We move to question 10, for which I call Alex Fergusson.
Official Report · Chamber
Beef Exports
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Environment and Rural Development
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 5
- Alex Fergusson Con 3
- Trish Godman Lab 2
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 1
- Andrew Arbuckle LD 1
- John Scott Con 1
The record
13 contributionsWell-recognised, Presiding Officer.
To ask the Scottish Executive what steps it is taking to encourage the export of Scottish beef. (S20-10094)
To ask the Scottish Executive what steps it is taking to encourage the export of Scottish beef. (S20-10094)
The Executive is working closely with Quality Meat Scotland in its efforts to promote Scottish beef in mainland Europe. I have already attended events in Brussels, Monaco and Rotterdam to launch Scottish beef into those areas. Next week, I will attend a dinner in Bologna that will relaunch Scottish beef into Italy. We are also providing financial assistance towards the cost of QMS marketing agents in France.
I am sure that all members will agree that the efforts that are being made could not be better directed.
Does the minister agree that an important component of the trade, especially for the dairy sector, is the resumption of live exports? Now that the rest of Europe is on the verge of adopting new rules on veal production, can he assure the Parliament that the Executive will not attempt to hinder that trade as long as all relevant welfare concerns are addressed and legislation is properly adhered to? Will he assure us that a tough line will be taken with any individual or organisation that attempts to hinder the trade?
Does the minister agree that an important component of the trade, especially for the dairy sector, is the resumption of live exports? Now that the rest of Europe is on the verge of adopting new rules on veal production, can he assure the Parliament that the Executive will not attempt to hinder that trade as long as all relevant welfare concerns are addressed and legislation is properly adhered to? Will he assure us that a tough line will be taken with any individual or organisation that attempts to hinder the trade?
Alex Fergusson certainly makes a valid point, in that substantial changes have been made to the nature of the regulations that govern the live-meat trade. I think that almost all European Union member states have now abandoned the old veal cages. That is to be warmly welcomed as we know that the resumption of the meat trade will bring the issue of live exports into play. It is absolutely clear that, as long as regulations on international trading and the welfare of animals are adhered to, there is no reason for ministers or any other Government to impede progress.
Clearly, British legations and consulates abroad potentially have an important role in the promotion of Scottish beef exports. Will the minister say what steps he is taking to ensure that the legations and consulates are aware of the fact that Scottish beef is now available for export once again and of the distinction between Scottish beef and beef from other parts of the United Kingdom?
I assure Alasdair Morgan that the respective British embassy—and, indeed, the respective British ambassador—was intimately involved in each of three events that I attended in the Netherlands, Belgium and France. They are part of the wide dissemination of information. The same process will be undertaken as we relaunch next week into Italy. I assure the member that all steps have been taken and the appropriate information has been provided to ensure that the attempt to launch and relaunch Scotch beef into mainland Europe is well co-ordinated.
In his primary answer, the minister indicated that he had been over in Europe promoting Scottish beef. I understand that the receptions were very successful. He indicated that there are one or two slots in his future itinerary. Does he have any plans to further extend this European tour to promote Scottish beef?
I am sure that the member appreciates the infelicitous nature of the split infinitive "to further extend". I am sure that that was not quite what he meant.
It was very important for the Scottish Executive—the Scottish Government—to be seen at those events, which were well prepared and rehearsed. We were absolutely clear that the invitations should be extended to those with a genuine interest in the matter—leading chefs, journalists in the technical press, and those with a clear interest in the importation and processing of beef.
QMS has plans to ensure that the momentum of the initial launch is sustained. As we get into the autumn, I will want to meet QMS to review progress and to see whether it is appropriate for Government to give a further boost to that kind of promotional event. However, I rather suspect that the money that we are giving to assist in the appointment of agents in those key countries is now the issue and that, from now on, our main task will be to ensure that the message goes out about the quality of the product that we are selling on the ground and that key buyers are targeted.
It was very important for the Scottish Executive—the Scottish Government—to be seen at those events, which were well prepared and rehearsed. We were absolutely clear that the invitations should be extended to those with a genuine interest in the matter—leading chefs, journalists in the technical press, and those with a clear interest in the importation and processing of beef.
