To ask the Scottish Executive whether there are any plans to expand Scotland's open prison estate. (S3O-3248)
Official Report · Chamber
Open Prisons
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Justice and Law Officers
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kenny MacAskill SNP 3
- Mike Pringle LD 2
- Bill Aitken Con 1
The record
6 contributionsAs I confirmed on 22 November 2007, there are no plans to expand Scotland's open prison estate. However, the open estate remains an important part of the Scottish Government's penal policy.
The minister is aware of the problems that are faced by long-term prisoners on release from prison and their undoubted contribution to Scotland's high reoffending rates. He is also aware that 75 per cent of people who are sent to prison for six months or less reoffend within two years, whereas only 42 per cent of those who are given community sentences do so. Will the minister consider making greater use of the open estate as a halfway house to reintegrate long-term prisoners into society and, in so doing, to cut reoffending rates? Moreover, does he believe that there is a need for more open prison places and agree that more use should be made of community sentencing to free up the open estate?
The member raises a variety of points, many of which I agree with. I reiterate that we have no plans to expand the current open prison estate. However, following an internal review by the Scottish Prison Service, there is now a substantial capacity in the estate that no doubt will be considered in due course. Moreover, the McLeish commission is examining whether the SPS and the open estate are operating appropriately.
However, as the member correctly points out, the Government believes that the open estate forms a valuable part of how we rehabilitate people into the community. As all the evidence clearly suggests, if we simply release a person without making any attempt to rehabilitate or to reintegrate them, they are very likely to be back to see us again very soon. That serves neither us nor our communities well.
That said, we agree with Mr Pringle and the Liberal Democrats about community sentencing. Prison should be for serious or dangerous offenders. Instead of funding free bed and board for those who commit less serious offences, we should ensure that they repay with the sweat of their brow the damage that they have done to their communities.
However, as the member correctly points out, the Government believes that the open estate forms a valuable part of how we rehabilitate people into the community. As all the evidence clearly suggests, if we simply release a person without making any attempt to rehabilitate or to reintegrate them, they are very likely to be back to see us again very soon. That serves neither us nor our communities well.
That said, we agree with Mr Pringle and the Liberal Democrats about community sentencing. Prison should be for serious or dangerous offenders. Instead of funding free bed and board for those who commit less serious offences, we should ensure that they repay with the sweat of their brow the damage that they have done to their communities.
Although there is unanimous agreement in the Parliament that the open estate plays a definite role in the prison system, does not the minister agree that it would be absolute folly to extend the number of open prison places before a full inquiry has been held into the criteria that are used to send people from the closed to the open estate?
The member's position is very wise. Back in November, I told Mr Aitken's colleague Mr Fraser that we had no plans to expand the open estate. Nothing has changed since then.
The fact is that the prison estate's capacity has not yet been fully utilised. We are trying to work out why that should be, but it appears that, following the tragedy of the Robert Foye case, some of the criteria have quite correctly been changed. That is understandable. After all, the Government made it quite clear that the SPS had to review the situation; it has done so and is now implementing many changes to ensure, for example, that there are proper risk assessments. The service is also on the case with regard to reintroducing dedicated governors to our two open estate prisons—an issue in which, I have to say, it was rather remiss.
The fact is that the prison estate's capacity has not yet been fully utilised. We are trying to work out why that should be, but it appears that, following the tragedy of the Robert Foye case, some of the criteria have quite correctly been changed. That is understandable. After all, the Government made it quite clear that the SPS had to review the situation; it has done so and is now implementing many changes to ensure, for example, that there are proper risk assessments. The service is also on the case with regard to reintroducing dedicated governors to our two open estate prisons—an issue in which, I have to say, it was rather remiss.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 May 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 8 May 2008 Debate · 1
- Housing Needs Debate · 107
- Air Discount Scheme Questions · 6
- Housing Associations (Glasgow) Questions · 6
- Advanced Highers Questions · 8
- Falkirk Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Council Houses (North Lanarkshire) Questions · 4
- School Building Programme (Edinburgh) Questions · 4
- Broadband (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
- Interisland Ferries Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Fuel Prices First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Futures Trust First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Peak Oil First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Scotland Rural Development Programme (Small Farmers and Crofters) Questions · 4
- Flooding Questions · 11
- Environmental Justice (Local Authorities) Questions · 4
- Environmental Impact Assessments Questions · 4
- Glasgow Airport (Noise Impact) Questions · 6
- Environment Questions · 4
- Sustainability Questions · 4
- Forensic Science Services Questions · 7
- Open Prisons Questions · 6
- Women in Custody Questions · 6
- Firearms (Consolidation Bill) Questions · 6
- Strathclyde Police (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Offenders (HM Prison Inverness) Questions · 4
- Effective Public Services Debate · 88
- Decision Time Decision time · 52
- Right to Read Campaign Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.