Item 3 is consideration of the section 23 report, “Commonwealth Games 2014: Progress report on planning for the delivery of the XXth Games”. Correspondence from the accountable officer has been circulated to members, and we will deal with it section by section. The first section is headed “Pension Arrangements”. Do members have any comments on it?
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Commonwealth Games 2014: Progress report on planning for the delivery of the XXth Games”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- The Convener 23
- George Foulkes 9
- Angela Cullen Audit Scotland 5
- Willie Coffey 5
- Anne McLaughlin 3
- Murdo Fraser 2
- Bill Kidd Glasgow) (SNP 2
- Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland 2
- Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland 1
- Mr Black 1
The record
53 contributionsIt is reassuring to know that the company has a maximum amount that it will spend. We are told that“the scheme is not a ‘public sector final salary scheme’ meaning the company knows exactly how much it will pay for each employee”and that it is“substantially cheaper than the public sector equivalent.”It is reassuring to know that the maximum cost will not exceed £3 million. Because of the new regulations, the company must provide pensions.
I am intrigued. I am led to believe that the chief executive is a member of the Strathclyde Pension Fund, in which I declare an interest as a beneficiary through my previous employment. I do not understand why he is a member of that local authority fund rather than the pension arrangement that is outlined here. I would be interested to know the reasons for that and its implications. It appears that the company is making some provision and accounting for it. Does anyone from Audit Scotland want to comment on that, or are you reasonably happy with it?
We are reasonably happy with the response. We have not looked at the pension fund in detail.
Okay. There is nothing else to say on that. “Road Map” is the next heading, which refers to page 17 of the business plan, which has been circulated. Do members have any thoughts or comments to make on that? I think that it is just a matter of record more than anything for the committee to comment on.
Yes.
The third heading is “Athletes’ Village”. My recollection is that, at the time, there were issues to do with the development of the village that the company could not comment on because the tendering process was at a significant stage. I do not know whether there are any issues arising from the conclusion of that process. Has anyone from Audit Scotland looked at what has come out of the tendering process?
We have not looked at anything else since we published the report. We will look at the Commonwealth games again in a second report next year.
Okay. Willie—sorry, Bill Kidd.
I thought I was back at school—that is what everybody called me.The last paragraph of this section mentions the “second phase of development” that was to be “undertaken after the conclusion of the Games” and “a further 750 units.” I wonder about the prospects of that development still going ahead, given the current economic circumstances. Will those have an impact on the finances of the games? Have any changes had to be made to the plans because of the economic situation, and will those 750 units still go ahead?
We could clarify that.
I do not know whether the planned costs of the games included the cost of that further development taking place.10:15
It would be worth clarifying that. I am puzzling over whether we would clarify it with the organising committee or with Glasgow City Council. We will leave Jane Williams to determine who to ask whether the overall costings of the project are dependent on the final property development phase going ahead.Under the next heading, “Inflation”, I was intrigued to read:“It was suggested by the Committee during the evidence session on 27 January that inflation had been built into the financial planning for the Games for the first time only in 2010.”My recollection is that it was actually Liz Hunter who said that—it is as if she is trying to rewrite her evidence. Her evidence at the meeting was somewhat contradictory and confused, but we can get hold of the Official Report and maybe we need to write back to her. It was certainly not the committee that said that; she said that and it is outrageous that she tries to say in her letter that we suggested it.During the past few days I noticed that there was some coverage on accounting for inflation. Do members have comments on how inflation is being treated?
In her subsequent letter, which is dated 6 May, Liz Hunter wrote:“the agreed Games Budget would translate to £524m in cash terms”.However, in the next paragraph, she went on to say:“The Games partners are determined to work within the agreed budget which remains unchanged from that announced in November i.e. £454m at 2007 prices”.Why is she still talking about 2007 prices? Why does not she stick to the £524 million?
Can Audit Scotland throw any light on that?
We understand that the original bid to the Commonwealth Games Federation had to be in 2007 prices, to ensure that it was comparable against the bids of all the countries that were bidding. Updates on those costs against the budget at 2007 prices need to be maintained, as does updating for inflation—so there need to be two different comparable budgets.
Okay, as long as we have a budget that is in cash terms, which is the one that people like us—I do not mean you lot in Audit Scotland—understand, because it is a bit more realistic.
How can people make comparisons if the bid is at 2007 prices but the reality is that the cost will be in cash prices? If inflation is running at different levels in the countries that are bidding, how can comparisons be made?
