Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“The Gathering 2009”

Wednesday 6 October 2010 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Committee business 301 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

301 contributions · showing 1–200
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

The second item is the section 23 report on “The Gathering 2009”. We have with us Sir John Elvidge, who was formerly the permanent secretary to the Scottish Government. He has now left the service—I do not know whether “retired” is the right word—and is doing a lot of productive things with his life in a new environment.Before I go into detail on the report, I beg Sir John’s indulgence while I remind committee members about matters being sub judice. I make it clear that liquidation proceedings are on-going in the courts, so members should refrain from saying anything that has the potential to prejudice the outcome of the court process, as advised by the Presiding Officer in accordance with rule 7.5 of standing orders on matters being sub judice.Thank you, Sir John, for taking the time to come along. I know that although you have left the employment of the Scottish Government you are a busy man, so we appreciate your attendance.We have received your written statement. Would you like to say anything in advance?

Sir John Elvidge
link

No, thank you—I would rather you got on with the questioning.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay. Thank you.I want to ask about communication and liaison with other public bodies. To go back to the original £100,000 grant, I do not know whether you were involved in that, but it appears that the Scottish Government did not discuss the grant with The Gathering 2009 Ltd, or the event with the existing steering group members. Was there a reason for that?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I was not involved in any part of making the original loan. Indeed, I was not aware until after the event that the original loan existed, so it is difficult for me to talk about the rationale for the way in which people handled that process.Having read the Auditor General for Scotland’s report, I note that it says explicitly that the members of the steering group were not informed. In my experience, there is a lot of contact at working level between the Scottish Government and the various organisations, so I do not know whether that statement means that the organisations were unaware or simply that the members of the steering group were unaware.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

For the record, the original payment was a grant rather than a loan. The loan was a subsequent payment; I think that you were involved at that point.

Sir John Elvidge
link

I was not involved in any financial transactions before the event took place.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

No. At what point did you become involved?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I became involved in the second half of September 2009, when the company had made it clear to ministers that it could not meet its debts.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Did ministers or other civil servants approach you at that point?

Sir John Elvidge
link

First of all, other civil servants alerted me to the fact that the company had communicated that to ministers, and to the possibility that complex issues might have to be considered regarding what action the Government was able to take. Then I was involved, with others, in a meeting with ministers to consider what options were available for dealing with the circumstances.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So your involvement did not start until the second half of September 2009, but the Government had already decided to offer a short-term interest-free loan of £180,000 in June 2009.

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

And you had no knowledge of that.

Sir John Elvidge
link

No, I did not.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Who, then, would have cleared the decision about the method that was used to justify that loan? The loan was awarded under section 23 of the National Heritage (Scotland) Act 1985, which relates to the power of the Secretary of State to make “payments”—not loans—“to any body whose activities appear to him to be likely to promote the development or understanding of cultural or scientific matters.”That was a very unusual route, was it not? In your experience, have other loans been given under that heading?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I think that my successor has provided some evidence on that. If I recall it correctly, that evidence was that it is unusual for the Scottish Government itself to use that power to make loans, because a range of non-departmental public bodies that are active in culture would normally be responsible for making loans.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

That is right. So, in your experience, that mechanism had not been not used before, given that other bodies would normally do that type of thing. It was therefore a very unusual situation. Given that it was unusual—potentially unprecedented—for the Government to give a loan of £180,000 under the National Heritage (Scotland) Act 1985, do you not think that it should have been drawn to your attention before the decision was made?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I am not sure that it should. It is a good question—one of the standard tests for considering transactions is whether they are novel or contentious, to use the jargon of the trade. I can understand that someone might have considered whether they needed to alert me. Without knowing what thought process they went through, I am not necessarily surprised that they reached the view that assistance to private companies was not in itself a particularly contentious principle. Whatever process they went through, however, they did not see the need. Neither the division making the loan nor the finance directorate, which it consulted—if I understand the Audit Scotland report correctly—thought that there was an issue that required to be passed up the line to me.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

When you eventually became involved some three months later and you started to look at the issue, did you first determine who had authorised the loan?

Sir John Elvidge
link

No. I was not much exercised with the past at that point, because the pressing issue was that we were in a period in which, on any given day, an action by one of the creditors could have precipitated insolvency proceedings. I was entirely focused on how we might deal with the issue in front of us.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

It is understandable that you would be focused on the most pressing issue, which was the potential insolvency. However, I find it strange that when you became aware of a loan of £180,000 being made in a very unusual—perhaps unprecedented—way you did not ask who made it, which is something that we do not really know, or whether it was done properly and whether the right route was taken. This comment is not aimed at you personally, but I think that there is an organisational issue to deal with. As you will recall, our previous discussions about the capital programme highlighted that certain decisions were being made without their being flagged up to you as head of the civil service in Scotland. It seems that significant and potentially controversial decisions can be made without you or your successor having any knowledge of what is going on. Should that not be addressed?

Sir John Elvidge
link

At this point, I need to remember that I have no authority to speak for the Scottish Government.

