To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1623)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
The record
10 contributionsLater today I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
Today is 23 April, St George's day, so I think it appropriate to congratulate the people of England on their national day.
Today is 23 April, St George's day, so I think it appropriate to congratulate the people of England on their national day.
The whole country wants to see all politicians, all parties and all sectors working together to help hard-working families through the global economic downturn. Yesterday's United Kingdom budget included £400 million for Scots seeking work, pensioners paying their fuel bills, and families bringing up children. It included new support for Scotland's oil and gas industry and for our renewable energy industry. It also showed that the Scottish budget will, in the teeth of a recession, grow by £2.2 billion over the next two years. Can the First Minister confirm that?
I am afraid that Iain Gray will have to come to terms with reality. If yesterday was a day of reckoning for Labour at Westminster, today is the day of reckoning for Labour in the Scottish Parliament.
Since November, Iain Gray has been saying of the cuts that are planned for next year that the amount might be less than £500 million. He has been appealing to his financial guru Andy Kerr for advice, who also says that it could not possibly be worked out. This morning on the radio, the Chancellor of the Exchequer said that it could still not be worked out. Well, we can work it out. The total cut by Labour on Scotland for next year is £496,682,000. That is the reality of what Labour in Westminster is forcing on the Scottish people.
Does Iain Gray understand that that level of reduction in funding for vital services in Scotland is not only bad for the economy and bad for public services, but threatens 9,000 jobs in Scotland?
Since November, Iain Gray has been saying of the cuts that are planned for next year that the amount might be less than £500 million. He has been appealing to his financial guru Andy Kerr for advice, who also says that it could not possibly be worked out. This morning on the radio, the Chancellor of the Exchequer said that it could still not be worked out. Well, we can work it out. The total cut by Labour on Scotland for next year is £496,682,000. That is the reality of what Labour in Westminster is forcing on the Scottish people.
Does Iain Gray understand that that level of reduction in funding for vital services in Scotland is not only bad for the economy and bad for public services, but threatens 9,000 jobs in Scotland?
Last week, the First Minister was caught out by the old trick question: what do you get if you divide by zero? The correct answer is that the question is meaningless—and so is his budget arithmetic.
Since November, I have been saying that the First Minister's budget would in the next year increase, and that in the year after that it would increase. So—let us do a bit of reckoning, and let us keep it simple. The First Minister's budget is £33.3 billion in 2008-09, £34.8 billion in 2009-10, and £35.5 billion in 2010-11. Is his budget going up, or is it going down?
Since November, I have been saying that the First Minister's budget would in the next year increase, and that in the year after that it would increase. So—let us do a bit of reckoning, and let us keep it simple. The First Minister's budget is £33.3 billion in 2008-09, £34.8 billion in 2009-10, and £35.5 billion in 2010-11. Is his budget going up, or is it going down?
Iain Gray will find the answer on page 241 of the red book that is published with the budget. This year, total managed expenditure for the Scottish budget is £29.1 billion. That is revenue and capital. Next year, it will be £29.3 billion. In real terms, that will be the first cut in the Scottish budget since the Tory years. In real terms, next year's figure will be £28.8 billion.
Now, I know that Iain Gray was a maths teacher, and I have to say that the BBC made one of its few apologies to me as far as the maths question was concerned. I know that he has been out of teaching for some time, but even Iain Gray must recognise that 28.8 is less than 29.1. Whatever way it is divided, that is the first real-terms cut in Scottish expenditure since the Tory years—something, of course, that the Labour Party said it would never do.
People in Scotland must find extraordinary the contrast in the rhetoric of the chancellor and the Prime Minister, who at Westminster berate the Tory party on cutting public services, when that is exactly what they propose to do next year in Scotland.
Now, I know that Iain Gray was a maths teacher, and I have to say that the BBC made one of its few apologies to me as far as the maths question was concerned. I know that he has been out of teaching for some time, but even Iain Gray must recognise that 28.8 is less than 29.1. Whatever way it is divided, that is the first real-terms cut in Scottish expenditure since the Tory years—something, of course, that the Labour Party said it would never do.
People in Scotland must find extraordinary the contrast in the rhetoric of the chancellor and the Prime Minister, who at Westminster berate the Tory party on cutting public services, when that is exactly what they propose to do next year in Scotland.
The First Minister can play around with his annually managed expenditure, his total managed expenditure and his departmental expenditure limit until he gets the figure he wants. However, any honest appraisal of the figures shows that his budget is still going up year on year, increasing by more than £2 billion in two years. The real question is this: what choices will the First Minister make with that budget? Labour at Westminster has promised to safeguard front-line services and to maintain budget increases of 5 per cent for local health services and 4 per cent for schools. Will the First Minister make the same promise for Scotland?
