Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Dairy Farmers (Human Rights) (PE1263)

Tuesday 18 May 2010 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 15 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
The Convener
link

PE1263, by Evelyn Mundell, on behalf of Ben Mundell, calls on the Parliament to urge the Government to accept that individual dairy farmers have human rights and that those have been breached by the operating rules of the ring-fencing mechanism attached to the management of milk quotas, which should have been carried out in accordance with objective criteria and in such a way as to ensure equal treatment between farmers and avoid market and competition distortion.Jamie McGrigor MSP has expressed an interest in the petition and is here this afternoon, so I invite him to make some comments.

Jamie McGrigor Highlands and Islands) (Con
link

Thank you for allowing me to make a short statement in support of my constituents, Mr and Mrs Mundell, and others who were financially crippled by the ring fencing of dairy quotas in their area, which was known as the southern isles. Before doing that, may I say that the Scottish Government’s letter of 12 March 2010 refers to the “Kyle peninsula”. I looked that up on Google, but I cannot find it anywhere. I do not know whether other members may be able to tell me where it is, but it does not seem to exist.

The Convener
link

It might mean Jeremy Kyle, which is a thought, indeed.

Jamie McGrigor Highlands and Islands) (Con
link

I will carry on. The Scottish Government moved its position when it conceded in its letter of 3 December 2009 that human rights issues were involved in terms of“a control on the use of property”.In this case, that refers to my constituents being prevented from selling—or leasing, for that matter—their dairy quota on the open market. Previously, the Government had suggested that purely agricultural matters were involved.In its letter of 12 March 2010, the Scottish Government seems to argue that it had to balance the “general or public interest” with the individual rights of my constituents. Understandably, my constituents still feel unfairly treated and question which other individuals in Scotland are seeing their rights to sell the assets that they own sacrificed for a perceived general or public interest. The fact remains that my constituents and others in their area are facing imminent bankruptcy. Had they been allowed to realise the potential of their milk quota in the way that most other Scottish dairy farmers were able to do, they would not be in a dreadful predicament that is not of their making.My constituents were also prevented from obtaining planning permission, which might have alleviated their financial position. My constituents and I look to the Public Petitions Committee to continue to press the Scottish Government to answer the questions properly, to justify in full why it was prepared to suspend their human rights—something that has caused so much worry, anxiety and financial loss—and to admit that human rights have indeed been breached in this case.Committee members will have read the Mundells’ paper. I hope that, in the words of the petition, you will accept that individual dairy farmers do have human rights and that those rights have been breached in this case.14:45

The Convener
link

I do not know whether the committee can make that assessment on human rights, but you raised some points that we will wish to explore. I invite comments from members and we will then decide what to do.

Nigel Don
link

You are absolutely right, convener. We are not in a position to judge whose human rights even exist, never mind whether they have been breached. However, there is an extremely important point in the petition.I am forced to the conclusion—I hope that I have got it right—that when the European Union or whatever it was at the time decided that there would be quotas for milk that were enforceable by Governments, that decision must have been consistent with the European convention on human rights. I hope that it would not have introduced the quotas otherwise. The problem would therefore appear to be the ring fencing and not the original concept. If that is the case, it will clarify that those whose human rights might have been breached will have been within an area that was ring fenced. That seems to be consistent with what is going on here.Will an individual’s human rights have been breached for the sake of a collective benefit? The answer might well be yes. I do not understand the Government saying, “Collectively, we have this right and therefore no individual could have had their rights breached.” There is no logic in that. I am absolutely with the petitioners on that. The question that follows, I guess, is how we should pursue this. We have asked the Government and it has said that it does not think that those rights have been breached. That is its view. If we ask it again, we will get the same answer. If there is background information that has not been brought before us, such as papers on how the matter was considered at the time, we should ask for it. I do not know whether we need to use freedom of information to get that. I suggest that we probably do not, although we could do it under FOI if the Government does not answer.I would have thought that the first thing that we should do is to get back to the Government and say, “Can we see the background papers, please? Did you actually consider this? If so, what was your considered response?” In the first instance, that is where I would stop. Our next step will depend on the response that we receive.

Rhona Brankin
link

I understand from our papers that the Scottish Agricultural College has carried out a study of the matter and the draft report is being considered, but we do not have any further information on that. That is an obvious thing to have a look at, is it not?

Robin Harper
link

The notes with which we have been provided do not explain why ring fencing was introduced in the first place. Is there an answer to that?

Jamie McGrigor Highlands and Islands) (Con
link

Do you want me to explain that, convener?

The Convener
link

Briefly.

Jamie McGrigor Highlands and Islands) (Con
link

I believe that it was considered that it would keep the creamery in Campbeltown in sufficient milk. Most of the milk at that time went to the creamery. I think that that was the rationale. At the time, every other dairy farmer in the country except those in Orkney and the southern isles, which is the location of the case that we are discussing, and those in Shetland and the Western Isles, was allowed to sell their quota on the open market. My constituents were not allowed to do so, which put them in an invidious position. Combined with everything else, it has forced them into a position of near bankruptcy. Another question worth asking is why the ring fencing on the Shetland Islands and the Western Isles was taken away. Those two areas were initially included in the ring fencing as well.In answer to your question, Robin, it was considered that, somehow, ring fencing the milk from within a certain radius would keep the Campbeltown creamery going. In other words, quotas could be swapped only by farmers within that area. I hope that I am right in saying that. They were not allowed to sell on the open market whereas any other dairy farmer was. Is that clear?

Robin Harper
link

Yes.

Bill Wilson West of Scotland) (SNP
link

I want to be clear about that. Does it mean that the farmers were guaranteed sales to the Campbeltown creamery? If so, what prices were guaranteed through that quota system and how did they compare with those on the open market?

Jamie McGrigor Highlands and Islands) (Con
link

I cannot answer that question. You would have to discover that from another source. You are going back a long way. I imagine that they would have got a price from the Campbeltown creamery, but I cannot tell you whether it was effective or good enough. I do not think that there was a guarantee, but that is pure speculation on my behalf.

The Convener
link

A number of outstanding questions that we want to explore have been raised by Jamie McGrigor and have come up in the discussion. We will pull those together. There are one or two queries about the reasoning and purpose behind the ring fencing. We will try to get greater clarity on those for the next time that we consider the petition. That might respond to the questions that Robin Harper and Bill Wilson raised.We will continue the petition and explore those issues. Jamie McGrigor knows the process through having been at the committee before. We will bring the petition back in due course and, no doubt, see him at that meeting.

  1. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 28
  2. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  3. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  4. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.