Sir John Elvidge
link

My view, though, is that there is a system of internal checks. One of the primary functions of the finance directorate, which has knowledge of all such transactions, is to act as a prompt to inform me if it thinks that something about a financial transaction might raise accountable officer issues. It is clear from the Audit Scotland report—or, I should say, from my reading of the report; I should not put words into the mouths of those in the finance directorate—that the directorate satisfied itself that there was a legal basis.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You did not, however, ask those questions. By the time you became involved, which was in September, a decision had already been made in June to give a £180,000 loan. Things started to disintegrate very quickly thereafter, but you do not know who authorised the loan, who gave the legal advice, what advice was given or whether ministers were involved in trying to solicit some means of finding money. You became involved only when it looked as though the event itself was starting to come under threat rather than as a result of worries about the use of public funds.

Sir John Elvidge
link

Without pretending to know things that I do not know, I will try to help a bit. There is a clear system of financial delegation in the Scottish Government that gives people authority to make decisions within particular boundaries, and which would have given the relevant deputy director the authority to make the decision without reference to someone else. I do not know whether they did so or whether they involved their director, but I think that the system of who is authorised to make the decision is clear enough. The Audit Scotland report says that in making that decision the relevant division took the finance directorate’s advice and that no one considered that explicit legal advice was needed. I must rest on the Audit Scotland report in that respect. It also makes it clear that ministers were part of the consideration of the process. Audit Scotland will correct me if I am misremembering any part of the report, but it seems to me that there is clear evidence in it of a system and a process.10:15

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Ministers talked to officials about coming up with an appropriate solution and the suggestion was made to offer a loan. We cannot get hold of advice to ministers, under freedom of information rules, but can you tell us whether you were copied into the exchange of correspondence?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I cannot tell you that with any certainty.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Do you not remember reading anything about any of it?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I can tell you with some certainty that I never read a piece of paper about it. It would be a bigger claim to say that I can guarantee to you that my name was not on a copy list in relation to any document.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We cannot establish what was in the information, but we might be able to establish whether there was an audit trail in relation to who received information. We can also ask separate questions about who made the decision and when, and about what legal advice was taken.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Sir John, will you help us with our understanding of the process? Can you give us an illustration of a circumstance in which a proposed loan would have come to your notice? Would that have been unusual?

Sir John Elvidge
link

It would be very unusual. The Government lending money—and lending to a private company—is not an unusual occurrence, although in general it is slightly unusual for that to be done at first hand rather than through a non-departmental public body. I cannot immediately recall an occasion during my time as permanent secretary when someone would have found it necessary to refer the issue of a loan to me.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Would the level of the loan be relevant in that regard?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes it would, if it were a very large sum of money. One must always be careful, because we can sound airy about sums of money that are quite large to many people, but in the context of a £35 billion budget what constitutes a large sum of money has to be a very big number.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You are saying, in effect, that £180,000 is pretty small beer in the wider scheme of things.

Sir John Elvidge
link

It is a smaller transaction than many of the transactions that the Scottish Government conducts day to day.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You said that it is unusual for the Government to lend money at first hand rather than through an agency. Can you give other examples of the Government providing a loan at first hand?

Sir John Elvidge
link

That would happen mainly in the enterprise area—that is the area in which the Government is primarily in the loans business. There is a bit of history in that regard. You might recall that, in the to-ing and fro-ing of functions between the core of the Scottish Government and Scottish Enterprise, some functions to do with assistance to private companies have moved about over time, generally in the direction of Scottish Enterprise. Before that happened, the Scottish Government itself would have had a reasonably regular volume of loan transactions with private businesses.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Are you aware that anything else has been done under the National Heritage (Scotland) Act 1985?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I am not, and if I may rely on my memory, without looking at my successor’s written evidence, I recall that he says clearly that there are not many—I cannot recall whether he said “not any”—instances of that power being used to make a loan.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to move on a little bit. Given what you have told us about your personal involvement in the matter, I appreciate that you may not be able to help us with the aspects that I want to discuss. However, the Auditor General’s report identifies the lack of any formal due diligence on The Gathering 2009 Ltd before the loan was granted. Do you know what the reason behind that was?

Sir John Elvidge
link

No I do not, because of the complete absence of my involvement in that matter. Obviously, I have thought about that, as I have thought about all the questions that Audit Scotland has raised, and it seems to me that the circumstances may have had something to do with what happened. The company openly said that it had a significant cash-flow problem, after all. One might think that if a company says, “We’re coming to you because we’re in trouble,” there might be slightly less likelihood of going through the due diligence process, which is designed to flush out the negatives about a company that people are not being told about. However, that is hypothesising on my part.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I suppose, however, that one might want to find out just how bad the troubles are. Although the company says that it is in trouble, it may not be aware of how serious that trouble is. From your experience, can you tell us whether it would be normal in a situation in which a Government loan or grant was being granted that detailed inquiries would be made about the financial position of the recipient of that loan or grant?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I need to be careful not to claim omniscience, which I do not have. My view is that, in most circumstances in which a private company approaches the Government or an NDPB for a loan, there probably would be a process of due diligence, but in most cases, one starts without self-declared information about the company. Therefore, one starts from a lower base. Due diligence is a natural response to starting from scratch. However, I think that some form of request to the company to provide financial information is a normal part of a loan-giving process.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Okay. I assume that, when a Government grants a loan, it is normal for it to do so on the basis that a risk assessment had been done on the company’s ability to repay it at the end of a defined period.