I will tell Iain Gray the choices that we would make if we were in government at Westminster. We would not choose to spend £25 billion on Trident nuclear missiles. Labour at Westminster has also chosen to spend £5 billion on a national database for identity cards that will do nobody any good. That is an extraordinary position. Those are the real political choices. Hands up who in the Labour Party wants to spend £100 billion on Trident while cutting public expenditure in Scotland. Lord George Foulkes is the only Labour member to put his hand up.
Iain Gray will have to come to terms with the fact that this is not playing around with financial aggregates. What Labour proposes is a cut of 9,000 jobs in Scotland—real jobs and real people are at risk of redundancy because of Labour.
Iain Gray will have to come to terms with the fact that this is not playing around with financial aggregates. What Labour proposes is a cut of 9,000 jobs in Scotland—real jobs and real people are at risk of redundancy because of Labour.
Were we to cancel Trident, we would cut 11,000 jobs in the west of Scotland. Is that really the First Minister's brilliant idea to save the Scottish economy? We know the choices that the First Minister makes because he has been making them for two years. There have been cuts in teacher numbers—his cuts—and cuts in school building programmes, which are his cuts. Twenty thousand construction jobs have gone already and there have been cuts in housing completions—his cuts. There have been cuts in apprenticeship programmes—his cuts—and pensioners have been cut out of the central heating programme by means testing. Those are his cuts. Those cuts have nothing to do with next year's budget, the year after's budget or the budgets in 2013 and 2014. They have got nothing to do with Westminster; the person who is responsible for them is right here. The First Minister's budget is going to grow by £2.2 billion. When will he grow up, take responsibility and get on with the job?
We have already demonstrated that the cuts that Labour has refused to acknowledge since November will come in the Scottish budget next year—the first cuts since the Tory years.
I am interested in Iain Gray's inability to understand the difference between reinvesting in public services and top-slicing from the Scottish budget. I was also interested in Andy Kerr's analysis on "Newsnight Scotland" last night, in which he attacked the Scottish National Party. He said:
"They've, you know, reduced expenditure in Scotland by £1.6 billion worth of cuts. They've spent to the hilt."
In one breath, Andy Kerr said that we have been both cutting and spending "to the hilt."
The difference is that the efficiency savings that are being made in Scotland are going back into local government and the health service, whereas the Darling-Gray cuts will be top-sliced from the Scottish budget and will cost 9,000 jobs in Scotland. It is not only the SNP that is arguing that: the Scottish Trades Union Congress and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities share our concerns. Every social partnership in Scotland knows the difference between investment by the SNP and cuts in public spending by the Labour Party.
I am interested in Iain Gray's inability to understand the difference between reinvesting in public services and top-slicing from the Scottish budget. I was also interested in Andy Kerr's analysis on "Newsnight Scotland" last night, in which he attacked the Scottish National Party. He said:
"They've, you know, reduced expenditure in Scotland by £1.6 billion worth of cuts. They've spent to the hilt."
In one breath, Andy Kerr said that we have been both cutting and spending "to the hilt."
The difference is that the efficiency savings that are being made in Scotland are going back into local government and the health service, whereas the Darling-Gray cuts will be top-sliced from the Scottish budget and will cost 9,000 jobs in Scotland. It is not only the SNP that is arguing that: the Scottish Trades Union Congress and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities share our concerns. Every social partnership in Scotland knows the difference between investment by the SNP and cuts in public spending by the Labour Party.
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Apr 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 23 April 2009 Debate · 1
- Newspaper Industry Debate · 25
- Transport Infrastructure (West of Scotland) Debate · 57
- Road Safety Questions · 6
- Business Support (North-east Scotland) Questions · 6
- National Concessionary Travel Scheme Questions · 6
- National Health Service Aroma Cafe Questions · 4
- Wrongful Death (Damages) Questions · 4
- Road Safety Questions · 4
- Public Sector (Pay and Conditions) Questions · 4
- Scotland Rural Development Programme Questions · 6
- Great Britain Football Team Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 21
- Drug and Alcohol Services First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Ambulance Response Times First Minister’s Questions · 6
- National Trust for Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Chinese Culture, History and Language Questions · 7
- Teacher Training (Scots Language) Questions · 4
- Additional Support Needs (Resources) Questions · 4
- Universities (Graduate Career Prospects) Questions · 8
- Primary Schools (Class Sizes) Questions · 6
- South Ayrshire Council (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Teacher Numbers (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
- Creative Scotland (Funding) Questions · 6
- First Minister (Visit to China) Questions · 6
- United Kingdom Permanent Representation to the European Union Questions · 7
- Buildings of Historical Interest Questions · 9
- Creative Scotland (Set-up Costs) Questions · 4
- Broadcasting and Print Media Questions · 6
- Commission on Scottish Devolution Questions · 6
- Glasgow 2014 Legacy Plan Debate · 35
- Decision Time Decision time · 43
- Daily Record and Sunday Mail Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.