To ask the Scottish Executive whether it is aware of any new evidence regarding offences of attempting or conspiring to commit torture being committed in Scotland or Scottish airspace and what action it has taken as a result of any such evidence. (S2O-8231)
Official Report · Chamber
Torture
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Justice and Law Officers
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- The Lord Advocate Colin Boyd 5
- Murray Tosh Con 5
- Chris Ballance Green 2
- Sandra White SNP 2
- Rosemary Byrne SSP 1
- Jim Wallace LD 1
- Margaret Jamieson Lab 1
The record
17 contributions
The Lord Advocate
Colin Boyd
link
Scottish ministers take allegations of such offences seriously. Civil aviation is a reserved matter and is therefore the responsibility of the United Kingdom Government. However, attempts to commit or to conspire to commit torture are crimes under Scots law and it is for the police to investigate allegations of such offences and for the procurator fiscal to decide whether to bring proceedings. If anyone has evidence, including new evidence, of criminal offences being committed within Scottish jurisdiction, they should take the matter to the police in the first instance.
I thank you for your reply, which is familiar to me.
If you were watching "Newsnight" this week, you might be aware that I have now received a reply from the chief constable of Strathclyde police refusing my request for a meeting and refusing to conduct such an investigation.
Can you give me a categorical assurance that, to your knowledge, no one from your Government has had any communication with Strathclyde police relating to this issue that might have influenced their decision?
If you were watching "Newsnight" this week, you might be aware that I have now received a reply from the chief constable of Strathclyde police refusing my request for a meeting and refusing to conduct such an investigation.
Can you give me a categorical assurance that, to your knowledge, no one from your Government has had any communication with Strathclyde police relating to this issue that might have influenced their decision?
The Lord Advocate
Colin Boyd
link
I am not going to comment on communications between the Scottish Executive, particularly my office, and Strathclyde police. The matter is particularly one for the police, whose job it is to investigate crime. They are not instructed by ministers. As Lord Advocate, I am the only person who can instruct the police if I have evidence of criminal offences being committed. If there is evidence of such activity, the proper thing to do is to give that evidence to the police so that they can make an assessment and, if necessary, refer the matter to the procurator fiscal for advice.
Before I proceed, Mr Ballance, for future reference, you should know that, when members use the word "you" in this chamber, it applies to me. Members really should refer to ministers in the third person.
Central Intelligence Agency torture flights are stopping to refuel in Scotland. Any act that aids and abets torture contravenes the European convention on human rights. Will the Minister for Justice give a guarantee that she will do everything in her power to stop the torture flights? We need the police to investigate this matter. We cannot give you the evidence until it has been investigated. Will you get an investigation under way?
I will not. However, on your behalf, I will redirect the question to the Lord Advocate.
The Lord Advocate
Colin Boyd
link
The matter is not for the minister, because she does not have the power to direct the police, nor does she have any responsibility for civil aviation in this country. Civil aviation is a reserved matter and it is for the United Kingdom Government, acting under the Chicago convention, to regulate civil aviation.
I repeat that the investigation of crime is a matter for the police. Before they apply for a warrant to enter any aircraft, they would have to have evidence of criminal activity on board that aircraft.
I repeat that the investigation of crime is a matter for the police. Before they apply for a warrant to enter any aircraft, they would have to have evidence of criminal activity on board that aircraft.
I do not wish to labour this point—if you will pardon the pun—but I would like to ask the minister outright whether she has had any dealings, discussion or communications with Strathclyde police. Does she agree that, as she is the Minister for Justice, she must have at least some responsibility in this regard and should be aware of all prisoner movements, regardless of whose prisoners they are? You must come clean and say yes or no. Have you had discussions and what have they related to?
Fortunately, my duties do not go as far as gender definition questions. However, I think that these particular questions are being handled by Mr Boyd.
