Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Independence (Debt)

Scottish Executive Question Time Finance and Sustainable Growth

Thursday 9 September 2010 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab The Party Spokesperson on Culture · Glasgow Kelvin
link


5. To ask the Scottish Executive how much debt it estimates that Scotland would inherit if it was to become independent. (S3O-11222)

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth · North Tayside
link
The proportion of the United Kingdom national debt assigned to Scotland under independence would be subject to negotiation, as part of a revised constitutional settlement.

The most recent “Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland” figures confirm that Scotland has run a cumulative budget surplus worth £3.5 billion during the past four years, while the UK has run a deficit worth £72.3 billion. The Scottish Government thinks that any apportionment of UK debt must take into account the historic strength of Scotland’s public finances relative to the UK as a whole.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Party Spokesperson on Culture · Glasgow Kelvin
link
After all the work that was done on the national conversation, why cannot the cabinet secretary name a figure for what the debt would be should the Government enter into negotiations with the UK about an independent Scotland? Does he acknowledge the authenticity of the report of the Centre for Public Policy for Regions, which estimates that a £125 billion debt for Scotland would be the starting point for negotiation?

The Government dumped the referendum and the democratic mandate of the Parliament. Will the cabinet secretary put the facts to the Scottish people and acknowledge that an independent Scotland would have substantial levels of debt and that it would not therefore be in Scotland’s interests to take independence forward?

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth · North Tayside
link
The Labour Party is in no position to talk to me about debt, after what it did to the UK economy and public finances during the past few years. It is more than a little rich of the member to lecture me about debt.

I reiterate the point that I made in my first answer to Pauline McNeill. The proportion of the UK national debt that would be assigned to Scotland under independence would be subject to negotiation. She mentioned the CPPR, which recently forecast that Scotland will be in a stronger fiscal position than the UK in each year between 2008-09 and 2011-12. That puts into context what Pauline McNeill said.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link
The cabinet secretary is aware of the new oil fields that have been found in Scotland, and he will be aware that the Nobel prize winner and former chief economist of the World Bank, Professor Joseph Stiglitz, said that it is “imperative” that an oil fund be established. Can the cabinet secretary give the Parliament details of how such a fund would affect Scotland’s budget?

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth · North Tayside
link
Clearly, the example of creating a long-term investment fund from finite resources is a well-tried approach to creating financial stability and certainty for individual countries. As I am sure Sandra White will be aware, the strength of the position in Norway is generated by its long-term investment fund, from which the Norwegian Government derives an income and which provides capital security for the Norwegian economy into the bargain. Although Norway and Scotland discovered oil at entirely the same time, the approach that Norway took to the development of that resource, which was fundamentally different from the approach taken in the United Kingdom, demonstrates an important lesson on how long-term financial security can be delivered and secured by establishing a long-term investment fund from natural resources such as oil.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link
Has the Scottish Government made any assessment of the percentage of Scottish gross domestic product that an independent Scottish Government would have had to spend on bailing out the Royal Bank of Scotland and HBOS in the same way that the UK Treasury did?

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth · North Tayside
link
Perhaps if Mr Fraser was keeping up with events, he would understand that at various stages over the past 18 months the United Kingdom Government has dramatically reduced the level of provision in its accounts in support of the bank bail-out. As a consequence, the UK Government will undoubtedly be in a position to make a financial return on that investment. That benefit will of course go to the United Kingdom Government. Perhaps if Mr Fraser could abandon the short termism that is so characteristic of his approach to politics and debate, he could take the broad perspective that I take in considering how some of these questions can be addressed.

  1. Independent Budget Review Debate · 167
  2. Forensic Services (Edinburgh) Questions · 8
  3. Public Processions (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  4. Dyslexia and Additional Support Needs (Professional Development) Questions · 4
  5. Ambulance Cover (Rural Communities) Questions · 6
  6. Science Strategy Questions · 4
  7. Fitness Campaigns (Budget Reductions) Questions · 6
  8. Food Waste Questions · 4
  9. Proposed Private Sector Housing Bill Questions · 4
  10. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  11. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  13. Alcohol (Minimum Price) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  14. Mackerel Stocks First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Ferry Services (Northern Isles) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  16. Scottish Enterprise (Meetings) Questions · 10
  17. Glasgow City Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
  18. Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd Questions · 6
  19. Renewables Targets (Wind Generation) Questions · 6
  20. Independence (Debt) Questions · 8
  21. Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Meetings) Questions · 4
  22. Council Tax Freeze Questions · 4
  23. Labour Market Participation Questions · 4
  24. Kintore Station (Reopening) Questions · 6
  25. Road Equivalent Tariff Pilot (Extension) Questions · 9
  26. Opencast Mining Questions · 4
  27. Councils for Voluntary Service (Funding) Questions · 5
  28. Council Tax Freeze Questions · 5
  29. Council Tax Freeze Questions · 4
  30. Midlothian Council (Meetings) Questions · 5
  31. Glasgow City Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
  32. Independent Budget Review Debate · 99
  33. Decision Time Decision time · 1
  34. Edinburgh Airport (Drop-off Charges) Members’ business · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.