The next item is consideration of a section 23 report entitled “Emergency departments”. Before I invite the Auditor General to give us a briefing, I note that Caroline Gardner is with us. She will not be here again for a while because, as members might know, she is taking up a secondment to the Turks and Caicos Islands.Members: Wow!
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Emergency departments”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- The Convener 8
- Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland 8
- Murdo Fraser 3
- Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland 3
- Mr McAveety 2
- Bill Kidd 2
- George Foulkes 1
- Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland 1
The record
28 contributionsIndeed.
I can tell you a thing or two about that.
Don’t, George—your microphone’s on.
Suitably, she has waited until winter approaches before deciding to depart. The appointment is significant—the Administration there has been in significant financial difficulty for a period—and I am sure that Caroline Gardner will relish the challenge.I invite Mr Black to give us a briefing on the report.
In this case, I think it right and appropriate that Caroline Gardner should introduce the “Emergency departments” report.
From accident and emergency units to the Caribbean, eh?
I am afraid that there will be no fact-finding visits, convener. I thank members for their good wishes.This report looks at emergency care in the national health service in Scotland. As we know, such care is a vital part of the health service. The numbers of people attending emergency departments are increasing, reaching about 1.4 million attendances in 2008-09, the cost of which was around £150 million or about 1 per cent of overall health service spending.12:15
I will briefly highlight three key issues in the report to inform the committee’s consideration of what it might want to do with it. The first thing to say is that although several policy documents set out the broad approach to emergency care, fundamental challenges remain, some of which relate to the fact that the type and location of emergency services have evolved over time. Moreover, during that time, new initiatives such as NHS 24 and various minor injury units have been introduced. The fact that there is no consensus on which place of treatment is best for which type of patient or condition can be confusing for patients and it is important that they are clear about when they should go to a minor injuries unit rather than an emergency department. However, that is not always the case.As I said, demand for emergency services is increasing, which means that costs over the past few years have increased significantly. We think that more can be done to manage the costs of services more effectively. For example, with regard to workforce pressures, staffing levels have increased over the past few years, but the impact of the European working time directive, the new consultant contract and changes to junior doctors’ training have reduced the number of available working hours in emergency departments. Not all of those pressures can be handled locally, and there is a need for clearer strategic direction for emergency services to ensure that the national element of the planning is being done as well as it can be.Although limited information is available on the medical condition of all the patients who attend emergency departments, we know that more than half of them are classified as having minor injuries or illnesses. That raises the question whether such patients are best treated in A and E. Indeed, the question of appropriateness is highlighted by the fact that we also know that the patients who arrive at A and E and leave without treatment cost more than £2 million a year.Another area of service management that we think merits attention relates to waiting times and the quality of care. Although it is good news that the length of time that people wait to be seen in emergency departments has in recent years decreased significantly and that patients are happy with the treatment that they receive, we know that at the moment it is difficult for emergency departments to maintain the four-hour waiting time standard. That difficulty is likely to increase in future.In addition, we think that there is scope to improve the quality of services for vulnerable groups such as children, vulnerable adults and people with a disability. More generally, we know that there is limited monitoring of and reporting on the quality of care provided. The report highlights some examples of quality monitoring and reporting, but such approaches are not consistent across the country.Finally, given that the demand for emergency services is continuing to rise, it is important that everyone involved in such services in the NHS and social work work together to make the best use of resources. Medical and nursing staff in the emergency departments that we surveyed registered concerns about referrals to emergency departments, particularly from NHS 24. We think that there is scope for NHS boards, the Scottish Ambulance Service and NHS 24 to improve information sharing to meet patients’ needs. All emergency departments should have access to care plans and get advance warning of patients who are being brought to the department by ambulance, but that does not always happen across Scotland.There is a perception among emergency department staff of a growing number of inappropriate self-referrals, but we know—and have had it confirmed in a wide range of research—that it is difficult to define who those patients are. However, we think that there is limited evidence that the health service has explored real alternatives to emergency departments, whether they be minor injuries units or other ways of meeting that need, or has assessed properly the impact of those alternatives. That seems to us to be a very important direction for the future of these services and to ensure that they are sustainable in the longer term. NHS boards have been asked to prepare local targets for what they will do to reduce attendances at emergency departments and are due to publish those targets later in the year. I hope that that has been helpful. The team and I will do our best to answer your questions.
Thank you very much, Caroline.Something that has often struck me about A and E services is that they are, as you have indicated, under a great deal of pressure. However, with the changes to out-of-hours doctor support, people who are desperate for medical advice and treatment, often when children are involved, do not stop to consider the niceties of whom they should go to. All they want is some support and A and E is the most obvious and visible medical help available. Moreover, it can be quite time-consuming to contact NHS 24 or your own out-of-hours service. Do we have any quantification of how many cases are being dealt with by accident and emergency that could be better dealt with by other parts of the health service?
It is difficult to define exactly which patients need to be in emergency departments and which patients do not. Our estimate is that a little over half of the people who turn up at an emergency department could be classified as having minor injuries or illnesses, rather than the serious ones for which those departments are designed. The question of where else those people might have gone is a complex one, however. First, patients do not always know about the alternatives that are open to them. Secondly, the number of patients who arrive at emergency departments who are referred by either general practitioners or NHS 24 is very small. It is about 4 per cent for NHS 24 and 10 per cent for GPs. The whole question of who is being treated in emergency departments and whether that is the best place for them is ripe for exploration, and that is one reason why we are concerned that the NHS is not collecting better information about the patients who arrive and the quality of care that they get.
