Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Male Victims of Domestic Abuse and Violence (PE1307)

Tuesday 18 May 2010 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 10 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
The Convener
link

PE1307, by Alison Waugh and Jackie Walls, calls on the Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that all publicly funded action on domestic abuse and/or violence fully addresses the needs of male victims and their children.We have explored some of the issues that the petition raises, and the petitioners recently gave evidence to the committee. I invite comments from members on what to do with the petition.15:30

Nigel Don
link

I found the evidence session, when the petitioners first came to the committee, extremely memorable and very moving. I acknowledge that the Government has moved faster than Governments often do. It has bought into a UK-wide men’s advice line, the number of which I will put on the record: it is 0808 8010327. I checked the number by ringing it yesterday. The Government tells us that it will get monthly statistics—confidentially, I take it—on where the callers come from and what the problems are. That is a good way of starting some research.Immediately after the last meeting of the Public Petitions Committee at which the petition was discussed, a constituent came to see me, as a result of which I wrote to Grampian Police, Aberdeen City Council and the Lord Advocate—she was not on our list. Grampian Police made the point that 80 per cent of victims of domestic abuse are female, but there is a steady rise in the number of men reporting domestic abuse. It also recognised that there is a lack of services for male victims.The statistics from Aberdeen City Council were slightly different: they show that 93 per cent of those who go before the sheriff court for domestic abuse are men. The council pointed to programmes such as the Caledonian programme for men and connections women’s programme. The Lord Advocate confirmed that the law is gender blind, saying:“Perpetrators are dealt with according to a robust prosecution policy where there is a presumption in favour of prosecution in all cases, regardless of gender.”Bearing in mind that there is some dispute about the information and that one particular report is not widely regarded as being very effective, we seem to have been pointed by correspondents to the “2008-09 Scottish Crime and Justice Survey: Partner Abuse”, which contains interesting statistics. It estimates that only 8 per cent of men who suffer from domestic abuse actually report it, which compares with about 35 per cent of women. If those statistics are anything close to being right, they confirm that by and large men do not report and that we need to be aware of an iceberg effect in respect of both genders.I note that Victim Support Scotland is having a conference in October on victim reporting, which is an important issue. That will be held here in Edinburgh.The conclusion that I draw is that there is a need for more research into the issue. I just do not think that we know enough about it, and the honest correspondents also recognise that. That is the underlying point that I would like to make. I also note that the letter from the Scottish Government—I will not quote the person’s name—comes from a team that is described as the “Gender Equality and Violence Against Women Team”.

Rhona Brankin
link

I do not see why that is a problem. I do not think that people would deny that violence against men exists—we see that coming through in the evidence—but we need to be careful about thinking that the situation is the same for men and for women. There are clearly gendered differences, and one question that we should ask the Government is whether it has done any gendered analysis of the situation. I would not want us to accept that there should necessarily be some sort of dismantling of the Government’s approach to violence against women in recognising that men also experience violence.

John Wilson
link

The petition has clearly opened up a debate, which is not just confined to this committee, as I am aware that more and more statistics are reported almost daily on male victims of domestic violence. Some figures from down south that came out last week said that men are the victims in one in seven cases of domestic violence. There is a wider debate to be had. As Nigel Don said, we are looking at the tip of the iceberg, because of perceptions about how domestic violence affects a particular gender. That is part of the debate. Thirty or 40 years ago, we managed to turn around and recognise that domestic violence against women had to be tackled by society and agencies and that the correct facilities must be put in place to enable people to escape from it. I welcome the Scottish Government’s commitment to funding the men’s helpline, although I hope that, when he said that he phoned it yesterday, Nigel Don was not stating publicly that he needed its support. However, I have to say that the help offered is quite restricted. We have to get the message out to individuals who need such support and advice, but we also need to address the underlying problem of the lack of facilities or support systems for men and their children to fall back on. Female victims of domestic violence have women’s refuges and can seek support from Scottish Women’s Aid, but that support is not available to men. We need to take the debate forward to ensure that we get equality in services.

Bill Butler
link

This is a sensitive issue and, as I recall, some of the evidence that we received from the petitioners was controversial, to say the least. I certainly did not accept all of it. I had sympathy for the two male witnesses, who obviously wished to remain anonymous; indeed, who would not have sympathy for anyone in that situation? However, we should bear in mind some of the comments in the responses that we have received. For example, our background paper refers to Professor Marianne Hester of the University of Bristol who, in her June 2009 paper “Who Does What to Whom?: Gender and Domestic Violence Perpetrators”, makes it clear that“there were significant differences between men and women as domestic violence perpetrators, with men much more likely to be repeat offenders.”In her paper, Professor Hester says:“the intensity and severity of violence and abusive behaviours from the men was much more extreme. This”was“also reflected in the nature of the violence used ... Men’s violence tended to create a context of fear and related to that, control. This was not similarly the case where women were perpetrators.”Similarly, in its response, Glasgow City Council says, among many other things:“There is no evidence of there being a particular issue of men under reporting domestic abuse. Reporting domestic abuse is never easy whatever your gender, hence the importance of publicity campaigns such as those run by the Scottish government. However, there are sections of the community where there are additional barriers such as those from smaller communities based on geography or identity. Those from rural areas, the lgbt, the Traveller or BME communities face particular difficulties that all agencies should address.”This is not an easy issue, but I echo my colleague Rhona Brankin’s comment that we should not be looking at tearing down structures that have been built up over a number of decades to meet the severe problems faced by women and children because of predominantly male violence. Although I agree that there is no harm in asking the Scottish Government to carry out more research, I will take some persuading to accept the views expressed by the two—if you like—professional folk who were the petitioners. Indeed, I might never be persuaded. I did not find their evidence at all convincing in any regard. Is that clear enough for the record, convener?Although we can ask the Government whether it wants to examine some of the issues and carry out more research, I think that we should be very careful indeed about accepting the premise on which the petitioners based their petition.

The Convener
link

I understand that individual committee members have strong views about the petitioners’ overall direction of travel, but we are trying to deal with the points raised in the petition and the responses that we have received. In that respect, I think that the view seems to be that we keep the petition open.

Nigel Don
link

I want to make it absolutely clear that I am not for one moment suggesting that we tear down existing structures that protect women who are victims or that there is anything wrong with the current assumption that women are overwhelmingly the victims and men are overwhelmingly the perpetrators—although I recall that we are not supposed to use the word “overwhelming” because the statistics might not support that view. The petition asks us to address the fact that we have more or less assumed that men have never been victims of such violence. Plainly the balance has gone slightly wrong in that respect and we should correct it.Just for the record and to assure John Wilson, let me say that my wife and I are still on speaking terms. In fact, I never got round to speaking to anyone on the helpline, because I was held in a queue. Nevertheless, I did work out the right number in the end.

Rhona Brankin
link

When we contact the Government about this petition, we should make it clear that in keeping the petition open we are not suggesting that it should dismantle existing structures or change its approach to women as victims of domestic abuse.

The Convener
link

We can make it clear in our inquiries that we are not seeking to diminish the predominance of domestic violence against women and children. We just want to ensure that a distinction is made here.Are we happy to keep the petition open to ensure that the issues that have been raised are explored?Members indicated agreement.

The Convener
link

We have no notification of new petitions. Our next meeting will be on 1 June here at Holyrood.Meeting closed at 15:42.

  1. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 28
  2. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  3. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  4. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.