I understand that if inflation in each country is stripped out and the 2007 prices are kept, there is more comparability. In some economies inflation might be running at 25 per cent, whereas in others it might be running at 2 per cent, so people would not be comparing like with like.
So people are comparing what is actually delivered and pricing it accordingly.
There is a benchmark, so that the final costings can be compared with a clear statement of the initial cost on those prices.
I am looking at the tables on pages 21 and 22 of Glasgow 2014’s “Annual Business Plan 2010/11”. Table 1 shows the 2007 benchmark prices and table 2 shows the budget at projected outturn prices with the inflationary element across the board. We would be interested if any budget lines stood out, beyond the inflationary amount, which would suggest cost overruns and so on. There do not appear to be such issues, but that remains to be seen.I am interested in the contingency figure that is expressed on page 20—the additional £20 million that has been set aside to be used only as a last resort. That money appears to be built into table 1 as a spend item, although I might be getting confused about that, because several contingency pots have been established. One was £40 million, but it was then topped up. Is the Audit Scotland team aware of that? If the £20 million is to be used only as a last resort, I would not expect it to be built into the budget lines on page 21.
I will attempt to answer that and Tricia Meldrum can correct me if I am wrong. There are two contingencies. There is a contingency fund of £60 million—in 2007 prices—in table 1 on page 21, and there is a special contingency of £20 million that is to be used only in exceptional circumstances. No spend is forecast against the £20 million because it is to be used only as a last resort.
Thank you.
Does anyone from Audit Scotland have any comment to make on the response on inflation?
I do not think so, convener.
Okay. Are there any comments on the sections headed “OC-Generated Income” and “Ticketing”?
Can somebody remind me why we asked the organising committee about projected ticket sales? Is it because we were concerned that it was overestimating the number of tickets that will be sold? We asked a number of questions about that. The response tells us what the projections are based on, but it does not reassure me, because it admits that Glasgow is smaller than Manchester. We did ask the organising committee to compare Glasgow with Manchester. If our motivation for asking the question was the concern that I mentioned—I think that it was—I am not sure that the question has been answered.
As I remember it, the committee was sceptical about whether the ticket sales projections were realistic given the population and catchment area of Glasgow and the likely spend. I am not sure that the answer that we have received fully reassures us.
We should also bear in mind the point that it is not just the actual population of the defined area of the venue that is important but the socioeconomic profile and the willingness and ability of people in the area to spend money on events such as the games. My understanding is that the area on the periphery of Manchester probably contains more people with significantly more disposable income. That must impact on the potential ticket sales.
The organising committee states that in its response. It acknowledges that there is a “lower average income” in Glasgow and a lower population, but it does not state how it came to the conclusions that it reached. It mentions non-revenue seats, seat kills and so on, but those would be the same anywhere. I just cannot see anything in the response that makes me think, “Yes—that’s how they came to that conclusion.” Obviously, if there is going to be a problem and the organising committee is going to have to attract more ticket sales, the earlier it gets on to that, the better.
We can certainly try to clarify that. Are there any comments on the remainder of the letter?
An alarm should sound on the broadcasting issue. It is not clear whether we are getting a deal with the BBC to broadcast the games. We already have a deal in place with Australia. That is great—it is to be welcomed—but I do not understand what the problem or issue is with the BBC. Did we get any clarification of what the difficulties are and when we might get a resolution? Does anybody know?
Our understanding is that hopefully something would be agreed by next year. That is fairly in line with typical timescales for agreeing these deals. The BBC has only recently agreed the deal to screen the Delhi games, which are happening this year, so things can happen a wee bit later. The Australian deal was concluded quite early in the process. It is still obviously a concern.
It is concerning that the letter states:“The OC has also reviewed its domestic broadcast revenue target downwards during the budget review.”Why would it do that if it does not even have a deal—or any semblance of a deal—in place? What is going on? I do not get it.
It says in the organising committee’s business plan:“During 2010/11 we aim to ... Continue to negotiate with the BBC with a view to achieving a ‘bundled’ agreement where the BBC agrees to act as Host Broadcaster in exchange for the domestic Rights to cover the Games.”Obviously such an agreement is fundamental to the financial success of the games. I suppose that we should ask for a progress report on when it expects that to be concluded.
We should also ask about the differing approach to covering Manchester compared with Glasgow. I do not know what the differing approach is or whether it is to do with scale. I would like to understand a wee bit more about the broadcasting issue and whether there is a plan for free-to-air broadcasting or internet media broadcasting. How the games are broadcast to the public around the world is bound to be of interest.
