Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Wild Salmon and Sea Trout (Protection) (PE1336)

Tuesday 7 September 2010 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 53 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

53 contributions
The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the 12th meeting in 2010 of the Public Petitions Committee. I hope that you all had a good summer recess.We have received no apologies; I understand that Bill Butler will come later. I ask everyone to ensure that all mobile phones and other electronic devices are switched off—I have checked mine.Agenda item 1 is consideration of new petitions, of which we have a considerable number—13 in total—today, although eight of those relate to the same issue and will be considered together. We will take oral evidence on the first two petitions.The first new petition is PE1336, from Lawson Devery on behalf of the Salmon and Trout Association, which calls on the Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take immediate action to protect wild salmon and sea trout stocks from inappropriate commercial fish farm activities by taking action to ensure that all sea-based fish farms are moved away from the estuaries of major wild salmon rivers to reduce the impact of sea lice; and to ban the operation of salmon smolt farms in any wild salmon river system.I welcome to the table Lawson Devery, Paul Knight and George Holdsworth. One of you is invited to make an opening statement of no more than three minutes, after which members will have the opportunity to ask questions. The floor is yours.

Lawson Devery Salmon and Trout Association
link

I would like my chief executive to make the statement.

The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

That is fine.

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

The Salmon and Trout Association would like to thank the Public Petitions Committee for giving us this opportunity to provide evidence to the fish farming debate.The fish farming industry is still largely self-regulated with regard to its impacts on wild fish, with a voluntary code of practice and area management agreements. That results, for instance, in Norwegian companies being able to operate in Scotland under less stringent regulation than apply in their own country, especially when it comes to the siting of smolt units in freshwater lochs. Even the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2007, which was supposed to tighten up on malpractice, relies on fish farmers to report escapes and other incidents. Unsurprisingly, there has not been one prosecution since the act came into force.Meanwhile, a recent review of the code of practice removed all reference to wild fish. Their protection appears to be no longer an issue, let alone a priority, for fish farmers. Rather, the industry purports to operate sustainably, but the fact that it fails to recognise any environmental problems is especially alarming, given its plans for future expansion.The underlying principle of our petition is to ask the committee three specific questions. First, why does the Scottish Government allow salmon farms to operate to standards that are below those that are required to protect wild fish? Secondly, why does it allow international fish farming companies to operate under less stringent environmental constraints than apply in their home countries? Thirdly, why does it allow the siting of smolt farms in freshwater lochs with natural salmon populations?We freely accept that salmon farming is important to Scotland, but so are wild salmon and sea trout fisheries. We want the two to co-exist, thereby maximising social and economic benefits to communities. That cannot be achieved by allowing fish farming to ignore its impacts on legitimate neighbouring businesses. The Scottish Government must face up to its international responsibilities and use its regulatory system to set environmental standards that will genuinely protect wild fish.Relocation will be key in many areas, but that offers Government and industry positive win-win opportunities. Encouraging fish farming on the open sea in return for closing controversial inshore sites near important wild fisheries will allow the industry to expand, wild fisheries to recover and animosity to be removed, but that will require the Government to oblige the industry to think creatively rather than simply deny that there is a problem. We therefore challenge the Government to take four immediate actions: to participate in drawing up a list of sensitive wild fish catchments; to agree to the premise that no new farms be permitted on sites that are identified on that list; to encourage industry expansion into large offshore units; and to close down existing sites that are identified on the sensitive list and remove all cage units from river systems that contain wild salmon populations.Finally, ladies and gentlemen, never forget that Scottish salmon is marketed on the back of one of Scotland’s most iconic and precious natural resources: the wild salmon that flourish in Scottish lochs and rivers. Destroy the latter and the former becomes just another commodity.

The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

Thank you, Mr Knight.

Nanette Milne North East Scotland) (Con
link

Under recent legislation, it is planned that Marine Scotland will regulate new fish farms in the areas that you talked about. Do you know when that legislation will come into force?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

Personally, no. We have not heard anything for sure yet. The basic problem is that, although in the 15 years for which I have been dealing with this, man and boy, we have heard a lot of talk—there is a new act, as you know—nothing concrete ever happens on the ground and we still have the impact of fish farming. We feel that it is now time for action. I reiterate that no one wants to see fish farming go away—quite the opposite. The two industries have to co-exist side by side. If they do not, the marketing of Scottish farmed fish will suffer over time. We have farmed fish, but they are destroying an iconic natural resource. When people think of Scotland, they think first of whisky and then of salmon—it is that iconic. We are saying, “Don’t have one and destroy the other.”