Sir John Elvidge
link

That seems to me to be a sound commonsense principle.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You have told us that it was the second half of September 2009 before you were alerted to matters due to the problems that the company was facing. By that time, the £180,000 loan was significantly outstanding—it was due to be paid back within 14 days of the payment from WorldPay being received, and by 31 August at the very latest. From the Scottish Government perspective, given that the event was so high profile and given the crisis that already existed around the event, should not a process have kicked in to focus hard on the responsibility to the public purse, which is ultimately the Scottish Government’s responsibility? Should not a process have kicked in to focus hard on the responsibility for the use of public funds and the recovery of that £180,000?

Sir John Elvidge
link

As I recall—again, I am relying principally on the Audit Scotland report—the final date for payment was 31 August. I was told by colleagues that there was an issue sometime in the second half of September. I am not sure that I would have expected people to be faster than that. People being late in paying us money—I am sorry, I should not say “us”, should I? People being late in paying the Government money is not a particularly unusual occurrence.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

When you discovered in mid-September what had happened, the level of due diligence associated with the loan—which seems to have been virtually non-existent—the fact that there was no interest on the loan, and the fact that it was issued through a letter that had a schedule that calls it a grant claim form, you must have been horrified that the system that you were ultimately responsible for had failed, and had failed badly.

Sir John Elvidge
link

I was not focused on those issues; as I have said, I was focused on the pressing problem that was in front of us. In so far as I might have thought about those issues, my approach would have been that the audit process would need to take care of them. It was not my habit to go chasing after individual investigations of things that I knew the audit process would look at thoroughly anyway.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

The organisation that you were responsible for had given money to a company that was insolvent, with no or only very limited checks and in very unusual circumstances. Was that not a matter of deep concern to you as the leader of that organisation?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Again, I need to be careful not to pretend to know things that I do not but, if the company had been insolvent when we made the loan, the directors would have been committing a criminal offence. I do not take it from anything in the Audit Scotland report that the company was insolvent at the point at which the loan was made. It had a cash-flow problem.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

The company became insolvent. Is that what you are saying?

Sir John Elvidge
link

The company became insolvent because—again, as I understand it from the Audit Scotland report—the non-advance revenues did not live up to expectations, although they do not seem to have been easy for anyone to judge in advance of the event.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You discovered the information in September. From that point until you retired, you did not instigate any review of systems or procedures and you did not express any concern about the process that led to the loan, which you believed would be picked up through the audit process. Is that correct?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes. Once the case became so high profile, it was clear that the audit process would consider it thoroughly, so I thought that the right thing to do was wait for the audit process to reach its conclusions.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You did not ask for that or alert the auditors or anybody involved in the audit process to your concerns.

Sir John Elvidge
link

I did not. I think that our systems for dealing with instances in which we may have to write off money are such that there is automatically a strong audit process. There was no need for me to do something extra.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

On a point of clarification, you have said twice now that you were not really focused on current issues but were trying to resolve the problem that had developed. You also said that you had not looked at how the original grant had been given, how the loan was given or the processes and procedures involved, some fairly unusual aspects of which have just been highlighted by Nicol Stephen.You then said that you were content for the audit process to look at the matter. The specific function of that process is to deal with the efficacy and legitimacy of decisions taken and payments made, but the fact is that you were the senior manager of the civil service in Scotland and had experienced some very unusual decisions and what one might generously describe as highly imaginative ways of making payments to a company that very quickly got into trouble. I presume that at that time you realised that no detailed checks had been made. Setting the audit process to one side, I wonder whether it should be the responsibility of the person who is ultimately responsible for not just the civil service but Government funds in Scotland to initiate a review of how decisions are made. Would it not be good practice to say, “There’s something badly wrong here. We need to make sure that for the future we learn lessons and improve”?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Well, the audit process is precisely that. There was nothing that I was going to do without evidence. You are assuming that I had reached a conclusion that something had gone badly wrong in the system. I have not reached any such conclusion.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So at the point at which you became involved you did not think that there was much that was wrong and, subsequently, you feel the same.

Sir John Elvidge
link

I did not see anything unusual about making a loan to a private company or anything intrinsically unusual about private companies getting into trading difficulties that make them incapable of meeting their obligations. However, it would be true to say that I was also very focused on the rather unusual issues that were personal to me as accountable officer that came up in the weeks succeeding my involvement. My energy was pretty fully taken up with those issues.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Even though you recognise that using the Natural Heritage (Scotland) Act 1985 in such a way is exceptionally unusual, you do not think that making a loan to a private company, or the loan in and of itself, is unusual.

Sir John Elvidge
link

It is not part of my way of looking at the world to be overly focused on the specific powers that we use to do something, provided that the powers exist. At the risk of going off at a tangent, I have over the years been struck by the fact that one of the differences between public administration in the United Kingdom and such administration in some other countries is that in those other countries people are very focused on the specific powers that they use to pay money. The nature of the financial powers in the UK is broader and more flexible and therefore we—Interruption. I must stay away from words such as “we” and “us”. There is a tendency to be less concerned about the specific power that is used, provided that it has a legal basis.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But you do not know whether there was a legal basis because you did not ask that question, did you?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Given the thousands of transactions that take place every day, it is not my habit to ask whether there is a legal basis for each of them. I work on the presumption that there is a legal basis, unless someone gives me reason to think otherwise.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Once you became involved and saw what was happening, did you ask why the steering group members had not been informed of the loan?

