areas of live, invest, visit, work and study, so the intention was to select directors from those disciplines. George Stonehouse, who is with Napier University, was appointed. Stephen Hillier, from the University of Edinburgh, had just been appointed.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That was helpful. Even though DEMA is wholly owned by the council, because the council provides the funding, it is operationally a separate entity and it takes its own decisions.Was the decision that was taken—or not taken—to take over The Gathering 2009 Ltd’s obligations, or at least to proceed with the event, discussed? Did DEMA hold a board meeting to discuss that?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No. It was discussed after the press release. A board meeting was scheduled for 21 October; by that time there was some furore around the issue, so the item was on the agenda and was discussed at that point. It had not been discussed prior to the press release because, at that point, no one—including me—was aware we were under such an obligation.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Leaving aside the issue of the previous debt, when it was originally proposed that DEMA should proceed with the gathering, that was obviously put to you as the chair, and you consulted other directors by telephone. You got the understanding from them that they were in agreement. Although there was no time to call a formal board meeting, you felt that the gathering was something that DEMA wanted to go on with.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Oh yes; there is no doubt about that. If I were to be asked again, I would still say that the promotion of the gathering within the city would be to the city’s economic benefit. If we had been asked whether DEMA could have run an event, the answer would have been that DEMA is a marketing organisation rather than an events promotion organisation, but we still felt that, given proper funding, the gathering would benefit the city and that DEMA could and should be involved in it.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I return to the press release that was issued. Was there an understanding between DEMA and the council about statements being issued by the council on behalf of DEMA? Did that happen on a previous occasion?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I do not recollect that a press release would be specifically headed, “Issued by the City of Edinburgh Council on behalf of DEMA.” Numerous press articles were written for DEMA but would go out in DEMA’s name, having been done by DEMA’s in-house team, which had marketing and promotion expertise. It was quite customary that whatever event DEMA was trying to promote, it would be dealt with by that in-house team and it would issue a press release.Although I did not think that it was suspicious, I thought that it was unusual that it was specifically stated that the press release would be issued by the City of Edinburgh Council on behalf of DEMA.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Is it fair to say that it would have been improper for the City of Edinburgh Council to issue a press release on DEMA’s behalf without checking whether you were fully happy with its content?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I certainly feel that the council should have consulted DEMA’s chief executive but, as he was off at the time, perhaps that is where the system fell down. I have no idea who originated the press release. I was not asked to comment on it; I was asked merely whether I was happy with the quote that was being attributed to me, and the answer was yes. That was all that I was asked to do. As I said, although DEMA is a legal entity on its own, it has strong ties to the council, so my natural conclusion was that it was not my place to question the press release.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It is clear that you were left in an embarrassing position when you saw the press release as issued.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

As I said, I had no doubt—and the directors’ view was similar—that it would be illegal for us to accept what the press release said. We could not meet £300,000 of liability. As I said, accepting that would be a breach of fiduciary duty. I was placed in a difficult and untenable position, which—unfortunately—it is clear caused the council embarrassment.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You say that you were asked about the quote that was attributed to you and that you were happy with that. Scottish Government officials—some were fairly senior—worked on the press release over several days. They wrote the whole press release and gave it to the council, and an exchange took place between the Scottish Government and the council. Did officials not share with you the full content before the press release was issued?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No. As I said, all that emerged was that, in a phone call on probably 13 October, the first indication was given that DEMA was being invited to the party. I did not see a copy of the press release until 4.20 on 14 October.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So you were unaware until late in the day not only of the emerging discussions about DEMA taking on responsibility—although you were happy for the principle to be considered—but of the press release’s full content, including the significant statement that Scottish Government officials prepared, which said that DEMA would take on the “remaining private sector obligations”.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I will be a bit more specific. At 4.20 on 14 October, I received a copy of the press release that contained a line that said that DEMA would take over the private sector obligations. That was the first indication to me that that scenario was likely. I guess that, at that point, the chief executive would have said, “No—we cannot do this.” As a private sector individual in the midst of a public sector-funded organisation, my view was that something had been done before DEMA’s involvement that allowed that statement to be made.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I accept 100 per cent what you say and the dilemma that you faced, but I will describe the difficulty for us. A press release was produced at a senior level in the Scottish Government and given to the City of Edinburgh Council. They agreed the press release, which was issued. A line, which the press officials wrote, was put in about DEMA taking on the “remaining private sector obligations”. Press officials would not put in that line unless someone agreed and authorised it, so someone, somewhere along the line—in the Scottish Government, the council or both—agreed to something and to putting in that line. However, you were completely unaware of that. That is significant and worrying for an organisation such as DEMA, which could have been left with liabilities that could have had significant repercussions for the reputations of you as a businessman and of the other businesspeople who were involved.10:00

