1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2423)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Alex Fergusson 2
The record
14 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2423)
I have a range of engagements to carry forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
In these difficult financial times, what would the First Minister think of a Government organisation that planned a visual identity transition—a change of name, to you and me—on which it planned to spend more than £0.5 million?
I am sure that Iain Gray will inform a startled chamber in his second question, but I can be absolutely certain that, as demonstrated across the range of Government departments, this Government’s efficiency programme stands comparison with any. The difference, of course, is that our efficiencies have been recycled into front-line services in Scotland.
The First Minister is right that he is indeed, as usual, in the dark and I intend to enlighten him. I refer to Scotland the Works—he is probably still none the wiser—which we know as Skills Development Scotland. It was set up just two years ago, at a cost of £16 million, and has now come up with this daft scheme to spend £555,000 rebranding itself. Its real job is supposed to be getting our young people into work, which could not be more important. Why is it wasting our money on this?
The real job of Skills Development is to get our young people into work. That is why we should all welcome the fact that it has exceeded the target of 20,000 new modern apprenticeships in Scotland. Furthermore, given that we all agree across the chamber that there is a challenge with youth unemployment in the context of the severest recession since the 1930s, while acknowledging that youth unemployment in Scotland—at around 13 per cent—is far too high, we should welcome the fact that it is four percentage points lower than across the rest of the United Kingdom. I would have thought that even Iain Gray might have given Skills Development Scotland some credit for the action that it has taken through its job action plan to ensure that so many of our young people are gaining life opportunities.
I am very happy to give Skills Development Scotland credit when it spends money on what it is supposed to spend money on, which is creating the kind of opportunities that the First Minister has elaborated on. However, those targets are not the only things that Skills Development Scotland is exceeding. As well as its visual transition strategy, Skills Development Scotland has a marketing and brand migration plan that will cost not £0.5 million but £1.68 million. As the First Minister can—probably—tell, Skills Development Scotland does not have that money spare, so it will ask the First Minister for a £500,000 top-up.
Let us not forget that the same organisation booked Paul McKenna for unemployed youngsters. Perhaps it will bring Paul McKenna back to hypnotise the First Minister into handing over that cash. Why has the First Minister still not got a grip of that organisation?
Let us not forget that the same organisation booked Paul McKenna for unemployed youngsters. Perhaps it will bring Paul McKenna back to hypnotise the First Minister into handing over that cash. Why has the First Minister still not got a grip of that organisation?
The Paul McKenna joke was not very effective the first time that Iain Gray told it some months ago and it is less effective now that it has been recycled. The point was made then that people did not need Paul McKenna when they had Iain Gray to send an entire Parliament to sleep.
Skills Development Scotland is getting on with the job of securing life chances for young people in Scotland. When the target of 20,000 modern apprenticeships was set in the midst of the deepest recession for generations, many people were sceptical that it could be achieved. The fact that the target has been not only achieved but exceeded is a credit to the work of Skills Development Scotland. It does no good whatsoever, when people are engaged in that vital work of gaining life chances for our young people, for that work not to be supported across the chamber as it should be.
Skills Development Scotland, by its actions, is demonstrating its commitment to young people in Scotland. At some point, the leader of the Labour Party will demonstrate a similar commitment. [Interruption.]
Skills Development Scotland is getting on with the job of securing life chances for young people in Scotland. When the target of 20,000 modern apprenticeships was set in the midst of the deepest recession for generations, many people were sceptical that it could be achieved. The fact that the target has been not only achieved but exceeded is a credit to the work of Skills Development Scotland. It does no good whatsoever, when people are engaged in that vital work of gaining life chances for our young people, for that work not to be supported across the chamber as it should be.
Skills Development Scotland, by its actions, is demonstrating its commitment to young people in Scotland. At some point, the leader of the Labour Party will demonstrate a similar commitment. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order, Mr McNeil.
From the First Minister’s answer, I take it that he approves of Skills Development Scotland spending £2 million on changing its name and marketing that name change.
I well remember the meeting that the First Minister and I had, when we forced him to include in his budget the apprenticeships target that he trumpets. I well remember him asking me, “How can we possibly deliver this many apprenticeships?” We made some suggestions, the First Minister, to his credit, followed them and we achieved 20,000 apprenticeships. Perhaps the First Minister will listen to me again when I tell him that the £2 million should be spent on more apprenticeship places and skills training.
It is the First Minister who is not too effective if he cannot get a grip of Skills Development Scotland. However, the issue is not only that organisation. Last week, he did not know about nursing jobs going; this week, his Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning had to write to parents, apologising for the shambles in our schools; and now money for skills is being spent not only on hypnotists, but on marketing mumbo-jumbo. The Government is adrift. How long will it be before the First Minister’s colleagues realise that they need a rebranding—starting at the top?