Sir John Elvidge
link

No. I did not know that they had not been informed of it, and I am not sure that the question would have come to the front of my mind.

Sir John Elvidge
link

And you.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I wish to ask about the time when you were closely involved in this matter. You have said that creditors could have taken action “on any given day”, which would have threatened the event. You were extremely focused on it. You had seen that the loan of £180,000 had not solved the problems, and you became involved with trying to save the event. Is that right?

Sir John Elvidge
link

To save the future of the event—the event had happened.

Sir John Elvidge
link

The focus was on enabling someone to run a further iteration of the gathering. That was the objective.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

That involved dealing with the public creditors and the private creditors. Is that right?

Sir John Elvidge
link

There were different phases. The first phase involved thinking about the options for preserving the company as an entity. It is important to draw a distinction between the company as a name or a brand and its directors. Without wishing to be rude to them, what happened to the original directors of the company was never the slightest part of my concern. There was a view, however—which I shared—that the gathering, as a brand and as an image, would be damaged by insolvency. The focus was on how one could extract the brand from the situation.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

We can come to that in a moment. I want to concentrate on what you said about how, “on any given day”, creditors could have come in. You made it very clear that the whole thing would have gone belly up.Were you in touch with the City of Edinburgh Council about its role?

Sir John Elvidge
link

At a later stage. There was a stage at the beginning that involved thinking—this was internal to the Scottish Government—about what the options were. Could the Scottish Government deal with the matter itself, or would it need to involve some third party?There was a second phase, when the conclusion was reached that a third party would have to be involved. In the process of discussions around that, the city council, as a significant funder of the gathering itself, was automatically drawn in.There was a third phase, when the council emerged as the potential purchaser of the company.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Did someone say to you that the City of Edinburgh Council would take over the company’s private sector liabilities?

Sir John Elvidge
link

That was my understanding.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Why did you come to that understanding? Who told you or made you aware of that?

Sir John Elvidge
link

We are heavily reliant on my memory of meetings that were not necessarily focused on that specific question. The fact that the Scottish Government could not justify taking responsibility for the private sector creditors was an explicit part of the basis for the discussion with third parties. The desirability of protecting the private sector creditors was also an explicit part of the discussions.It would be truer to say that I thought it was implicit that anyone who bought the company was taking on responsibility for its private sector liabilities, rather than that anybody told me explicitly that they were taking those on.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

So who in the City of Edinburgh Council made you aware that the council was willing to take on the liabilities of the operation?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Again, we are reliant on my memory—

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes. I simply enter a caveat that, although I remember some things, I cannot guarantee that I remember every single thing. At the first meeting in which I was involved and at which the council was engaged in the discussions, the principal representatives of the council, as I recall, were Councillor Cardownie and Mr Jim Inch, whose title with the council I confess that I have forgotten, but he is a member of the executive of the council.

Sir John Elvidge
link

No, she was not. I was never at a meeting in the process at which Councillor Dawe was present.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

So Councillor Cardownie was the senior person representing the council at that meeting.

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes. Again, if my memory is correct, that is because he is convener of the relevant committee of the council.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

You understood from Councillor Cardownie and Jim Inch that the council was going to take on the liabilities.

Sir John Elvidge
link

It seemed to me that it was an implicit understanding that whoever bought the company would take on the liabilities. That is an automatic feature of buying a company. It was always absolutely explicit in the discussions that the Scottish Government could not justify bearing the financial costs of meeting those liabilities.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Am I correct that the council was going to take on the company through the Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance?

Sir John Elvidge
link

So I understand.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

That was the understanding, and the press release that was issued on 15 October was done on the basis of that understanding. Is that right?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I had no involvement in the press release because, by that stage, I thought that we had a solution. I left it to others. However, I am certain that my colleagues would have shared my understanding that taking on the private sector liabilities was an integral part of purchasing the company.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

After the meeting with Councillor Cardownie and Mr Inch, did you get anything in writing from the council? Did you seek confirmation in a letter, minute or memorandum?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes and no. I will do the no bit first. I never went through a process of asking the council to write down what it was undertaking to do. Remember that we are talking about a private company being purchased by a public body that the Scottish Government does not control. The Scottish Government had no locus to require the council to do anything and the council was not accountable to the Scottish Government for what it chose to do. There were exchanges about the financial framework within which the Scottish Government might be willing to provide funding if, having bought the company, the City of Edinburgh Council wanted to mount a second iteration of the gathering.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

But you never explicitly got from the City of Edinburgh Council, either from the leader or from the chief executive, in writing that it was arranging for DEMA to take over the liabilities of the company.

Sir John Elvidge
link

I am sure that there are bits of paper discussing the possibility that DEMA would take over, because everyone was working on the assumption that that was the solution.

Sir John Elvidge
link

I have no knowledge of the dealings with the chairman of DEMA.10:45

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

We will no doubt come back to that. You said that once you thought that everything was okay, you left it to someone else to deal with the press release. Who concocted the press release of 15 October?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I have no idea.