I anticipate that the committee will wish to examine this subject more closely, but is there anything that members wish Caroline Gardner to clarify at this stage?
I have a follow-up question on the point about changes to GP out-of-hours cover. The report contains a helpful discussion on the matter at page 11. There has been a 9.4 per cent increase in attendances at emergency departments over the past 10 years. You acknowledge in paragraph 23 of the report:“It is possible that a lack of available alternative services may be another cause of differences in rates of attendance across Scotland, for example if GP services are limited.”I assume that you mean out-of-hours services. When you produced your report, the British Medical Association Scotland issued a press release in response. It states:“The report confirms that rising demand is not the result of the new GP contract introduced in 2004.”I do not think that your report actually says that. Do you have any comment on that?
We say that we cannot tell. At the moment, it is not clear that patients are being treated in the right place. More than half of them appear to have minor illnesses and injuries, rather than more serious ones. On the other hand, only 10 per cent of patients are being referred by their GPs, and that figure has not changed significantly over the last period. There is a question there.The wider issue is that, across the NHS in Scotland, we need to know more about which patients are in A and E and whether there is a more appropriate place for them to be treated, which might be closer to home, with more flexible treatment that could be better value for money. At the moment, we do not know.There is probably also an effect from the fact that the standard time for treatment in A and E is four hours, whereas it is 48 hours for a GP appointment. Some patients going to an A and E department will have been affected by that factor—rather than waiting for an appointment with a GP. The situation is complex and it needs to be better understood.
It sounds like the BMA is putting a bit of a spin on your report that is perhaps not justified.
Its comment certainly goes further than we have gone.
I was interested to note a reference in paragraph 49 to the cost of patients who attend emergency departments but who leave before receiving treatment. The report says that, in 2008-09, 9,500 people were“brought to hospital by ambulance, at a cost of £2.3 million”,but presumably they decided that they could not be bothered waiting, or they were not really all that unwell, and they just wandered off home. It seems extraordinary that 9,500 people in Scotland feel so unwell that they phone up to get an ambulance, but decide when they get to hospital that they are not really that ill after all. Can you tell us what is being done to try and reduce those figures?
I will ask Claire Sweeney or Angela Canning to answer the second part of that question. On the overall picture, you are right to say that it is an extraordinary figure. We know that the situation is more complex than it looks, however. We know that some of those patients will have been removed from emergency departments by the police—they will have been brought in drunk and when they started to come round they will have caused a disturbance and been removed. It is a complex picture.
There is a general point in the report about the need for education for people using the service. A lot of work has been done to explain to people which services are available, where they can go and when they should use them. There is a message there about how people are using services. The point has already been made about the lack of clarity. The system is very confusing for people to find their way around but, throughout the report, we have identified definite ways in which the service could be managed more efficiently. That is not the emergency departments themselves; I am talking about working with partners such as the Ambulance Service and NHS 24.
I have worked in accident and emergency departments and alcohol consumption has a great deal to do with it, although people get the chance to sober up during the four hours that they sometimes have to wait.Triage has made a huge difference to prioritising illness. Things move on much more effectively than they did previously. However, some hospitals are simply much busier than others. In some areas, more people use the hospital accident and emergency department than in others. The numbers must affect the percentage of people who are seen within the four-hour period. Does the report mention that at all?
Claire Sweeney will pick up on that.
One of the challenges that we faced with the report was trying to build up a picture of who is using the service. It comes through quite clearly that there is little information available about what is coming through the door. Even the triage categories are very broad. It is difficult to get a handle on complexity and case mix. We struggled with that because the information is just not there at the national level. We were not able to go on to make some of the conclusions that we would have liked to have made about the impact of the complexity of the work on cost, activity, and cases seen per staff member because the information is not collected in that way—it is not available.
Information is collected that way in the hospitals, so I am quite surprised that it is not made available. I imagine that the health boards collate it in some way, but I do not know whether it goes into national figures.
There is something. Two exhibits in the report give indications about triage and the condition in which people come through the door, but they are such broad categories that they are relatively meaningless in terms of our trying to understand which patients could be seen in, for example, a primary care setting. It is difficult to see that from the information that we have.
Exhibit 13 mentions Monday and Saturday attendances. Apart from the period between midnight and 8 o’clock in the morning, attendances are higher on a Monday than on a Saturday. That seems to be counterintuitive.
We also thought that that looked odd. The pattern is the same in England and it appears to be because of patients who go to their GP on a Monday morning and are found to be ill enough to require referral at that stage. That is particularly true of elderly patients.
Thank you for that. We will come back to the report at a later point in the agenda, and when we come to our conclusion, you will be somewhere warmer, Ms Gardner.
I will be thinking of you.
I am sure that you will. Good luck; it is a fantastic opportunity and I am sure that you will do well.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Sep 2010 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 603
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 28
- 10:00 Section 22 Report Committee business · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.