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I want to go back to what Murdo Fraser said. DEMA had only recently been set up when the press release was about to be issued, so it did not have the capital to be able to take on those responsibilities, did it?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

That is correct. It was a fledgling organisation that had funding of around £1.5 million. Most of that was provided by a direct grant or in-kind services such as staffing and various other expenses. The budget that we prepared initially had a £300,000 deficit. It was revised at later board meetings so that there was almost a break-even situation, but that did not include £300,000-worth of liability.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

As the convener said, the press release was issued on 15 October. We know from the letter that we received from the new permanent secretary that two meetings took place on 14 October to discuss it. Were you at either of those meetings?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Not that I am aware of.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

That is not recorded. From the letter, it seems that Scottish Executive officials and people from the City of Edinburgh Council were at the meetings, and I notice that a special adviser was at both. However, no one from DEMA was at them.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I was not aware until now that there was a meeting.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

There were two meetings. Do you find it astonishing that two meetings took place on 14 October to discuss a press release that was going out in your name, but nobody from DEMA was at them?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

As I said, we were doing our best as a private sector organisation, but we accepted that the ball was with the City of Edinburgh Council. I would not say that it was riding roughshod—far from it. It was entirely open in allowing DEMA to carry out its wishes, but the funding was its funding. I was not aware of meetings outwith us, and would not expect to be party to political meetings of that nature.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

We have a copy of the press release. At the top of it are the words:“Issued on behalf of Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance by the City of Edinburgh Council”.It was issued on behalf of the organisation of which you were chair.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I admit that I find that strange—or unusual, not strange. That was not a normal press release.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, I was not. My view was that there must have been some other discussions to which I was not party that allowed The Gathering 2009 Ltd to be taken over by the City of Edinburgh Council and DEMA.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Were you not annoyed that you were not party to discussions that involved the organisation of which you were chair and that were about a press release that said that you were taking on responsibilities that you said that it would be illegal for you to accept?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I am certainly not annoyed.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No. My view is that something could have been agreed between the Scottish Government and the City of Edinburgh Council that allowed DEMA to proceed. As I said, we did not know about the debt and so on; we were merely invited to run a future event that seemed to be for the good of the city and we were honoured to be able to do that.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

But the press release said that DEMA would take on the responsibilities and liability of The Gathering 2009 Ltd.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

It did, but I was quick to announce publicly the following day that DEMA could not do that.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

You have said that and made that clear. That contradicted the press release that was put out in your name.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

It did indeed. That was the difficulty that I was faced with. I could not agree with the press release. My view was that it had been agreed outwith us and that until DEMA had written assurances that funding would be available to meet the obligations, the only stance that my fellow directors and I could take was that we could not accept the liability.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Mr Wardrop, your chief executive, was abroad at the time, so he could not have authorised the press release.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

That is correct.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, I did not.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No. In fact, I have not received a formal copy of the press release.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I received an e-mail of what was proposed, but I have still never seen what actually went out.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Is it possible that Councillor Buchanan might have agreed it on behalf of DEMA?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I cannot answer that. It is possible, but I cannot comment on that, since I was not party to it.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

