Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“The role of boards”

Wednesday 6 October 2010 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Committee business 17 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I apologise to the Auditor General and his staff because item 3 has been somewhat delayed and we are now a bit pressed for time. I invite Mr Black to make his contribution to the meeting.

Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland
link

The report was laid last week. There were three reasons why I thought that it might be useful to do a report on the role of boards in Scottish public life. First, the committee’s strong interest in the area has come through during inquiries into public bodies over several years, when weaknesses in governance have led to problems. Secondly, many of the bodies discussed have existed since well before devolution. Given the role that they play in Scottish public life, it seems appropriate to provide an overview of how they are operating. Thirdly, and quite significantly, during the past 10 years, those bodies, along with the rest of the public sector, have enjoyed a period of significant spending growth. With the predictions that the budget will be more than £4 billion smaller by 2014-15, there will undoubtedly be risks, so it is important to ensure that the accountabilities in public bodies are clear, and that boards are able to manage and plan for the difficult times that lie ahead.12:15

As committee members are well aware, there is a range of bodies, and the report looks at more than 100 of them. They provide a range of functions, including health, further education, and the protection of the environment. They spend approximately half of the public sector budget each year; £17 billion in 2008-09. Most of those bodies are governed by boards that are in place to ensure good corporate governance. The boards’ role is to provide leadership and strategic direction. Of course, local government bodies are rather different. They have different accountability, so the report does not cover them.Colleagues in Audit Scotland undertook a comprehensive audit. We had a good response to a survey of all 1,500 board members. There were interviews with around 70 non-executives, and visits were made to a sample of organisations. We therefore think that we have a good information base for the report.I would like to highlight briefly some of the issues that came out of the report, specifically about the complexity of the accountability arrangements that we see in Scotland, about the skills and expertise of board members, and about the way in which the boards operate in practice.As we know, the Scottish Government is making progress with its public sector reform agenda, but the report confirms that the landscape is complex and likely to remain so. Six types of public body are included in the review, and all have their own arrangements for accountability to the Scottish ministers and the Scottish Parliament. I will give a few examples. Non-departmental public body boards are accountable to the Scottish ministers, but the chief executives are accountable to the Parliament. The boards of colleges are accountable to neither the Scottish ministers nor the Parliament. The boards of executive agencies are appointed to advise the chief executives and have limited scrutiny responsibilities. Some non-executives on those boards are not entirely clear about the role that they are expected to fulfil.The parallel lines of accountability of chief executives and their boards might cause some confusion about who leads the organisation, unless the separate roles are clearly defined and understood. Chief executives have delegated responsibility as accountable officers for the proper use of resources and they are accountable to the Scottish Parliament. In most cases, the boards are responsible for the performance of their organisation and for ensuring that it delivers the policies and priorities of the Scottish ministers.Boards will clearly be central to the way in which public bodies meet the financial challenges that lie ahead. They will be faced with difficult decisions about funding priorities and they will have to have strong leadership and ensure that good governance is in place during a period of financial uncertainty.It is important that the relationships between the Scottish Government and public bodies are clear, so that there is a shared understanding of priorities. It is also important that relationships with the Parliament are clear. We have found that those relationships are not always absolutely clear. National health service bodies have a close relationship with the Scottish Government and the Scottish ministers, and there is consistency in the way in which those relationships work. For NDPBs, the relationships with the Scottish Government are managed by civil servants and the term of art that is used is “sponsors”. However, such arrangements differ across the sector, and they tend to involve senior management in the bodies concerned, not the boards.The relationship between colleges and the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council is also not entirely clear. Scottish boards are not directly accountable to the Scottish ministers or the funding council. College principals are not statutory accountable officers, but they can be held to account by this committee through the reports that I produce. They are also accountable to the funding council for the public funds that they receive.The second major heading that I want to touch on is the skills and expertise of board members. I suggest that the important factors that make for a strong and successful board can be broken down into three headings, the first of which is the calibre and personalities of the chair and individual board members. Second is the question whether the board has the right combination of skills and experience available to it, and third is the way in which the board members work together as a team.We found that boards are working hard to ensure that they have round the table the right combination of skills and expertise. For example, some boards are using a sort of mapping of skills and experience of current members against those that they think that their board should