To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1729)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 11
- Alex Fergusson 8
- Iain Gray Lab 6
The record
26 contributionsLater today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
As members know, we had a substantial discussion in the budget process about the importance of apprenticeships and of delivering the most ambitious apprenticeship guarantee in the United Kingdom. After the apprenticeships summit, which we agreed on, and discussions with major employers with the capacity to take up apprentices, we have decided on a policy of offering a one-off payment of £2,000 to enable apprentices in Scotland who discontinue their employment to move into gainful training. I know that Labour members will welcome that.
As members know, we had a substantial discussion in the budget process about the importance of apprenticeships and of delivering the most ambitious apprenticeship guarantee in the United Kingdom. After the apprenticeships summit, which we agreed on, and discussions with major employers with the capacity to take up apprentices, we have decided on a policy of offering a one-off payment of £2,000 to enable apprentices in Scotland who discontinue their employment to move into gainful training. I know that Labour members will welcome that.
Last week, I asked the First Minister twice whether the gunman who strolled out of Castle Huntly prison 10 days ago should have been in an open prison in the first place, and the First Minister twice failed to answer my question. In light of the statement by his Cabinet Secretary for Justice yesterday, will the First Minister now answer that question? Should a dangerous convicted gunman with a history of violence and escapes have been in an open prison barely three years into a 10-year sentence?
I heard the Cabinet Secretary for Justice make the point yesterday that if the processes had been followed correctly and the information flow had been appropriate, the likelihood is that the decision that was made would not have been made. I do not know where Iain Gray was yesterday. I watched the Cabinet Secretary for Justice making his statement, and he answered that question and every other question comprehensively.
I was in the Parliament listening to Mr MacAskill making his statement, which—like the First Minister's response last week and his response today—simply reeked of complacency. Yesterday, Mr MacAskill told us that he had contacted the Scottish Prison Service last Thursday to ask it to review the circumstances of Brian Martin's transfer to an open prison. I wonder whether he did that before or after I raised the matter at First Minister's question time. Whatever, Mr Martin had absconded three days earlier, on the Monday. What was Mr MacAskill doing for three days with a dangerous and violent criminal on the run? Why did it take three days for him to get round to asking what had gone wrong?
I am getting groundhog day from Iain Gray. The prisoner concerned has been recaptured, as other prisoners from the open estate have been recaptured. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
One of the reasons why that can happen is the comprehensive increase in the number of police officers in Scotland. The other reason is that absconds from the open estate are running at only a fifth of the level that they were at under the Labour Party and an eighth of the level that they were at under the Conservative party. Mistakes happen—that is obvious. That was why Professor Alec Spencer was appointed to conduct an inquiry. However, it is clear that the system is functioning five times better than it was under the Labour-Liberal alliance.
As usual, the First Minister is barking—up the wrong tree. The issue is not the number of absconds; it is what went wrong in a particular case. It is groundhog day because of an answer that was read out three times last week and once again this week. Yesterday, Mr MacAskill said:
"The SPS has apologised to me for what appears to have been a failure in its information-sharing processes."—[Official Report, 27 May 2009; c 17836.]
The SPS has apologised to Mr MacAskill. Why is he not apologising to the Scottish public, who naively expect their Cabinet Secretary for Justice to keep violent criminals in jail? What about the First Minister? He was going to resign if we did not stop being nasty to Mr MacAskill. He would huff and puff and blow the house down. We have heard it all before—instead of throwing his toys out of the pram, why does he not throw his Cabinet Secretary for Justice out of his Cabinet?
"The SPS has apologised to me for what appears to have been a failure in its information-sharing processes."—[Official Report, 27 May 2009; c 17836.]
The SPS has apologised to Mr MacAskill. Why is he not apologising to the Scottish public, who naively expect their Cabinet Secretary for Justice to keep violent criminals in jail? What about the First Minister? He was going to resign if we did not stop being nasty to Mr MacAskill. He would huff and puff and blow the house down. We have heard it all before—instead of throwing his toys out of the pram, why does he not throw his Cabinet Secretary for Justice out of his Cabinet?
