Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Commission on Scottish Devolution

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Europe, External Affairs and Culture

Thursday 23 April 2009 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 6 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

6 contributions
George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link
To ask the Scottish Executive whether it considers that the Calman Commission on Scottish Devolution is making a positive contribution to the debate on Scotland's constitutional options. (S3O-6608)

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
The Scottish Government has consistently said that the commission might make a useful contribution to the national conversation. However, by refusing to consider independence, the commission limits debate and denies the people of Scotland the opportunity to consider all the options.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link
Is the minister aware that, at the Plaid Cymru spring conference, his colleague Aileen Campbell described the Calman commission as anti-democratic? Since the commission was established following a large majority vote in the Parliament from three parties representing nearly two thirds of the electorate at the previous Scottish Parliament elections, will he dissociate himself and the Scottish Executive from those ill-judged and contemptuous remarks?

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
It will not surprise the member to learn that I will not do that and that I endorse Aileen Campbell's remarks, because her point is entirely clear. Any commission that rejects any of the available options is anti-democratic. If all the options are genuinely included, a process is by definition democratic.

I look forward to the opportunity to have that discussion with Sir Kenneth Calman. I have agreed that we should have that conversation, in which, I am quite sure, he will argue otherwise. That said, the weight of truth is on my side. In the end, only an examination of all the options will lead to a clear choice by the people of Scotland.

I hope, Presiding Officer—I am sorry, Deputy Presiding Officer—I have just realised that there has been a change—

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
Alas, given that sedentary intervention from Mr McAveety, I cannot say that things have changed for the better beside me.

I hope that Lord Foulkes will take part in the national conversation, lend his undoubted weight to the issue and ensure that we understand his considered position, after which he should vote for the people of Scotland to make the final choice. That is democratic.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 23 April 2009 Debate · 1
  2. Newspaper Industry Debate · 25
  3. Transport Infrastructure (West of Scotland) Debate · 57
  4. Road Safety Questions · 6
  5. Business Support (North-east Scotland) Questions · 6
  6. National Concessionary Travel Scheme Questions · 6
  7. National Health Service Aroma Cafe Questions · 4
  8. Wrongful Death (Damages) Questions · 4
  9. Road Safety Questions · 4
  10. Public Sector (Pay and Conditions) Questions · 4
  11. Scotland Rural Development Programme Questions · 6
  12. Great Britain Football Team Questions · 4
  13. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  14. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 21
  16. Drug and Alcohol Services First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Ambulance Response Times First Minister’s Questions · 6
  18. National Trust for Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 8
  19. Chinese Culture, History and Language Questions · 7
  20. Teacher Training (Scots Language) Questions · 4
  21. Additional Support Needs (Resources) Questions · 4
  22. Universities (Graduate Career Prospects) Questions · 8
  23. Primary Schools (Class Sizes) Questions · 6
  24. South Ayrshire Council (Meetings) Questions · 5
  25. Teacher Numbers (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
  26. Creative Scotland (Funding) Questions · 6
  27. First Minister (Visit to China) Questions · 6
  28. United Kingdom Permanent Representation to the European Union Questions · 7
  29. Buildings of Historical Interest Questions · 9
  30. Creative Scotland (Set-up Costs) Questions · 4
  31. Broadcasting and Print Media Questions · 6
  32. Commission on Scottish Devolution Questions · 6
  33. Glasgow 2014 Legacy Plan Debate · 35
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 43
  35. Daily Record and Sunday Mail Members’ business · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.