To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1500)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 8
- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Fergusson 2
- Mike Rumbles LD 1
The record
16 contributionsLater today I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
Will the First Minister remind us why he decided to drop his bill to introduce a local income tax?
There were two significant reasons: one was the indication that I could not persuade the Labour Party, the Conservative party and, probably, the Scottish Green Party to back a sensible measure on behalf of the Scottish people; the second was the looming budget cuts of £500 million that the Westminster Government was threatening. Under those circumstances, we reluctantly had to accept that it was not the time to introduce a fair, representative tax that was well supported by the people of Scotland.
The financial reason that the First Minister gave is now his single transferable excuse for every failure on his Government's part. Let us return to the other reason, which the Scottish National Party made clear when it ditched the local income tax. Mr Swinney said,
"we cannot put together a stable majority … to steer"
the plans through the Parliament. He continued:
"Indeed, Parliaments vote in December last year made it clear that"—[Official Report, 11 February 2009; c 14896.]
the Parliament does not support the local income tax. Tonight, the Parliament will reject the First Minister's referendum bill in exactly the same way. Will he respect the will of the Parliament again and kill the referendum bill too?
"we cannot put together a stable majority … to steer"
the plans through the Parliament. He continued:
"Indeed, Parliaments vote in December last year made it clear that"—[Official Report, 11 February 2009; c 14896.]
the Parliament does not support the local income tax. Tonight, the Parliament will reject the First Minister's referendum bill in exactly the same way. Will he respect the will of the Parliament again and kill the referendum bill too?
Iain Gray will not be able to slip away from the £500 million of looming Labour Party budget cuts because, day after day, as Labour members call for increased public spending on every item under the sun, it will be explained to him what the consequences are.
We live in hope that the Labour Party will see the sense and logic of giving the people of Scotland the right to choose their own future. Indeed, it is less than a year since the Labour group united behind a rallying call for a referendum for the people of Scotland. That was when Wendy Alexander was in charge, but I have discovered that Iain Gray was giving her his complete backing, as his interview with "Newsnight Scotland" on 7 May 2008 shows. Gordon Brewer said, "Whenever the SNP brings forward a bill, you'll have to vote for it." Iain Gray responded, "Well, we've said—and Wendy Alexander has made clear—that we won't stand in the way of the people having a say."
I am confident that Iain Gray will realise the electoral repercussions of trying to deny the Scottish people the right of self-determination and, when the bill is introduced, go back to his position of May last year.
We live in hope that the Labour Party will see the sense and logic of giving the people of Scotland the right to choose their own future. Indeed, it is less than a year since the Labour group united behind a rallying call for a referendum for the people of Scotland. That was when Wendy Alexander was in charge, but I have discovered that Iain Gray was giving her his complete backing, as his interview with "Newsnight Scotland" on 7 May 2008 shows. Gordon Brewer said, "Whenever the SNP brings forward a bill, you'll have to vote for it." Iain Gray responded, "Well, we've said—and Wendy Alexander has made clear—that we won't stand in the way of the people having a say."
I am confident that Iain Gray will realise the electoral repercussions of trying to deny the Scottish people the right of self-determination and, when the bill is introduced, go back to his position of May last year.
The First Minister is absolutely right: in May last year, Labour offered him a chance to hold his referendum, fair and square. He lost his nerve and slipped away from that opportunity. When the chance was offered, he was found wanting; the chance has gone.
I believe that, right now, Scotland wants us all to concentrate all our efforts on protecting jobs and supporting Scottish families and communities through the global economic downturn. Does the First Minister really think that his referendum bill is a good idea during that downturn?
I believe that, right now, Scotland wants us all to concentrate all our efforts on protecting jobs and supporting Scottish families and communities through the global economic downturn. Does the First Minister really think that his referendum bill is a good idea during that downturn?
I remind Iain Gray of his answer to the question that he was asked last May, which was whether he would support a referendum whenever the SNP brought forward a bill. He answered in the affirmative, which was a bit like the declaration the previous day from Duncan McNeil, who said, "Our position is clear. We're not against a referendum bill in principle." Therefore, in principle, the Labour group is in favour of a referendum bill.
Iain Gray should better understand the clear connection. Obviously, we do everything within our existing powers to heed the Scottish economy and stimulate its recovery from this deep recession. There are 50 measures in the six-point plan, all of which are designed to give Scottish businesses and families the maximum help at this difficult time, such as the acceleration of public investment, which will guarantee 5,000 jobs in Scotland over the coming year.
