To ask the Scottish Executive how many of the 3,599 targets, outcomes and indicators contained in the 32 local authority single outcome agreements commit to delivering class sizes in primaries 1, 2 and 3 to a maximum of 18 by 2011. (S3O-4266)
Official Report · Chamber
Primary Class Sizes
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Education and Lifelong Learning
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Fiona Hyslop SNP 3
- Jeremy Purvis LD 2
- Murdo Fraser Con 1
The record
6 contributionsUnder the terms of the concordat, local government has undertaken to make year-on-year progress on class size reduction in primary 1 to primary 3. Therefore, it was unnecessary for local authorities to include references to class size reduction in primary 1 to primary 3 in their single outcome agreements.
On 25 June, Rob Gibson asked the cabinet secretary:
"Do you agree that the concordat's single outcome agreements will be a more accurate measure of progress than we have had in the past?"—[Official Report, Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee, 25 June 2008; c 1285.]
She answered: "They will". However, there is no published objective or independent system of verifying whether the Government's policy is being delivered. For the Government simply to state now that there was never any intention that the single outcome agreements would mention it is outrageous. Not one of the 3,599 outcomes, indicators and targets is about class sizes. The Government is letting down Scotland's parents significantly. Will the cabinet secretary ensure that next year's single outcome agreements have at least some published indicators that demonstrate whether the policy is being implemented?
"Do you agree that the concordat's single outcome agreements will be a more accurate measure of progress than we have had in the past?"—[Official Report, Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee, 25 June 2008; c 1285.]
She answered: "They will". However, there is no published objective or independent system of verifying whether the Government's policy is being delivered. For the Government simply to state now that there was never any intention that the single outcome agreements would mention it is outrageous. Not one of the 3,599 outcomes, indicators and targets is about class sizes. The Government is letting down Scotland's parents significantly. Will the cabinet secretary ensure that next year's single outcome agreements have at least some published indicators that demonstrate whether the policy is being implemented?
I can certainly make representations that that is the Liberal Democrats' view when I meet representatives of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities this afternoon. However, there are 14 commitments in the concordat with local government, many of which are not mentioned in the single outcome agreements. The freezing of council tax rates, the small business bonus scheme, free school meals, allowances for kinship carers and carers support through extra respite weeks are all commitments that have been agreed by local government in the historic concordat, although none of those is in the single outcome agreements. The agreement is with local government; it will deliver and we trust it to do so.
link
At First Minister's questions, I referred to Friday's Court of Session judgment, which rides a coach and horses through the Scottish National Party's class size policy. Does the cabinet secretary accept that, without legislation being put in place to protect them, councils could face legal challenge from parents even if they wanted to implement the policy and had the money to do so? Does she accept that, if she is serious about the policy, the Government must legislate?
I refer Murdo Fraser to the First Minister's reply, in which he said that we are reviewing the judgment in the East Lothian case. I point out that the 12 per cent of classes that are already smaller than 18 are not operating illegally.
Yes, we need resources to reduce class sizes. Indeed, the concordat refers to maintaining 53,000 teachers in our education system, which would allow headroom to make progress. However, Murdo Fraser is right to identify placing requests as an issue—the case that the Court of Session recently considered was not about the SNP's commitment with local government to class sizes of 18, but about the previous Administration's proposals for class sizes of 25 in primary 1. We will reflect on whether there is a requirement for legislation, but it is not a prerequisite to deliver on class sizes.
Murdo Fraser might consider the Conservatives' position. If they take the position that there should be no class size limits whatever and that headteachers should have discretion, that would make it difficult to protect parents when they make placing requests. Parents would have difficulty making such requests without class size legislation unless there was another test for access to a school: passing an examination. That may be the system south of the border, but it is certainly not the system in Scotland. Murdo Fraser should tread carefully before asking for legislation that would put the Conservatives' policies in jeopardy.
Yes, we need resources to reduce class sizes. Indeed, the concordat refers to maintaining 53,000 teachers in our education system, which would allow headroom to make progress. However, Murdo Fraser is right to identify placing requests as an issue—the case that the Court of Session recently considered was not about the SNP's commitment with local government to class sizes of 18, but about the previous Administration's proposals for class sizes of 25 in primary 1. We will reflect on whether there is a requirement for legislation, but it is not a prerequisite to deliver on class sizes.
Murdo Fraser might consider the Conservatives' position. If they take the position that there should be no class size limits whatever and that headteachers should have discretion, that would make it difficult to protect parents when they make placing requests. Parents would have difficulty making such requests without class size legislation unless there was another test for access to a school: passing an examination. That may be the system south of the border, but it is certainly not the system in Scotland. Murdo Fraser should tread carefully before asking for legislation that would put the Conservatives' policies in jeopardy.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Sep 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 18 September 2008 Debate · 1
- Less Favoured Areas Debate · 79
- Fuel Bills (Fife) Questions · 6
- British Energy (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Summary Justice Reforms (Glasgow Bar Association) Questions · 4
- Post Office Network Change Programme Questions · 6
- Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise Questions · 10
- House Building Firms (Economic Downturn) Questions · 4
- St Andrews Community Hospital and Health Centre Questions · 4
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 25
- Domestic Energy Efficiency First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Sewage Pollution (Beaches) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Class Sizes First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Primary Class Sizes Questions · 6
- Probationary Teachers Questions · 6
- Pupil Support (English as an Additional Language) Questions · 8
- School Building Programme (Highland Council) Questions · 6
- School Buildings (Renewal) Questions · 10
- Minimum Income Guarantee (Students) Questions · 4
- Lewis Chessmen Questions · 8
- Paintings (National Collections) Questions · 4
- Creative Scotland (Costs) Questions · 6
- Creative Scotland (Recruitment) Questions · 10
- Artists (Support) Questions · 6
- World Heritage Status (Edinburgh) Questions · 8
- Traditional Arts Questions · 4
- Tourism Debate · 49
- Decision Time Decision time · 29
- Cancer Poverty Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.