Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Tree Preservation Orders (PE1340)

Tuesday 7 September 2010 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 25 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

25 contributions
The Convener
link

The second new petition is PE1340, by John Scott, on behalf of Neilston and district community council. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to extend and simplify the system of tree preservation orders to give all trees protection similar to that which is enjoyed by trees in conservation areas.I welcome John Scott from Neilston and district community council, and Jill Butler, who is conservation adviser to the Woodland Trust. One of you is invited to make an opening statement of no more than three minutes, after which members will have the opportunity to ask questions. I thank you for the additional information that has been provided to members.

John Scott Neilston and District Community Council
link

Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. As has already been mentioned, I am here on behalf of Neilston and district community council. I thank the Public Petitions Committee for inviting us here and giving us the opportunity to discuss the petition.We have come together as a community to improve the protection of mature and ancient trees, not only in our local area but throughout Scotland. We feel extremely strongly about the continued loss of trees from our communities, which often happens for the most trivial of reasons. Unfortunately, the problem seems to be getting worse every year. We believe that the current system and, indeed, some of the proposals that are set out in the Scottish Government’s recent consultation on TPOs do not adequately protect the important trees in our communities, so we would like to see changes to the legislation and the tree protection system in order to give all trees a similar level of protection to that which is enjoyed by trees in conservation areas.Scotland is already at the forefront of tree conservation, with imaginative projects such as the big tree project, which is rescuing and conserving some of the world’s most threatened conifers from as far away as Brazil and Chile and replanting them in the Perthshire woodlands. It is both historically and culturally important and has a potentially long-term tourist benefit.Unfortunately, however, the majority of our own home-grown and—dare I say it?—less glamorous trees have little or no protection. I offer a brief example that I mention in the petition. Between the villages of Neilston and Uplawmoor there is a 2 mile long avenue of beech trees, which are about 150 years old. At one point on the road, they are straddled by power lines on tall pylons. I am not talking about small pylons; I am talking about your big 142,000kV pylons. Every four to five years those trees used to be trimmed back by Scottish Power for obvious health and safety reasons. One summer afternoon this year, three trees on each side of the road—a total of six mature beech trees—were cut down and put through the chipper. The answer to the question why Scottish Power did it is that rather than trim the trees every four or five years, it is cheaper just to chop them down and that is your problem solved forever.Neilston and district community council and Uplawmoor community council approached East Renfrewshire Council and asked it to at least write to Scottish Power to ask why it cut down the trees without any consultation and whether it would consider replanting semi-mature trees in their place. The council was unwilling to do so and said that the trees had no protection and it was not really within its remit to do so. Unfortunately, after all this time we have mature trees without any protection.There are problems with tree protection in Scotland. When the Scottish Government started to consider changes to the Planning Act 2008, the input on trees was supplied mainly by external consultants. They are good consultants who know all about planning, but they are not exactly tree experts. The people with the knowledge and experience in the field—the Woodland Trust and the ancient tree forum—lobbied hard but unsuccessfully for a change to the TPO regulations.The local authority approach to trees also varies considerably, as was mentioned in Roger Jessop’s report, which I also mentioned in the original petition. In East Renfrewshire Council we have one planning officer who deals with trees, tree protection orders and maintenance. To put that into perspective, East Renfrewshire Council covers 174km2, is classed as being 85 per cent rural and has a total of 73 tree preservation orders in place. That is one tree preservation order per 2.5km2.Although the concept of having some sort of protection order for every tree in Scotland would be an ideal, it is vital that we acknowledge and identify our trees of greatest value and make sure that they are adequately safeguarded. We need a system that identifies such trees and their value to our communities at both local and national levels, and which ensures that owners are aware of trees’ significance.At present, conservation areas are determined by the architecture or historical value of the buildings within a village, town or settlement. The protection of trees in conservation areas has been included almost as an accidental by-product of the legislation. As a practical approach, we could develop one of the concepts in our petition, which calls for the extension to“all trees a protection similar to that enjoyed by trees in conservation areas”to at least have areas or groups of trees in Scotland designated as tree conservation areas. For example, those might be avenues of trees leading into a village or within a village, groups of trees in the countryside, groups of important trees in a garden or designed landscape in the Scottish inventory, even within a town. The trees within such designated tree conservation areas would enjoy the same protection as trees within the present conservation areas—that is, any proposed tree works would have to be notified to the local authority before any work was carried out. The identification of such proposed tree conservation areas could be led by community groups submitting their proposals to the local authorities.We earnestly ask the Scottish Parliament as a matter of urgency to examine and enhance the legislation to protect and ensure the conservation of trees in Scotland. As I mentioned, I have with me Jill Butler from the Woodland Trust Scotland and the ancient tree forum to help to answer any questions. Jill Butler has many years’ experience of tree conservation both with the Woodland Trust and the ancient tree forum and has a long-standing interest in the protection of trees and woodland in Scotland and throughout the UK.