have. The Scottish ministers appoint most non-executives, with college boards being the main exception to that. In other words, the public appointments process applies to most non-executive appointments, but college boards operate their own system.The process is improving, but there are still weaknesses, particularly around the length of time that it can take to make an appointment and how the range of skills and qualities that need to be acquired to be an effective non-executive are identified. Despite improvements in the process, fewer people are applying to become non-executives. Since 2004-05, the number of applications has gone down by half. Some progress is being made to increase the range and diversity of people who apply for non-executive posts, but further work remains to be done, particular in identifying and being explicit about the core skills, knowledge and personal qualities that a non-executive needs to be effective.Another interesting finding was on the variation in the time commitment that is required of non-executives. We are not entirely clear why that is the case. For example, NHS chairs are expected to commit nearly twice the amount of time that is expected of NDPB chairs. About 80 per cent of non-executives told us that they had received some form of induction, but not all chairs or chief executives receive opportunities for training or have their performance assessed. Also, not all of them were given a formal induction process—again, there is quite a variation.My final heading is on the way in which public sector boards operate. As I think I mentioned, the Audit Scotland team visited 17 public bodies—a representative sample of the sector—to look at how they operate and the extent to which they provide leadership and scrutinise the organisation’s risks, financial management and performance. Clearly, one key factor in determining whether leadership is effective is the relationship between the chief executive and chair of the board, both of whom have important, but different, roles to play. “On Board”, the relevant Scottish Government guidance, is a useful basic primer for the governance role, albeit that it could be clearer on the dual responsibility for leadership between the chair and chief executive and how it is exercised.One general finding was that board scrutiny of risk, financial management and performance could be improved. That finding applies to a number of organisations. As public bodies start to operate with fewer resources, this scrutiny will be of particular importance. Also, with less money around, risks will increase and organisations will have to be safeguarded.We found that the scrutiny of risk was largely designated to audit committees. In some cases, risks were not reported to the board. Although it is appropriate for audit committees to have that role, it is also important that all boards should receive clear summaries of the organisation’s financial position. That is not always the case. A summary of the forecast outturn position for the financial year should be made to the board, with commentary and assessment of any risks that may affect the organisation’s position, but such summaries are not always given to the full board. Board papers and performance are quite good in all the boards that we visited. All 17 boards are making serious efforts to improve the quality of the information.Boards generally operate pretty well, but there is some room for improvement. Some boards are more open than others. We found that only around two fifths hold meetings that are open to the public. In some boards that we visited, it was not always the case that members were asked to declare their interests at board meetings where it might be appropriate to do that in terms of the business on the agenda. Also, not all boards review regularly the way in which they operate.The size of boards is an interesting issue. As the committee will see from the report, the range is quite wide—from four to 32 members. Also, NDPB boards have an average of 12 members with NHS bodies having an average of 18. Obviously, one developing issue is the increase in elected board members; examples of boards with elected members are the national park authorities, the crofting commission and two health boards—NHS Fife and NHS Dumfries and Galloway. While we understand and acknowledge the policy initiative, it is important that people who are so elected should recognise that their first duty is always to the board and its interests and not to any other interests that they may have in the community.One issue that is of significance as we look to the future of good governance in these difficult financial times is that not all chief executives are members of their boards. In about a third of NDPBs, the accountable officers are not board members. I have picked up in my conversations that there are different views on whether chief executives should be members of boards, but my clear view is that they should be. After all, they are personally accountable to the Parliament for the proper and efficient use of public funds and therefore they should be able to participate fully as board members. Provided that there is an overall majority of non-executives, there should be good governance, and the arrangements should help to make the organisation resilient through challenges, because everybody takes ownership together and speaks fully and openly about what lies ahead for their boards.Ultimately, whatever the make-up, it is important that boards exercise collective responsibility for the decisions that they make. I am pleased to say that, in the boards that Audit Scotland visited, collective responsibility for decisions was demonstrated, even when there had been strong differences of opinion during the discussion that led up to that decision.As ever, I am happy to answer questions, and I am heavily reliant on my team that did the work.

Bill Kidd SNP Glasgow
link

We have a sort of byzantine situation, with so many boards and different numbers of members, whether executive or non-executive. That situation has obviously grown up over many years. Is it true to say that, because of the different circumstances under which each board operates as a result of different responsibilities, standardisation would not be practical?

