4. To ask the First Minister what evidence the Scottish Government considered before deciding on a 45 pence per unit minimum price for alcohol. (S3F-2552)
Official Report · Chamber
Alcohol (Minimum Price)
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Joe FitzPatrick SNP 2
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
- Murdo Fraser Con 1
- Ross Finnie LD 1
The record
10 contributions4. To ask the First Minister what evidence the Scottish Government considered before deciding on a 45 pence per unit minimum price for alcohol. (S3F-2552)
Based on a detailed analysis, we consider that a minimum price of 45p per unit is appropriate. In the first year, we could see 50 fewer deaths, 1,200 fewer hospital admissions, 400 fewer cases of violent crime, 22,900 fewer days’ absence from work, and 1,200 fewer unemployed. The total value of harm reduction for health, crime and employment would be £52 million in the first year and £720 million over 10 years.
It is encouraging that the Opposition parties have finally accepted that pricing intervention has a part to play in reducing consumption and harm. We remain strongly of the view that minimum pricing is the most effective and efficient intervention that we have available.
The Alcohol etc (Scotland) Bill must be considered in its entirety. We are imposing a social responsibility levy, which will require retailers to make a bigger contribution to the cost of the public services that are needed to deal with alcohol abuse. In that light, and given the comprehensive nature of the proposed legislation, I hope that the Parliament will carry the minimum price proposal.
It is encouraging that the Opposition parties have finally accepted that pricing intervention has a part to play in reducing consumption and harm. We remain strongly of the view that minimum pricing is the most effective and efficient intervention that we have available.
The Alcohol etc (Scotland) Bill must be considered in its entirety. We are imposing a social responsibility levy, which will require retailers to make a bigger contribution to the cost of the public services that are needed to deal with alcohol abuse. In that light, and given the comprehensive nature of the proposed legislation, I hope that the Parliament will carry the minimum price proposal.
The First Minister might be interested in the initial analysis that the Scottish Parliament information centre carried out into the submissions that were received by Labour’s commission on alcohol. Of the 80 respondents, 45 were in favour of minimum pricing, 23 did not express a preference and 12—mostly drinks manufacturers—were against the proposal. Only one of the 80 respondents—a drinks company—put forward Labour’s preferred proposal of restricting alcohol sales below the total cost of production, duty and VAT. Given that Labour’s own alcohol commission failed to find support for its proposal, does the First Minister agree that it is time that Labour stopped playing politics with the health of the nation, accepted the overwhelming evidence in favour of minimum pricing and got behind the Scottish Government’s plan?
I am not surprised that a majority of organisations supported minimum pricing. There is a mood swing in Scotland, with a recognition that minimum pricing would be effective. More and more people in Scotland recognise that we must rebalance this country’s relationship with alcohol, and more and more people are prepared to support courageous decisions to do so.
Why did it take so long for the First Minister to name the price? Is he completely comfortable with the fact that a minimum unit price, now named as 45p, will hand a windfall of £140 million to retailers, but nothing to the Exchequer—and that it is unlikely to produce much for health either?
Richard Simpson spent several years—almost—bemoaning the fact that a minimum price had not come forward, and he presented that as a serious problem with regard to his support for the Alcohol etc (Scotland) Bill. Now that a minimum price has come forward, he presents other reasons for not supporting the bill. I have given statistics on what a minimum price of 45p would do. The social responsibility levy, to which I referred in answer to Joe FitzPatrick, partly answers the questions that he put.
If the Parliament had power over taxation, we would have other options, but the Labour Party does not support the Parliament’s having control over excise duties. Therefore, it seems an extraordinarily easy position for Richard Simpson to adopt: he would maybe do something if only the Parliament had the power to do it, but he does not support our getting those powers. That seems a rather dubious and ridiculous position for someone of Richard Simpson’s eminence to support.
If the Parliament had power over taxation, we would have other options, but the Labour Party does not support the Parliament’s having control over excise duties. Therefore, it seems an extraordinarily easy position for Richard Simpson to adopt: he would maybe do something if only the Parliament had the power to do it, but he does not support our getting those powers. That seems a rather dubious and ridiculous position for someone of Richard Simpson’s eminence to support.
link
Notwithstanding Joe FitzPatrick’s claims, does the First Minister not accept that there is no evidence in support of all the extravagant claims for minimum unit pricing, other than the now widely discredited University of Sheffield modelling study that was commissioned by the Scottish Government, which even its own authors accepted in evidence to the Health and Sport Committee had no greater currency, authority or standing than a weather forecast?
Sheffield university has more currency, standing and authority than Murdo Fraser.
Given the need for the minimum price to effect a material change in public health in order to satisfy the requirements of article 36 of the Treaty of Lisbon, can the First Minister explain why his Government appears to have rejected the advice of medical experts, such as Dr Peter Rice of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, who considered the appropriate level to be 50p, and the Faculty of Public Health in Scotland, which expressed a preference for 60p?
In the first year, 50 fewer deaths, 1,200 fewer hospital admissions, 400 fewer cases of violent crime, 20,000 fewer days’ absence from work and 1,200 fewer unemployed seems to me a significant improvement in Scotland’s health and welfare. That is the estimate of the benefits of having a minimum price of 45p per unit.
I find the gymnastics of members of the Opposition parties on the matter quite extraordinary: the Labour Party says that pricing has a role to play but it does not support the proposal for minimum unit pricing; the Conservatives say that the University of Sheffield lacks authority; and the Liberal Democrats would apparently now be attracted to support minimum pricing if only we proposed a higher price. Members can think of all sorts of reasons for not supporting the substantive proposal that is before us, but people who are concerned for the health and welfare of Scotland will back the bill and back minimum pricing.
I find the gymnastics of members of the Opposition parties on the matter quite extraordinary: the Labour Party says that pricing has a role to play but it does not support the proposal for minimum unit pricing; the Conservatives say that the University of Sheffield lacks authority; and the Liberal Democrats would apparently now be attracted to support minimum pricing if only we proposed a higher price. Members can think of all sorts of reasons for not supporting the substantive proposal that is before us, but people who are concerned for the health and welfare of Scotland will back the bill and back minimum pricing.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Sep 2010 →- Independent Budget Review Debate · 167
- Forensic Services (Edinburgh) Questions · 8
- Public Processions (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Dyslexia and Additional Support Needs (Professional Development) Questions · 4
- Ambulance Cover (Rural Communities) Questions · 6
- Science Strategy Questions · 4
- Fitness Campaigns (Budget Reductions) Questions · 6
- Food Waste Questions · 4
- Proposed Private Sector Housing Bill Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Alcohol (Minimum Price) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Mackerel Stocks First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Ferry Services (Northern Isles) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Scottish Enterprise (Meetings) Questions · 10
- Glasgow City Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd Questions · 6
- Renewables Targets (Wind Generation) Questions · 6
- Independence (Debt) Questions · 8
- Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Council Tax Freeze Questions · 4
- Labour Market Participation Questions · 4
- Kintore Station (Reopening) Questions · 6
- Road Equivalent Tariff Pilot (Extension) Questions · 9
- Opencast Mining Questions · 4
- Councils for Voluntary Service (Funding) Questions · 5
- Council Tax Freeze Questions · 5
- Council Tax Freeze Questions · 4
- Midlothian Council (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Glasgow City Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Independent Budget Review Debate · 99
- Decision Time Decision time · 1
- Edinburgh Airport (Drop-off Charges) Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.