He had two roles: as a DEMA board member and as chairman of the appropriate committee.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

That is right.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

At any point, did you discuss the issue with Councillor Cardownie, the deputy leader of the council?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Not at all.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Mr Springford, you said that nobody from DEMA authorised the press release. The press release went out on 15 October in the name of DEMA, and you were sent a copy of it the day before. In effect, was that not you authorising it?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No. As I said, the e-mail that I received from a council official said, “Here is the press release that is going out. We ask you to comment on the statement in it that has been attributed to you.” That is all that I was asked to do. I was not asked to approve the press release; I was merely asked whether the comment that was attributed to me was acceptable.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I read the press release. When I responded, I said that there was a technical error in that there was no company called Gathering Ltd—it was The Gathering 2009 Ltd. I corrected that point, but I was not asked to comment on the press release.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

When I get my staff to send out a press release from me, they send it to me before it goes out so that I can check it for accuracy. As you just said, you corrected one technical point in it. There has been reference to this statement being slipped in, but the font size is exactly the same as the rest of the press release when it says that“DEMA will take on The Gathering 2009 Ltd’s remaining private sector obligations”.If you felt able to comment on the name that they were giving to The Gathering 2009 Ltd, why did you not feel able to comment on that statement? The next day, you said publicly that DEMA could not take on those obligations. Why did you not do that the day before the press release went out? Would that not have been a more sensible time to question that statement?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

It would have been if it had been my company. As I said, I was acting as a private sector chair of an organisation that was almost 100 per cent funded by the local authority. My view was that an arrangement had been made that the obligations would be met.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

If you felt that it was your place to state publicly the next day that DEMA could not do it, why was it not your place to say privately the day before that DEMA could not do it? Why were you in a position to make a public statement once the press release had been published, but not the day before?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

The day before I was still under the impression that a deal had been arranged or an agreement had been made and that, although the press release said that DEMA was responsible for the obligations, I would be, I suppose, assured that the funding was in place. As soon as it became clear that the funding would not be in place, I had no option but to say that we could not accept the liabilities. We could have accepted them if somebody had given us funding.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

In a letter to the committee on 22 October, the permanent secretary states:“on 14 October, the Director of Corporate Services at the City of Edinburgh Council spoke by telephone to my predecessor, Sir John Elvidge, to confirm that the Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance would be purchasing The Gathering 2009 Ltd. As Sir John stated when giving evidence to the Committee on 6 October, there ‘was an implicit understanding that whoever bought the company would take on the liabilities’.”Although there was an implicit understanding, there was a glaring statement in the press release that was sent to you the day before it went out that DEMA would take on the remaining private sector obligations of The Gathering 2009 Ltd. That is not implied; it is stated explicitly.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I quite agree.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

And you did not question that; you allowed the press release to go out and then you questioned it.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

As I said, my remit with regard to that e-mail was to comment on the item that had been attributed to me. If it had said, “Please review the press release”, I would have commented, but I felt that it was not my place to do so. The arrangement between the Scottish Government and the City of Edinburgh Council appears to have been to take the gathering forward to a future event. That was my understanding; that was what was put to me on 13 October. DEMA was perfectly happy to take on a future event. I was not aware of what arrangements were being made about the existing debt. I assumed—perhaps that was my error—that the City of Edinburgh Council and the Scottish Government had resolved the matter between them.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