If we had an election in Scotland, it is the Labour Party that would be blown away. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
I have listened carefully to Iain Gray's performance on the issue. This morning, on "Good Morning Scotland"—I have the transcript here—the question was put:
"It's an interesting thing responsibility though isn't it, because in 2006/07, there were 79 absconds from Scottish prisons—2008/09 there's just been 16. Where was responsibility then, Mr Gray?"
And the answer?
"Well that's a very welcome improvement".
Indeed it is a welcome improvement—under this Cabinet Secretary for Justice. It compares well with the abysmal record of the Labour and Liberal parties. [Applause.]
"It's an interesting thing responsibility though isn't it, because in 2006/07, there were 79 absconds from Scottish prisons—2008/09 there's just been 16. Where was responsibility then, Mr Gray?"
And the answer?
"Well that's a very welcome improvement".
Indeed it is a welcome improvement—under this Cabinet Secretary for Justice. It compares well with the abysmal record of the Labour and Liberal parties. [Applause.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. Iain Gray has a final question.
It is a very welcome improvement. I welcomed it last week—the first time that the First Minister said it, I welcomed it; the second time that he read it out, I welcomed it; I did that the third time that he read it out. I welcome it again today.
This is about the complacency of Mr MacAskill's response, the full measure of which we saw when he called the accidental release of a violent prisoner
"a glitch in the system".
What about the other glitches? Missing the knife crime summit: was that a glitch? Failure to control knife sales: was that a glitch? Hundreds of cases being delayed in our High Courts: is that another glitch? Ditching community courts: was that a glitch, too? Telling Scotland's criminals that prison is "a skoosh": was that a glitch in the system?
Look at the headlines: "MacAskill ‘on the run'", "MacAskill under fire", "Sack him now." This is not a "glitch", "gaffe", "bungle" or "fiasco". When will the First Minister admit that his Cabinet Secretary for Justice is the glitch in the justice system and do something about it?
This is about the complacency of Mr MacAskill's response, the full measure of which we saw when he called the accidental release of a violent prisoner
"a glitch in the system".
What about the other glitches? Missing the knife crime summit: was that a glitch? Failure to control knife sales: was that a glitch? Hundreds of cases being delayed in our High Courts: is that another glitch? Ditching community courts: was that a glitch, too? Telling Scotland's criminals that prison is "a skoosh": was that a glitch in the system?
Look at the headlines: "MacAskill ‘on the run'", "MacAskill under fire", "Sack him now." This is not a "glitch", "gaffe", "bungle" or "fiasco". When will the First Minister admit that his Cabinet Secretary for Justice is the glitch in the justice system and do something about it?
Like all the best action replays, we get it from Iain Gray in slow motion. I heard him try to remember the reality of what happened under Cathy Jamieson's stewardship as Minister for Justice—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
He was asked this morning about the high rate of absconds under the Labour-Liberal alliance. This is what he said in answer:
"I don't actually remember that happening under Cathy Jamieson stewardship at the Justice Department."
Let me try to jog his memory. In February 2007, the Evening Telegraph and Post reported:
"A murderer serving a life sentence and a man convicted of attempted murder are among the inmates who have been on the run from open prisons in Tayside for more than a year … They include a 51-year-old who was serving a life sentence, with a minimum of nine years, for murder. He escaped in May 2005."
Tragically, that man was not recaptured before he murdered again.
Iain Gray attempts to attack the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, whose record is five times better than that of the previous Minister for Justice. Why did he not try to allocate individual responsibility to the Labour Minister for Justice who presided over not only a record rate of increases, but a systematic tragedy? [Applause.]
"I don't actually remember that happening under Cathy Jamieson stewardship at the Justice Department."
