To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Government remains opposed to the United Kingdom Government's ID card scheme. (S3F-1488)
Official Report · Chamber
Identity Cards
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Robert Brown LD 2
- Alex Salmond SNP 2
The record
6 contributionsThe Scottish Government remains opposed to the UK Government's ID card scheme. The Scottish Parliament debated this issue on 19 November 2008, and we indicated our opinion by voting for the UK Government to cancel its ID card scheme. The result was:
"For 69, Against 0, Abstentions 38."—[Official Report, 19 November 2008; c 12544.]
The costs are currently estimated as more than £5 billion. In my opinion, the UK Government would be better advised to use that money to protect vital public services instead of cutting £5 billion from public sector budgets in 2010-11.
"For 69, Against 0, Abstentions 38."—[Official Report, 19 November 2008; c 12544.]
The costs are currently estimated as more than £5 billion. In my opinion, the UK Government would be better advised to use that money to protect vital public services instead of cutting £5 billion from public sector budgets in 2010-11.
I am extremely grateful for the First Minister's reassurance, but actions speak louder than words. Will the First Minister explain to the chamber why the Cabinet Secretary for Justice is asking Parliament to cede to Westminster the power to legislate for data sharing by Scottish Government bodies with Westminster Government bodies; why that substantial power will be at the discretion of UK Government ministers, without the involvement of this Parliament; and whether his ministers have yet sought guarantees from the UK Government that such orders under the Coroners and Justice Bill cannot be used for the ID card scheme?
As has been indicated to Robert Brown a number of times, the provision would give UK ministers the power to enable, but not enforce, the sharing of information by bodies, by laying an order that the relevant Parliament must approve. As the cabinet secretary said in his letter to the convener of the Justice Committee on 21 February, ministers would be in a position to decline to participate in any proposed information gateway.
I would say two things to Robert Brown. The sharing of information is not, in itself, a bad thing. In plenty of ways, the sharing of information in the public sector can bring about better outcomes in society. Nor should it be thought that the Coroners and Justice Bill, in itself, is a bad thing. After all, one of its provisions is to allow fatal accident inquiries to hear the causes and investigate the deaths of Scottish servicemen on active service overseas—something that is supported throughout the chamber.
I assure Robert Brown that we absolutely oppose the introduction of an identity card scheme. We believe that the expenditure on it is misapplied and that the questions for civil liberty remain unanswered. We are therefore examining every provision in the Coroners and Justice Bill, and if it provides any loopholes by which the UK Government could implement by the back door, he can be assured that the justice secretary will take the required action.
I would say two things to Robert Brown. The sharing of information is not, in itself, a bad thing. In plenty of ways, the sharing of information in the public sector can bring about better outcomes in society. Nor should it be thought that the Coroners and Justice Bill, in itself, is a bad thing. After all, one of its provisions is to allow fatal accident inquiries to hear the causes and investigate the deaths of Scottish servicemen on active service overseas—something that is supported throughout the chamber.
I assure Robert Brown that we absolutely oppose the introduction of an identity card scheme. We believe that the expenditure on it is misapplied and that the questions for civil liberty remain unanswered. We are therefore examining every provision in the Coroners and Justice Bill, and if it provides any loopholes by which the UK Government could implement by the back door, he can be assured that the justice secretary will take the required action.
Meeting suspended until 14:15.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Feb 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 26 February 2009 Debate · 1
- Financial Services Advisory Board Statement · 29
- Disabled Persons' Parking Places (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 37
- Strategic Transport Projects Review Questions · 6
- Diabetes (Insulin Pumps) Questions · 4
- Clostridium Difficile (Royal Alexandra Hospital) Questions · 7
- International Markets (Assistance) Questions · 4
- Local Government Funding Distribution Formula (Review) Questions · 6
- Town Centre Regeneration Fund (Fife) Questions · 8
- Homelessness (2012 Target) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Royal Bank of Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Alcohol Abuse First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Identity Cards First Minister’s Questions · 6
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 3
- Alcohol-related Crime Questions · 4
- Debt Recovery (Public Authorities) Questions · 4
- Direct Measures Questions · 4
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 Questions · 6
- Domestic Violence (Compensation) Questions · 5
- Young Offenders (Communication Difficulties) Questions · 6
- Polmont Young Offenders Institution Questions · 4
- Flood Prevention Questions · 7
- Hill Farms (Livestock) Questions · 6
- Chlorofluorocarbons and Hydrofluorocarbons (Demolished Buildings) Questions · 4
- Packaging (Supermarkets) Questions · 7
- Flooding (Coastal Areas) Questions · 4
- Fife Coastal Path Questions · 5
- Skills Strategy Statement · 20
- Marine Bill Consultation Bill debate · 43
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 17
- Decision Time Decision time · 34
- Mesothelioma Members’ business · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.