7. To ask the Scottish Government what assurances it can give to workers in the national health service in the wake of projected reductions to the Scottish budget. (S3O-10711)
Nicola SturgeonSNPThe Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
Staff are at the heart of our national health service. Their contribution is crucial. I have made it clear to NHS boards that protecting the quality of front-line services and valuing those who work in the NHS are our priorities. I have given, and I am happy to repeat today, three important guarantees. First, the quality of care will be the guiding principle behind any service redesign. As I scrutinise NHS boards’ plans, I will seek to ensure that they, and the service changes that underpin them, protect the quality of care. Secondly, no one in the NHS will lose their job. The NHS has a policy of no compulsory redundancies and that will remain the case. Thirdly, there will be more people working in the NHS in Scotland at the end of this session of Parliament than there were at the start.
I particularly welcome the principle and guarantee of no compulsory redundancies, which I believe does not exist south of the border. How many more redundancies, voluntary redundancies or cutbacks would there have to be if this Government accepted Scottish Labour’s plans to cut a further £332 million from this year’s budget? I am very worried about the damage that that could inflict on the NHS and other front-line services.
Nicola SturgeonSNPThe Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
Bob Doris will know that this Government has taken the decision not to impose the cuts announced by the chancellor earlier this week in this financial year. That was as a result of George Osborne’s offer. The reason for our decision, as the First Minister said at First Minister’s questions, is twofold. First, it is important in this financial year, when budgets have been set, not to force local authorities, NHS boards or any other organisation to rip up those budgets, because that would cause significant instability for those who work in and use those services. Secondly, it is really important that we support economic recovery at this time of fragile recovery. To take money out of public spending within this financial year would put that at risk. For those reasons, I think that we were right to take that decision. Unfortunately, from reading and hearing some of the conflicting comments made by those in the Labour Party, it seems that they cannot quite decide which side of that debate they are on.
Is it not the case that not one penny would require to be taken from the NHS budget? Far be it from me to defend the Conservatives, but none of the £6 billion of cuts was taken from the NHS.
Nicola SturgeonSNPThe Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
I will say a bit about our commitment to the NHS. It is important that people hear this. We have ensured that there are real-terms increases in NHS budgets this year. We have given a very clear commitment to continue to protect NHS budgets as far as we can.
Let us also consider the reality, however. The economic mess that was created by the previous United Kingdom Labour Government means that budgets will be tight not just this year but for some time to come. Frankly, Labour’s desperate attempts to dodge responsibility for that simply will not wash with anyone in Scotland.
It is important that NHS boards look to deliver services as efficiently as they possibly can, that they redesign services and that they ensure the greatest possible productivity so that they can continue to deliver quality and ensure that Labour’s economic and financial incompetence does not impact on patient care in Scotland.
Will the cabinet secretary join me in congratulating the Conservative-Liberal Democrat Government in Westminster on scrapping Labour’s jobs tax and, therefore, saving the NHS in Scotland £20 million each year, which will help to protect jobs and front-line services?
Nicola SturgeonSNPThe Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
I will certainly congratulate Murdo Fraser on his promotion to the position of his party’s health spokesman. I look forward to working with him in the same consensual and collegiate manner in which I work with all the other party health spokespeople in this chamber.
In the interests of consensus, I should say that it is important to recognise that the national insurance increase that was planned by Labour would have put an additional burden of £40 million on the NHS next year, at a time when budgets are already tight. I agree that it is good news that that burden has been removed, but I will wait a bit longer to see what the Conservative and Liberal Democrat coalition has in store for Scotland before I go much further than that in my congratulations.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.