Let me try to jog his memory. In February 2007, the Evening Telegraph and Post reported:
"A murderer serving a life sentence and a man convicted of attempted murder are among the inmates who have been on the run from open prisons in Tayside for more than a year … They include a 51-year-old who was serving a life sentence, with a minimum of nine years, for murder. He escaped in May 2005."
Tragically, that man was not recaptured before he murdered again.
Iain Gray attempts to attack the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, whose record is five times better than that of the previous Minister for Justice. Why did he not try to allocate individual responsibility to the Labour Minister for Justice who presided over not only a record rate of increases, but a systematic tragedy? [Applause.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. Iain Gray: one final, brief question.
I heard "Good Morning Scotland"—I was there, so I know what was said. I have checked how Cathy Jamieson dealt with those issues, particularly the issue of Reliance and prison absconding. I will tell the chamber how she responded: she came to the chamber and apologised. I am willing to listen to the First Minister apologise now.
Members
link
Apologise.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
We are talking not about the Reliance fiasco, but about absconds from the open estate—the ones that Iain Gray could not remember under Cathy Jamieson's tenure. It is important that Government accepts responsibility and we do—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. First Minister—
It is even more important that he should—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
First Minister, I know that you could not hear me, but I must stop you.
When I ask for order in the chamber, I expect to get it. I allow as much latitude as possible for members to support or decry what is being said, but when I ask for order, I expect to get it.
When I ask for order in the chamber, I expect to get it. I allow as much latitude as possible for members to support or decry what is being said, but when I ask for order, I expect to get it.
Thank you for your guidance, Presiding Officer.
I am sure that every Labour member will want to hear how Labour's record in Government was five times worse than the record now. Governments have to accept responsibility, but the individual amnesia from Iain Gray on the reality of the rate of absconds under the Labour-Liberal Administration and the collective amnesia from the entire Labour group on the subject is no substitute for the effective action of the Cabinet Secretary for Justice—action that has brought about dramatic improvement in the open estate.
I am sure that every Labour member will want to hear how Labour's record in Government was five times worse than the record now. Governments have to accept responsibility, but the individual amnesia from Iain Gray on the reality of the rate of absconds under the Labour-Liberal Administration and the collective amnesia from the entire Labour group on the subject is no substitute for the effective action of the Cabinet Secretary for Justice—action that has brought about dramatic improvement in the open estate.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 May 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 28 May 2009 Debate · 1
- Missing Children Alert System Debate · 22
- Supporting Scottish Business Debate · 81
- Employment (Equality) Questions · 4
- Judiciary (Support for Victims) Questions · 4
- Civil Contingency Plans Questions · 6
- Student Support (Maintenance Loans) Questions · 8
- Sri Lanka (Humanitarian Assistance) Questions · 4
- Opencast Coal Mining (Climate Change) Questions · 8
- Gulls (Nuisance) Questions · 8
- Compulsory Purchase Legislation Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 26
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- National Health Service Consultants (Distinction Awards) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Financial Inclusion First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scotland's Colleges (Recession) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Medical Services (Decentralisation) Questions · 8
- Medical Technology Questions · 4
- Volunteer Ambulance Services Questions · 8
- CT Scanner (Orkney) Questions · 6
- Stobhill Hospital (Proposed Extension) Questions · 4
- Asylum (Alternatives to Detention) Questions · 4
- Well Man Clinics (Sports Clubs) Questions · 6
- Parkinson's Disease (Lothians) Questions · 8
- Affordable Homes for Rent (Midlothian) Questions · 12
- Cancer (Treatment and Survivability Rates) Questions · 6
- Osteoporosis Services (Community Health Partnerships) Questions · 4
- Cancer (Waiting Time Targets) Questions · 4
- Ambulance Response Times (Rural Areas) Questions · 4
- Commissioner for Public Appointments in Scotland Debate · 3
- Cashback for Communities Debate · 53
- Point of Order Procedure · 7
- Decision Time Decision time · 22
- Infertility Treatment Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.