Robin Harper
link

Again, I refer people to the register of interests and my membership of several woodland trusts including Carrifran wildwood and the Woodland Trust Scotland.I was involved in trying to get some improvements to the legislation back in 2007, but was sadly ineffective. Would it be even a start to have a presumption against the cutting down of mature trees and an injunction that notification of intention with several months’ notice should always be given before such a tree be attacked?My second question is tangential to the petition as it stands, and is about the extra recognition that you and I feel should be given to trees that could be identified as being of great historic and cultural significance. There are not so many of them, but there is no special recognition of their value or special protection for them under the legislation as it stands. Do you want to make any observations on that?

John Scott Neilston and District Community Council
link

The answer to your first question is emphatically, “Yes.” We would like there to be a presumption against felling. Your second question about ancient trees and so on falls more within Jill’s territory. They would require special protection in addition to conservation.

Jill Butler Woodland Trust
link

Conservation is the mechanism, but at the moment the historic and architectural interests of conservation areas drive the system and it sweeps up trees as part of that. We are asking only for a very modest step to be taken to broaden that concept for designation of conservation areas to include trees. We believe that the system that we propose would be effective because all that would be required is a notification system for the owner of the trees. It is relatively straightforward for the local authority to manage notifications in such a way as to give permission for works to go ahead in the majority of cases, if it is happy with that. The system that we would prefer is therefore very simple.Scotland has an international heritage of important trees and our current system means that many of our most important trees have no protection whatever, so someone could cut them down without doing anything legally wrong—we are not accusing people of that—whereas many other trees, particularly those in conservation areas, are extremely modest, if not relatively unimportant, but are protected. That is an anomaly and we are not balancing the situation very well.It is also unfair for tree owners. On the one hand, a tree owner with an important tree has no need to notify anyone or to pay any money to manage that tree, while on the other hand someone who lives in a conservation area or who has a tree protection order, which usually means that the tree is important, faces a big burden. The system that we have at the moment is very unfair.We would like communities to be involved in identifying areas of rich and important trees. The concept behind conservation areas is that communities get involved in the process of identifying those areas: we have, through our ancient tree hunt project, demonstrated during the past four years that communities are interested in that process.I can give you any number of examples. For example, in south-west Scotland, Cally Palace park, which is on the register of landscape gardens and historic parks, and Cardoness Castle, which is not, have superb trees, but neither of them will have protection for those trees. We are looking for a mechanism to introduce conservation areas for such incredibly rich collections of trees. Generally speaking, we are talking about areas that have many highly important trees with many ownerships. The conservation area approach is very cost-effective in such circumstances.15:00

John Scott Neilston and District Community Council
link

I will add one thing from my experience. At the moment, a developer who wants to build houses in an area where there are mature trees must submit to the council their plans for which trees they would leave and which they would remove. That is all agreed with the council and, if there are trees to be retained, the council will apply the legislation. I do not know the exact British standard, but the trees have to be fenced off and protected and no damage must be done to them in the course of the development. However, as happened where I stay, once the houses pass into private ownership, that protection lapses and some owners chop the trees down because they do not like their gutters getting full of leaves or having leaves in their driveways. Believe it or not, that has happened. We are protected from the developers but not from householders. There is something wrong with that.

Jill Butler Woodland Trust
link

We know from arboricultural contractors and surveyors who are involved in such developments that, in certain cases, before they are invited in to do their presentations before a project goes to planning application, the developer cuts down the trees because they know that they are important and do not want them in the way, which would jeopardise their planning application. We have the evidence that that is happening.

Nanette Milne
link

You took the words out of my mouth. I was going to cite an instance from when I was a council member of beautiful trees being felled just ahead of a planning application’s being submitted. It was very frustrating even though the trees were obviously not protected.I have a lot of sympathy with what you propose. However, given that councils are under significant pressure and that there might be only one tree expert in a large council area, would it place an even greater burden on councils? Having heard you, I am not sure that that would necessarily be the case. Would it increase or, perhaps, decrease the load on them?

Jill Butler Woodland Trust
link

It would, if it were introduced, be one tool in the package of tools that the local authority would have. Authorities would be able to choose the right tools for the right circumstances. There would still be a notification process, but we would bring many trees into that process under the same auspices and it would be simpler.If the community encouraged the owners of 75 per cent of the trees to realise that they were living in an important tree area, it would probably work to ensure that the trees were looked after and the notifications would just be a question of ticking a box. We want to move to proactive engagement with the community to ensure that it values what it lives in.I do not underestimate how valuable such areas are. Recent research says that avenues such as the one that John Scott mentioned reduce speed and save lives. There are all sorts of benefits. We know about climate benefits. Mature trees are more important for those, as well as being important for health benefits and the value of properties.We need to shift into a much more explanatory role. If we introduce a conservation area approach, it will be more possible for communities that have been designated as important to draw down money from sources other than the local authority to help them to manage the trees in highly effective ways such as tree trails, awareness raising, events and publicity.

Nanette Milne
link

I envisaged that the notification would go to the council, which would be obliged to verify it. Would it have to go and check every tree in an area that was notified? However, if communities were to be much more proactive, I can see where you are coming from.

