To ask the Scottish Executive what representations it has received regarding the case for a computed tomography scanner to be located in Orkney. (S3O-7137)
Nicola SturgeonSNPThe Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
The director and the secretary of the Scottish Islands Federation have both written to me recently supporting the case for a CT scanner in Orkney. The member wrote to me on the subject on 24 October last year, and I replied on 15 November. He also asked me about the issue during question time on 4 December.
Since I last raised the issue at health questions in December, my constituent Mike Craigie has suffered a stroke. Thankfully, Mr Craigie has made an excellent recovery and is now using his skills as a successful local businessman to spearhead the campaign for a CT scanner to be located in Orkney. Will the cabinet secretary agree to meet Mr Craigie and local clinicians to discuss the case for an Orkney-based scanner? Does she accept the view of Peter Malcolmson, chair of the Shetland community action for trauma support group—or CATS group—that the example of Shetland proves how a locally based scanner
"saves lives and … also saves money"?
Will she therefore reconsider allowing NHS Orkney to retain savings that are made in transport, admissions and air ambulance budgets so that a locally based scanner can be introduced and operated successfully in my constituency?
Nicola SturgeonSNPThe Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
I met local clinicians as part of the annual review last year, when the issue of a scanner was among the topics of discussion. I am sure that either the Minister for Public Health or I—I cannot immediately recall which one of us will be chairing the annual review this year—will be happy to meet the member's constituent when we are on the islands.
I well understand the strength of feeling on the issue of a scanner among both the public and clinicians in Orkney. It is ultimately for NHS Orkney to assess the demand for and the benefits of a scanner, and it is in the process of doing that. The member will be very much aware that the board held a public meeting on 12 May to hear local views about a scanner.
The Scottish Government would of course be happy to consider a business case if the cost exceeded the delegated limit for NHS Orkney, which is £5 million. It is unlikely that the cost of a scanner would exceed that amount, so it would be for NHS Orkney to decide how to fund it out of its revenue budget. Any savings that NHS Orkney makes as a result of having a scanner on the islands are open to be reinvested and may offset the cost of the scanner. I am sure that we will continue to have dialogue about the issue, and that it will be discussed again when we conduct the annual review later this year.
Given that there is a scanner in Wick, whose population is similar to Orkney's, that the possibility of treating strokes is much improved if the patient can have a scan and that injections within four hours of a stroke can be effective, does the cabinet secretary agree that there is an open-and-shut case why places with around 20,000 people, such as Orkney, should have a scanner?
Nicola SturgeonSNPThe Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
In some respects, my answer to that relates to the answer that I gave to Jamie Stone on an earlier question. I want to see services being provided locally where possible; equipment such as telehealth equipment and scanners are crucial in ensuring that that can happen. Ultimately, though, it is for NHS boards to assess the demand for, and the benefits of, scanners or other items of equipment. I am sure that all members would agree that it would be wrong for me to try to micromanage around the country and say where every piece of medical equipment goes. However, in the interests of ensuring local delivery of health care where possible, NHS boards are encouraged to, and do, take decisions that as far as possible facilitate that.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.