Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

High-voltage Transmission Lines (Potential Health Hazards) (PE812)

Tuesday 1 December 2009 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 5 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

5 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Item 2 is consideration of current petitions, the first of which is PE812, by Caroline Paterson, on behalf of Stirling Before Pylons. It calls for the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to acknowledge the potential health hazards associated with long-term exposure to electromagnetic fields from high-voltage transmission lines, and to introduce as a matter of urgency effective planning regulations to protect public health.A couple of elected members have shown a keen interest in the matter in the past. I welcome Chris Harvie MSP and Dr Richard Simpson MSP.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The petition focuses on potential health hazards associated with long-term exposure to electromagnetic fields from high-voltage transmission lines. The matter is of particular concern to me, as the proposed 400kV high-voltage Beauly to Denny line will run through built-up areas of my Mid Scotland and Fife constituency, from Bannockburn to Dunblane.I have heard numerous concerns expressed about the detrimental effects of the proposed overhead line on landscape, scenery and tourism. The health aspect is by far the most worrying of those effects.When I submitted my previous statement in May, I listed in some detail the studies that provide evidence for tangible health risks. I am not satisfied with the responses that have now been received from the Health Protection Agency and the Scottish Government. Both claim to uphold the 1999 European recommendation guidelines on public exposure to electromagnetic fields—EMFs. Those guidelines are outdated: they basically permit high-voltage power lines to run directly above homes, schools and nurseries, and they give a benchmark guideline of 100 microtesla. Subsequent studies have shown that even 0.4 microtesla can pose considerable health risks.In its response of 25 September, the Health Protection Agency admits that its current advice is based on"a comprehensive review of the science published in 2004".That is a year before the agency was set up in its current form. It claims that recent research is being monitored but that it has not sufficiently changed the balance of evidence.In response, I point to the appended list in my notes of 12 peer-reviewed publications since 2002, all of which evidence considerable health risks—particularly to children and infants—resulting from proximity to power line EMFs. However, the HPA has not engaged with or advised the Westminster and Holyrood Governments on any of them. Instead, the joint Government response of 16 October states:"The HPA advises that the EMF association with childhood leukaemia is weak and unproven".There is no mention of any other associated conditions such as Alzheimer's, adult cancers, motor neurone disease, miscarriage, or other cancers and brain tumours in children.The HPA's dismissal of those studies contradicts the Scottish Government's confidence in that body's diligence, expertise and ability to review and advise"on the totality of the available scientific evidence".Furthermore, the precautionary principle to which the UK signed up in the Maastricht treaty means that decisions need not be based on such established evidence. The principle comes into play when health risks begin to emerge that might, in time, be substantiated by research.Denis Henshaw, who is a professor of physics at the University of Bristol and the author of one of the papers, points out:"We have long passed the stage where application of the Precautionary Principle and of appropriate legislation against undue exposure is warranted, including a substantial lowering of permitted MF exposure limits, currently 100 microtesla. In the case of high voltage overhead powerlines, these should not be built close to houses".Other European countries with advanced electricity-dependent economies, such as Germany, Sweden and Switzerland, have already taken precautionary steps, even though the UK remains intransigent. The Scottish Government needs to engage critically with such evidence, and consider an enlightened precautionary approach. That would mean either routing the proposed Beauly to Denny line away from residential areas, or—better still—undergrounding it in crucial areas, thus avoiding all health risks and other disadvantages.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Chris Harvie has outlined the case in some detail. We have already presented to the committee the fact that the evidence for childhood leukaemia is certainly at the point beyond the precautionary principle and is well established. We now have a new paper from Japan, by Tomohiro Saito and colleagues, on "Power-Frequency Magnetic Fields and Childhood Brain Tumors: A Case-Control Study in Japan". There is some indication of growing evidence that brain tumours could also be a factor here.We await a further study that will cover six countries and include those Japanese data. One problem is that the numbers are very small, and studies therefore have wide confidence intervals, which makes things difficult. If even just a few cases switch from one direction to another, one can get a negative rather than a positive outcome.The proposed new pooling of data from Sweden, Norway, Finland, Denmark, Germany, the UK, the USA and Japan is under way, and we look forward to the analysis. We would expect it to confirm health risk associated with high-frequency lines, particularly those of 400kV-plus.The other arguments that have been put forward by the proposers of the line are that putting the cables underground would be inordinately expensive. Circumstances have changed since the process began. The old oil-filled underground lines are now being replaced with what is called XLPE—cross-linked polyethylene—cable, which rapidly reduces the cost. The latest German line to be implemented, as a result of new legislation and as one of four pilots, cost only seven times the amount. As oil and gas pipelines are already laid around Stirling, I suspect that costs there would be even lower because there is no evidence of massive rock formations on the route that is proposed by SNH, which came in purely on landscaping.In North Yorkshire a line has been put underground because of one particular 18th century church. Stirling has the Wallace monument, the Sheriffmuir battlefield and the view from the castle. There are small power lines there at the moment and they are not particularly intrusive, but the proposed new one will be substantially higher and will affect the landscape. It is also proposed to put lines underground at Elstree, Beddington and the Olympic park—some of them will be tunnelled, but some will be XLPE lines—so England is going ahead with the undergrounding of lines for a variety of reasons.Since I last presented evidence to the committee, other countries have also made similar moves. Copenhagen is undergrounding two lines of 12km and 22km respectively, and in Germany, following new legislation that came in this summer, four pilots are being done on lines of 16km and 30km. A considerable number of other countries are already undergrounding. We therefore suggest that the 23km on the route around Stirling should be undergrounded for health and landscaping reasons.The Government has indicated that it will give its response before Christmas to the reporter's report that was tabled in March, but it might be that the committee will wish to make further comment at this stage before a final decision is reached.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

We should certainly keep the petition open. We had a detailed submission from the petitioner before the meeting, so we could forward that to the Scottish Government, along with Richard Simpson's up-to-date information about undergrounding. I do not know whether the Government already has that information, but it would do no harm for us to forward it. I do not think that we can do much more at this point when the issue is with the Government, and I do not think that we can discuss it again until we have heard more from the Government.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We recognise the contributions that Dr Simpson and Professor Harvie have made today. If we pull them together as part of our response, we can pass it on to the Government and wait for its response on the report.I thank you for your patience, gentlemen. It has been a long afternoon.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 1 December 2009 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 63
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 67
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 12
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 13
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 31
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 16
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  18. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.