To ask the First Minister what progress the Scottish Government is making in reducing the impact of overconsumption of alcohol. (S3F-1515)
Official Report · Chamber
Alcohol
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Nigel Don SNP 2
- Richard Baker Lab 1
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
- Murdo Fraser Con 1
The record
10 contributionsWe have already taken action to reduce alcohol overconsumption in Scotland. The record investment of more than £120 million over three years will make a difference to thousands of Scots through improved prevention, treatment and support services. The scale of the problem requires us to do more. That is why, this week, the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing and the Cabinet Secretary for Justice published our response to the consultation on alcohol misuse and outlined our next steps. "Changing Scotland's Relationship with Alcohol: A Framework for Action" outlines proposals for specific legislation that is designed to effect change in the short term, as well as measures that will help to create a change in cultural attitudes in the long term.
If I may, I will quote:
"Alcohol has cost Scotland dearly. Through its significant contribution to violence, it has placed an immense financial burden on this country. … Fundamentally, if you want to reduce violence then you need to reduce access to alcohol. We know that the group most at risk from violence is young males aged 10-29, so if you limit access to alcohol in certain areas then it can only be a good thing, especially as it is done with local agreement and is locally relevant."
Those are the words of Detective Chief Superintendent John Carnochan, the head of the violence reduction unit. Does the First Minister agree with that view?
"Alcohol has cost Scotland dearly. Through its significant contribution to violence, it has placed an immense financial burden on this country. … Fundamentally, if you want to reduce violence then you need to reduce access to alcohol. We know that the group most at risk from violence is young males aged 10-29, so if you limit access to alcohol in certain areas then it can only be a good thing, especially as it is done with local agreement and is locally relevant."
Those are the words of Detective Chief Superintendent John Carnochan, the head of the violence reduction unit. Does the First Minister agree with that view?
I certainly think that we would do well to listen carefully to the experience of serving police officers. We should also reflect on experience in the pilot areas, where restrictions on sales at weekends and sometimes more generally have been tried over the past year or so, which gives us strong indications. In Stenhousemuir, there was a 40 per cent reduction in breach of the peace offences; in the first week of the Cupar pilot, there was a drop of 60 per cent in calls to the police relating to antisocial behaviour; and, during the Armadale pilot, there was a reduction in the number of calls about youth disorder and vandalism. We should listen carefully to the experience of the professionals who are working in this field. We should listen also to Nigel Don, who makes the point in exactly the right way when he says that those who are most at risk are young people themselves.
Why did the First Minister say last week that mandatory challenge 21 schemes and alcohol treatment and testing orders are in place when they are not? I ask that not to debate veracity in the chamber; I ask him to agree that all parties wish to tackle alcohol abuse, that sensible proposals from all sides should be seriously considered and that the final decision on major policy changes in this area must be for the whole Parliament.
I said that they were coming in in September, and tried to inform and help Richard Baker along those lines. He would do well not to assume that everyone, including ministers, is always trying to put a trick over on him.
I have to warn Richard Baker that I think that he is heading for a substantial fall on the issue of police numbers. I give him that cautionary piece of advice on that matter, because I know that, if he proves to be wrong on that issue, he will be the first to come to the chamber to apologise.
I have to warn Richard Baker that I think that he is heading for a substantial fall on the issue of police numbers. I give him that cautionary piece of advice on that matter, because I know that, if he proves to be wrong on that issue, he will be the first to come to the chamber to apologise.
I think that the First Minister agrees that legislation is not a cure-all, and that educating our young people plays an important part in the matter that we are discussing. In that context, I suggest that either he or his ministers should visit Peebles high school to meet the members of the up to you group, who go to the feeder primaries to talk about the consequences of alcohol consumption. That is a very successful project for the primary pupils and the secondary pupils.
