To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1472)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
11 contributionsLater today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
With your permission, Presiding Officer. Members of the Westminster Parliament united yesterday in sympathy with David and Samantha Cameron on the loss of their young son Ivan. I know that everyone in the chamber will wish to express their deep condolences to the whole family and the many people who have been touched by this tragic bereavement. The loss of a child is the worst thing that can happen to any parent and we can only hope that the expressions of support and solidarity for David and Samantha Cameron from across the political spectrum are of some comfort in this time of extremity.
With your permission, Presiding Officer. Members of the Westminster Parliament united yesterday in sympathy with David and Samantha Cameron on the loss of their young son Ivan. I know that everyone in the chamber will wish to express their deep condolences to the whole family and the many people who have been touched by this tragic bereavement. The loss of a child is the worst thing that can happen to any parent and we can only hope that the expressions of support and solidarity for David and Samantha Cameron from across the political spectrum are of some comfort in this time of extremity.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Thank you. Members might wish to know that I have written this morning, on behalf of the Parliament, to David and Samantha Cameron.
Indeed; probably no words can express a parent's pain on the loss of a child, but the thoughts and prayers of Labour members are certainly with David Cameron and his family today.
This morning, the Royal Bank of Scotland announced the largest loss in Scottish and, indeed, British corporate history. We also discovered today that the outgoing chief executive of RBS is already, at 50 years old, drawing a pension of £650,000 per year. Does the First Minister think that that is right?
This morning, the Royal Bank of Scotland announced the largest loss in Scottish and, indeed, British corporate history. We also discovered today that the outgoing chief executive of RBS is already, at 50 years old, drawing a pension of £650,000 per year. Does the First Minister think that that is right?
No, I do not and I do not think that the small shareholders, the bank's customers and the general public think that it is appropriate either. However, Iain Gray should note this morning's comments by the new chief executive of RBS, Stephen Hester, on that matter. When he was asked about it, he said:
"The arrangements for my predecessor's departure are part of a legal agreement that the Government—"
that is, the Westminster Government—
"was fully involved with at the time."
That is, last October.
"The arrangements for my predecessor's departure are part of a legal agreement that the Government—"
that is, the Westminster Government—
"was fully involved with at the time."
That is, last October.
It is, indeed, the case that Fred Goodwin's contract probably entitles him legally to that bumper pay-off, although morally surely it does not. However, the person who appointed him and who presumably put those contractual arrangements in place in the first place is Sir George Mathewson, the man whom the First Minister appointed as his key economic adviser. Is the First Minister still happy with that appointment?
First, when Sir George Mathewson was chief executive of the Royal Bank of Scotland it was, indeed, a highly profitable and successful institution. Iain Gray, or anyone else on the Labour seats, would be extremely unwise to attack Sir George Mathewson's reputation. However, let me turn to the complete misunderstanding of Fred Goodwin's departure from the post of chief executive of RBS. Stephen Hester dealt with that issue, too, this morning, saying:
"The arrangements negotiated for my predecessor with the Government on his departure are not something that I should be spending time on."
In other words, according to the new chief executive of the Royal Bank of Scotland the leaving, the arrangements for it and, presumably, the pension arrangements were part of negotiations in which the Westminster Government was directly involved. Now that Iain Gray has those facts at his disposal, would he care to rephrase his question or revise his opinions?
"The arrangements negotiated for my predecessor with the Government on his departure are not something that I should be spending time on."
In other words, according to the new chief executive of the Royal Bank of Scotland the leaving, the arrangements for it and, presumably, the pension arrangements were part of negotiations in which the Westminster Government was directly involved. Now that Iain Gray has those facts at his disposal, would he care to rephrase his question or revise his opinions?
I do not seek to examine George Mathewson's reputation, but I think that the views that he has recently expressed bear some examination. George Mathewson is the First Minister's adviser on the economy and it was he who defended short selling—he said that the First Minister's views were "ignorant". It was he whose hedge fund made millions out of the disastrous RBS-ABN Amro deal. It was he who said that bankers should not apologise and
"I don't believe in all this sorry bit."
It was he who said that his £2.5 million bonus would
"not give you bragging rights in a Soho wine bar."
It is he who still draws a large salary from RBS. Is the First Minister really still happy with his appointment of that adviser with those views?
"I don't believe in all this sorry bit."
It was he who said that his £2.5 million bonus would
"not give you bragging rights in a Soho wine bar."
It is he who still draws a large salary from RBS. Is the First Minister really still happy with his appointment of that adviser with those views?