Nanette Milne North East Scotland) (Con
link

And Norway has set the example.

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

It has indeed.

Nanette Milne North East Scotland) (Con
link

When did it do that?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

Norway introduced a statutory measure at the beginning of the year to deal with the major problem of sea lice. Whereas in Norway there is a statutory limit of 0.1 lice per fish, the Scottish industry works to a voluntary limit of 0.5 lice per fish. There is a big discrepancy there. We are worried about the impact of the statutory versus the voluntary.

Nanette Milne North East Scotland) (Con
link

And the new act does not cover that.

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

We do not believe so. Again, we have not seen chapter and verse.

Robin Harper Lothians) (Green
link

I am not sure whether this counts as a declaration of interest, convener, but, as you and others know, I have been concerned about this area for the past 12 years, ever since I was elected to the Parliament. I have asked many questions on the subject and tried to find some way of getting successive Governments to make the kind of improvements that the Salmon and Trout Association is asking for. I am thoroughly biased; I am on the petitioners’ side. I thought that I ought to declare that interest. A large proportion of the industry on the west coast is now owned by Norwegians. I assume that all the profits go to Norway. Do you see any sign of any extra investment in the west coast as a result of the Norwegian involvement in fish farming?

George Holdsworth Salmon and Trout Association
link

The majority of fish faming is Norwegian owned, so most of the profits go back to Norway, as is the case with any organisation that works in a foreign land. If I am being polite, I could say that, arguably, the level of investment in the area is not as high as it could be. We feel that the Norwegians are trying to make a fast not a sustainable profit. The company makes a good profit, but the environment is damaged and the Scottish community does not get the full benefit of its natural resource. I stress again that we are not anti-fish farming. Fish farming is a positive thing to do but, as with any industry, we do not want fish farming to destroy an aspect of the environment. The proportion of profit that is held back for the local community is not significant, whereas it is well known that all the proceeds of angling stay in the country. It is well known—VisitScotland statistics back this up—that anglers are one of the highest-spending tourist sectors in Scotland, if not the highest spending. According to published figures, angling brings more money into the Scottish economy than golf does.14:15

Robin Harper Lothians) (Green
link

My second question is about smolt rearing in freshwater lochs. You will be aware that I have made a little bit of progress with the minister. I have had two meetings with Roseanna Cunningham and a committee has been set up to consider whether closed containment is the way forward for smolt rearing in Scotland, particularly because salmon are being marketed as Scottish when the smolts come from Norway, are reared somewhere in East Anglia and then brought on as salmon for a few weeks in a Scottish loch—I thought that I would slip that by people’s attention. However, I have recently learned that there is only one representative of wild fish interests on the closed containment committee. Would you recommend that the Government see its way to ensuring that wild fish interests are better represented on the committee that has been set up to examine the protection of freshwater lochs by improving the way that we raise smolts, preferably by removing them from fresh water altogether?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

Yes. That is imperative for credibility. The foundation of what we say is that, for the future credibility of the marketing of Scottish farmed salmon, wild fish interests must be taken into account. We really feel that the fact that the review of the code of practice has taken out all reference to wild fish is tantamount to a kick in the teeth. We have only to consider the marketing of tuna and other species. Very few tuna that are sold in supermarkets are not labelled as coming from a sustainable resource and being caught in a sustainable manner. Salmon farming must face up to the same issues, so I would go along with what you say entirely.In Norway, it is not permitted to farm in freshwater systems that have access to wild fish—that is just verboten. Why is it allowed in this country?

Robin Harper Lothians) (Green
link

I wish that I could answer that. However, I think that the answer is perfectly clear. As to my other question, would you welcome better representation on the closed containment committee?

George Holdsworth Salmon and Trout Association
link

Very much so, yes. That is a straight answer for you.