QMS has plans to ensure that the momentum of the initial launch is sustained. As we get into the autumn, I will want to meet QMS to review progress and to see whether it is appropriate for Government to give a further boost to that kind of promotional event. However, I rather suspect that the money that we are giving to assist in the appointment of agents in those key countries is now the issue and that, from now on, our main task will be to ensure that the message goes out about the quality of the product that we are selling on the ground and that key buyers are targeted.
The minister is aware that, pre-BSE, the beef export industry was worth £120 million. Has any work been done to estimate the potential market that is currently available to Scottish farmers? In addition to the answers that he has given thus far, does the minister have any further initiatives up his sleeve? I am thinking in particular of on-the-ground initiatives to promote Scottish beef in Europe.
I am sorry that £10 million seems to have got lost in translation. The industry has generally regarded the figure as being £130 million, but there we are. If it helps the member, I can give the figure in euros—it is €200 million. I suspect that that remark might be rather more contentious. John Scott spoke about getting Scottish beef back into Europe. Of course, beef never left Europe; Scotland is in Europe. We must be careful about what we say in that regard.
As the analysis that QMS Scotland and others have undertaken shows, there will be a long gestation period before we fully re-establish these markets; time has moved on. The people I met during each visit told me clearly of their appetite to purchase Scottish beef—oh, that was a very bad pun. I should say that they told me of their willingness to purchase Scottish beef. However, the price, quality and all of those aspects must be set out.
Agents have been appointed in the Benelux countries and France and we are reassessing the situation in Italy. That work on the ground is absolutely critical. I have no reason to believe that, in a year or a year and a bit, we will not have gone way beyond the £130 million figure, but it would be foolish to pretend that that will happen overnight. We have had 10 years in which people have not had the opportunity to purchase the product. I am satisfied that the campaign has been structured very professionally indeed.
As the analysis that QMS Scotland and others have undertaken shows, there will be a long gestation period before we fully re-establish these markets; time has moved on. The people I met during each visit told me clearly of their appetite to purchase Scottish beef—oh, that was a very bad pun. I should say that they told me of their willingness to purchase Scottish beef. However, the price, quality and all of those aspects must be set out.
Agents have been appointed in the Benelux countries and France and we are reassessing the situation in Italy. That work on the ground is absolutely critical. I have no reason to believe that, in a year or a year and a bit, we will not have gone way beyond the £130 million figure, but it would be foolish to pretend that that will happen overnight. We have had 10 years in which people have not had the opportunity to purchase the product. I am satisfied that the campaign has been structured very professionally indeed.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. I welcome the fact that my question elicited a record number of supplementaries, but I modestly suggest that it would have been more in order to fill in the time available as a result of questions not being lodged, a member not being in the chamber in time to ask her question and questions being withdrawn. The situation highlights the point of order that Stewart Stevenson made this morning, when he drew attention to the problem of questions that are not lodged. I understand that the matter must be referred to the Procedures Committee, but could the name of the person who failed to lodge a question be published in the Business Bulletin before the phrase, "Not Lodged"? That might reduce the number of questions that are not lodged.
That is a matter for the Procedures Committee, as the member knows, but we will reflect on what he has said.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Jun 2006 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 8 June 2006 Debate · 1
- Regulatory Framework Debate · 36
- Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 8
- Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament Bill Bill debate · 21
- Point of Order Procedure · 3
- Reparation Actions Questions · 9
- Class Sizes Questions · 6
- A75 Questions · 6
- National Transport Strategy Questions · 6
- Kilmarnock to Glasgow Rail Line Questions · 4
- Enterprise in Education Questions · 4
- Youth Facilities (Audit) Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Scottish Executive (Targets) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Glasgow Bar Association First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Criminal Record Office Inquiry First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Teachers (Paperwork) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Diversion from Landfill Questions · 6
- Scottish Natural Heritage and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (Public Inquiries) Questions · 7
- Fly-tipping Questions · 8
- Aberdeen Beach Recharge Scheme Questions · 8
- Beef Exports Questions · 13
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Digital Hearing Aids (Waiting Times) Questions · 11
- Residential Care (Highland) Questions · 4
- NHS Boards (Performance) Questions · 4
- Drug Addiction (Specialist Facilities) Questions · 9
- Primary Care (Springburn) Questions · 4
- Osteoporosis (West of Scotland) Questions · 6
- Cancer (Waiting Times) Questions · 4
- Climate Change Debate · 78
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 35
- Muscular Dystrophy Members’ business · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.