To ask the Scottish Executive whether it has any plans to review the policy of placing children with special needs in mainstream schools. (S2O-7222)
Official Report · Chamber
Schools (Mainstreaming)
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Education and Young People, Tourism, Culture and Sport
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Peter Peacock Lab 3
- Tricia Marwick SNP 2
- Cathie Craigie Lab 1
The record
6 contributionsChildren should have the opportunity to be educated in mainstream schools where that is appropriate. We have no plans to change the law where the presumption in favour of mainstreaming is established.
Has the minister noted the comments made recently by Baroness Warnock on the idea that the policy of mainstreaming should now be revisited? Does he agree that, as people who support the principle behind mainstreaming, we should have the courage to examine how the policy is working in practice? Will he make a commitment to begin doing so?
I am aware of Baroness Warnock's comments as they have been reported. However, her report on the subject has not been published yet, and I look forward to seeing it. Her critique was principally about the system that operates in England, which is different to ours. Given that we have now radically reformed our system—the Parliament considered the matter last year—we have already addressed the issues that the Baroness has raised in relation to the English system. I understand that a report published earlier this week—or perhaps last week—by a committee of the British-Irish Inter-Parliamentary Body commended what has been happening in Scotland in comparison with what has been happening in England. Indeed, that report also commended what has been happening in Wales. We have made progress on the areas on which Baroness Warnock commented in relation to England.
On evaluation, an Audit Commission report on mainstreaming has already been published, and we have commissioned the Scottish centre for research in education to examine the mainstreaming policy. SCRE will report at the end of this year.
It is important that we do not allow something of a myth to develop around the mainstreaming policy. Special schools will still have an important role to play in Scottish education. There are now 32 more special schools than there were in the mid-1990s. The percentage of the school population who have moved from special schools to mainstream schools has changed only by 0.03 per cent, which is equivalent to one child for every nine schools in Scotland. There has not been some wholesale shift away from special education settings into mainstream schools. That said, it is right that children should get the opportunity, where that is appropriate for the individual child—individual judgments have to be made—and where there are safeguards for other children in the schools concerned.
On evaluation, an Audit Commission report on mainstreaming has already been published, and we have commissioned the Scottish centre for research in education to examine the mainstreaming policy. SCRE will report at the end of this year.
It is important that we do not allow something of a myth to develop around the mainstreaming policy. Special schools will still have an important role to play in Scottish education. There are now 32 more special schools than there were in the mid-1990s. The percentage of the school population who have moved from special schools to mainstream schools has changed only by 0.03 per cent, which is equivalent to one child for every nine schools in Scotland. There has not been some wholesale shift away from special education settings into mainstream schools. That said, it is right that children should get the opportunity, where that is appropriate for the individual child—individual judgments have to be made—and where there are safeguards for other children in the schools concerned.
That was certainly a full response to Tricia Marwick's question.
Will the minister acknowledge the experience of young people who have been integrated into mainstream education? In the vast majority of cases, mainstreaming has been a great success. The young people with whom I have come into contact and their families are very happy that they have the opportunity to be educated with their friends and peers. However, I believe that the Executive could do better by making further information available, not just to parents of children with special needs but to all parents. Will the Executive undertake to provide more detailed and valuable information?
Will the minister acknowledge the experience of young people who have been integrated into mainstream education? In the vast majority of cases, mainstreaming has been a great success. The young people with whom I have come into contact and their families are very happy that they have the opportunity to be educated with their friends and peers. However, I believe that the Executive could do better by making further information available, not just to parents of children with special needs but to all parents. Will the Executive undertake to provide more detailed and valuable information?
I heartily agree that it is always important to empower people with respect to the provisions that are available to them—the laws, structures and policies that we have created are of little use unless people understand what has been made available to them. I agree that we need to continue to improve the supply of information to parents. The Executive now spends a lot of time working with groups of parents of young people with additional support needs, and I hope that one of the products of that work will be an improvement in the flow of information to young people.
I agree entirely with Cathie Craigie on her point about the success of mainstreaming for a lot of young people. In fact, it was in North Lanarkshire where I first met parents whose children had been put into a mainstream setting. The parents had felt great trepidation; nonetheless, they discovered that, as a consequence, rather than their child being stared at in the streets on a Saturday morning for being someone unusual or out of the ordinary, in the particular instance to which I refer, their child was greeted by friends from the mainstream school and made to feel part of the community in which they lived. That has to be a good thing for the children concerned and for the wider community.
I agree entirely with Cathie Craigie on her point about the success of mainstreaming for a lot of young people. In fact, it was in North Lanarkshire where I first met parents whose children had been put into a mainstream setting. The parents had felt great trepidation; nonetheless, they discovered that, as a consequence, rather than their child being stared at in the streets on a Saturday morning for being someone unusual or out of the ordinary, in the particular instance to which I refer, their child was greeted by friends from the mainstream school and made to feel part of the community in which they lived. That has to be a good thing for the children concerned and for the wider community.
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Jun 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 23 June 2005 Debate · 1
- Financial Management 2004-05 Debate · 121
- Homophobic Bullying Questions · 5
- “World Competitiveness Yearbook” Questions · 6
- Cancer Treatment Targets Questions · 9
- Disclosure Scotland Questions · 6
- Cataract Operations (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
- Universities (Points System) Questions · 4
- Health Priorities Questions · 5
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Cultural Commission Report First Minister’s Questions · 6
- W8 Conference First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Children's Services First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Homestake Scheme Questions · 4
- Central Heating Programme Questions · 12
- Local Authority Services (Equitable Provision) Questions · 5
- United Kingdom Presidency of the European Union Questions · 11
- Public Sector Jobs (Relocation Policy) Questions · 8
- Out-of-hours Facilities Questions · 6
- Schools (Mainstreaming) Questions · 6
- Schools (Foreign Language Teaching) Questions · 4
- Children's Panel System Questions · 4
- School Meals Questions · 8
- Teacher Numbers Questions · 10
- Legal Aid Reform Debate · 56
- Business Motions Business motions · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 28
- W8 Summit Members’ business · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.