John Farquhar Munro Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD
link

Good afternoon, gentlemen. The petition that you are presenting covers a wide range of issues that affect salmon and sea trout up and down the west coast but is basically to do with whether sea cage fish farming of salmon and the problems that it is likely to cause have brought about the decline in salmon and sea trout. I have listened to that debate for many years. We do not seem to be getting anywhere, but it is obvious that the decline in salmon and sea trout on the west coast of Scotland is a drastic situation and that something must be done to address it.You mentioned the contrast between east and west. The rivers on the east coast of Scotland do not seem to have the same problem: they seem to have a healthy fishery, whereas those on the west coast of Scotland are almost denuded of salmon and sea trout. I know that because, in the past, I was a keen angler and I have been involved in salmon fishing, so I can see the decline from my own back door.What is the answer? The salmon and sea trout industry and those who have an interest in salmon and sea trout have campaigned for years to get the fish farming industry to address the situation, but nothing seems to happen. The fish farming industry says that it is doing everything legally if it does it under the current legislation, but who knows what happens at sea?I know that—this might provide some comfort—fish farming is now moving into much deeper waters. Fish farms are coming out of the inland lochs and going out into deeper waters, where there are stronger currents that can wash away the effluent and debris that emanate from the sea cages. Why has the industry not responded to claims that people such as you have been making for 20 years or more?

George Holdsworth Salmon and Trout Association
link

The answer is that any industry—not just fish farming—will try to reduce the amount of legislation that impinges on its ability to make a profit. That is just a fact. As my colleague pointed out, the fish farming industry has had only a voluntary code, whereby people say that they will do their best to do this or that. Of course there are good fish farmers—there is no question about that—but, as in any industry, there are also some who are not good. Our belief is that the code needs to be tied in with the legislative side. For example, the reporting of sea lice numbers on smolts and fish is a statutory requirement in Norway, whereas it is voluntary in Scotland. Any voluntary code will be broken. That does not happen just in fish farming but is a fact of life. We all agree that that can happen.We are saying not that sea lice have caused the collapse but that they are a massive contributing factor that could easily be identified. In theory, we could solve the problem very quickly. I do not suggest that we should suddenly shut down all fish farms in Scotland, but that could be done in theory. We do not want to do that. We could solve the problem by moving fish farms offshore, by changing the stocking densities and by doing many other things.However, although the fish farming industry is partly moving offshore, much of it is still not moving offshore. My understanding is that only the increase in production—not the existing capacity—is moving offshore. In addition to the X million tonnes per year produced inshore, production will be increased offshore, especially following the collapse in Chile’s Atlantic salmon fishing due to disease and so on. Obviously, fish farmers here believe that they can now increase production because they now have more of a market to sell in. We are not moving production but increasing it.As you say, we still have the problem on the west coast that there has been a complete collapse of salmon and sea trout, with massive damage to the local tourism economy. In the Western Isles, the last-reported survey showed that only 12 per cent of all tourism spend is on angling. That figure should be higher, but it is decreasing. The reason why it is decreasing is that the number of fish is decreasing. Angling is a sustainable resource that we can use to market our own rural economy.I hope that that answers your question.

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

A further point is that there has been very little consumer pressure for change. Following consumer pressure over the fishing of tuna and various other species, people got Marine Stewardship Council certification. However, that sort of consumer pressure does not exist yet for salmon. We have tried to lobby and influence Parliament and the industry, but that has not worked. The petition seeks to rekindle that relationship, in the hope that the issue can be sorted out in this place. If that does not happen in the short term, I think that our lobbying must change tack and we must start talking to retailers. Every supermarket in the UK that sells farmed product says that it is farmed from responsible sources. With the best will in the world, there is not enough responsibly farmed salmon in Scotland to stock one set of supermarkets, let alone all the supermarket chains. Consumer-led pressure will always change systems, but we have not had that so far. We would prefer that to happen through this place without the need for that wider pressure.

John Farquhar Munro Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD
link

We can all point a finger at the fish farming industry one way or another, but what about predation at sea, before the salmon hit the coast? There is deepwater drift netting for salmon and there is a proliferation of seals on the west coast. What is the argument against the suggestion that there is a broader issue to do with predation?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

Your question takes us back to what George Holdsworth said. The Salmon and Trout Association has just completed a review of 137 peer-reviewed scientific papers—members have a copy of the report. We know that aquaculture is impacting on wild fish and we can do something about that.We have cut down fairly drastically on human predation at sea off Greenland and the Faroe Islands. The Faroe Islands no longer fish and Greenland has a subsistence tonnage of about 20 tonnes a year, which is just for internal consumption. As you said, that has had a real impact and some of the east coast rivers are doing pretty well at the moment.However, fish farming is still having an impact and we can do something about that. We can do nothing about the gulf stream or the north Atlantic oscillation; we can do something about aquaculture and fish farming, to ensure that there is more responsible farming. Let us do something about it. That is what we are saying.

