Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Overview of the NHS in Scotland’s performance 2008/09”

Wednesday 23 June 2010 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Committee business 157 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

157 contributions
The Convener
link

Agenda item 2 is a section 23 report: “Overview of the NHS in Scotland’s performance 2008/09”. I welcome our witnesses, Dr Kevin Woods, from NHS Scotland; Dr Harry Burns, the chief medical officer; John Connaghan; and John Matheson. Do you want to make any introductory remarks, Dr Woods?

Dr Kevin Woods Scottish Government Director General Health and NHS Scotland
link

Very briefly, if I may. Good morning, everyone. We welcome the opportunity to give evidence this morning on the overview report. The report highlights significant achievements by NHS Scotland up to the end of 2008-09. In particular, I draw the committee’s attention to the performance of the national health service against the challenging performance targets that were set and the fact that, in that year, we achieved an excellent financial outcome, having secured a position very close to recurring financial balance.It is 15 months since the end of the period that is covered by the report and much has happened since then. Subject to the audit of 2009-10, I can report that the health service continues to achieve good performance against key targets and I can highlight particular improvements in, for example, health care associated infections and waiting times. As the committee knows, we recently launched our quality strategy to build on “Better Health, Better Care”. I am pleased to advise that financial balance is also being maintained.The committee has taken a specific interest in the adverse effects of alcohol misuse, in trends in mortality and in their relationship with social deprivation. In recent times, our understanding of the links between those has increased. The committee might, therefore, find it helpful if the chief medical officer joins me and my colleagues in exploring those issues this morning, if you wish.

The Convener
link

Thank you very much for that. We are pleased to have Dr Burns with us.I will start with a couple of general questions. You spoke about the national health service being well on course to meet its targets and its continuing improvements in quality, and you mentioned improvements in HAI and waiting times. Will you be able to continue to improve quality in that way with significantly fewer doctors and nurses?

Dr Woods
link

Yes, we believe that we can do that. We are committed to continuing our quality improvements, and we see our pursuit of quality as being linked to our policy on improving efficiency. We have invested considerable amounts of money in equipping the health service with the tools to do that, and we believe that we can continue to make progress on all our performance targets.

The Convener
link

Information about the number of doctors and nurses that you require to deliver continual improvement in the health service is coming out in a piecemeal fashion. Why is that? If there is a planned quality improvement strategy, why have the boards reported on staffing levels in the way that they have done over the past few months? Why was it not spelled out clearly that they do not need as many doctors and nurses?

Dr Woods
link

The information was, of course, ultimately published on 3 June in a collective picture of workforce projections. Every year, boards have been required to produce workforce plans in their more general work on the preparation of local delivery plans. That is intended to demonstrate to us how they will achieve the targets that have been set. We in central Government have always taken an interest in those plans.Obviously, as the financial position has tightened, we have wanted to ensure that boards are focusing on the importance of key front-line clinical services, that the quality of services will be protected, and that the analysis of workforce and efficiency savings is being properly considered in our local partnership arrangements to draw together the management and staff-side representatives. Information became available as that process unfolded locally in an open way. We thought that it was important to pull together all that information, and the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing decided to publish the workforce projections on 3 June.

The Convener
link

Are the doctors and nurses who have expressed concern that reductions in staffing levels will potentially lead to poorer-quality services just plain wrong?

Dr Woods
link

We are all concerned to ensure that we maintain the quality of services. An important dimension of our approach has been the commitment to establish a monitoring group. That proposal builds on the strength of partnership working, which is an important feature of our health service governance arrangements. Members of the committee will know what those arrangements are at the local level; we have similar partnership arrangements at the national level. I am a co-chair of the Scottish partnership forum, which brings together employers, the Government and trade unions. We wanted to ensure that we had arrangements in place through which concerns, if they existed, could be aired and considered, and that those discussions would inform the development of local plans. We understand that, in a time of change, there will potentially be concerns about service change, but we believe that we have well-established machinery in place to enable people to contribute to local discussions and to contribute at the national level, too.10:15

The Convener
link

Finally, on the same issue of staffing levels, what are you doing to curb the significant growth in the number of highly paid staff who work in the NHS across Scotland? In addition, what do you intend to do to pull back and curb the very significant salaries that have been paid, under successive Administrations, to those at the top of the NHS in Scotland?

Dr Woods
link

I am sure that you have looked at the detail in the workforce projections, where it can be seen that the group with the largest reduction, at 7.5 per cent, in whole-time equivalent posts over 2010-11 is indeed management. Further, management pay in Scotland, out of the total NHS pay bill of £6.1 billion, is about £100 million, and that pay is subject to ministerial direction. That arrangement was put in place eight or nine years ago, and management is the only group of staff in the NHS whose pay is directly under the control of ministers. For other groups in the NHS, there has traditionally been a very important role for independent pay review bodies informing ministers.The management group is therefore subject to very close scrutiny by ministers. Over the years, we have put in place some other very important procedures on pay. First, staff in the management group do not receive any progression in their salary without a thorough assessment of performance. Most other groups in the NHS receive an annual increment in pay as well as the traditional cost-of-living increase. However, that does not apply to managers, unless they can achieve the performance objectives that have been set for them. Those determinations are the responsibility of remuneration committees on the one hand, but we established at national level something that we call the national performance management committee, which is independently chaired and which moderates the considerations of the remuneration committees to ensure that proper and thorough governance is in place for the staff groups. Beyond that, decisions about management pay are, indeed, a matter for ministers, within the context of public sector pay policy.

The Convener
link

But when people receive salaries approaching £100,000 a year, and indeed beyond that, they do not need annual increments, do they? Will you recommend to ministers that something should be done to pull back both the number of such posts and the level of the salaries that are currently paid?

Dr Woods
link

I think that the Government has made it very plain that there will be a pay freeze for senior salaries. You will appreciate that that is the context in which ministers will have to make decisions about what the levels should be.

The Convener
link

Will you recommend to ministers that something should be done about the salaries that are paid to senior NHS staff in Scotland?

Dr Woods
link

Earlier in the review, the Government referred some of the issues around senior staff salaries to the Senior Salaries Review Body. Clearly, as we gather together all the information on this, ministers will be provided with advice. I fully accept that there is a need for pay restraint generally; I think that that is a well-established public policy in Scotland. Recommendations that may go to ministers will be framed in that context. Beyond that I am not really able to elaborate at this stage.