Sir John Elvidge
link

I assume that it was some combination of people who were working in the division and dealing with that set of issues.

Sir John Elvidge
link

The division in the Scottish Government. I have read in the council’s evidence a statement that some of the text of the press release was generated inside the Scottish Government; I have no idea whether that is true.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

That was said to us by Jenny Gilmour in evidence to the committee. She said that she was called to St Andrews house with Lord Sempill to look at the draft text of a press release that was to go out in the council’s name, although it was drafted by the Scottish Office—sorry, the Scottish Executive; I am reverting. Is that unusual?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I am sure that the answer to that must be yes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Is it permissible?

Sir John Elvidge
link

When we are working closely with another public sector body to resolve an issue, it is give and take. We could not have put any statement out in the council’s name; the council must be responsible for anything that it puts out in its own name.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Even though you wrote it?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Even though we may have contributed to the writing.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

No, not contributed to it—my understanding is that your officials wrote it. You have admitted that you had no locus in relation to what was being said, but my understanding is that your officials wrote the press release to be issued in the name of the City of Edinburgh Council.

Sir John Elvidge
link

I cannot know whether that is true or not.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

If it is true, is it acceptable?

Sir John Elvidge
link

It is very generous of them to do that work for the council.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

It may be generous; we have seen untold displays of generosity from the Scottish Government and senior officials in making payments to Transport Scotland staff. This is potentially another act of generosity, but is it permissible?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Formally, given that ministers wanted a positive solution to this set of issues, it is permissible for civil servants to spend their time doing things that are conducive to an outcome that ministers believe is in the public interest.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

You said that ministers wanted a solution. In the scenario that you have just described, how were ministers involved in finding a solution and in the drafting and issuing of the press release? Were they involved in that?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I have no idea whether they were involved in drafting the press release. They were actively involved in, first, the pursuit of the consideration of whether the Scottish Government itself could be the vehicle for preserving the company, and, secondly, when it became clear that that was not feasible, in discussions with other potential purchasers of the company.

Sir John Elvidge
link

Primarily the First Minister and Mr Russell.

Sir John Elvidge
link

And Mr Russell, who was of course the portfolio minister. In line with all my caveats, I am not giving you a guarantee that my memory is so perfect that I can say to you that no minister other than those two was ever involved.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Were you surprised to find out that Jenny Dawe and the council as a whole had not agreed to what appeared to have been agreed at the meeting that was attended by Councillor Cardownie?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Were you surprised when the chairman of DEMA, Mr Springford, resigned? Did that cause you disquiet or concern?

Sir John Elvidge
link

It caused me disquiet in the sense that it was evidence that what I had understood to be a settled solution was not going smoothly.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

You realised that what you had thought was a settled solution was not going smoothly. What did you do about that?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Either I or someone acting on my behalf—I genuinely cannot remember which—had a conversation with the council about whether the solution was still on track. At that stage, the belief was that the solution was still on track.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

We have an exchange of correspondence that shows that in—I think—December, Councillor Dawe, who is the leader of the council, indicated that the council was not willing to take on the responsibilities.

Sir John Elvidge
link

It was all past praying for at that point.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Does it seem to you that Councillor Cardownie, who is a Scottish National Party councillor, the First Minister and Mr Russell might have come to an agreement of which Councillor Dawe was not aware?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I am not sure that their party allegiances have anything to do with it. I was present, as were many other people, in the meeting when Councillor Cardownie said that he believed that there was a case for the council taking the lead in a solution. The discussion was predicated entirely on the evidence of the economic benefits that had come principally to Edinburgh.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Were the First Minister and Mr Russell at that meeting?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes. I make the usual caveat about the accuracy of my memory, but I am reasonably certain of that.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I am sure that your memory is accurate. You have been very helpful. Thank you.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Sir John, you came to the view that the Scottish Government could not assist with the purchase of the company—although there is the issue of the write-off of the public sector liability.

Sir John Elvidge
link

Indeed. That is a separate set of issues.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Perhaps we will come on to that, because you were involved.Can you explain why one public sector organisation, the Scottish Government, could not take on the liabilities but expected another public sector organisation, the City of Edinburgh Council, to do so?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I can have a go. It is a balance of considerations. The costs of meeting the liabilities of the private sector creditors all related to benefits that had already been delivered. I took the view that the Scottish Government could not justify spending public money for the benefit of a number of companies whose impact was in a particular geographical area. It is not the business of the Scottish Government to favour companies based in Edinburgh, say, over companies based in Glasgow, which might be their competitors. I do not think that the Scottish Government ever expected the council to do something. However, it seemed to me that the council for the area in which the companies were predominantly based might come to a different conclusion about whether legitimate public interests enabled it to spend money in the interest of such companies. Ultimately, I took the view that what constituted defensible value for money for the council was the council’s business.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Did you take the view that it was within the powers of the Scottish Government to take on the private sector liabilities but that it would have been inappropriate to do so?

Sir John Elvidge
link

As far as I could tell, it was certainly within the powers of the Scottish Government to purchase the company and thereby take on the liabilities. However, I thought that that option failed the value-for-money test and that it potentially raised a different kind of legal issue with European Union state aid legislation. It would have been possible to interpret such action as a decision to find a route to channel public funds to certain companies, which by definition would have raised state aid issues.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Your advice was obviously accepted in that regard, so the focus shifted to the City of Edinburgh Council.