Nigel Don North East Scotland) (SNP
link

My first question is perhaps technical, but it has emerged from what you said in the petition. You talked about escapees breeding with wild fish and “diluting natural gene pools”. It is obvious that escapees might dilute the gene pool, but so what? What is the issue?

George Holdsworth Salmon and Trout Association
link

We are now finding that in different rivers the wild salmon have a unique genetic imprint. Indeed, in some rivers there might be four or five different genetic strains. The main problem with the growing of smolts in fresh water is that escapees that come from Norwegian rather than west coast stock can interbreed with the wild fish, which changes the genetic make-up. All research into not just fish but all wild animals shows that, once that starts to happen, an animal’s ability to survive in the wild drops dramatically—it drops by a massive amount.The situation is unlike that of farming, where we can bring in different genetic strains because we are dealing with domesticated animals, which we look after. Wild fish are adapted to survive in a specific river, given the river’s flow, acidity or whatever. When we start to dilute the gene pool, there can be unbelievable problems, because the fish do not spawn properly when they come back and do not survive as well as they used to. In theory, the whole system can crash.

Nigel Don North East Scotland) (SNP
link

Do scientists think that the genetic make-up is part of what brings the salmon back to a particular stream?

George Holdsworth Salmon and Trout Association
link

That is absolutely correct, and it is not just about coming back to a particular stream. Through Marine Scotland, a huge amount of work is being done on the genetics of salmon. The research is moving far faster than my brain will ever go and is accelerating all the time. It is not just a question of one strain in a single river, as we used to think; research shows that, even in a quarter-mile section of a river, there might be a completely unique strain. Fish will go to that part of the river to breed with the other fish there. Once we bring in alien strains, the system can start to collapse.

Nigel Don North East Scotland) (SNP
link

Thank you for clarifying that. For folk who are unfamiliar with the ways of salmon, that will have meant absolutely nothing. I do not know much about salmon, but I understood what you said.On a different matter, I think that I understand what you are asking for, but does the Government or the Parliament have the power to do what you want? Talking is easy, but do we need statutory instruments or guidance on the matter? Do we need new primary legislation?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

No. You had new primary legislation, in the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2007. We think that the Government has extensive powers under the 2007 act, which it is not using. We need a statutory approach and we need the industry to come on board. The industry must be made to see that what we seek is in its best interests.I would far rather take a partnership approach. Nobody wants to go to the marketing director of Tesco and say, “Do you realise what you are selling?” That is the last thing that we want to do. We want to see action taken by the Government with the full connivance of the industry.As I said, we have been trying for 15 years, and it is not happening yet. That is the reason for the petition, which has been signed by 17,000 people. There is a lot of deep feeling behind it. Let us start again and see whether we can get something moving under your auspices.14:30

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

That was a helpful question and a helpful response. You want the powers that we already have to be enforced by the appropriate agencies. That takes me on to the question that I intended to ask. In the information that was provided to support the petition, you make the point that the North Atlantic Salmon Conservation Organization has said officially that“conflicts of interest can arise in jurisdictions where the same department is responsible for managing both aquaculture and wild salmon, which is the case in the Scottish Government.”You go on to make the linked point that“Conflicts can also arise when the same department is responsible for promotion of aquaculture and its regulation.”Which department should be responsible for your organisation and for regulation and support of your sport?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

I invite George Holdsworth to respond.

George Holdsworth Salmon and Trout Association
link

Why pick me? Laughter. I spend a lot of time working with Marine Scotland. Most of the time, we find it very good. The problem is that there is a conflict between aquaculture and the wild side; that is the most fundamental point. Much of the time, we get on well. It goes back to the point that Paul Knight made: if everyone would sit down, admit that there is a problem and see whether it can be sorted out, for everyone’s benefit—especially the long-term, sustainable benefit of the Scottish economy—there is no reason for the current arrangement not to continue.I have been dealing with the issue for 15 years—since I still had hair. The problem is that we have found that the fish farming industry is almost in a state of denial about certain things, so that we hit a wall. If all the industries would sit down and admit that there is common ground and all of us want the same thing, I see no reason to split up the sector at the moment—that would cause more confusion and, to be blunt, a lot more expense to the Scottish Parliament, which we definitely do not want to do. Paul Knight is right—we can move forward if people are willing to do so. If Marine Scotland helps us to move forward to common ground, with proper, balanced representation on different committees, we can do so, possibly quite quickly in relative terms.