The business plan has been presented to us. The letter of 6 May comments on the spend profile, including inflation. Are there any comments on that?
I have a general comment on the games partnership structure, which is shown on page 7 of the business plan. Accountability, which is illustrated on that page, seems to go round in circles. Does the organising committee report to any parliamentary committee other than the Public Audit Committee?
It does not report to us. The only reason why we are looking at the business plan is that Audit Scotland has produced a report.
Which committee deals with sport in the Parliament? Is it lifelong learning or the jumping up and down committee, or whatever it is called?
It could be a couple of committees. The Health and Sport Committee would have an interest from the sports perspective and the Local Government and Communities Committee would probably have some degree of interest because of the involvement of Glasgow City Council.
I am talking about a committee not just having an interest in it but regular oversight of it. We have four more years until the games. Things could go drastically wrong in the planning. All the people listed on page 7 of the business plan are Government or council people. There is no regular parliamentary scrutiny, is there?
We will have the opportunity to look at this again next year once the Auditor General produces his next report. He will be reviewing progress.
So, this committee will review regularly the proposed expenditure right up until 2014.
Depending on what the Auditor General and Audit Scotland do, the committee might have the opportunity to do that, but we do not have the right to commission work on any issue at our own hand.
You know my view on that. It is astonishing that a committee of the Parliament does not have the right to do that. I do not know why the hell we are here as an elected Parliament unless we have some degree of responsibility. I mean no disrespect to the Auditor General; he is very good, and produces a lot of reports. However, we ought at some point to be able to examine our remit so that we can commission reports from the Auditor General, or else there is no reason for us to be sitting here.10:30
That is part of a bigger debate, on which a number of members have commented. As far as this is concerned, we are constrained by whatever the Auditor General and Audit Scotland decide to do. There will be a further report for us to comment on.George Foulkes is right—given that the Glasgow 2014 strategic group is chaired by the First Minister, the wider issue is how Parliament is able to hold those who are involved to account. There are a number of levels at which that can be done. There will be financial implications, so there will be an opportunity each year at the budget debate. Other committees can decide to examine various aspects of the Commonwealth games bid and the progress that is being made. Those are the parliamentary opportunities, and in addition we will have the opportunity to comment on the progress report from the Auditor General.
I have a second, and even more general, question on the issue. In the past when I have asked about some issues, the Auditor General has said that he cannot report until after the expenditure has been incurred. In this case, very creditably, we are considering the expenditure at an early stage, before the vast majority of it has been incurred. Is that a change in policy? Can we do the same in other cases? If there is a major infrastructure project, for example, can we examine it at an early stage rather than waiting until the money is committed?
I invite the Auditor General to comment.
Those things are a matter of judgment. Generally speaking, audit is a retrospective process, as the committee is aware. I would report to the committee only on expenditure that has already been incurred and audited, so that we have reliable financial numbers.Over the years, I have adopted the policy that if there are very significant projects that might present significant risks to public money, I will ask Audit Scotland to report at key points during the project and—explicitly and implicitly—use the language of the risks that we see. For example, a couple of major areas of risk that we saw in relation to the Commonwealth games project were around the allowances for inflation, which are by no means clear, and some of the income projections, with the United Kingdom economy heading into quite a severe recession.Using the language of risk is appropriate; we have done it in other reports. We did it first in relation to this Holyrood Parliament building, on which I made three reports that informed Lord Fraser’s inquiry. As we go forward, we will bear in mind some of the major capital projects that have been committed and consider whether particular pieces of work need to be done.That said, there is a limit to our resources. The team that does that type of work, under Barbara Hurst and Angela Cullen, is really stretched, and we cannot second-guess the desire of an organisation such as this, with all its expertise, to undertake projects such as this at its own hand. Fundamentally, the committee’s role is to hold others to account for their actions and their performance. We are not resourced to second-guess that process, and nor should we be.
Nevertheless, while accepting that constraint and qualification, we should welcome and encourage the initiative that the Auditor General has taken. Rather than crying over spilled milk and saying that it is terrible after the event, when hundreds of millions of pounds could have been saved, it is much better to get in at an early stage and say, “Unless you change this, you will spend—and waste—a huge amount unnecessarily.” It is good that the Auditor General is doing that.
Okay. I see that members have no further comments on the letter of 6 May.Are we agreed that we will start to prepare a draft report, and in the meantime ask our clerking team to request further information and go back on the issue of inflation? We can then return to the matter.Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 May 2010 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 17
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 53
- 10:00 Performance Audits (Programme) Committee business · 29
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.