Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 18 September 2008 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1008)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I welcome Iain Gray to his place.

This morning, as many members will know, I was in Rosyth announcing the resumption of Scotland's ferry service from Rosyth to Zeebrugge. The announcement about the restoration of the route today is particularly important when there is potentially grave economic news on other fronts.

A number of meetings have concerned the HBOS takeover by Lloyds TSB. Members will wish to know that I have arranged calls with both of the financial sector unions concerned. I have spoken with both banks and parties concerned today, as I did yesterday. For the information of members, I have called an emergency meeting of the Financial Services Advisory Board for next Tuesday. The board represents a wide range of interests in the financial sector, including the unions, universities and many other interested parties. The entire Parliament will greet yesterday's news with the seriousness that it deserves.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I thank the First Minister for his kind words of welcome. Indeed I will cherish them in the sure and certain knowledge that such words will probably be few and far between in the weeks ahead. I also welcome the news from Rosyth.

The First Minister is right—this is a bad day. We are in the midst of a global financial crisis and the past 24 hours have demonstrated that Scotland is far from immune. There are three key aspects to the HBOS-Lloyds merger that I wish to explore with the First Minister: the implications for employees, the implications for customers and the implications for the economy.

This morning, I met trade union representatives of the workforce. Tens of thousands of jobs are under threat. Many people in the workforce are shareholders too, and they are worried not just about their jobs but about their savings and pensions.

I am pleased to hear that the First Minister has arranged calls with the trade unions involved, and indeed with the two banks. I ask that, in making those calls, he uses his offices to ask the new Lloyds-Halifax bank to meet the trade unions as a matter of urgency. That has not happened yet. It must happen today. Will the First Minister make it happen?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I can certainly ask for that to happen. HBOS, whose practices I know well, had what the Scottish Trades Union Congress described as a model agreement with the trade unions. I hope and expect that Lloyds TSB willfollow suit. I will certainly urge the bank to meet its unions as soon as possible. I will make that point in the calls that I make to the unions this afternoon. I am grateful to Iain Gray for raising the matter and for understanding the seriousness of the situation that we face.

There are two aspects to the matter. First, we might ask whether it had to happen: was it inevitable that a 300-year-old institution, with all that it means to the Scottish economy, should be laid low in such a manner? I do not believe that it had to happen; I believe that HBOS was a soundly based institution. Only yesterday, the Financial Services Authority described it in those terms. It has been laid low by the actions of speculators in the money markets, and action must be taken against that, not just looking back at what has happened to HBOS, but considering the possibility of other financial institutions being targeted unless restraints are made on short selling.

Short selling is when people enter into selling shares to which they have absolutely no title whatever and do so with the aim of making a speculative profit over other people's misery. I note that Russia has outlawed short selling and I understand that American authorities have suspended short selling today. I urge—and I hope that all members will urge—our financial authorities to follow suit, lest other financial institutions come under the cosh in the way that HBOS has done during the past three days.

The second aspect is the substantial risk to jobs in Scotland. Some of the headlines that we have seen today have been exaggerated. Many of the jobs that we have in the financial sector, in the two institutions in Scotland, are extremely soundly based—they are based on retail banks and highly profitable areas of the financial sector. For example, Scottish Widows is a substantial part of the Lloyds TSB operation. However, we have 7,000 employees in Lloyds TSB and 17,000 employees in HBOS in Scotland, so it is understandable that many employees will be concerned about their future employment prospects. Therefore, what those employees will expect, and get, from the Government—and what I know they will get from all members—is that this Parliament and Government will strain every sinew and fight to the last iota to protect and retain as many as possible of those jobs and decision- making functions in the Scottish economy.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I very much welcome the First Minister's assurances and I have every sympathy with his anger at speculation and short selling. Frankly, anyone who is today celebrating a profit from what has happened should go to the fire.

We must be honest. There is more. HBOS was highly exposed to the mortgage market and there is a liquidity crisis, which is global. The First Minister has said a great deal during the past 24 hours about the crisis that faces the banking sector but, a year ago, in his role as chair of the Financial Services Advisory Board, he noted that the recent liquidity problem was

"a good example of the type of issue which FiSAB should be discussing"

and instructed that the matter be a standing item for discussion at all future FiSAB meetings. I think that FiSAB has met twice since then. What further discussions have taken place and what action has the First Minister taken?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
FiSAB considered a paper produced by Martin Gilbert of Aberdeen Asset Management in which he made a range of recommendations about how Scotland should respond to the financial difficulties and how we should inform the financial authorities in the United Kingdom and offer our opinion on such matters—indeed, that was done. There has been a standing item, as we have discussed Martin Gilbert's paper.