The Convener
link

Okay, thank you.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

Good morning. At our previous evidence session, I and my colleagues around the table were able to congratulate the chief executives of different health boards on some fairly significant achievements. In the report, for example, the numbers of deaths from cancer, heart disease, stroke, AIDS and suicide are down, waiting times are down and hidden waiting lists are gone. I am happy to do that again, regardless of what you are paid. I put on record my opinion that the report shows that you have done an excellent job recently.We also congratulated the chief executives on their achieving the efficiency savings, and it is efficiency savings to which I now turn. Does the Government have a method for enabling health boards to share good practice? It is not purely about the NHS. Right across the board, we are continually hearing about good local practice that people in other parts of Scotland are not aware of. Is there anything in place to enable good practice that achieves better efficiency savings to be made without affecting the quality of service to be shared among the health boards?

Dr Woods
link

Thank you very much for your comments on the performance of the NHS. The report reflects well on the efforts of health service staff the length and breadth of Scotland, and I agree that they are to be congratulated on what they have achieved.We have a good record on efficient government savings and have exceeded the targets that were set. About two years ago—possibly a little bit longer—in view of the fact that the resource position was tightening and because the efficiency challenge was growing, we established our national efficiency and productivity programme. That was an attempt to provide a framework in which we could examine all aspects of efficiency and productivity, bring together best practice and promote well-established ideas to different parts of the service. We appointed a colleague from a health board to lead that, supported by Mr Connaghan’s team. That efficiency and productivity programme has served a useful purpose in helping us to understand where there are opportunities for increased efficiency and productivity consistent with the securing of continued improvements in quality. I am happy to let Mr Connaghan elaborate on some of the detail, if that would be helpful.

John Connaghan Scottish Government Health Delivery Directorate
link

In June, we published a progress report on the NHS Scotland efficiency and productivity programme, which contains a number of examples of good practice relating to the improvement of the patient experience, well-organised boards and the reduction of ward supply costs. Those are exemplars for the whole service. On top of that, a central improvement support team exists to spread best practice across all NHS boards. On that group’s website, you will find all the examples of good practice that we can muster in Scotland, which are available to all NHS boards.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

There is concern about whether the NHS will be able to sustain the 2 per cent efficiency savings without services being affected. Are you confident that they can be sustained? Nicola Sturgeon, the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing, has guaranteed that quality of service will not be affected by the efficiency savings, and a quality strategy has been published, to which Dr Woods referred in his opening remarks. At the evidence session in March, we were given as an example of service redesign—which is where the chief executives said that most of the savings would come from—the fact that poor practice in operating theatres, late starts and early finishes, and so on had been improved on.I wrote down some remarks by Robert Calderwood, from NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, who said that“there are still areas of overlap, duplication and historical working practices that need to be examined and resolved.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 24 March 2010; c 1611.Are you confident that you can achieve savings without quality being affected? In addition, can you give other specific examples of service redesign, which was referred to in the previous evidence session, so that we have a better idea of where the money will be saved and an assurance that quality will not be affected?

Dr Woods
link

I will do my best. I read the Official Report of the discussion with the chief executives and thought that it was very interesting. On efficiency savings, they made the important point that there is a limit to which you can take off 2 per cent in slices and that you actually have to look at redesign in a broader sense. Mr Calderwood’s example around operating theatres was a very good one. He gave another good example regarding the rationalisation of laboratories in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. From his evidence, I seem to recall that, as part of the board’s reconfiguration of acute services, it has been able to restructure those services and to secure and maintain the appropriate quality but also release resources.Other examples that I can recall in which we have done redesign in a number of places include one-stop clinics, which are obviously very desirable from the standpoint of the patient, because they avoid multiple interactions and appointments and all the consequences that go with them. We know that patients value that very strongly.One of the areas in which we have taken a very close interest and on which we want to do even more work is prescribing practice. We have done a lot on generic substitution, but we are looking at other ways of providing decision support tools to prescribers. We have been running a couple of pilot projects—in NHS Tayside and NHS Highland, I think—to examine that so that cost-effective prescribing is prompted at the point of prescription. The report to which Mr Connaghan referred, which we published a few weeks ago, contains many more examples. It might be helpful to the committee if we were to let it have that report, so that members can see all the content.

The Convener
link

I appreciate that.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

On the sharing of good practice, you said that there is a practice support team that has a website. Is that team doing anything proactively? I assume that it does not simply rely on health boards taking a look at the website when they feel like it. Is overall co-ordination going on?

John Connaghan Scottish Government Health Delivery Directorate
link

The simple answer is yes. The website is not just passive. We encourage the transmission of best practice through helping boards with expert advice. Perhaps a good example of that is where we combine two or three programmes. At NHS Highland’s annual review yesterday, we heard about telehealth services in Argyll and Bute, which can combine the best practice from outside NHS Highland and deliver it to remote and rural locations. The example that we heard about yesterday showed a reduction in hospital admissions of some 91 per cent for respiratory patients in Bute and a 41 per cent reduction in general practitioner attendances. Those are all good examples of our helping boards to reach best practice.

The Convener
link

Dr Woods, may I return to a comment that you made about what the chief executives had said? Do you disagree with their view that the salami-slicing approach is not sustainable?

Dr Woods
link

Do I disagree with their view that salami slicing is not sustainable?

The Convener
link

Yes.

Dr Woods
link

No—we need to do all those things. As we have said, we wish to continue with the 2 per cent savings; we need to consider everything that we do, and to examine ways of improving quality and efficiency. We need to do all that.10:30

The Convener
link

I understand that, but the chief executives said that the salami-slicing approach is not sustainable. Are they wrong?

Dr Woods
link

No, I do not think that they are wrong.

The Convener
link

So, they are right.

Dr Woods
link

They are saying the same thing that I am saying, in a sense: that approach has a place, but it is not sufficient.

The Convener
link

No—the chief executives said that it is not sustainable. They did not say that salami slicing has a place but that it is not sufficient. It is either sustainable or it is not—I am asking you whether the salami-slicing approach is sustainable.

Dr Woods
link

If the only thing that we did was simply to take off 2 per cent, we would not achieve what we need to. We need to consider how we organise and do things, and that is what has been reflected.For example, we are aware that lengths of stay in hospitals vary quite a bit. We have done a lot of work on benchmarking lengths of stay. There are productivity opportunities there. It would not be possible to secure such savings simply by salami slicing, as it were.It is necessary to examine the organisation of in-patient care and the balance between in-patient care and day care, and that must all be worked through. Mr Calderwood said that NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde had done that on a grand scale in moving to two brand-new ambulatory care hospitals over the past 10 years, and that has released resources for reinvestment.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

From the examples that Dr Woods has given, I am finding it difficult to work out his understanding of the term “efficiency”. How would you describe “efficiency”, Dr Woods?