Iain Gray is the Opposition leader in the Parliament, so let me give him some advice. He is meant to be attacking, criticising and examining me on my record, not on Sir George Mathewson's. The names of the people who regulated the banking and financial system are Gordon Brown and Alistair Darling. If it is the case—as Stephen Hester, the new chief executive of the Royal Bank of Scotland, said this morning—that the arrangements for Sir Fred Goodwin's departure from the bank fully involved the Westminster Government, at what stage in this line of questioning will Iain Gray revisit the premise of his first question?
Let us examine the First Minister's views. The regulatory system that he criticises is the one that he previously criticised for gold plating, which he said he would replace with light-touch regulation. However, the First Minister has changed his mind. At the weekend, the First Minister's spokesman said of banking:
"The first minister believes that … a different set of values is required."
I think that the people of Scotland agree with that, but the First Minister's key economic adviser does not. George Mathewson is still defending short selling, big bonuses and obscene pay-offs. The First Minister should decide which side he is on. Is he with Sir George and the bonus bankers or the people of Scotland?
"The first minister believes that … a different set of values is required."
I think that the people of Scotland agree with that, but the First Minister's key economic adviser does not. George Mathewson is still defending short selling, big bonuses and obscene pay-offs. The First Minister should decide which side he is on. Is he with Sir George and the bonus bankers or the people of Scotland?
As it happens, Sir George Mathewson, to my personal knowledge, was the foremost opponent of the investment banking bonus culture spreading into retail banking.
Iain Gray should have had a mind to look at the evidence that the Financial Services Authority gave to the House of Commons committee this week. The FSA argued—admittedly, this might be self-serving—that the reason that it did not go in for the sort of regulation that would have uncovered the malpractices taking place throughout the financial sector was political direction from above. Who on earth might have been responsible for that political direction if not the long-standing chancellor who is now Prime Minister of the United Kingdom?
I know that it is difficult for the Opposition leader to respond to information that comes up during questions, but I take it that, despite his refusal to say so at any point, Iain Gray's initial premise that Sir George Mathewson was somehow responsible for Sir Fred Goodwin's pay-off has been revised in light of the information from the new RBS chief executive, who has said that Alistair Darling and the Westminster Government were fully involved in the process. When we on this side of chamber say that we do not think that Sir Fred Goodwin's pension level is justified, we are entitled to say that. It seems passing strange that the Labour Party is adopting that position now, given that last October it was fully implicated in making the arrangements.
Iain Gray should have had a mind to look at the evidence that the Financial Services Authority gave to the House of Commons committee this week. The FSA argued—admittedly, this might be self-serving—that the reason that it did not go in for the sort of regulation that would have uncovered the malpractices taking place throughout the financial sector was political direction from above. Who on earth might have been responsible for that political direction if not the long-standing chancellor who is now Prime Minister of the United Kingdom?
I know that it is difficult for the Opposition leader to respond to information that comes up during questions, but I take it that, despite his refusal to say so at any point, Iain Gray's initial premise that Sir George Mathewson was somehow responsible for Sir Fred Goodwin's pay-off has been revised in light of the information from the new RBS chief executive, who has said that Alistair Darling and the Westminster Government were fully involved in the process. When we on this side of chamber say that we do not think that Sir Fred Goodwin's pension level is justified, we are entitled to say that. It seems passing strange that the Labour Party is adopting that position now, given that last October it was fully implicated in making the arrangements.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Feb 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 26 February 2009 Debate · 1
- Financial Services Advisory Board Statement · 29
- Disabled Persons' Parking Places (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 37
- Strategic Transport Projects Review Questions · 6
- Diabetes (Insulin Pumps) Questions · 4
- Clostridium Difficile (Royal Alexandra Hospital) Questions · 7
- International Markets (Assistance) Questions · 4
- Local Government Funding Distribution Formula (Review) Questions · 6
- Town Centre Regeneration Fund (Fife) Questions · 8
- Homelessness (2012 Target) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Royal Bank of Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Alcohol Abuse First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Identity Cards First Minister’s Questions · 6
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 3
- Alcohol-related Crime Questions · 4
- Debt Recovery (Public Authorities) Questions · 4
- Direct Measures Questions · 4
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 Questions · 6
- Domestic Violence (Compensation) Questions · 5
- Young Offenders (Communication Difficulties) Questions · 6
- Polmont Young Offenders Institution Questions · 4
- Flood Prevention Questions · 7
- Hill Farms (Livestock) Questions · 6
- Chlorofluorocarbons and Hydrofluorocarbons (Demolished Buildings) Questions · 4
- Packaging (Supermarkets) Questions · 7
- Flooding (Coastal Areas) Questions · 4
- Fife Coastal Path Questions · 5
- Skills Strategy Statement · 20
- Marine Bill Consultation Bill debate · 43
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 17
- Decision Time Decision time · 34
- Mesothelioma Members’ business · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.