Nobody would rightly claim to have anticipated the speed of the events that have overtaken HBOS. I mentioned the statement that the Financial Services Authority released on its website yesterday morning. It reads:

"We are satisfied that HBOS is a well-capitalised bank that continues to fund its business in a satisfactory way."

We are not talking about a deficient financial model or an investment bank with insecure assets; we are talking about a highly capitalised bank with excellent ratios, which has been laid low by successive waves of speculation.

I welcome Iain Gray's support. Something has to be done—intervention has to be made—to put the hems on short selling in the financial sector in particular and perhaps more broadly, because if that does not happen a succession of financial institutions will come under the same sort of pressure that HBOS has experienced. That must not be allowed to happen; people must not be allowed to profit from billions at the expense of tens, or perhaps hundreds, of thousands of jobs across the banking sector.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I agree that the regulatory regime with regard to short selling should be reviewed. Indeed, as the First Minister knows, the FSA was given additional powers when new rules on short selling were introduced in June, and new powers will be legislated for in the autumn. What other regulatory changes does the First Minister propose?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
There are aspects of transparency that the FSA and the Bank of England have been working on and that similar financial authorities worldwide have been working on.

I point out again that, in this case as in the cases of several other institutions that have come under pressure, we are not dealing with deficient financial sector models. The UK banking sector as a whole relies on wholesale money—we are a net importer of wholesale money. We are dealing with institutions that are well capitalised, well funded and well founded, but which are coming under waves of speculative pressure. That is why action must be taken and why I am delighted that action has been taken in other financial sectors this very day. I urge the financial authorities in this country to take such action, and I understand that there is general agreement in the Parliament on that. Those authorities should not look back on what has happened and say, "We told you so," but look forward and try to protect other institutions.

We know that the thousands of jobs in the financial sector are important for Scotland, but let us not underestimate the consequences for the rest of the economy. Only yesterday, according to the International Labour Organisation measurement, unemployment in Scotland reached a serious low—the lowest figure on record. Nevertheless, the rest of the economy will follow a financial sector that is in turmoil. What is happening is important for the thousands of people who have jobs in the financial sector—they will be understandably concerned today—but it is also important for the fabric not just of the Scottish economy, but of the mixed economies throughout the western world.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The First Minister is absolutely correct to talk of the importance of the financial services sector to Scotland and its wider economy. Earlier this week, on television, he talked about the importance of confidence in the success of the financial services sector. He was right to do so. I therefore welcome his announcement that FiSAB will meet next week to consider these matters, but I believe that the circumstances are such that, to ensure that we are doing everything possible to sustain confidence and protect jobs, savings and mortgages, the discussion should be widened a little. We propose an urgent summit that involves all parties—trade unions, business leaders and the industry—to examine whether we are doing all that we can. Will the First Minister take such action, so that we can all play our part in this crucial matter?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
It is exactly because I agree with doing that that I have called the emergency meeting of FiSAB. Iain Gray will be aware of the breadth of the membership of FiSAB, which represents a wide range of institutions across the financial sector, including the unions and the universities. That is why we have FiSAB. It is an important institution and innovation at any time; it is particularly important at a time such as this. If broader discussions need to take place to mobilise forces in Scottish society to retain every possible job and headquarters function, the Government—with, I hope, the support of the entire Parliament—will engage in exactly that.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 18 September 2008 Debate · 1
  2. Less Favoured Areas Debate · 79
  3. Fuel Bills (Fife) Questions · 6
  4. British Energy (Meetings) Questions · 8
  5. Summary Justice Reforms (Glasgow Bar Association) Questions · 4
  6. Post Office Network Change Programme Questions · 6
  7. Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise Questions · 10
  8. House Building Firms (Economic Downturn) Questions · 4
  9. St Andrews Community Hospital and Health Centre Questions · 4
  10. First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  12. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 25
  14. Domestic Energy Efficiency First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Sewage Pollution (Beaches) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  16. Class Sizes First Minister’s Questions · 7
  17. Primary Class Sizes Questions · 6
  18. Probationary Teachers Questions · 6
  19. Pupil Support (English as an Additional Language) Questions · 8
  20. School Building Programme (Highland Council) Questions · 6
  21. School Buildings (Renewal) Questions · 10
  22. Minimum Income Guarantee (Students) Questions · 4
  23. Lewis Chessmen Questions · 8
  24. Paintings (National Collections) Questions · 4
  25. Creative Scotland (Costs) Questions · 6
  26. Creative Scotland (Recruitment) Questions · 10
  27. Artists (Support) Questions · 6
  28. World Heritage Status (Edinburgh) Questions · 8
  29. Traditional Arts Questions · 4
  30. Tourism Debate · 49
  31. Decision Time Decision time · 29
  32. Cancer Poverty Members’ business · 11

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.