Dr Woods
link

We are trying to secure the same or more outputs while reducing the level of inputs.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Could a huge amount of savings be produced by having, for instance, just one health board for the whole of Scotland?

Dr Woods
link

We have not done the calculation for that, but there possibly would be savings. It would be an interesting calculation to do. You will recall that in 2004 we abolished trusts in Scotland and adopted single-system working. Although I cannot recall the figures, there were savings there.We have also learned that structural change brings with it costs in the short term.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

I go further back than that—you probably do, too, Dr Woods, looking at you. You will remember when trusts did not exist, and we had only health boards. We have had two reorganisations within my lifetime.

Dr Woods
link

At least.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Of course it would save a huge amount of money to have just one board. We would not have all the chief executives and all the finance directors, and you would probably not need a chief medical officer and a head of the health service in Scotland. Your own job might become redundant—I think that you are one of the three top-paid people in the Scottish Executive, judging from what I saw the other day. That would be a huge saving, would it not?

Dr Woods
link

Potentially, but one would need to have a well-thought-through, properly presented business case that considered the existing cost structure. We would apply that approach to all changes on such a scale. Intermediate arrangements of some kind would still need to be put in place. The short-term costs and long-term benefits would need to be weighed up.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

There would be losses in terms of local input, in Aberdeen or Orkney, for instance.

Dr Woods
link

Potentially. You make a good point, if I may say so: people greatly value local health boards. Although the health service functions in an integrated way and as a whole for people in Scotland, people nonetheless want to have access to a local organisation that they believe should be responsive to their needs and concerns. That aspect would have to be weighed as well.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Which brings me to a subsequent question. Local MSPs in Lothian had a meeting recently with NHS Lothian to discuss its plan to reduce the number of its nursing staff by 333. Would you consider that to be an efficiency saving?

Dr Woods
link

I think that the board is saying that it can deliver everything that it needs to achieve with the workforce changes that it has described and that it intends to achieve those changes through natural wastage, not filling vacancies and staff turnover. In that respect, no one is going to lose a job, but there will be fewer job opportunities at the end of the process.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

And a much inferior service to the public. Surely 333 nurses in NHS Lothian are not surplus to requirement.

Dr Woods
link

I am looking for the Lothian data among my papers. In Scotland as a whole at 1 April this year, there were 59,257 nurses and midwives. We should remember that the projections are not necessarily cast in stone: boards must work their way through them. We are determined to apply downward pressure, so that boards can try to achieve savings in other ways. However, in Scotland as a whole, the projections suggest a decline of 1,500, which is 2.6 per cent.I come back to my earlier point about the importance of the national monitoring group in ensuring that the consideration of quality is central and, indeed, takes place at a local level. I am sure that Mr Barbour and his colleagues from NHS Lothian would have explained that they have worked very closely with trade unions to ensure that service standards and quality are properly maintained.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Professor Barbour and Dr Winstanley actually flunked the meeting, because they knew that this was—maybe that was not the reason, and I am reading too much into it. However, they did not attend the meeting; it was chaired by the vice-chairman, so we did not get an explanation. Surely common sense indicates that if you take 333 nurses away from the staff in a health board, there must be a reduction in service, otherwise it beggars belief and is a miracle like that of the loaves and the fishes.

Dr Woods
link

I do not believe that it is impossible to achieve that reduction. We have discussed in this committee over the years the need for greater efficiency and productivity in the health service. What really matters is that we can demonstrate that the need for nurses or, indeed, any other group of staff has been carefully considered, using methods to assess the needs of patients and the skills mix of nursing and other staff. In that regard, it is important for the committee to be aware that we require all boards to use particular methods to examine the relationship between the needs of staff and the numbers and skills mix of nurses. A great deal of work has been done with colleagues in the nursing profession and with their staff-side partners to ensure that those tools are fit for purpose. We can demonstrate through that work that we are getting the balance right. However, I understand Mr Foulkes’s point. What I am trying to convey is that that is why we have put in place the arrangements that we have. We must ensure that, as boards address the need to improve quality and balance the books, concerns about quality are properly addressed.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

A last question, then. If one of those nurses came to me—as I am sure that they will—and told me what she did in the hospital then asked what would be lost if your job, for example, were to go, how should I reply to her?

Dr Woods
link

First, you might want to establish whether she was moving on to something else. We would not—

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

I think that you misunderstand me. What if she asked, “What would happen if Dr Woods lost his job?” Would that be an efficiency saving? Would it damage the health service? How would I explain to her the importance of your job—not you personally, but your job?

Dr Woods
link

You would refer to the role that I play in advising ministers, providing leadership to colleagues in the Scottish Government and contributing to the Scottish Government and the NHS as a whole. The point that needs to be considered is not my particular role. All of us who work in the public service need to understand and be prepared to address how we can do things differently. That is really all that I can say.

Murdo Fraser Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con
link

Good morning, Dr Woods. I will follow up some of the questions that Lord Foulkes and other colleagues have put to you. Some of them go to the heart of committee members’ concerns about the Audit Scotland report and what we have seen since, in particular the various announcements about reductions in staff counts in different NHS boards and their impact on services. We are looking for reassurance from the Scottish Government that there will not be an adverse impact on the quality of care.I will expand my question a little on a slightly more philosophical level. How should we measure the effectiveness of the national health service? Should we measure it as we have traditionally done, on the basis of inputs, looking at the amount of money that we put into it and the number of staff who are employed in it, or should we measure it on the basis of outputs—in other words, the quality of patient care? I am interested in your understanding of that question. I also seek a reassurance from you that the Scottish Government will put pressure on health boards to ensure that the quality of patient care will not be adversely affected by the reductions in staff numbers.

