The next petition is PE1171, by John Muir, calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Government to introduce mandatory sentencing for persons who are found carrying knives or other dangerous weapons in public. Members will be aware that we have given the petition substantial consideration, which culminated in a major debate in Parliament on knife crime in Scotland. What do members want to do with the petition?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Knife Crime (Mandatory Sentencing) (PE1171)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 6
- Rhona Brankin Lab 4
- Nigel Don SNP 2
- Nanette Milne Con 1
- Fergus Cochrane Clerk 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
- Robin Harper Green 1
The record
16 contributionsFor a start, there are a couple of projects that we do not know the results of yet. One is campus cops and the other is medics against violence. It would be interesting to know the outcome of those two projects.
If you will forgive me, I will take a slightly pedantic line on this. I am bothered that we are having debates in the chamber and in public in which people are using the word "mandatory" incorrectly. John Muir himself understands that the word—which he included in the petition—may not have been the one that he really meant to use. I understand that you used the word in introducing the petition, convener, because it is in the petition. However, John Muir's latest letter—which, incidentally, contains a vast amount of good sense—states:"The importance of ‘Damian's Law' was never specifically the absolute introduction of mandatory sentencing".The word "mandatory" does not need to be qualified by the word "absolute", because it means absolute. It comes from the Latin word for "to command", and commands do not come with ifs, buts or maybes. Therefore, if folk want to talk about mandatory sentencing, they should be made aware of the fact that they are saying that there are no ifs, buts or maybes.If members think that the carpet fitter who puts the Stanley knife in his pocket and, at lunch time, goes around the corner looking for a pie for lunch should be sent to jail for having that Stanley knife in his pocket, they may wish to advocate mandatory sentencing. However, like me, they may think that it would be better for there to be a presumption that there will be prison sentences for those who are caught carrying knives. That would be a much better way of putting it, although there may be other wording for it. Can we please register that "mandatory" means something and that we will not help the discussion or improve the English language if we use it to mean something else?"conditions fixed by the Scottish Government".The word has a place in the discussion, but can we please use it properly? More specifically, can we please not use it improperly?
In my view, it is absolutely clear to the vast majority of the public what "mandatory" means. I would be concerned if the term were softened, because I know that there is a huge amount of public support for mandatory sentences for people who are found carrying knives and other dangerous weapons.
Nanette Milne has made a specific suggestion, and both Nigel Don and Rhona Brankin have made comments on meaning and interpretation, which are now on the record.
I will meet John Muir tomorrow afternoon. I can have a chat with him about the word "mandatory" and see whether he wants to amend the terms of the petition.
We are, ultimately, the custodians of what petitioners put forward. As long as it is deemed to be acceptable under our standing orders, what the petitioner wants is what we must deliberate on. In the knife crime summit and the public debate that we have had in the chamber and in the wider world, there has been discussion about how we could, through legislation, implement a policy to tackle the use of knives and so on.I think that the intention is to reach a situation in which people feel that a stronger message is sent out to those who carry knives with intent—I am not talking about tradespeople. Ultimately, the issue is about the fact that too many people in our communities—tragically, it is mainly young men—carry knives with intent on evenings out or at the weekend, when activity is guaranteed. We can explore those issues, but I acknowledge the positions that members have taken.
I would not want Mr Muir to think that the views that have been expressed about the word "mandatory" necessarily reflect the view of the Public Petitions Committee.
We will ensure that that is made clear.
I disagree with those views.
I understand that.
My point was about the use of a word. That word has a meaning, which I think Mr Muir understands. I, personally, am surprised at the length of the sentences that are handed down. I would have thought that anyone who carries a knife with intent should expect to go to prison, so I am probably of the same view as most people, including Mr Muir. That is not my point. As the convener has just said, it is a question of intent.In addition, there is the slight problem of the fact that, in this country, we expect our judges to use discretion. We take away judicial discretion at our peril, which is why we must ensure that we know precisely what we are saying. The proposal to have a Scottish sentencing council is one way of dealing with the issue and getting people to sort out what the policy should be.
The convener quite rightly identified that the issue is about carrying weapons with intent. Nigel Don gave a good example of the difficulty with a mandatory policy. If someone who was working near a certain shop that sells pies went out at lunch time with his tool-belt on or with a Stanley knife or chisel in his pocket, he could be stopped in the street and arrested, because that would be mandatory for anyone who was caught carrying a dangerous weapon in public.We need to be clear about what we are saying about how we treat people. The convener made it clear that intent is the determining factor when it comes to mandatory sentencing of people who carry dangerous weapons in public. We all need to be extremely careful about how we proceed. Are we saying that a person should be convicted and sentenced just because they happened to be, when they were stopped by the police, carrying in their back pocket a Stanley knife that they use at work for opening parcels or whatever? Should such a person be arrested and put in prison just because they had forgotten to take out of their back pocket the Stanley knife that sits there eight or 10 hours a day while they are at work?
It is clear that when Mr Muir lodged his petition, he was not thinking about people who happen to carry Stanley knives around with them. That is pretty self-evident, to be frank. I would not want Mr Muir to get the impression that the committee was being in any way critical of his petition. The issue will be considered by Parliament when it deals with the forthcoming legislation. It will be up to Parliament to make the decision.
One of the most important things to come out of the work on knife crime was the Government's encouragement of campus cops and medics against violence, but what concerns me about those initiatives is that they seem to be more like extremely small pilot projects. If we want to do something in schools, we must adopt a whole-school approach instead of just focusing on second year. All that we have are pupil numbers. We need to ask the Government whether it will step up the initiatives on the back of the two pilots and go for a whole-school approach that has a chance of being effective. It will not be particularly effective to carry on piecemeal. Taking just the second year in perhaps no more than three schools would give the Government an idea of whether the initiatives might work with second years, but it would not have any impact on overall knife crime in the school or area.
We will have a major opportunity to get to the heart of the issue in the chamber debate. Members will determine the best course of action on the sentencing council and the role that judges need to play as part of the wider concern that we all have about the impact in our parliamentary areas on individuals, not only the victims, but young men who, at a particular age, have chosen to behave in a certain way for which they need to be punished, which also has future consequences for them and their families. I am conscious that members feel strongly, but we want to interrogate the additional points a bit more thoroughly. I thank Robin Harper for his contribution on that petition.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Dec 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 1 December 2009 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 63
- New Petitions Petitions · 67
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- New Petitions Petitions · 13
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 16
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.