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I will move on to the 15 October press release. As I understand it, as part of the deal there was to be a write-off of the public sector liabilities—the public sector was a significant creditor—and the council was expected to take on the other, private sector liabilities. The press release went out in the joint names of the organisations involved—is that correct?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I do not believe so. Again, I want to be careful not to get beyond the boundaries of my knowledge, but my understanding—and I think that this is clear from the Audit Scotland report—is that the press release went out in the name of the council.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

It was a council press release but it included quotes from representatives of other organisations, such as“Scottish Government Culture Minister Michael Russell”.The organisations involved in the difficult and delicate negotiations, including the Scottish Government, cleared the wording of the press release. It was drafted by the Scottish Government, there was some negotiation around the wording, and after amendment it was issued in the name of the council.

Sir John Elvidge
link

If you say so. You are offering a version of events that I cannot verify at first hand. It appears to be consistent with the evidence that I have read.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Okay. Is it not important that an organisation such as the Scottish Government is alert to the legal ramifications of such a press release being issued—particularly the legal consequences in relation to the creditors?

Sir John Elvidge
link

Yes, that must be so—in principle. I am sorry—I am hesitating for two reasons, one of which is the convener’s caveat at the beginning about sub judice, because it seems to me that we are beginning to brush up against that territory.What I can say is that I am confident that, if you had asked me on the day the press release was issued whether it corresponded with my understanding of what was happening, I would have said yes. Of course, the press release must have some implications for the council’s position, but that has to be the council’s business. If we had had any reason to suppose that it was misleading—sorry, I must stay away from the “we” thing. If the Scottish Government had had any reason to believe that the press release was misleading, I think that the Scottish Government would have had a role. However, I can say with some certainty from my knowledge of the Scottish Government’s beliefs at that time about the council’s intentions that there was no reason to suppose that the press release was misleading.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

But there can be no doubt that it was misleading, because the reality was very different from your belief on that day.

Sir John Elvidge
link

The subsequent outcome was very different from my belief on that day. It is a different statement to say that the reality was different on that day.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

On that day, there was no agreement by the council to fulfil the obligations that were referred to in the press release.

Sir John Elvidge
link

If the council says so.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Just before I bring in Anne McLaughlin, I have a couple of questions about the press release. You said that you had no reason to believe that it was misleading, but Councillor Dawe, the leader of the City of Edinburgh Council, has said that she believes that the release was rushed. We are talking about something that was prepared by your staff in your time not for you or for ministers but—generously, as you described it—for a completely independent organisation. Your senior staff reviewed it and potentially ran it past ministers for authorisation, because it contained a ministerial quotation. I assume that ministers would not have agreed to the inclusion of their words on a very sensitive issue without their being aware that they were being used.We can assume, therefore, that, although you might have had no knowledge of the release, it was cleared at the highest level in the Scottish Government. Nevertheless, the leader of City of Edinburgh Council says that“it was rushed and contained references which were both premature and somewhat misleading”.Basically, your organisation prepared something for the City of Edinburgh Council and the leader says that it contained “misleading” information. Is not it outrageous that Scottish Government officials are producing such shoddy, ill-informed, inaccurate and, indeed, “misleading” information for a completely independent organisation that caused it embarrassment and, as you indicated to Nicol Stephen, might have had legal implications?

Sir John Elvidge
link

That is an unsustainable interpretation of events. Of course officials were involved. As you rightly point out, a ministerial quotation could not have been used without authorisation. As I have said, it is perfectly proper for officials to work with the council on the wording of a press release about the outcome of a process of joint endeavour, but any attempt to suggest that the Scottish Government made the council utter particular words is simply unsustainable.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

The Official Report will show whether I am wrong, but I do not think that I said that the Scottish Government made the council utter any words. Instead, I said that it had been involved in “shoddy” work, that Jenny Dawe had called what was produced “misleading” and that in my view it did a disservice to an independent agency or organisation by producing something that the leader of the council was not prepared to accept. Does not that reflect badly on your officials?

Sir John Elvidge
link

No. I think that it is entirely a question of the City of Edinburgh Council’s processes for ensuring that its leader is happy with its press releases. I have said to you in the plainest possible terms that the understanding that was reflected in that press release is the understanding that I would, if anyone had asked me—which they did not—have held on that day. I do not think that you can blame Scottish Government officials for reflecting the Scottish Government’s understanding. If it was wrong, it was the council’s business to deal with it.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Of course. You are entirely right to say that if the matter was wrong it was up to the council to deal with it. However, the council usually deals with and takes responsibility for inaccuracies in press releases that it has produced. We are talking about a press release that was produced by your officials and which was perhaps sanctioned by ministers of the Administration in the name of the City of Edinburgh Council, and that the council leader says contained information that was “misleading”. Do you not find anything wrong with that?

Sir John Elvidge
link

We—the Scottish Government, I mean, is not capable of producing and issuing a statement for any local authority.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I am sorry, but could you correct that? Earlier you acknowledged that Scottish Government officials prepared a press release for another organisation. They did not issue it, but they prepared it.