The framework for action indicates a number of ways in which we intend to take forward our work to support young people to make more informed choices about alcohol. Officials have already visited the project that Christine Grahame has mentioned, and we find it extremely interesting. Of course, local authorities have to determine how best to deploy resources for education, including substance misuse education. Within the hugely expanded budget in this area, there will be many projects that point the way to a better future for the young people of Scotland, and the project that Christine Grahame mentions is an extremely interesting example of that work.
link
The First Minister is fond of trumpeting his support for the Scotch whisky industry. However, on Monday, Gavin Hewitt, the chief executive of the Scotch Whisky Association, said of the Government's minimum-pricing proposals:
"It is hard to believe any Scottish Government would bring forward proposals that are likely to be both illegal in international trade law and risk damaging the whisky industry. Regrettably, minimum pricing achieves both and undermines our success in breaking down illegal discrimination against Scotch Whisky around the world."
Why is the First Minister determined to press ahead with those unworkable proposals when they will so damage the industry that he claims to support?
"It is hard to believe any Scottish Government would bring forward proposals that are likely to be both illegal in international trade law and risk damaging the whisky industry. Regrettably, minimum pricing achieves both and undermines our success in breaking down illegal discrimination against Scotch Whisky around the world."
Why is the First Minister determined to press ahead with those unworkable proposals when they will so damage the industry that he claims to support?
We are confident of the legal position of our proposals.
I could answer Murdo Fraser's question by giving him a range of quotations from people who support the Government's proposals, including people in the licensed trade and the drinks industry. However, there is a position of greater principle. Scotch whisky's huge success in the international marketplace is based on the concept of its being a premium drink of exceptionally high quality. Even a casual observation of our proposals—I know that Murdo Fraser will have examined them—will show that they are directed at the low-quality, high-strength drinks that are causing enormous damage to Scottish society.
Last week, I attended a meeting of the Distilled Spirits Council of the United States at which the president of the association commenced his speech by speaking about Scotch whisky's profile in the international marketplace as a high-quality, premium drink that is marketed with a socially responsible attitude. That is exactly what the future success of Scottish whisky should be based on.
I could answer Murdo Fraser's question by giving him a range of quotations from people who support the Government's proposals, including people in the licensed trade and the drinks industry. However, there is a position of greater principle. Scotch whisky's huge success in the international marketplace is based on the concept of its being a premium drink of exceptionally high quality. Even a casual observation of our proposals—I know that Murdo Fraser will have examined them—will show that they are directed at the low-quality, high-strength drinks that are causing enormous damage to Scottish society.
Last week, I attended a meeting of the Distilled Spirits Council of the United States at which the president of the association commenced his speech by speaking about Scotch whisky's profile in the international marketplace as a high-quality, premium drink that is marketed with a socially responsible attitude. That is exactly what the future success of Scottish whisky should be based on.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Mar 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 5 March 2009 Debate · 1
- Scottish Government (Record) Debate · 168
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- International Children's Games Questions · 9
- Property Developers (Delays) Questions · 6
- Scots Questions · 4
- United States of America (Co-operation) Questions · 8
- National Conversation Questions · 9
- Patient Records Questions · 4
- Scottish Commission for Human Rights (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Affordable Housing (Edinburgh) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Alcohol First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Class Sizes First Minister’s Questions · 10
- VisitScotland First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Water Testing (Church and Community Halls) Questions · 4
- Local Government Finance Questions · 4
- Scottish Futures Trust Questions · 10
- Orkney Islands Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Town Centre Regeneration Fund Questions · 10
- Local Government (Executive Pay) Questions · 6
- Carbon Savings (Reporting) Questions · 4
- Local Authority Funding (Roads) Questions · 6
- Manufacturing Sector Questions · 6
- Scottish Futures Trust Questions · 10
- Town Centre Regeneration Fund Questions · 4
- National Planning Framework (Consultation) Questions · 5
- Bus Services Questions · 7
- Borrowing Powers Questions · 4
- National Planning Framework Debate · 70
- Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Bill Bill debate · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 43
- International Women's Day Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.