To ask the Scottish Executive, in light of the call by the Association of British Insurers, what plans it has to stop developments designated as being at high risk of flooding across Scotland. (S3O-3181)
Official Report · Chamber
Flooding
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Rural Affairs and the Environment
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael Russell SNP 4
- Helen Eadie Lab 3
- Alex Fergusson 2
- John Scott Con 1
- Des McNulty Lab 1
The record
11 contributionsThis is clearly an important issue for Helen Eadie. She will recall that she and I discussed flooding earlier this year and that she is due to meet me again next Thursday. In March, she asked seven written parliamentary questions on flood risk and coastal planning, and I have previously answered two oral parliamentary questions from her on the subject. Next week, we are due to provide answers to a further 38 written parliamentary questions on the subject. This is an issue that is dear to her heart. More specifically, it is also near to her home.
Turning to the substance of the question, Scottish planning policy 7 includes a risk framework that sets out the planning response to developments that are proposed in areas of high flood risk. The Association of British Insurers was a key consultee during its preparation and fully endorsed the risk framework approach.
Turning to the substance of the question, Scottish planning policy 7 includes a risk framework that sets out the planning response to developments that are proposed in areas of high flood risk. The Association of British Insurers was a key consultee during its preparation and fully endorsed the risk framework approach.
The minister might not know, but I live a good 40 minutes' walk from the particular site in question. The development that we are discussing was recommended for refusal on one occasion by the local authority and was about to be recommended again for refusal when the Scottish Executive's reporter said that it would be approved.
The minister needs to look at the photographs that I sent to him earlier this week, which show that houses, flats and a bistro are about to be built on an area of infill land that is at high risk of flooding. The photographs provide a shocking and devastating account of that. It will be on your watch, minister, that those homes are placed at risk.
The minister needs to look at the photographs that I sent to him earlier this week, which show that houses, flats and a bistro are about to be built on an area of infill land that is at high risk of flooding. The photographs provide a shocking and devastating account of that. It will be on your watch, minister, that those homes are placed at risk.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Could we have a question, please?
I ask the minister to study carefully, when he meets me, the photographs that I have sent you and that you consider withdrawing the approval for building permission.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
I was not planning to meet you, Ms Eadie, but I am sure that the minister will answer accordingly.
I admire persistence wherever it is shown. However, persistence should not fly in the face of facts. For example, many of the written parliamentary questions that have been submitted by the member on the subject reflect planning and flooding issues and the language and legislation on planning and flooding that apply south of the border, but not in Scotland. They do not show a sound understanding either of the Scottish position or of the issue. I am sorry to say that. I am also sorry to say that the purpose of the question is exactly what the chamber has just heard—to try to spread alarm and despondency where there should be none.
The effect of section 48(6) of the Town and County Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 is that once a reporter has issued a decision on an appeal, that decision is final. Neither he or she, the Scottish ministers, nor anybody else has any further jurisdiction on the matter. That means that it is not possible for the Scottish ministers, the appointed reporter, or the directorate for planning and environmental appeals to comment on the merits of the appeals, other than to say that the reporters' decisions were based on the evidence that was presented at the public local inquiries, and on all written submissions by the parties involved. That is the fact of the matter.
The effect of section 48(6) of the Town and County Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 is that once a reporter has issued a decision on an appeal, that decision is final. Neither he or she, the Scottish ministers, nor anybody else has any further jurisdiction on the matter. That means that it is not possible for the Scottish ministers, the appointed reporter, or the directorate for planning and environmental appeals to comment on the merits of the appeals, other than to say that the reporters' decisions were based on the evidence that was presented at the public local inquiries, and on all written submissions by the parties involved. That is the fact of the matter.
I declare an interest. The minister has outlined his views on the need not to build on flood plains when doing so is avoidable, as outlined in SPP 7. Given the need once again to maximise food production from our best land, can he outline what measures the Government will take to incentivise farmers both to grow food and to allow flood plains to again be used as natural flood defences?
That is a good and pertinent question and it needs to be dealt with in the context of the report of the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee, of which John Scott is the deputy convener. It should also be dealt with in any consideration of the flooding bill, and be taken into account in the bill itself. I do not think the amount of land in question is as large as some people have claimed. However, the way in which we encourage land managers and landowners—and tenants of land—to ensure that that land is available for sustainable or natural flood defences is a key issue. I look forward to a constructive engagement on that issue with Mr Scott and with the chamber.
Does the minister believe that there should be an obligation on developers that are building in areas where there might be a risk of flooding to disclose what the flood risk is as part of the assessment process, and to give people a clear indication of the degree of security they might realistically expect?
That is also a positive approach, which has been mentioned and discussed in committee. In principle, I would welcome that approach. It is important that there is full disclosure, but we must remember that indicative flood maps are indicative and are not, in fact, an indication of the likelihood, or possibility, of actual flooding in any property. There are issues to be considered, but in general I would welcome that approach. I hope that it will be something the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee reflects upon, after which we will see how we can bring it forward in terms of legislation.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 May 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 8 May 2008 Debate · 1
- Housing Needs Debate · 107
- Air Discount Scheme Questions · 6
- Housing Associations (Glasgow) Questions · 6
- Advanced Highers Questions · 8
- Falkirk Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Council Houses (North Lanarkshire) Questions · 4
- School Building Programme (Edinburgh) Questions · 4
- Broadband (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
- Interisland Ferries Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Fuel Prices First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Futures Trust First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Peak Oil First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Scotland Rural Development Programme (Small Farmers and Crofters) Questions · 4
- Flooding Questions · 11
- Environmental Justice (Local Authorities) Questions · 4
- Environmental Impact Assessments Questions · 4
- Glasgow Airport (Noise Impact) Questions · 6
- Environment Questions · 4
- Sustainability Questions · 4
- Forensic Science Services Questions · 7
- Open Prisons Questions · 6
- Women in Custody Questions · 6
- Firearms (Consolidation Bill) Questions · 6
- Strathclyde Police (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Offenders (HM Prison Inverness) Questions · 4
- Effective Public Services Debate · 88
- Decision Time Decision time · 52
- Right to Read Campaign Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.