Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Overview of the NHS in Scotland’s performance 2008/09”

Wednesday 26 May 2010 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Committee business 17 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
The Convener
link

Item 2 is consideration of the section 23 report, “Overview of the NHS in Scotland’s performance 2008/09”. We have received correspondence from the accountable officer, which has been circulated to members.There was one thing that struck and intrigued me and made me want further information. One of the witnesses from NHS Grampian, Dr Strachan, was quite explicit about the increase in the number of children under the age of 16 who present drunk at accident and emergency departments. She said that she believed that the figure had increased by “some 60 per cent” in her area.However, the response from the accountable officer seems to indicate that there are no figures on that. Members were quite alarmed to hear what Dr Strachan, a senior member of staff, had to say, but Kevin Woods suggests that there is no evidence on the issue. I think that it would be helpful if we could clarify with Dr Strachan exactly how the figures that she used were compiled. It is in everyone’s interest for us to get to the bottom of an extremely serious suggestion. Do members agree to my proposal?Members indicated agreement.

The Convener
link

Are there any other comments on Dr Woods’s response?

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

Dr Woods says that the figures“are currently not held centrally.”Does that mean that there are figures and that, although we cannot access them centrally, we could get them health board by health board? Dr Woods also says:“Information Services Division (ISD) Scotland is in the process of developing a national A&E data set which may include collection of the data requested.”Would it be in order for the committee to write to ISD to ask it to consider including such data, if it is not already considering doing that?

The Convener
link

Those are two reasonable points, which we can follow up with Dr Woods.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

Anne McLaughlin has made an important point. How many times have we been told in letters or in oral evidence, by people who are supposed to be running the national health service with some kind of strategic overview, “We do not hold that information centrally”? If they do not hold information centrally, how can they have a strategic overview? How can they make decisions about the health service? How can they allocate resources? I find it astonishing that with such a huge bureaucracy, which Murdo Fraser and his comrades will no doubt be having a look at—

Murdo Fraser Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con
link

Comrades?

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

How can the people in the huge bureaucracy down at Victoria Quay, or wherever it is now, who sit around purporting to direct the health service, have any oversight of it without such statistics? Anne McLaughlin’s point is a good one, which we should pursue.

Murdo Fraser Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con
link

I will need to ask my comrades in the Liberal Democrats how they intend to deal with the matter.I have a slightly different point, which relates to the quite striking details of rates of alcoholic liver disease on the second page of Dr Woods’s letter. The figures demonstrate substantial increases in such disease, particularly among younger age groups, which is an immensely serious matter. I am not suggesting that we should deal with it, but perhaps we should pass it on to the Health and Sport Committee, once we get the responses that we have talked about, and ask it to give the issue some attention, as it is clearly of some relevance to that committee’s work. In particular, it is relevant to consideration of the Alcohol etc (Scotland) Bill, which is currently progressing through the parliamentary system.

The Convener
link

We will wait for the further information that we have agreed to request.

Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP
link

The question whether data are held centrally or locally has been a recurring issue in this committee and others for a long time, stretching back to the beginning of the Parliament. Members seem to be giving the message that sometimes we would like to know about the data in a national Scottish context. There is merit in asking for that from time to time. We will not get that context for every detail that we ask for in this committee and others, but we would like some indicators. For example, when we discussed antidepressant prescribing in a previous meeting, we were interested in the Scottish picture, but it was not readily available. It would be useful in some cases, but I am not certain which committee would be the one to point the way towards gathering those kinds of statistics for the other committees. It is something to think about.

The Convener
link

We previously agreed that we would invite the accountable officer to the committee to speak about that. It would be useful to pursue the matter with him, because a number of members have raised similar concerns. If members agree, we can invite Dr Woods to the committee.

George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab
link

On the whole report?

The Convener
link

Yes, and that issue would be a significant part of it.

Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab
link

I know that this would not have been included in the Auditor General’s report, but the letter from Dr Woods to the committee states:“Almost two-thirds (64%) were sent home directly from the emergency department.”It would be interesting to see how the figures change for presentation at emergency departments when minor injury units are associated with the hospital. Presumably many of those people should have presented at a minor injury unit rather than A and E. It would be interesting to find out whether statistics are being gathered on that, as more and more hospitals, particularly in the Glasgow area, are running a full A and E with a minor injury unit close by.

The Convener
link

We can write to Dr Woods ahead of his evidence session to flag that issue up to him. He can respond in writing ahead of coming to the committee or address the point when he attends the meeting.

Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP
link

I just want to point out that although we do not have centrally held figures for the number of young people who are admitted to A and E because of alcohol, we have such figures for young people who are admitted to hospital overnight.Willie Coffey is right—some figures are held centrally and some are not, but it would help if we were explicit in the letter. In the letter to Dr Woods we said that we“would be grateful if you would provide figures, by health board”.Perhaps we should have added, “and if you do not hold them, could you get them in?”, because then it would be possible for him to gather the information, rather than gathering it ourselves. As Dr Woods helpfully reminds us at the end of his letter, rates for liver cirrhosis in Scotland are“50% higher than the EU average.”It is clear that alcohol is a huge problem, and we must do everything that we can to deal with it. Our questions should be more explicit.

The Convener
link

Okay. We will pursue the correspondence as we have agreed, and invite Dr Woods to the committee to give evidence.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 17
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 53
  4. 10:00 Performance Audits (Programme) Committee business · 29

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.