I well remember the meeting that the First Minister and I had, when we forced him to include in his budget the apprenticeships target that he trumpets. I well remember him asking me, “How can we possibly deliver this many apprenticeships?” We made some suggestions, the First Minister, to his credit, followed them and we achieved 20,000 apprenticeships. Perhaps the First Minister will listen to me again when I tell him that the £2 million should be spent on more apprenticeship places and skills training.
It is the First Minister who is not too effective if he cannot get a grip of Skills Development Scotland. However, the issue is not only that organisation. Last week, he did not know about nursing jobs going; this week, his Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning had to write to parents, apologising for the shambles in our schools; and now money for skills is being spent not only on hypnotists, but on marketing mumbo-jumbo. The Government is adrift. How long will it be before the First Minister’s colleagues realise that they need a rebranding—starting at the top?
Iain Gray will have to decide whether he wants to claim the credit for the success of the 20,000 modern apprenticeships that have been started in Scotland; that is 85 per cent up on the previous year. If that happened only because of the Labour Party’s intense pressure in the Scottish Parliament, why did Labour then vote against the budget?
Iain Gray questions public spending across a range of activities. If his concern is the deep pressure across the range of public services, why on earth are so many of his own front benchers and back benchers calling for the immediate implementation of cuts? [Interruption.] Andy Kerr says that they are not. When I raised the issue last week, I thought that only Andy Kerr was rebelling on that point, but now I find that the Labour Party’s justice spokesman is also attacking the SNP. Richard Baker stated:
“The SNP administration is, for political reasons, deferring cuts until after next year’s elections”.
My belief was that the Labour Party wanted to resist cuts because it did not want to jeopardise recovery in Scotland, but now it is calling—as Des McNulty did a few minutes ago—for the immediate implementation of Tory cuts in Scotland. When Iain Gray decides whether he wants more cuts and immediate cuts, or fewer cuts, perhaps he will be able to come to this Parliament with a semblance of coherence.
Iain Gray questions public spending across a range of activities. If his concern is the deep pressure across the range of public services, why on earth are so many of his own front benchers and back benchers calling for the immediate implementation of cuts? [Interruption.] Andy Kerr says that they are not. When I raised the issue last week, I thought that only Andy Kerr was rebelling on that point, but now I find that the Labour Party’s justice spokesman is also attacking the SNP. Richard Baker stated:
“The SNP administration is, for political reasons, deferring cuts until after next year’s elections”.
My belief was that the Labour Party wanted to resist cuts because it did not want to jeopardise recovery in Scotland, but now it is calling—as Des McNulty did a few minutes ago—for the immediate implementation of Tory cuts in Scotland. When Iain Gray decides whether he wants more cuts and immediate cuts, or fewer cuts, perhaps he will be able to come to this Parliament with a semblance of coherence.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
The question was about Skills Development Scotland. Iain Gray has another question.
My question is a simple one. Skills Development Scotland has £2 million. Does the First Minister think that it should spend the money on changing its name, or on getting young people into work?
Skills Development Scotland is demonstrating its effectiveness in terms of achieving its targets. It is getting young people into work in Scotland in the most difficult situation that has been faced for many generations. Skills Development Scotland is doing its job of supporting the Scottish community; perhaps the Labour Party should do its job and back Scotland.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 May 2010 →- Her Majesty’s Government (Relations) Debate · 112
- Driving Licences (Drug Misuse) Questions · 4
- Council Tax Collection Questions · 6
- Road Safety Questions · 6
- Asylum Seekers (Detention) Questions · 6
- English as an Additional Language (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Library Services Questions · 4
- Congestion (Inverness) Questions · 6
- Rail Services (Aberdeenshire) Questions · 7
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Boiler Scrappage Scheme First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Calman Commission First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Teachers (Abuse) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy Questions · 6
- Medical Equipment Failure Questions · 4
- Huntington’s Disease Questions · 4
- Hospital Consultant Bonus Scheme Questions · 6
- Diabetes Action Plan Questions · 8
- Budget Reductions (Workforce) Questions · 8
- European Working Time Directive Questions · 4
- Oesophageal Cancer Questions · 6
- NHS Lothian (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Coeliac Disease Questions · 4
- Disabled Young Adults Questions · 5
- Climate Change (Annual Targets) (Scotland) Order 2010 (Draft) Debate · 18
- Waiting Times Debate · 33
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 10
- Decision Time Decision time · 31
- Employment and Support Allowance Members’ business · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.