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

In the next paragraph of the information that we have received, the Salmon and Trout Association expresses the view that“The Scottish Government’s record on regulating aquaculture means that it is falling short of its international responsibilities and obligations”.That is quite a serious charge. Would the obligations be fulfilled if everyone were to sit around the table and iron out their differences?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

No. As we have said, we have been sitting around a table and talking for at least 15 years. We have reached the stage at which we must have action. Every year I go to the NASCO meeting, which is a week out of our year in some far-flung part of the world. This year was the year of aquaculture, which is the big issue in Canada, America and Norway. As I am sure you know, Norway produces about 700,000 tonnes of salmon a year. Scotland now produces 140,000 or 150,000 tonnes, but production in Chile has collapsed. The international salmon world is saying, “Have we learned and are we learning the lessons from Chile? This could happen off Scotland—like that.” However, all the Scottish industry is saying, “Great—Chile’s gone. We can bring the tonnage to Scotland.” That is the wrong attitude. Let us sit back and think how we can make salmon fish farming sustainable in this country alongside sustainable wild fisheries.I do not want to digress too much, but let us take the example of the Loch Maree and Loch Ewe system. There is a big fish farm in Loch Ewe. Loch Maree used to be the finest sea trout fishery in the world. We have about 15,000 members and, if I am at a game fair, the biggest issue that members raise when they come to my stand is still, “My goodness—I wish we could still go to Loch Maree.” People used to come from all over the world to fish Maree, but it is now not worth fishing. The hotel there used to employ nine boatmen; it now employs one. Yes, the fish farm employs people—that is all that we hear about in the press: that the fish farm is the big employer. However, nobody talks about the eight boatmen who lost their jobs.We are saying that, if the fish farm operation were moved out to a safe distance, so that fishing at Loch Maree returned and the hotel could start to employ staff and boatmen as a result, that would be a fantastic benefit to the whole community. We should not pass one off against the other—let us have both operating sustainably together. That can be done, but that involves not sitting around a table and talking about it but doing that and then going on to action, which we have not seen.

The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

I will slightly abuse my position as chair. I spent a good few of my years as a minister discussing the issue and was involved in putting through legislation that was seen as introducing a potentially effective system of regulation. Why is the regulatory framework not working?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

I think that it is just not being imposed. I have here a report from Lochaber Fisheries Trust, which has pretty much an official position—the Scottish Government gives it money to do much of its work. The trust surveyed about 90 parr on the Strontian River, of which 80 per cent were not genetically close to anything else in the Lochaber district. The trust is fairly certain that the parr come from farmed strain, but the local farm—I will not mention its name—will not give the trust samples on which to do genetic work.Our legal adviser tells us that, under section 5 of the 2007 act, the fish farm must give up samples for any type of official monitoring. If that is not being done, why not? If I am a fish farmer who is not giving a sample, why am I not doing so? You do not need to be Sherlock Holmes to sort that out; the fish farm is worried that its fish are polluting the gene banks of local rivers and will not give up samples until it is made to do so. As I said, our legal adviser says that those powers exist under section 5 of the 2007 act. Go in there and say, “Sorry guys—you’ve got to give us those samples.” Why is that not being done? We are putting such issues on the table.

The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

I have just one more question. I will be quick. Some fish farms have moved to other positions and away from sea lochs that did not have much current. Has research been done on that? Has sufficient time elapsed for us to draw conclusions about the impact of such movement?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

We reviewed 137 papers, but very little research has been done on specific areas, purely because the fish-farming industry has not wanted to get involved in that. However, there is a lot of circumstantial evidence, much of which comes from Ireland. On a river in south-west Ireland—I am ashamed to say that I do not remember its name—a fish farm was fallowed for a year, and the sea trout run returned by 12 per cent in just one year. The reason why is that when sea trout go to sea, they do not go off to Greenland and the Faroes as salmon do—they hug the coast and so are absolute sitting targets for lice. If those lice are taken out of the system, there are immediate benefits. Rather than the fish becoming lice burdened and either dying or coming back prematurely into freshwater and failing to breed, they can feed as nature intended and come back strongly.As I said, the circumstantial evidence is very strong. What we do not want is to say, “Let’s have another five or 10 years getting more scientific evidence”. We believe that the evidence exists, and our review shows that there is a very strong correlation between aquaculture and impacts on wild fish. Let us do something about it, and let us do it together. With all due respect, let us not prevaricate for another five or 10 years.