Anyone with a semblance of understanding of the Scottish economy will understand that if we are to reflate the Scottish economy, using the same approach to the current recession as every single Government in the western world, we need borrowing powers and the ability to increase aggregate demand and confidence. That is the connection between the powers of this Parliament and the ability to deliver for the Scottish people.
Iain Gray should better understand the clear connection. Obviously, we do everything within our existing powers to heed the Scottish economy and stimulate its recovery from this deep recession. There are 50 measures in the six-point plan, all of which are designed to give Scottish businesses and families the maximum help at this difficult time, such as the acceleration of public investment, which will guarantee 5,000 jobs in Scotland over the coming year.
Anyone with a semblance of understanding of the Scottish economy will understand that if we are to reflate the Scottish economy, using the same approach to the current recession as every single Government in the western world, we need borrowing powers and the ability to increase aggregate demand and confidence. That is the connection between the powers of this Parliament and the ability to deliver for the Scottish people.
I remind the First Minister of his answer to our offer a year ago of a referendum, fair and square. His answer was no. He always puts narrow party politics ahead of what is best for Scotland, and never more so than in these times. He has failed on so many issues: local income tax; the Scottish Futures Trust; class sizes; police numbers; house building—the list goes on. On this issue, however, he will not accept his failure, and so diverts the energies of his Government away from the real concerns of Scots, who worry about their jobs, their mortgages and their children's future.
Right now, Scotland needs the referendum bill like it needs a hole in the head. I ask the First Minister again whether he really thinks that a referendum bill is a good idea during these times. If he does not, will he put Scotland first for once, and drop the bill?
Right now, Scotland needs the referendum bill like it needs a hole in the head. I ask the First Minister again whether he really thinks that a referendum bill is a good idea during these times. If he does not, will he put Scotland first for once, and drop the bill?
I will try to give Iain Gray some advice. Consistency on the referendum is not his strongest suit. I have seen many remarkable statements in politics, but as an extravagant claim in politics, yesterday's quotation to the Press Association from a Labour spokesman—presumably nobody wanted to put their name to it—takes some beating. They said:
"We've been clear all along when it comes to a referendum."
On the Government's programme and manifesto, as Iain Gray well understands, we have taken forward 46 of our 94 manifesto commitments in the first two years of government. Obviously, the Presiding Officer will not allow me to go through all 46—
"We've been clear all along when it comes to a referendum."
On the Government's programme and manifesto, as Iain Gray well understands, we have taken forward 46 of our 94 manifesto commitments in the first two years of government. Obviously, the Presiding Officer will not allow me to go through all 46—
Go on!
I am encouraged by Mr Rumbles's anxiety to hear them.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
You were right the first time, First Minister.
Let us try the top 10. We have abolished rates for tens of thousands of small businesses; restored free education by scrapping the graduate endowment; abolished tolls on the Forth and Tay bridges; funded an additional 1,000 police recruits—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
—started a phased abolition of prescription charges; saved the accident and emergency departments at Ayr and Monklands; increased payments for free personal care for the first time; introduced a world-leading climate change bill; doubled Scotland's international aid budget; and frozen the council tax for two successive years. Not bad for the first two years; for the next two years, let's bring it on.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Mar 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 5 March 2009 Debate · 1
- Scottish Government (Record) Debate · 168
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- International Children's Games Questions · 9
- Property Developers (Delays) Questions · 6
- Scots Questions · 4
- United States of America (Co-operation) Questions · 8
- National Conversation Questions · 9
- Patient Records Questions · 4
- Scottish Commission for Human Rights (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Affordable Housing (Edinburgh) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Alcohol First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Class Sizes First Minister’s Questions · 10
- VisitScotland First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Water Testing (Church and Community Halls) Questions · 4
- Local Government Finance Questions · 4
- Scottish Futures Trust Questions · 10
- Orkney Islands Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Town Centre Regeneration Fund Questions · 10
- Local Government (Executive Pay) Questions · 6
- Carbon Savings (Reporting) Questions · 4
- Local Authority Funding (Roads) Questions · 6
- Manufacturing Sector Questions · 6
- Scottish Futures Trust Questions · 10
- Town Centre Regeneration Fund Questions · 4
- National Planning Framework (Consultation) Questions · 5
- Bus Services Questions · 7
- Borrowing Powers Questions · 4
- National Planning Framework Debate · 70
- Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Bill Bill debate · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 43
- International Women's Day Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.