So, when you read the press release that said that DEMA would take on those obligations, as the chairman of DEMA you thought to yourself, “No, we’re not doing that, but I guess that somebody has sorted it out” and it did not occur to you to question it.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, it did not, unfortunately.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Okay. I have one more question; it is connected not with the press release but with your opinion of the loan that was given to enable the gathering 2009 to go ahead. We all accept that more than £8 million was generated for Edinburgh. Given your experience, what would the consequences have been of not having that loan for the gathering?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I cannot comment on the decision made by the Scottish Government to give that loan. If you want a personal opinion, there are umpteen instances of public sector grants that are unlikely to result in a return of those funds. If we take the example of Edinburgh’s hogmanay, no one in their right mind expects the return of the grants that are made to promote the city at hogmanay, but the economic benefits to the city are enormous. Personally, I see nothing wrong in any form of Government giving a handout of that nature if it can be shown that there are substantial economic benefits to be derived from it. I see nothing wrong in the £180,000 being written off in that way.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I return to the press release and the e-mail that you received at 4.20 pm on 15 October. You explained that you read the full press release and you commented on an item that was outside your quote, which I am reading now and which does not refer to The Gathering 2009 Ltd. Your comment was on an issue in the wider press release. You also told us that you read the sentence that says clearly:“DEMA will take on The Gathering 2009 Ltd’s remaining private sector obligations”.You did not miss that.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, I did not miss it.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, I appreciated its significance. The error was that I assumed that the Scottish Government and the City of Edinburgh Council had resolved that funding would be available to DEMA to meet those obligations.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So you saw that sentence in the press release and you decided to let it run and not draw attention to it. In summary, you trusted the council and the Scottish Government on the issue.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Yes, but it was not a commission of trust; it was an acceptance and presumption that the press release would not have been issued unless the matter had been resolved.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, it had not. Hindsight is wonderful, but at the time my assumption was that it had been resolved.10:15

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I am interested in the fact that you do not want to use the word trust, although I can see no other word for it. You relied on the Government and the council to come through with the £300,000. How would you describe that other than as an issue of trust?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

The issue of trust was that the press release would be issued with that point having been resolved.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

It is such a significant point.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

It had not been.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Yes. It is an issue of trust that, surely, the Government and the council would not have issued a press release of that nature unless the matter had been resolved.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

My assumption was that it had been resolved.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

With hindsight, it is clear that it had not.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Within hours, almost. Immediately that the press were on to the statement that we would meet the obligations, we had to say that, unless we could get written assurances that funding would be available to meet those obligations, DEMA would not be in a position to do so.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

At that point, you must have contacted the council or the Government—the council, I presume—to find out whether an agreement had been reached and what lay behind that sentence in the press release.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, I did not. I was responding to the question whether DEMA would meet the obligations.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Yes, but I was asked by the press whether DEMA would meet the obligations and my answer was that DEMA could meet the obligations only if it had the funds to do so, and it did not have those funds.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

At what point did you contact the council? You did not contact the council before issuing a clarification to the press. You must have contacted the council or the Government at some point that day to find out what lay behind the wording of that sentence in that press release.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I had no channels to the Government. I was not aware of any discussion—

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You were not aware that the Government had drafted the press release.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No. Until it came out in press articles recently, I was still not aware that the Government had done that. The press release said that it was issued by the City of Edinburgh Council, and I assumed that the City of Edinburgh Council had produced it.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You must have contacted Mr Anderson, who phoned you on 13 October to put the proposal to you.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No. My recollection is that Greg Ward would probably have been involved. I do not recollect speaking to Dave Anderson on the matter at any time after the press release was issued.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So, when did you speak to Mr Ward and what was the nature of that conversation?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

It is difficult to recollect the timings.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I presume that it was on that day. Was it on 15 October?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I can only say probably—I have no notes of any phone call at that time. Numerous discussions took place over the few days following the issuing of the press release. If you are asking me to be precise, I cannot say with certainty—

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

A number of telephone calls were made within two or three days of the press release being issued.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

When you made those calls, what did you discover?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I discovered that verbal assurances had been given that the funding would be made available either for clearing the obligations or for the subsequent event.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

That the funding would be available.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Verbal assurances by the council that it would make the funding available to DEMA, or was the Scottish Government to be involved?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I believe that the Scottish Government was to be involved.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I believe that discussions took place between Greg Ward and Sir John Elvidge to the effect that the Government would ensure that funding was available to meet the obligations of a future event. No assurances were given that funding would be available to meet the current creditors’ obligations.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You discovered that nobody in the council and nobody in the Scottish Government had authorised or approved any allocation of funding to DEMA that would justify the sentence in the press release on 15 October that said that DEMA would take on the remaining private sector obligations.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