Dr Woods
link

I can give you a complete reassurance that that is the focus of our work. We are just embarking on the round of annual reviews, and the second item on the agenda is quality of service—quality of care. It is clear to us that we need to maintain a focus on that.I will make a point about the link between quality and efficiency before I answer your question on outcomes, which is important. The CMO may want to comment on this in due course. Tackling health care associated infections is a hugely important priority for all of us. It goes to the very heart of quality of care, and we have made a lot of progress on it. Only yesterday, the cabinet secretary announced a further target of a 50 per cent reduction in the number of Clostridium difficile cases. As well as that being entirely the right thing to do for patients and for patient care, we know that it reduces length of stay in hospital and leads to improved efficiency in the use of resources. Studies have quantified the financial benefits of that. That illustrates the kind of relationships that exist.10:45

Your more general point about the tendency to focus on inputs rather than outputs or outcomes is important. In our work on targets and so on, we have ensured that all the work that the health service does can be mapped back to the Scottish Government’s national outcomes and to the strategic objectives—the purpose targets—so that there is a line of sight through all that work and the work that we are pursuing in relation to process targets. Indeed, the Scotland performs website, which was created by the Scottish Government and may be referred to in the Auditor General’s report, is intended to report publicly on that. The health service is the first part of the Government to provide the level of detail that allows you to see right from the purpose targets through the national outcomes that have been established and on to performance at national and health board levels. That is something that the Auditor General has wanted to see.We believe that the pursuit of outcomes is hugely important, and the work that we have done in relation to health improvement, efficiency, access and treatment targets supports that objective.

Dr Harry Burns Scottish Government Chief Medical Officer and Public Health Directorate
link

I am listening to the discussion about 2 per cent efficiency savings, workforce changes and so on. Clearly, those would be difficult to achieve if health care were static, but it changes rapidly. Like Lord Foulkes, I go back to the time before there were trusts. In those days, when I was a consultant at Glasgow royal infirmary, a gall bladder procedure was a significant procedure that required a stay of eight to 10 days in hospital. Very soon after keyhole surgery was introduced, it took a day or two for someone to recover from a gall bladder procedure. That meant that we did not need to staff nearly as many hospital beds. A whole load of surgical procedures have changed radically in the way in which staff are required to support them. It is important that, year on year, the health service considers such changes as they take place and reacts to them.A classic example of that is drugs coming off patent. When expensive patented drugs come off patent and generic equivalents appear, it is important that the health service uses resources effectively and makes the appropriate switch. The annual search for efficiency must take those changes and patterns of care into account and use resource effectively. When I was a junior doctor, one of my major duties every morning was to spend an hour or two going round the ward taking blood. Junior doctors do not do that any more, as there is a changing workforce pattern and phlebotomists now take all the blood. The idea is that expensive resources should not perform tasks that less expensively trained individuals can do. There have been significant changes, and it is important that we react to them.It is a source of some irritation—saving the presence of the accountants and economists in the room—that we measure efficiency by inputs and count the number of people who receive those inputs. It ought to be about the benefit to those people—their sense of wellbeing and the improvement in health that we create across the whole community. Instead of measuring the money that goes into the health service, we should measure how well the people of Scotland are at the end of the day. That is difficult to do, so we revert to doing the easy thing, which, as we saw from the recent Nuffield report, often trivialises what the health service does. Efficiency needs to be thought of on a broader, more ambitious scale. I have high ambitions for the health service, as does everyone who works in it. It is about making the people of Scotland live longer, healthier lives.

Dr Woods
link

That is why one of the national outcomes is healthier life expectancy. We are trying to orientate all our work behind that.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Dr Burns described some of the reductions in pressure on the health service, but there are also huge increases in demand, because people are living longer. In a previous session, we took evidence on all the work that is being done on knee and hip replacements. There is pressure from that direction as well.

Dr Burns
link

Lord Foulkes is absolutely correct, convener. However, even in the case of knee replacements, robotic surgery is coming in that will make operations much easier and require less blood transfusion, which in itself will shorten lengths of stay. Technology is changing the way in which we think about things. On hip replacements, the first port of call is now hip resurfacing, which is far less traumatic than hip replacement. Each year, we have to think about what the extra demands are and what things we can give up to meet those demands, hence the need for us to ask health boards where we can achieve efficiencies and where we can move resources around in order to meet those demands.

Bill Kidd Glasgow) (SNP
link

Thank you for the information that you have given us so far, gentlemen. In the health service, it is a wee bit of a case of being damned if you do and damned if you don’t. We have heard that life expectancy is increasing, which obviously is a success story, but the fact that people are living longer might have a great impact on the finances that the health service requires. Is that factored into the planning of future efficiencies and costs? Do you take into account the fact that we have a longer-lived and, we hope, healthier population? A number of different factors are involved, but do you consider the extension of life expectancy when you are planning future budgets?

Dr Woods
link

Yes. We know, for instance, that one driver of the increased volume in prescribing is the fact that people are living longer. We obviously think about that carefully.In a broader sense, we think carefully about demographic trends. In “Better Health, Better Care”, we have tried to create a situation in which we are better at anticipatory care, recognising needs early on and providing appropriate services for people. Beyond that, we are undertaking an important piece of work jointly with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities on how we will care for older people in the next 10 to 15 years. We talked to the committee previously about some of those complex but important issues.I am pleased to say that the work that we have been doing with COSLA has been productive in helping us to understand how we can use the totality of public expenditure on older people much more effectively. As I said to the committee previously, the total budget is far larger than just the personal care component or the resource transfer component. We have that very much in our sights and it is part of the general consideration of how we will provide care given that people are living longer and healthier lives.

Bill Kidd Glasgow) (SNP
link

I do not want to jump ahead, but given what you have just said, I think that it is the right moment to ask whether you propose a shift to more primary health care rather than secondary health care. Previous NHS overview reports have stated that evidence of large-scale transfer of resources from secondary to primary and community care has been limited.Are health boards and the Scottish Government’s health directorate transferring large resources from hospitals to primary and community care, to reflect the rise in life expectancy, which will mean that people will be in the community rather than making constant visits to hospital?

Dr Woods
link

I think that you are referring to a policy that has been given the label “shifting the balance of care”. I take the point in the Auditor General’s report about the shift of resources in that way.We do not think that a single measure can do justice to what we are trying to do in relation to that policy, so we are trying to do three things. First, as you said, we sometimes try to shift the location of the delivery of care. Secondly, we are trying to move to prevention and anticipation rather than treatment—that is sometimes described as trying to get upstream rather than downstream. The equally well and keep well initiatives are the two big programmes that we have been pursuing to try to achieve that move. Interesting things are emerging from that work. Thirdly, we have been considering how to shift responsibility for the traditional care of patients among professionals. We have talked to the committee about extended roles. For example, podiatrists can make a bigger contribution to orthopaedics.Shifting the balance therefore involves a broad set of objectives. The breadth of our policies in that regard is reflected in a number of HEAT targets. For example, we have ambitions to get on top of accident and emergency attendance and we have targets on doing more in relation to the self-management of long-term conditions and the management of complex care needs at home.We are trying to secure important improvements in our ability to capture such activity and its costs. I will mention two pieces of work in which the committee has taken an interest: the integrated resource framework, which is a joint piece of work with local authorities in four parts of Scotland; and programme budgeting, whereby we take a slice of activity or expenditure in the health service and try to assemble data that will enable us to consider how we might allocate resources differently across that segment of spend. That is part of the work behind the scenes to try to support the shifts that I have described.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

You mentioned that the NHS is due to achieve a 2.6 per cent reduction in the number of nurses. Is that correct?