Mr Black
link

That is an issue on which the report probably raises more questions than it answers. As I said, the system has been built up over many years and goes way back before devolution. It is not immediately clear to us why there is such diversity and difference in the public sector. I do not want to repeat what I said a moment ago but, for example, why should some chief executives and not others be on boards, or why should there be such variation in the size of boards and in how they operate? Colleges, which are governed by different statutes from those that govern other public bodies, are interesting because there is no direct accountability to the Parliament for the spending of further education money—that comes through the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council.Basically, boards fall into two types. There are those with overall responsibility for the performance of their organisations—health boards are a good example—and those that in essence have an advisory capacity. We can see a distinction between those two types but, given that all boards have the core responsibility of the non-executives to oversee the governance of the organisation, to manage performance and financial stewardship and to set the strategy of the organisation, it is at the very least interesting to note that there is such diversity, which has been built up over time.

Bill Kidd SNP Glasgow
link

I had a quick flick through the report when you were speaking, just to remind myself about the range of boards. NHS Tayside, which has 27 or so directors, is juxtaposed with Scottish Enterprise, which has 12. I cannot remember what page the exhibit that contains that information is on. That shows that the range of responsibility and professionalism that NHS Tayside has to cover is fairly wide and probably wider than that of Scottish Enterprise, which delivers a more focused service. I can understand why there are genuine differences, although I accept that, as you say, some differences are completely unexplained and perhaps need to be addressed. There is a range of responsibilities, which will mean that there will be different types of board. Even if there was a complete restructuring, certain differences would have to be maintained because of the service that each board delivers.

Mr Black
link

Yes, that is correct.12:30

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

The report raises hundreds of questions and issues. I am not sure that we will be able to deal with it today. Can we not hold it over and deal with it properly?

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We will come to our consideration of the report at a later point in the agenda. At the moment, members can seek any clarification that they wish from the Auditor General.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

With all the variations that you mentioned, Mr Black, is it your view that we need some kind of better, improved code of good governance for boards? There are many variations in their approaches to recruitment, risk management and performance management, and only two fifths of them open their meetings to the public. Those are things for which we might expect there to be standard processes across the public sector. To me, that points towards a need for an improved code of governance for boards to assist them in their role and clarify what their obligations are.

Mr Black
link

Not for a moment would I wish to give the committee the impression that one size fits all would be an appropriate message to come out of the report. As I implied in my answers to Mr Kidd’s questions, it is interesting to note the diversity that exists. However, given the core responsibilities for governance that all boards have, we have included at the back of the report a checklist of questions that board members could ask themselves, including questions about meeting in public, so that at least they think about why they are not meeting in public and, if necessary, can be challenged on some of the issues through the audit process, dare I say it.A lot of interest has been expressed in the report—which came out only last week—from a number of different sources. It is fair to say that the speaking engagements are beginning to line up, which is good and healthy. It is good to see that people are willing to use the contents of the report to reflect on how they do their business. I welcome that.The essence of what I am saying is that one size does not fit all, but there are common core standards that all boards should apply.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

What is happening as a result of your report is helpful, but it is a wee bit difficult to get why boards might suddenly want to open themselves up to the public as a result of reading a recommendation from you. They should have been doing that, or thinking about it, for a long time, rather than waiting for you to put it in one of your reports. That is why I talked about a general code of guidance that might be able to assist them at an earlier stage.

Mr Black
link

By and large, when it comes to the big issues that matter we do not live in a secret society. All health boards and a number of other public bodies meet in public, but that does not mean that we could not take the matter a stage further.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I have a quick question, but I am not sure whether you will know the answer to it. Do you have any inkling what the explanation might be for the reduction in applications for public appointments?

Mr Black
link

We did not research that directly, but we had some feedback on it in the large response to our survey. I invite my team to give an indication of the factors that were in that feedback.

Barbara Hurst Audit Scotland
link

I do not think that the reason is known, exactly. Through our survey, we asked all non-executive board members for their views about the reasons. Obviously, they have gone through the recruitment process and were successful, so they are a slightly biased sample. There were lots of comments about the reputational risk of being on some of the boards. Some of them mentioned pay, but that was not necessarily a big issue, because not all non-execs get paid anyway. Time commitments were also mentioned. The non-execs gave us a range of responses, but there is no clear picture of why the numbers have gone down. The complexity of the appointments process was also raised.

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

We recommend in the report that the Government do some research to try to establish the reasons why applications have fallen and that it do something about it.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I thank the Auditor General and his team for that report. We will consider action at a later point in the agenda.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 301
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 17
  4. 10:00 “Draft Code of Audit Practice” Committee business · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.