That is correct.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You had been completely stitched up, Mr Springford, had you not?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

The press release is clearly at odds with the circumstances that we faced. The question was whether we had funds available to meet the obligations. The answer was that we did not. Neither did we have any written assurances that funds would be available.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I felt disappointed, and more embarrassed for the city than personally embarrassed.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

But you have already told us that your position was difficult and untenable—you resigned from the post.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I did not necessarily resign because of the position that I was placed in.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I cannot think of a better reason to resign from an organisation than being placed in that position. Can you?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Yes.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You were placed in an untenable position because of—

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I was placed in an untenable position, but I resigned on 6 November, which was post the events. My resignation was part of the events, but it happened post the events.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Are you trying to tell us that the events that happened on 15 October were not a fundamental reason for your resignation on 6 November?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

They were a substantial part of the reason for my resignation, but it was not the—I am trying to be as careful and precise as I can—

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

It was not the funding issue, or the lack of funding, or the position that you effectively described when you asked whether I was stitched up. Was I sufficiently annoyed by that to resign? No, that was not the reason for my resignation.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

The reason for my resignation was that Councillor Tom Buchanan was on the point of issuing a letter on local government paper replacing me as chair. He did not have the authority to do that, because DEMA is a private limited company.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

When that happened, was there an exchange of correspondence, or did you feel that it was a step too far and that you would immediately resign?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

My view was that I did not wish to cause the city any embarrassment. I was in the privileged position of being party to a fair bit of involvement in the city’s affairs and I was privileged to be in the chair.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Was it explained to you why Mr Buchanan was taking those steps and was trying to get rid of you as chair?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No. I received a copy by e-mail of the proposed letter. The e-mail came from Kenneth Wardrop, who said that we had not discussed this at the board meeting, and made a certain number of proposed changes to the letter, but by that time the damage had been done. It was crystal clear to me that I was no longer welcome.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Do you believe that it might well have been because you were failing to go along with the City of Edinburgh Council and Scottish Government deal that the private sector obligations of The Gathering 2009 Ltd would be taken on by DEMA?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I have absolutely no doubt that that had caused embarrassment. Councillor Tom Buchanan is, in my view, a very honourable man. He would not have taken those actions without interference from or the involvement of someone else. I am certain in my own mind that I had embarrassed somebody—whether the Government or the local authority—and I was being replaced, and that was fine.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

But you do not know who that person or those persons are. You can only speculate.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I can, indeed, only speculate.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I will stick with this issue for a minute, Mr Springford. The situation is truly astonishing. An eminent businessperson in the city of Edinburgh took a hard and unpopular decision—some would say that it was a principled decision—that DEMA could not take on liabilities, because it had no money. That decision did not go down well, perhaps with people in Government or perhaps with people in the City of Edinburgh Council, and a matter of weeks afterwards someone who was regarded as making a significant contribution to DEMA found out that a letter was being prepared on the council’s headed paper to say that he was being removed.You regard Councillor Buchanan as an honourable person and you do not think that he made that decision. It would not have been council officials who made that decision, because they could not instruct a councillor to do that, so someone on the political side of the City of Edinburgh Council or someone on the political side of the Scottish Government contacted Councillor Buchanan and there was a discussion, after which Councillor Buchanan prepared a letter that you found out about. You decided that your position was untenable, not only because DEMA could not take on the obligations in question because there was no money, but because someone was saying, in effect, that you were out the door. We can only surmise that it was decided that you were out the door because, as a businessperson, you called it as you should have done, legally and financially, because you thought that DEMA could not take on something when you had no assets behind you.I find it outrageous that something like that should have happened to someone who did the right thing and who was not prepared to compromise themselves, financially or legally. Were you angry when you found out that someone was, to use Nicol Stephen’s phrase, not only well and truly stitching you up, but acting behind your back because you would not play along with whatever game was being played?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