Dr Woods
link

That is the projected reduction in the number of posts, according to the table on projected changes.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

Can you give figures and a percentage in relation to the reduction in the number of doctors?

Dr Woods
link

Yes. The projected reduction is 68 posts, or 0.7 per cent.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

The impact on nurses will be heavy in comparison with the impact on doctors.

Dr Woods
link

Proportionally, the largest projected reduction is in management posts, at 7.5 per cent.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

How many posts is that?

Dr Woods
link

The current number of staff in post is 1,312 and the number is projected to go down by 99 posts, which represents 7.5 per cent of the total.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

That is helpful, thank you.

Dr Woods
link

The table has been published at national level and for individual boards. Posts in administration services are projected to go down by 1,053, or 4.1 per cent.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

The largest number of projected reductions in posts—I accept that it is not the highest percentage of total posts—is in nursing staff.

Dr Woods
link

It is, and of course nursing and midwifery is the largest group of staff in the health service at 59,257.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

Indeed. I assume that, in some health board areas, the figures are higher than the national average and in some they are lower. What is the highest percentage of nurses that it is proposed to—

Dr Woods
link

I would have to go through the table, but the data are there.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

Is there a significant variation?11:00

Dr Woods
link

I cannot recall off the top of my head. I would have to look at the individual tables. What I can say—which I hope will be helpful—is that, in our dialogue with the health boards, we wanted to be sure that, to fulfil the cabinet secretary’s commitment to the importance of front-line clinical services, there was no weighting in relation to nursing and midwifery. Although we value the contribution of administrative and management staff, we wanted to be sure that we could achieve change in those areas if we wanted to. I am happy to give Mr Stephen the detail that he wants, but there are numerous pages here and it would take too long to flick through them.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

You are telling us that you have looked at the figures by health board area.

Dr Woods
link

Yes.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

You cannot give us the figures just now.

Dr Woods
link

Well, they are all published.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

They are all published but—

The Convener
link

If you get us the figures, we can circulate them to committee members.

Dr Woods
link

Absolutely.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

You would be concerned if there was one outlier or an area in which the figures were substantially higher than they are in others. You would have picked that up in the process.

Dr Woods
link

We would want to have a dialogue with the board to explore what lay behind the figures, and to ensure that the local and national monitoring arrangements were picking up the variation. We would also want to be satisfied that the health board was using the workforce measurement tools in nursing that we talked about earlier.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

How do you expect individual health boards to identify the number of individual nursing posts that are to go? What is the process for achieving that? Is there a general figure or is there a carefully structured process that identifies posts department by department or discipline by discipline?

Dr Woods
link

I will talk about Glasgow, which has a big health board that makes up 25 per cent of the NHS. In our dialogue with the health board, we have asked Glasgow to explain how its proposals match its service strategy, and how the changes relate to the development of ambulatory care hospitals and the redevelopment of the Southern general hospital. We have also asked how it used the workforce measurement tools to make those assessments. That is the kind of dialogue that we have had. Of course, that dialogue is far from finished. We are covering the territory in the annual review meetings, which have started and will continue over the next couple of months.

The Convener
link

This is your final question.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

Surely the decisions that the health boards are making are driven by the scale of the savings that are required. That is the starting point. The primary objective is to achieve savings; it is not to protect services or the quality of patient care. At what point in the process would a health board say that its savings target was prejudicial to patient care or the quality of service? Will everyone in the NHS accept a minister saying that services are secure and patient care will not be affected?

Dr Woods
link

We are pursuing all the objectives that you have described, not one to the exclusion of the others. As I explained, we are very committed to driving up the quality of care. We are also committed to improving the efficiency and productivity of the health service, and we are committed to ensuring that the health service responds to the changing needs that exist—

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

But there becomes one fixed savings target and a single figure—

The Convener
link

Let Dr Woods finish. Then we will move on to questions from Cathie Craigie.

Dr Woods
link

I am sorry—could you repeat what you said, Mr Stephen?

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

In every health board, there becomes one fixed savings target—a single figure that the health board is trying to achieve in efficiencies and savings.

Dr Woods
link

The 2 per cent?

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

The 2 per cent is part of it, but the overall budget is probably the most fundamental part.

Dr Woods
link

We encourage boards, if they can and if they have well-thought-through plans, to exceed the 2 per cent target because, if they do, they can reinvest those resources in new services. The existence of that incentive to generate more than 2 per cent efficiency savings is important. Indeed, a number of boards have efficiency targets of more than 2 per cent.Let me come back to your concern about quality. If we became aware of a concern that an approach was allegedly having an adverse impact on quality, we would obviously want to know what had gone on locally in creating the proposal and other local arrangements. No doubt, if there was a concern, it would be escalated to the national level. We would take a close interest in all of that.

Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD
link

Thank you, that is helpful.

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

Good morning to you, Dr Woods, and your colleagues. You have mentioned Glasgow a couple of times this morning—the redesign of the services there and how resources have been invested in other areas. That is one issue that we explored with the chief executives, as I am sure you will be aware from the Official Report. The chief executives highlighted that service redesign is needed to achieve savings in future years, but they recognised that, as happened in Glasgow, it can often take a very long time. How will the Scottish Government support the boards that wish to redesign services and ensure that they continue to provide quality care and services during periods of change?