Sir John Elvidge
link

You know as well as I do that documents that are to go into the public domain go through a variety of versions. The fact that Scottish Government officials were involved in offering wording does not make them in any sense responsible for the document that the council issued. No one put a gun to the council’s head.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

No, but you and your officials produced a press release for the City of Edinburgh Council. It was not done together—your people produced it for the council. To be fair to the council, as you said, the press release reflected the council’s understanding of the discussion that took place between the First Minister, Mike Russell and Councillor Cardownie and his officials.

Sir John Elvidge
link

It also reflected discussions that I had with council officials. There is not some political conspiracy here. There was a discussion involving a lot of people over a period of days that led—certainly as far as I was concerned—to a clear understanding. In relation to the press release, you are going well beyond any information that I have about the extent to which Scottish Government officials wrote particular words in it. You might have perfect knowledge of that, but I do not. However, I would be astonished if the press release had emerged through a process of Scottish Government officials writing it and everybody in the City of Edinburgh Council saying, “Oh that’s fine—we’ll just put that out.”

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

No, of course that did not happen because, when people in the City of Edinburgh Council saw it, they said, “No, we’re not putting it out.” That is the issue.

Sir John Elvidge
link

They did put it out.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

The leader of the council did not. She said that it contained “misleading” information and it is clear that she was not aware of the process.

Sir John Elvidge
link

That is a matter for the council. I cannot possibly comment on how the council came to issue a press release that its leader thinks was “misleading”.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Absolutely. We can find that out.You said to George Foulkes that you were focused on trying to get a solution and that, at one point, you still believed that a solution was at hand and you were discussing that with people in the council. Who in the council gave you the impression that a solution was still at hand?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I make the usual caveat about my memory but, as I recall, most of my conversations were with Jim Inch.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Before I come on to my question, I want to say that we all have the press release in front of us. It has six contact names on it—one from EventScotland, one from the Scottish Government, one from The Gathering 2009 Ltd and three from the City of Edinburgh Council. I would be astonished if none of those people who are authorised to speak on behalf of the council was aware of the contents of the press release.Lord Foulkes rightly gave credit to SNP councillor Steve Cardownie, who saw the benefits of taking on the company, given the £8 million-plus boost to the city’s economy. Were you ever made aware of why the Liberal Democrat leader of the council, Jenny Dawe, went back on that and what on earth the justification was for not taking the opportunity to protect Edinburgh businesses and to boost the economy of Edinburgh in years to come?

Sir John Elvidge
link

No. I did not regard it as my business to pry into the council’s internal political discussions. However, none of my conversations made me aware of why Councillor Dawe might take a different view from Councillor Cardownie on the merits of the issue.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

So, a reason or explanation was never given for not proceeding with the move.

Sir John Elvidge
link

As I recall, as things subsequently fell apart, the general statement was one of concern about the council’s overall financial position, but there was nothing more specific than that.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to bottom out the issue of the press release, which is important. I have been ploughing through papers that we received under freedom of information. Perhaps you can confirm whether my understanding is correct.According to the information that we have, the original draft press release was produced by Jane Robson in the Scottish Government—you might or might not know the detail of that. It went through a series of revisions with the City of Edinburgh Council during the course of the afternoon of 14 October 2009 and the final version was agreed later that evening, at 21:27.The important line in the draft press release was:“DEMA has agreed to discharge all the remaining obligations from this year’s event”.That was a significant point; it is the one that gave the reassurance to the creditors that meant that they did not at that stage take action to protect their position. The line appeared in the original draft, which was produced by Jane Robson and e-mailed at 14:05 to the City of Edinburgh Council. In the final version, the wording was more or less identical:“DEMA will take on The Gathering 2009 Ltd’s remaining private sector obligations”.Therefore, there was no change between the final version, which was issued by the City of Edinburgh Council, and the initial version, which Scottish Government officials provided. It is important that we get that on the record.You are right to say that it was a City of Edinburgh Council press release and that therefore the council had the final say. However, all the council did was pick up wording that Scottish Government officials had provided.

Sir John Elvidge
link

That is not all that the council did; it put out a press release in its own name. I have not seen the documents, but they say what they say. I have said that if you had asked me on that day what the council’s intentions and DEMA’s intentions were, that would have been my understanding of their intentions, so it is not surprising that other officials in the Scottish Government shared that understanding. If that were not so, it is clear that the council must have had ample opportunity to change the statement.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

It is not usual for me to jump to the defence of a Liberal Democrat. However, you said that you are not aware why Jenny Dawe took the view that she took. Have you not seen her letter of 23 December to Iain Smith, from which I think the convener quoted? She said of the press release:“it was rushed and contained references which were both premature and somewhat misleading”.She went on to say:“At the time of the news release, discussions with the Scottish Government and with DEMA were at a very early stage and the necessary due diligence had not been completed”.Jenny Dawe was concerned that the press release had been put out before that work had been done, which was a sensible and responsible point of view. Surely you must have known that, Sir John.