The Lord Advocate
Colin Boyd
link
At the risk of repeating myself, none of the ministers around me has any power to direct the police in individual investigations. It would be improper for ministers to do that. I hope that that is absolutely clear. I am the only person who can do that and before it can be done, there must be evidence on which I can act.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. I did not ask whether the minister could direct the police; I asked whether there had been communications and meetings—yes or no?
Members cannot use points of order to re-ask questions even if they believe that their questions have not been answered. There is no locus in standing orders for me to determine the content of ministerial answers.
I welcome the obvious seriousness with which the Lord Advocate takes the issue.
Given that article 4 of the United Nations convention against torture refers not only to acts of torture but to
"an attempt to commit torture and to an act by any person which constitutes complicity or participation in torture",
will the Lord Advocate tell the chamber whether our obligations under that convention would override any obligation under civil aviation conventions, such as the Chicago convention, in respect of persons on board planes and in transit through Scotland about whom there could be reasonable grounds to suspect that they had committed offences under the convention against torture?
Given that article 4 of the United Nations convention against torture refers not only to acts of torture but to
"an attempt to commit torture and to an act by any person which constitutes complicity or participation in torture",
will the Lord Advocate tell the chamber whether our obligations under that convention would override any obligation under civil aviation conventions, such as the Chicago convention, in respect of persons on board planes and in transit through Scotland about whom there could be reasonable grounds to suspect that they had committed offences under the convention against torture?
The Lord Advocate
Colin Boyd
link
I understand people's concerns about such matters. They are serious concerns that should be addressed seriously. I note that Mr Wallace's colleague at Westminster, Menzies Campbell, is progressing that matter and I look forward to seeing what the Westminster committee does.
The conventions do not compete; they are obligations that the United Kingdom has to implement. However, as far as I am concerned as Lord Advocate, I give the member the assurance that if offences are committed in the jurisdiction of Scotland and I am made aware of supporting evidence, they will be investigated. At the moment, however, we require evidence of specific conduct on specific flights before any movement can take place on the matter.
The conventions do not compete; they are obligations that the United Kingdom has to implement. However, as far as I am concerned as Lord Advocate, I give the member the assurance that if offences are committed in the jurisdiction of Scotland and I am made aware of supporting evidence, they will be investigated. At the moment, however, we require evidence of specific conduct on specific flights before any movement can take place on the matter.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. I ask you to reflect on what has happened during today's question time, particularly in relation to members who have not had the courtesy to stay for the duration of question time and who appeared only for specific ones. Other members who submitted questions that have been printed in the Business Bulletin and sat throughout question time have been disadvantaged.
Although I would like to deal with that situation, I understand that I do not have the power to do so. However, I sympathise with Margaret Jamieson's point about members being present throughout question time.
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Nov 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 24 November 2005 Debate · 1
- Business Motion Business motions · 9
- Housing (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 223
- Sex Education Questions · 4
- European Union Legislation Questions · 11
- Schools (Bullying) Questions · 4
- Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park (Byelaws) Questions · 6
- Sportscotland (Meetings) Questions · 8
- National Health Service (Missed Appointments) Questions · 6
- Fresh Talent Initiative Questions · 4
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Asylum Seeker Removals First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Police Safety First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Nuclear Power First Minister’s Questions · 4
- St Andrew's Day Celebrations First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Terrorism Suspects (Detention) Questions · 6
- Mobile Closed-circuit Television Cameras Questions · 4
- Movement of Prisoners (Correspondence) Questions · 4
- Fingerprint Evidence Questions · 13
- Corporate Homicide Questions · 4
- Environmental Law Questions · 4
- Torture Questions · 17
- A75 (Improvement) Questions · 6
- Glasgow Airport Rail Link Questions · 6
- Glasgow School of Art Questions · 6
- M74 (Northern Extension) Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Tramlines (Funding) Questions · 11
- Glasgow Airport (Discussions) Questions · 4
- Rail (Freight) Questions · 8
- Housing (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 134
- Housing (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 24
- Point of Order Procedure · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 7
- Television Licence and Digital Reception Members’ business · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.