Dr Woods
link

Change can be very uncomfortable. Over the years, we have seen many controversies about proposed changes, and the health service has learned many lessons from them. Put simply, there are two important lessons: the need for engagement of staff, and the need for engagement of the public from the outset in the development of proposals for change. We have tried to ensure that that happens in a number of ways.Earlier this year, we published a revised piece of guidance about the consultation process—actually, it is a revised approach to the management of change. Again, it might be helpful for the committee to receive that, because it is a considerable advance on the previous guidance, which existed for 20 or 30 years. We developed it through an extensive dialogue with all the interested parties that members would expect to be involved.The Scottish Health Council, which has been created to provide a perspective on the quality of engagement and consultation, will play an important role in the process. Moreover, ministers have introduced an independent scrutiny process to deal—if necessary—with cases of significant service change. Finally, it is worth mentioning that ministers very recently secured legislation to pilot direct elections to NHS boards, and Fife and Dumfries and Galloway now have some newly elected non-executive members. Such an approach will again improve the capacity for engagement and consultation with local communities. In all those ways, we have been trying to ensure that the lessons learned as a result of certain major processes that have taken place in Scotland are embedded in revised practice.

The Convener
link

I think that we will leave for another day the question whether elections to health boards were a wise use of scarce resources.

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

I have to say that I am looking forward to seeing the outcomes of the pilot. I support the principle of health board elections—and, indeed, have supported the pilot—but my intelligence on the ground suggests that the process has not been as successful as some of us had hoped. However, we will leave that issue hanging on the wall until we see the outcomes. I might well have to eat my hat in some places.

Dr Woods
link

Notwithstanding what the convener has said, I have met all the newly elected—

The Convener
link

No, no—let’s not go there.

Dr Woods
link

Not today, then.

The Convener
link

It could take us down a whole different track.

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

I know—I could talk about the issue for hours.Service redesign is very important. Dr Woods will know all about the proposed redesign in the Lanarkshire area, which I represent, and the difficulties of engaging the general public and pleasing everyone, including politicians. I am sure that, at the time, he could have seen me and my colleagues far enough. However, we should learn from the experience in Glasgow. At Stobhill hospital’s ambulatory care unit, you can see a consultant, get everything checked out and come away the same day with a diagnosis or something that you are happy with. That approach is certainly worth while but at a time when resources are tight how can we secure the money up front to ensure that before any changes are made to service delivery the general public, the patients and the people whom we are here to support can see the big picture?

Dr Woods
link

There are perhaps two dimensions to that question. First, anyone who has visited an ambulatory care centre will have seen the incredible services that it can provide with results such as the advance that has been made in health care in Glasgow. However, as Dr Burns will tell me, planning for these centres started 20 years ago, which shows that it can take an enormously long time to illustrate what certain changes will mean and convince people of that. The point, of course, is how we illustrate the benefits of these measures in a tangible way for people.The second part of your question relates to making financial provision for some of the changes, which I acknowledge is a really quite complex issue. Some, for example, have suggested that we create a national fund for change or some other kind of bridging resource. When we did that for mental health and learning disability services, we had many critics because the approach became somewhat bureaucratic, there was a sense that people were not necessarily being treated equitably and the whole thing became very difficult to manage. As a result, it was abandoned and the resources were distributed to the health service, in which our current policy is that people should make provision for significant service change in their financial planning.That is what we have seen in Glasgow in relation to preparation for the ambulatory care centres and the Southern general and it is what we are seeing in relation to the new Larbert hospital in Forth Valley, one of the first phases of which will open this year. Do you take money off the health service to create a national fund and then create a bureaucracy to distribute it back in some way, or do you integrate it with the financial planning of individual boards? We think that it is better to do the latter.11:15

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

I do not know, but you are the people charged with trying to find the best way of doing things.Given your evidence this morning, I think that you agree that we still need to focus on a shift from spending money on acute services to spending it on primary care services. Dr Burns said that it was important to invest in primary care services.I return to the experiences of the redesign in Lanarkshire. The document “A Picture of Health” was about trying to put services where they were needed—at the coalface in local communities. Although I did not totally agree with the proposals in that document, I agreed that we need to invest in our local health centres and in bringing services to the community, so that people do not have to travel to access them. Because of decisions that were taken about the redesign of services, that has not been able to happen in Lanarkshire—I do not know whether the situation is the same down in the NHS Ayrshire and Arran area. How is the Government trying to improve community services—if we all still believe that that is the best way to ensure that people lead longer, healthier lives?

Dr Woods
link

I will say something about Lanarkshire and then something about Ayrshire.

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

I am sorry; I just used that as a specific example of which I have experience.

The Convener
link

Can you be brief, as we really need to move on?

Dr Woods
link

I will probably not be able to cover all the points that I was going to make. I think that I covered the essential points of our policy earlier. I do not wish to be discourteous, but given that time is short, I do not want to reiterate the things that I said earlier about shifting the location of care. I add that over the past four or five months we have been having a dialogue about the development of primary care in Scotland. We have had meetings with a wide range of primary care professionals the length and breadth of the country. We are looking carefully at the performance of community health partnerships to see how they have been getting on since they were created. All that is informing our current reflections on what more we can do to support the direction of travel that I described earlier.

Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP
link

No matter the fledgling nature of some of the democratic institutions that are forming, I would much rather have elected bodies of some sort than unelected bodies. I think that the bodies need to be given an opportunity to grow and develop.Sometimes when I come to Public Audit Committee meetings I think that I am actually at the Finance Committee or the Health and Sport Committee, because we gaze into the future a lot, when, in fact, the scope of our work should allow us to examine past performance and so on.I return briefly to the issue of measurement and continuous improvement, which one or two members talked about earlier. How do we measure how we are performing as we are performing? We all understand that if the NHS—or any other service for that matter—shifts to an outcomes-focused service, sometimes the results and benefits will not be known for some years, or indeed many years. While we are making that journey—the patient journey in the case of the health service—how do we know that we are making good, wise decisions that will benefit not only the public but the public purse?Dr Woods mentioned a couple of measures that are in place: the integrated resource framework and the programme budgeting exercise. Do they allow you to affect service planning at present, and are we seeing the results of that? Alternatively, will you choose to apply those measures in the future?

Dr Woods
link

The two pieces of work that I described are intended to remedy shortcomings in some of our planning and costing methods, which have been considered previously. We are trying to put them right.We focus on outcomes. The Auditor General published a report on the public finances in November last year that contained an important diagram setting out the fact that, when thinking through investments in public services, one must consider outcomes and—working back—outputs, processes and inputs. A welcome shift has taken place in the debate from inputs alone to outcomes, but we need to consider carefully processes and outputs so that we can assess the extent to which what we do will secure the outcomes that we pursue. That is what the integrated resource framework and programme budgeting are intended to enable us to do.

Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP
link

That is encouraging. Audit Scotland’s overview report said that no link existed between specific activities and their costs. Are the measures that you describe addressing issues such as not knowing the relationship between cost and activity and therefore the benefit?

Dr Woods
link

We are doing work, which I have not mentioned, to review the cost book and improve its quality. The context for some comments in the report is that our approach to costing in Scotland is not similar to that in England, which was designed for the payment system there. That is called payment by results, but it is actually payment for activity rather than results—I hope that my comment is not considered inappropriate. In England, detailed costing is needed to support the approach to competition and contestability. As our health service in Scotland is designed differently, we have not gone down that route. Nonetheless, we are committed to improving the quality of our costing information and ensuring its reliability and consistency.

Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP
link

The committee has noted many times that data and information are not available nationally in Scotland and that they live in various health boards. Is a move being made to provide the committee and other interested bodies with the national picture on a range of indicators, particularly in health care? A common message throughout our meetings on health matters is that we do not have nationally collected information.

Dr Woods
link

I do not deny that we can always improve. However, I will add a couple of points. Audit Scotland submitted to the committee—I do not remember precisely when—a report on the activities that we undertook to improve the data that ISD Scotland holds at the national level, for instance. The conclusion of that discussion was that we were making quite a bit of progress.We had a review in 2005. We are in the midst of assessing how far we have gone with that. We will in the coming months develop a new strategy for health and care statistics for the next five years.I return to the Audit Scotland report that I mentioned. ISD collects 60 national data sets and has built a reputation across the United Kingdom for the quality of its data. Often, the questions that are asked are not directly answerable from some of those data. However, there is a lot of analytical capacity in ISD to try to answer the questions and we are making progress and creating data sets that are incredibly valuable.I will provide two recent examples to illustrate the point. The committee has looked at our implementation of the new ways of measuring waiting times, which was a very large undertaking. I was pleased that the audit that was conducted showed that the health service had done well in that respect. Another hugely important data set is the data on hospital standardised mortality ratios that we published earlier this week, which are intended to give us an insight into the progress that boards are making on our patient safety programme. The production of those data has been made possible by the work that ISD is doing on national data sets.There is a degree of imperfection, but we are committed to improving matters, are making progress and want to make more. That is my perspective on the issue.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

You said that sometimes the questions that we ask of national data sets cannot be answered. One question that we asked after considering the overview report concerned the number of young people who present to A and E under the influence of alcohol. Anecdotally, that appears to be a growing problem. We have examples from specific health boards where that is the case, but we have received a letter from NHS Grampian that states:“the data to support these statements is difficult to obtain due to the lack of a consistent and replicable information system across Scotland.”I know that ISD is developing a national data set for A and E. Is it possible to include in that figures for young people who present under the influence of alcohol?

Dr Woods
link

As part of our e-health strategy, we are standardising A and E systems across the country. That is an important starting point. You have referred to the work that is under way in ISD, which will improve the quality of those data. We will have further discussions with ISD about whether we can ensure that some data are captured. There are really difficult issues relating to definitions, standardisation and so on, to get the quality right. I know that the CMO has been looking into the issue. I invite Dr Burns to comment.

Dr Burns
link

First, the number of very young people attending A and E departments with alcohol-related problems is small compared with the overall problem of alcohol, so it is subject to significant year-on-year variations. Small numbers—an extra dozen a year across Scotland—can double the total. We are always cautious about interpreting statistics that involve small numbers.Secondly, the definition in the data set of an attendance that is associated with alcohol consumption is left to the clinical judgment of the doctor who sees the patients. Consider the case of someone who drank two pints of beer, tripped, fell and broke his arm. Did he trip because he had drunk two pints of beer or because his shoelace was not tied? That is the sort of judgment that must sometimes be made, so inconsistencies are involved.Dr Woods is correct to say that there are issues relating to definitions. Ten of the 14 territorial health boards have one system for recording such data; the others have a different system. ISD is doing work to ensure that there is consistency across those systems, so that we get the data that we seek. The information that I hold about under-15 hospital discharges that are associated with alcohol shows that they have been pretty flat throughout Scotland over the past decade.11:30

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

It is flat, so it is not increasing.

Dr Burns
link

The information that I have up to 2008 does not show a significant increase. I am talking about hospital discharges, not A and E attendances. Adult hospital discharges associated with alcohol are increasing consistently, but the number involving under-15s is relatively small.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

I hope that, if we manage to get our minimum alcohol pricing policy through, the number will reduce, but it would still be useful to be able to look at national figures.

Dr Burns
link

Any instance—it need only be one—of a young child presenting at an A and E department with an alcohol-related problem is a disaster. That is a life that is in some difficulty.

Murdo Fraser Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con
link

I will follow up on that point. You will have seen the letter that we received from Dr Strachan at NHS Grampian, with the helpful tables attached. When you drill down through the information, it seems to support what you were saying about there not being a substantial increase—in fact, there is very little increase. Such increase as there is would seem to be among the zero-to-five age range. Perhaps I am making an erroneous assumption, but I suspect that the toddlers of Aberdeenshire are not involved in drunken parties. I suspect that it is probably a case of a toddler drinking a glass of wine that was lying around the house and their parents taking them down to A and E, which is clearly a social ill but a completely different social ill from youngsters binge drinking. It would be helpful if we could get more robust data on the matter.

Dr Burns
link

In my experience of reviewing a range of clinical conditions for research purposes, in such cases you would want to go back and get case records out. I suspect that, in such cases, when you pull information off a computer system you need to go a stage further and look at the circumstances involved to be certain that you are dealing with what you are talking about. I think that we need to have a conversation with NHS Grampian to ask it to go that extra stage and look at the case records of the individual children concerned.

The Convener
link

The final issue that I wish to raise is deprivation, which I know is a matter that Dr Burns has spent some time on. Notwithstanding what Dr Woods is saying, which is that we want to see better outcomes and better results from fewer inputs—I know your reservations about the accountants and economists—there is always the worry that the impact of efficiency savings will be more severe on areas of the country where deprivation is high and will damage the attempts that are being made to improve health there. A number of recent reports have questioned the improvement in Scotland’s health, particularly in areas of deprivation, despite the fact that there have been significant increases in investment. What is your take on what the efficiency savings will mean for your strategy and our collective desire to see deprivation tackled?

