Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Colyn Evans

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Education and Young People, Tourism, Culture and Sport

Thursday 22 December 2005 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Iain Smith LD North East Fife
link
To ask the Scottish Executive how it will respond to the recommendations in respect of social work and related services of the joint Social Work Inspection Agency and Her Majesty's inspectorate of constabulary report on the Colyn Evans case. (S2O-8585)

Robert Brown LD The Deputy Minister for Education and Young People · Glasgow
link
I cannot begin to imagine the torment that must have been visited on the Dewar family by the loss of their daughter in such circumstances. We owe it to them to ensure that the lessons from any mistakes are learned and acted upon. The SWIA and HMIC report follows an earlier report by Fife Council and the police. Both reports conclude that, although mistakes were made, the escalation of Colyn Evans's behaviour to the point where he committed murder could not have been predicted.

The SWIA and HMIC report identifies a number of issues, including some to be addressed by the Scottish Executive. Substantial work is already being done to address the issues, including work under the child protection programme, work by the youth justice strategy and the work that is being done on the management of sex offenders. In particular, the youth justice improvement group and the expert panel on high-risk young people, including those with sexually problematic behaviour, will report around March 2006. An inspection of Geilsland School has just been carried out and we await receipt of the report.

Iain Smith LD North East Fife
link
The minister will appreciate that my constituents, the Dewar family, and the residents of Tayport are particularly concerned about the events that led to the death of Karen Dewar earlier this year. Does the minister agree that the joint SWIA and HMIC report identifies significant shortfalls in services that deal with children who exhibit inappropriate sexual behaviour? Secondly, does the minister agree that there is a major problem with people's transition from care to non-care services? In the case of Colyn Evans, there seems to have been a complete breakdown of support services at a time when he was at his most vulnerable because he was coming out of residential care and into the wider community. That probably led to the circumstances that, sadly, led to the death of my constituent.

Robert Brown LD The Deputy Minister for Education and Young People · Glasgow
link
I substantially agree with Iain Smith. The recommendations in the report concentrate on identification and risk assessment of, and planning for, young offenders, especially those with sexually aggressive behaviour. That is a particularly difficult area and there is a shortage of expertise on it throughout the country.

As I indicated, a professional group with expertise in adolescent sex offending has been set up to examine the issues and to produce a programme urgently to tackle, and to form a strategy for dealing with, the issues that arise. That will involve bringing on board the expertise of people who specialise in those areas. A risk assessment tool is available for dealing with adult sexual offenders, but it is not entirely appropriate for dealing with juvenile sex offenders. Part of the work, therefore, will involve refining the tool and assessing the availability of mechanisms for identifying, assessing and dealing with people who are in that particular position and increasing the system's capacity to handle them.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link
One of the greatest concerns about the case is that social workers failed to ensure that all the available information was placed before the children's hearing before Colyn Evans was discharged from supervision. The social workers' report appeared to understate any difficulties in relation to Colyn Evans's inappropriate sexual behaviour. Does the minister agree with the report's statement that professional staff should recognise their individual responsibilities for such matters? In the light of the catastrophic failures of judgment and action, is the minister concerned that no disciplinary action is being taken by Fife Council? If so, will the minister tell us what action he thinks the Executive should take so that, in the future, professional staff will be held to account for their failure to act in cases involving children and young people?

Robert Brown LD The Deputy Minister for Education and Young People · Glasgow
link
Tricia Marwick makes some clear and sensible points, which have also been made in a number of reports. The issues of people falling between different services and the failure to identify and pass on information are fairly commonplace issues that are at the heart of the Executive's programme to address the child protection programme in particular. The problem also exists in other areas such as additional support for learning, on which a bill was recently passed in the Parliament.

I will not comment on the council side of things, because, as I have indicated, various inquiries, not least the inspection of Geilsland School, are on-going. We will have to wait and draw our conclusions when we see the outcome of some of those inquiries and hear whether the Lord Advocate has an interest in the matter.

At our level, we are concerned about learning lessons that can be applied nationally to ensure that we reduce as much as possible the opportunities for such a situation to recur.

Ted Brocklebank Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link
Does the minister agree that the implications of the Colyn Evans case go far beyond the county of Fife and that the parents will not be satisfied until there is a full public inquiry on all aspects of the case? After all, it is relevant not only to Fife but to Scotland as a whole.

Robert Brown LD The Deputy Minister for Education and Young People · Glasgow
link
There is no doubt that a number of issues arise from the case. Indeed, as I have indicated, the report's findings will have implications not only for the local authority in the immediate future, but for the police and the Scottish Executive. All those are helpfully laid out in the report. I have touched on the duties of the Lord Advocate, who, if he is minded to do so, can ask for a fatal accident inquiry to be carried out. However, the matter is entirely at his discretion and I do not wish to comment on it.

Following this episode and other incidents in allied areas, the Executive is keen to do everything that is humanly possible to prevent this sort of thing from happening again. I very much share members' concerns about some of these matters.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 22 December 2005 Debate · 1
  2. Blood Products Debate · 31
  3. Rendition Flights Debate · 66
  4. Sustainable Development Strategy Questions · 4
  5. Memorandum of Understanding and Supplementary Agreements Questions · 6
  6. Cancer (Waiting Times) Questions · 8
  7. Pre-school Children (Health Checks) Questions · 6
  8. Fire Service Control Rooms Questions · 6
  9. Domestic Abuse Court Questions · 4
  10. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  11. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
  12. Equal Pay (Local Authorities) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Security Measures (Grangemouth) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Local Enterprise Companies First Minister’s Questions · 12
  15. Alcohol-related Health Problems First Minister’s Questions · 4
  16. Gas Work Notification Scheme Members’ business · 17
  17. Colyn Evans Questions · 8
  18. Education for Peace Questions · 4
  19. Childhood Obesity Questions · 6
  20. Asylum Seekers (Child Welfare) Questions · 6
  21. Young People (Football) Questions · 6
  22. Sport for Young People (Highlands) Questions · 4
  23. Glasgow City Council (Meetings) Questions · 6
  24. Equal Pay (Local Authorities) Questions · 11
  25. Young People (Local Authority Funding) Questions · 4
  26. Social Rented Housing (Development Constraints) Questions · 6
  27. Deprived Communities (Regeneration) Questions · 4
  28. Public Services (Access) Questions · 5
  29. Black and Minority Ethnic Community (Capacity Building) Questions · 4
  30. Affordable Housing (Linlithgow) Questions · 4
  31. Business Motion Business motions · 4
  32. Decision Time Decision time · 36

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.