I can merely comment that I think that you are spot on. I received a copy of the letter at about half past 12 and within 50 minutes, I had resigned. Yes, I was annoyed, but although I was annoyed, I did not wish any embarrassment to be caused. If someone had asked me whether I minded stepping aside because I was causing embarrassment, I would have been perfectly happy to do that. As I said, it was a privilege to act as interim chair of DEMA and I did not wish any harm to befall DEMA or the city.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

That is a highly honourable position to take. I just wish that other people had had the best interests of the city of Edinburgh at heart when they came to their conclusions about how the matter should be dealt with. Why they would have wanted to sacrifice someone like you who was making a significant contribution in your own time is truly beyond me.Did you speak to Councillor Buchanan about why he did that?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

The response that came from others was that it was not his intention to replace me immediately. In my view, the letter was crystal clear, but the subsequent response was that the lady who was being invited to become the chair was being invited to do so at a later date—in other words, it was not intended as an immediate invitation—but, in my view, the letter made it quite clear that it was an immediate appointment.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We are talking about quite ruthless behaviour. When you did not play along and said how you read the situation and what you, as a businessperson, believed the legal and financial position to be, that did not go down well. Ruthlessly, steps were taken to have you removed and poor old Councillor Buchanan, for whom you have a high regard, was used by someone else as the vehicle for dispatching you. That is truly astonishing and quite cynical in the extreme.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

First, I commend you for what you have said this morning. It has been a difficult time for you. It has emerged in the course of our discussion that a number of challenges emerged as the situation unravelled, and I think that we should put on record our appreciation of your commitment to the city of Edinburgh. Coming from a Glaswegian, that is an incredible commendation.In your previous experience in the private sector, for example of dealing with emergencies, have you experienced a similar way of handling a situation from the point of view of how information was shared—or, rather, not shared?10:30

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No, I think that I was ill prepared. I might well be a businessperson—in which respect, I would probably argue with the reference to “prominent”—but the fact is that we in business deal with things in a different way from the public sector. If you are asking whether I would have dealt with the situation in a different way had I been a politician like yourself, my answer is probably yes. Things run in different ways. I do not mean to demean your profession when I say that I do things in an open way, and I am not saying that as politicians you are necessarily covert in your actions—Laughter. However, you are not quite as forthright as I might be.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Given our obligation to be transparent in the way we conduct our business, I am interested—and worried—to hear your assessment of how some of this process has been handled.I believe that you have already said that, although you were one of DEMA’s key figures, you were not made aware of key discussions over whether certain obligations and liabilities could be met. Is that correct?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Yes.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

You said earlier that your organisation simply made assumptions that other discussions were taking place out of respect for the public sector’s parameters and the way in which it would debate the issues. I presume that, by that, you mean the dialogue that council officials, Government representatives and the political leadership at council and national level might have been having to try to address the issues. Are you saying that at no time did someone sit you down and say, “Here’s what we intend to do and here’s the exact programme of activity for the next period”?

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

No one did that.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

Well, yes. I am a member of the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants, but you do not need to be someone of that calibre or a financial genius to look at DEMA’s financial situation and work out that we could not afford those obligations and could not pay them without getting into difficulty. Even with the press release that said that DEMA would meet the obligations, my natural assumption was that a deal had been cut beforehand to ensure that DEMA was in a position to do so. After realising very quickly that there were no such assurances, DEMA’s directors were left in the position of saying, “We cannot meet the obligations”. It is as simple as that.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

In a sense, you are saying that you cannot be cavalier about your fiduciary duties.

Norman Springford Former Chair, Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance Ltd
link

That is correct.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

And the concern over whether such obligations could be met would make it impossible for you, as someone with liability, to confirm what was in the press release, whereas other individuals perhaps felt that they could stretch its meaning.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 344
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 151

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.