Dr Burns
link

The ways in which you can narrow the gap in health between rich and poor include steps such as ensuring that the poor have access to good health care. Over the years, I have looked closely at the issue, particularly in the cancer field. For certain cancers, such as breast cancer, there are differences in survival rates: rich women are more likely to get breast cancer, but poor women are more likely to die of it once they get it.Some years ago, I looked in great detail at the health service’s response to that. We discovered an interesting phenomenon, which is that access to health care is identical across the social spectrum—there is no evidence that women from poorer areas are treated any less well. In fact, there is some evidence that, because of the nature of the cancers they get, they get more chemotherapy and so on than more affluent women do. What we discovered was that there were subtle differences in the kind of tumours they had. That leads us back to the way in which we have to tackle health inequalities, which relates to the structure of society.We need a number of societal interventions that make it easier for people to adopt a healthier lifestyle. People are more likely to do that if they have a job and a decent house, if they feel that life is worth living, and if they are not living in a deprived area where they are constantly under threat either because they cannot pay their bills or because there is a culture of violence in the area. We now understand that people are more likely to succeed at school and get a job if conditions in early life are appropriate. Over the years, my strategy has moved to focus much more clearly on the early years.Some disturbing data emerged recently from a study that was conducted in Glasgow, Liverpool and Manchester. We tried to pick two cities whose socioeconomic composition is similar to that of Glasgow. The distribution of income among the residents of those three cities is almost identical—when we look at that, we cannot tell the cities apart. However, mortality across the board in Glasgow is 15 per cent higher than the average mortality in Liverpool and Manchester. It is higher among the affluent as well as among the deprived. When we look at causes of death, half the excess of mortality in Glasgow compared with Liverpool and Manchester is accounted for by alcohol and drug-related poisonings. If we add violence and suicide, the figure goes up to about 60 per cent. That tells me that there is a psychosocial driver that is leading people to adopt a chaotic lifestyle, and the causes of that are social interventions.To return to your question about the health service, another policy that will clearly help deprived areas and indeed is focused on them—it was set up as part of the Kerr report under the previous Government—is what Dr Woods referred to as anticipatory care under the keep well programme. In that work, we specifically target extra resources to deprived areas to pick up people with undiagnosed high blood pressure or high cholesterol and prevent that from leading to their having strokes, heart attacks or long-term limiting illness. We have the evidence for that strategy and we are selectively putting extra resources into deprived areas. That is absolutely correct and we will continue to do it as much as possible. However, the causes of health inequalities are to do with structural issues that need to be tackled not just by the health service but by local government, social work, justice and the whole of Scottish society.

The Convener
link

How will you be able to guarantee that the efficiency savings do not impact more severely on cities such as Glasgow and the small pockets of deprivation that are scattered across Scotland?

Dr Burns
link

Under the mechanism that Dr Woods set out, the impact of proposals that come from health boards will be scrutinised. The boards’ reasons for saying that certain jobs can go will be scrutinised closely to assess the impact on services.

The Convener
link

Either Dr Woods or ministers will have the final say on whether the job cuts will be at the levels that have been suggested, and either Dr Woods or ministers will have the final say on how money is spent and saved.

Dr Woods
link

Ultimately, accountability rests with the Scottish Government, but the boards nonetheless have an important role. Our interest will be awakened if we have drawn to our attention evidence that boards are embarking on changes that do not support national and local priorities of the sort that we have been discussing.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

If there are no compulsory redundancies—we have had a guarantee of that—and it is all done by voluntary redundancies, surely the vacancies will be haphazard. Some departments might lose all their staff. The people who are likely to go are the good people who have been there for a long time and who will get a good redundancy package. It is likely that the people who hang on will be those who are relatively incompetent and who know that they will not get a job elsewhere. Is that correct?

Dr Woods
link

No, I do not think that it is. We are trying to manage this through turnover, which we estimate to be about 7 per cent. The loss of posts is about 3 per cent. On your point that the vacancies will be haphazard, clearly we want the boards to keep an eye on that—Interruption.

The Convener
link

I am sorry. Whoever’s phone that is, can they switch it off?

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Now I can get my answer.

Dr Woods
link

As turnover occurs and vacancies arise, we expect boards to consider carefully their impact as part of the analysis of the situation. Some posts that become vacant might be filled because they are regarded as being particularly important to particular programmes—I am not saying that some jobs are more valued than others, but they will have to be assessed against the objectives that the boards are pursuing.

The Convener
link

It would be grossly unfair to leave an impression that, after voluntary redundancies take place, those who remain are incompetent. I do not think that the committee accepts that view. However, George Foulkes was right to say that we could lose the accumulated experience of a lifetime invested in services. We saw that in local government reorganisation, when talented people left at a relatively young age because there was an attractive financial package. That left people who were still developing their competence and experience to shoulder the burden. There is a valid point that the burden falls on people who are left to their own devices in areas in which experience has been lost.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

You have put the point far more diplomatically than I did, convener.

Dr Woods
link

There are no compulsory redundancies, and voluntary severance in the way that has been described is not part of the boards’ plans. Last year, the only board that ran a voluntary severance scheme was Grampian; as far as I know, none of the other boards is planning for any scheme of that nature. We do not anticipate that the situation will unfold in quite the way that you have described. Nonetheless, if people choose to leave because they have a job elsewhere, and their post is not filled, the board will have to consider whether to keep that vacancy and how to manage it within its overall workforce projections. It is a very important point.

The Convener
link

Cathie Craigie will make a final point.

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

I am flicking through the report because I am sure that it mentions something about the way in which the number of unfilled posts is calculated. Am I right in saying that? I am looking at Barbara Hurst because I am sure that there is something in the report about how that is calculated within the efficiency savings. Could you follow up on that and let the committee know how many unfilled posts there are across the boards and what the total cash amount is?

The Convener
link

You can revert to us with that at a later date.

Dr Woods
link

I am glad to say that the Auditor General looks suitably perplexed.

The Convener
link

If you can find any information that can help with that, you can send it to us.

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

It might have been another Audit Scotland report.

The Convener
link

Thank you. It has been a long meeting. I am sure that the issue will come back to the committee during the next few years as the financial implications of what we have been through and the budget that has just been announced hit us. This will be the first of many discussions to be held over the next few years.

Dr Woods
link

Thank you.

The Convener
link

We will have a break for five minutes.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Is it an official break?

Murdo Fraser Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con
link

Turn off the microphone.

The Convener
link

It is an official break.11:44 Meeting suspended.

11:49 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 157
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 92
  4. 10:00 Audit Scotland (Annual Report) Committee business · 14
  5. 10:00 Section 23 Report Committee business · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.