Nanette Milne North East Scotland) (Con
link

I presume that economics must come into the reasoning behind fish farms not wanting to move. Do you have any idea what it would cost a fish farm to move?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

That is an interesting question. The fish farmers themselves want to move offshore: they have said that they want, in order to take advantage of the lack of tonnage from Chile, to move to much larger units—I believe that we are talking about 5,000 tonne units—in deeper water.At the moment, however, they are not prepared to move and to get rid of their existing farms from inshore as well. Again, I am not a scientist and I cannot tell you the exact scientific impact of having a 6,000 tonne unit by taking away the 1,000 tonne unit and adding it to the 5,000 tonne unit. However, that is what we are saying: get rid of the controversial unit and have the farming offshore. That is the first stage.We agree very much with Mr Harper: our long-term aim, as we have said in our report, is for all fish farming to be closed containment. At the moment, that is probably asking a bit much economically, but we believe that we should start looking at that now—I know that Mr Harper is well up on this point. Norway is beginning to do it, and even China is doing it with their trout fisheries in freshwater lakes. Let us consider that so that, in 10 to 15 years, the industry can genuinely be closed containment, which would cut out all interaction between wild and farmed fish. In the meantime, there are steps that can be taken along that way, which we have set out in our paper. That is the long-term aim, but let us have some short-term to medium-term aims as well.

The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

Robin Harper—briefly, please.

Robin Harper Lothians) (Green
link

I will be as brief as I can.You have been advised that, legally, the fish farms should provide you with samples. A number of organisations are tasked with enforcing regulations. Is your lawyer saying that, as none of them has done anything, you will have to go to court to get those samples? Is that where we are?

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

That would be an option, but I must reiterate that we do not want to do that. We do not want to take the really militant options. They are there for the future, but we must be able to sort it out between wild fishing interests and the industry, with the Government taking the conciliatory role in the middle. We have the stick, in the 2007 act. We are saying let us have some more carrot. Let us encourage the industry to move in the direction that we want it to move in without our having to resort to the more militant options—although Mr Harper is right that they are there.

The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

Do members have thoughts about how to proceed with the petition?

Nanette Milne North East Scotland) (Con
link

As a first step, we should really get in touch with the Government on the implementation of the 2007 act—we should put pressure on it about that. That is my first suggestion.

The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

Absolutely. Anybody else?

Robin Harper Lothians) (Green
link

We need to gather a comprehensive set of opinions. Besides writing to the Government, we should write to the Association of Salmon Fishery Boards, the Association of Scottish Shellfish Growers and the Scottish Anglers National Association, to give all the associations the opportunity to respond. Marine Scotland has already been approached, and we could also write to Scottish Natural Heritage, the Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation, Shetland Aquaculture, WWF Scotland, and Friends of the Earth Scotland. They all have things that they would like to say on the issue. I think that we should invite them to respond as quickly as possible. The issues are not new, so they should be ready to respond at the drop of a hat. We should get their responses before we consider further action on the petition and whether we should point the issue to the Scottish Government or propose getting the management boards together. That is something that we have not thought of. Perhaps we should get some of them to come along and say to them, “You’ve been working together for all these years. Why have we only got this far?”14:45

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

I support Nanette Milne’s suggestion that we write to the Scottish Government to ask why it is not using its full enforcement powers. As a new member of the committee, I ask for your guidance, convener. Paul Knight gave an example in which pollution was identified in a water course, yet the authorities were not able to take samples away. Can we put that specifically to the relevant Government minister? If a problem is happening that we can resolve through questioning, that would be helpful.

Paul Knight Salmon and Trout Association
link

We will get a number of copies of the Lochaber Fisheries Trust report sent to the clerk, if you like. It contains a lot of information.

The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

That would be helpful. Are there any further suggestions?

John Farquhar Munro Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD
link

I support the suggestion that the committee write a strongly worded letter to the Government to find out why the current legislation is not being implemented. If we get a quick response, that will move things forward.

The Convener Rhona Brankin
link

Yes. We have been talking about the issue for a long time. Thank you very much for your attendance at the committee, gentlemen.

  1. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 53
  2. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 25
  3. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 5
  5. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  19. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  20. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  21. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  22. 14:00 New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.