Sir John Elvidge
link

I have no recollection of reading the letter, but that does not mean that I have not done so. I thought that the question was whether any explanation had been given to me, and the answer is that it had not been. If Councillor Dawe says that those were the reasons, I have no reason to doubt her account.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Do you think that she was right to say that the press release was put out prematurely, when due diligence had not been carried out, and that it created a “misleading” impression?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I do not know—

Sir John Elvidge
link

Has she? Are the facts different now from the facts that were known at an earlier stage? It is certainly true that everything that was done in the episode that we are discussing was done in a rush, because of the fundamental point that on any day the action of any individual creditor could have pulled the deal down. It is inevitable that people were making haste.11:15

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

You said earlier—unprompted, not in response to my questioning—that you, as the top man in the Scottish Executive, were involved because on any given day creditors could have taken action. You wanted to avoid Mr Smith or whoever it was taking action that would bring the whole edifice down. The press release was put out prematurely to prevent one of the 103 creditors from taking action. Is that right?

Sir John Elvidge
link

I do not think I said that that was why I was involved; I said that it was why I focused intensely on it. I was involved because there were accountable officer issues in the process.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

You were not involved earlier on. You became involved only in mid-September, when creditors could have taken action to bring the whole edifice down.

Sir John Elvidge
link

Indeed—and I became involved initially for the reasons that I have explained to you. An accountable officer view was needed on whether the Scottish Government would deliver value for money if it was the agent of the rescue.If you are seeking a single reason why my involvement began, it is because there was an explicit accountable officer issue to be considered. As I said earlier, it was implicit in the public policy objective of enabling a future iteration of the gathering to be run for the economic benefit of Scotland that it would be damaging if there was insolvency action rather than a purchase of the company.It was explicit in all the discussions in which I was involved that people were seeking an outcome that was favourable to the private sector creditors. Any purchase of the company would protect the private sector creditors, whereas the information that was available to us suggested that insolvency would be unlikely to deliver any financial return to those creditors.That becomes relevant when we come to the last phase of my involvement, which is the write-off of the Scottish Government loan, because that was based explicitly on advice that we, as a creditor, were unlikely to get any part of that loan back in the event of insolvency.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to clarify a point, Sir John. You said to us that the ultimate responsibility for issuing the press release, which we now accept was “premature” and “misleading”, lies with the City of Edinburgh Council. However, it is clear from what we have seen and from what you have said that the Scottish Government was pushing the City of Edinburgh Council down that road, encouraging it to issue the press release and putting words in its mouth. The Scottish Government clearly had an interest in getting that message out.

Sir John Elvidge
link

There was a shared interest in acting quickly to ensure that the risk of insolvency proceedings did not crystallise. Yes, the Scottish Government had an interest—it was intrinsic to the solution that people were seeking that such a solution was brought about as rapidly as possible.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

If there was a shared interest, there was also a shared responsibility to the creditors of The Gathering 2009 Ltd to ensure that the information that was put into the public domain did not mislead them.

Sir John Elvidge
link

Only the council can take responsibility for statements about the council’s intentions. As I have said, the press release reflected the Scottish Government’s understanding of the situation at that time.

Bill Kidd SNP Glasgow
link

Sir John, I think you said that people in the Scottish Government compiled the press release, but it was given to the council, as opposed to the Scottish Government simply sticking the council’s name on to the bottom of it and saying, “Here’s your contact.” The press release was sent to the council, which then had the responsibility for releasing it.The issue comes down to co-operation taking place in the hope, which seems to have been genuine, that The Gathering 2009 Ltd could be rescued from financial insolvency in order that the creditors, among others, would benefit. If the company had become insolvent, the creditors’ benefits would have been very small; indeed, many companies would not have been able to continue as solvent organisations. Whether or not the press release was “premature”, as Councillor Dawe said it was—although, in the light of the dates on the correspondence, it seems that she said that more than two months later—the intention was to rescue The Gathering 2009 Ltd and ensure that the creditors gained the moneys that they were due. Do you believe that some people were pulling in one direction and some were pulling in another and that, unfortunately, despite all the good will that existed, some people possibly panicked and decided that they would not be able to rescue the company, and that it was best simply to pull the plug on it altogether?

Sir John Elvidge
link

It is difficult for me to comment on people’s thoughts and motivations, but it is certainly true that protecting the interests of the private sector creditors was thought to be inseparable from the objective of protecting the reputation of the gathering as an event. I do not think that it would be right to say that protecting the private sector creditors was the primary objective, but there could not be one objective without the other. The gathering, as a brand, could not be protected without also protecting the private sector creditors.It is also true that although—as I said to Lord Foulkes—it was not my business to take advice specifically about the private sector creditors, I received advice about the position of the Scottish Government as a creditor. That advice was that the company’s assets were liable to be swallowed up by the costs of the process of insolvency and that, in the event of insolvency, it would be improbable that any creditor could expect to see any return from the process. It was certainly our belief that, unless a purchaser could be found, damage to the private sector creditors, which would in turn damage the status of the brand, would be bound to occur.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Before Willie Coffey moves on to the next questions, I want to be absolutely clear about the press release relating to the creditors. I think that you said, quite reasonably, that you took at face value what you were told, and that your contact was Jim Inch. When the press release was being constructed, did he indicate that the solution would mean that either DEMA or the City of Edinburgh Council would ensure that the creditors would be paid?

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 301
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 17
  4. 10:00 “Draft Code of Audit Practice” Committee business · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.