Jill Butler Woodland Trust
link

The notification process applies even to small trees. Mechanisms could be introduced through regulation, including raising the threshold for the size of tree that requires notification. It is important that the measures should be uniform across Scotland. We are concerned about that aspect of the latest TPO consultation. We do not want differences between one local authority and another. That would give the lawyers a licence to play off one authority against another in the courts; an owner in one local authority area could come under one set of rules and an owner in another authority under a different set of rules. That would be an onerous system that would be not only unfair but hugely confusing and difficult to manage. Indeed, over time, it would become an enormous burden. We are very concerned about the proposed changes to the model order. We are looking for improvements to TPOs and conservation areas so that the tools work as effectively as possible for tree protection. At the moment, trees are falling through the net. That is a serious situation.

John Wilson Central Scotland) (SNP
link

A number of years ago, I had experience of a local authority taking responsibility for topping an avenue of lime trees. I mention this in respect of the conflict that arises when local authority officers give their authority the go-ahead to top trees that have a TPO. The example also raises the issue of the application of TPOs by local authorities. You talked of a six-week notification period for consultation and raised the issue of local authorities interpreting the regulations differently. The community council has raised the question of conflict between a local authority and a local community. I referred to an authority removing an avenue of trees. An authority can get into conflict with a community because the community wants a preservation order placed on a tree or trees and the authority disagrees with the need for a TPO. Is the six-week notification period sufficient time in which to allow a community to be engaged in the consultation process? How can we ensure that authorities get the right solution to the issues that have been raised?

Jill Butler Woodland Trust
link

You are saying that if there was a conservation area for trees, would the six-week period be sufficient for consultation to take place?

John Wilson Central Scotland) (SNP
link

My concern is consultation with communities. If we are talking about communities being engaged in the process, surely they need to be consulted. At the moment, if a developer or someone else wants to remove trees, they need only consult the local authority. I understand that there is no onus on the authority to consult the local community.

Jill Butler Woodland Trust
link

In conservation areas, which are mainly for buildings, the strong guidance is that authorities should set up community involvement in area management plans. We are very supportive of longer-term management plans that set out what is expected in the community. Such plans would operate over five years and not require a lot of detail. We agree that the same standards that apply to a private owner should apply to local authorities in managing their own trees. We are not certain that that is happening as effectively as possible at the moment. We need a mechanism by which to determine the value of trees. Obviously, local authority resources have to go to the most important trees. We need a national register, beneath which would be a register of regional value trees and one for local value trees. Such a mechanism would enable resources to go to the most important trees as a priority. People will know which trees in their community are the most important, and when resources are tight they will ensure that resources go in that direction. We need such a system, not one that results in notifications for very small trees where the impact of losing them would be small. Resources must not be taken away from the more important trees.We feel that there is an opportunity for more reallocation of resources, but we need to have a tree conservation area tool in the toolbox so that when local authorities consider whether they have the right tree in the right place and do tree and forest strategies as part of the trees and woodlands strategy approach, they can follow that up by giving wonderful areas of trees conservation area-type designations.

John Scott Neilston and District Community Council
link

I would like to add to that. At the moment, there is a statutory obligation to consult community councils if any development work is to be done, regardless of whether it involves trees being felled. In addition, if someone wants to do any tree work in a conservation area, whether it is trimming or whatever, they have to fill in a form and state in their application the extent of the work and the reason for it. I think that having to put in such applications helps to focus people’s minds. For example, someone who wanted to chop down a tree simply because it was making a mess of their driveway would realise, “Oh no. Maybe that is not an acceptable reason for removing a tree.” Apart from anything else, having to sit down and put in writing why they want to carry out tree works raises people’s general awareness and appreciation of trees in the environment.

The Convener
link

Thanks very much. Do members have suggestions about where we should go with the petition?

Nanette Milne
link

Again, we need to get in touch with the Government and ask what its views are on what the petitioners propose. Some valid points have been made, which potentially offer a good way forward on the preservation of the country’s important trees.

The Convener
link

Absolutely. Anyone else?

Robin Harper
link

It might be useful to write to a selection of local authorities and—given that what is proposed has workload implications—the National Association of Tree Officers and the Royal Town Planning Institute, as well as the Forestry Commission and the Woodland Trust. We should ask them to address the issues that have been raised about TPOs and the idea of having a presumption against the felling of trees. That would be a simple way forward.

The Convener
link

Okay.

John Wilson Central Scotland) (SNP
link

I suggest that we also write to the RSPB and the Scottish Wildlife Trust because, as a member of both organisations, I know that they own extensive areas of land. In the past, the RSPB has been involved in clearing land of particular types of trees, so it would be useful to get its view on the proposals in the petition.

The Convener
link

Yes. Thanks for that.

Robin Harper
link

It has occurred to me that two other organisations—Historic Scotland and the National Trust for Scotland—might have some useful observations to make. I should add that I am a member of both those organisations.

The Convener
link

I thank the witnesses very much for their evidence.

  1. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 53
  2. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 25
  3. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 5
  5. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  19. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  20. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  21. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  22. 14:00 New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.