Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Central Heating Programme

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Finance and Public Services and Communities

Thursday 23 June 2005 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 12 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link
To ask the Scottish Executive whether it plans to extend the central heating programme beyond March 2006 and whether it is consulting on options for extending the programme. (S2O-7280)

Johann Lamont Lab The Deputy Minister for Communities · Glasgow Pollok
link
We plan to extend the central heating programme beyond March 2006 and will soon consult the fuel poverty forum and others on the options for the future programme.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link
The minister will be aware of the success of the scheme. Indeed, it surprises me that there is still a high demand from the over-60s for the initial scheme. In the consultation, will ministers give consideration to extending the provisions for pensioners with inadequate and obsolete central heating by reducing the age at which they are eligible for support to somewhere below 80?

Johann Lamont Lab The Deputy Minister for Communities · Glasgow Pollok
link
I am aware of the scheme's popularity. Members from all parties have recognised the significant progress that has been made. We have provided free central heating installation, advice and other benefits to more than 51,000 households. We have two key tasks. Currently, we are considering the fuel poverty figures in the 2002 Scottish house condition survey, because we want not just to improve the general infrastructure of people's houses and the housing stock but to tackle the problem of fuel poverty. To that end, we are consulting across the board. I hope that MSPs will participate in the consultation.

The fuel poverty forum captures interests such as the power companies, Energy Action Scotland, Shelter, Age Concern, Help the Aged, the Scottish Federation of Housing Associations and a range of other organisations—I can provide the member with a full list. The forum will be able to consider not just the issues for over-60s and over-80s—we have extended the scope of the programme for over-80s—but how the scheme can be matched with our fuel poverty targets.

John Home Robertson Lab East Lothian
link
Will the minister consider the problems that face pensioners whose landlords have refused to allow them to take advantage of the excellent scheme? I register my strong support for Elaine Murray's point that there is a case for extending the scheme to cover pensioners who have obsolete and hopelessly inefficient old central heating systems in their houses.

Johann Lamont Lab The Deputy Minister for Communities · Glasgow Pollok
link
When we extended the scheme to cover partial and inadequate central heating systems for the over-80s, we recognised the force of the argument that the member makes. At that stage, the decision was made that the over-80s were the priority group, but we can consider the issue further.

John Home Robertson and Dr Murray have raised the issue of the role of landlords in the past. We are continuing to look at the matter to establish the extent of the problem. We recognise that the problem might be partly hidden, as some people might not make an application for a new system because they think that it will be refused by their landlord. However, the extent to which landlords can resist improvements that tenants might wish to make is one of the smaller focuses of the Housing (Scotland) Bill.

Alasdair Morgan SNP South of Scotland
link
I hope that the scheme's criteria will mean that the net will catch not only obsolete and inefficient systems but, as one of my constituents said, the obsolete and inefficient people who use the systems. The elderly gentleman and his wife had an efficient and workable coal system, but because of their level of disability they could not get the coal into the system to provide the heat. It would have been very helpful to them had they qualified for the scheme.

Johann Lamont Lab The Deputy Minister for Communities · Glasgow Pollok
link
One of the fundamental aspects of the scheme is our recognition that vulnerable, elderly people are not necessarily in a strong position to negotiate with individual companies about the best system for them. That is why we tried to take away those difficulties through working with the Eaga Partnership Ltd. One of Eaga's responsibilities is to recognise the importance of speaking to people about using their systems efficiently.

On the specific point that Alasdair Morgan makes, one of my constituents has had a similar experience, in that, although they have an adequate system, they are no longer in a position to use it. We have to be more imaginative about how we support people in those circumstances. If they are not strong enough to carry in the coal, it might be that we should not put in a new central heating system but look at whether their levels of support are adequate. We recognise those challenges. The central heating programme is part of our support for elderly people; it should not be a substitute for the other bits of the system in which we work closely with individuals and families who need support in different ways.

John Swinburne SSCUP Central Scotland
link
What would the minister say to the pensioner who wrote to me this week to say that Eaga told them that it would cost £800 to remove their old system so that the new system could be put in? I thought that free systems were being installed. Surely that pensioner is not responsible for paying for the old system to be taken away.

Johann Lamont Lab The Deputy Minister for Communities · Glasgow Pollok
link
I advise John Swinburne to write to me so that I can make sure that he gets an absolutely correct and adequate response. There has been correspondence about the whole area. The original programme worked well for people who had no heating systems; in those cases, it was straightforward to install a new system. As systems have required replacement, we have had to ensure that our advice and guidelines catch up. The current position is that, if the installation of the new system does not require the old system to be taken away, people are expected to pay for the removal of the old system. I am more than happy to look at the specific details of the case that John Swinburne referred to, because we are not in the business of having a system that creates greater distress for people.

As that case highlights, some of the details and implications of such a programme cannot possibly be evident when we initially devise it. Our commitment as we move towards 2006 is to ensure that the nitty-gritty issues that can cause a lot of grief to people are addressed through the programme.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link
The minister will acknowledge that the central heating programme is probably the most effective measure that the Executive has taken to reduce fuel poverty among older people. Like others, I ask her whether she will consider extending the programme to include replacing inefficient or partial systems for all pensioners, rather than just obsolete systems for the over-80s. Will she also consider including for the first time people with a disability whose condition is such that they would benefit from central heating?

Johann Lamont Lab The Deputy Minister for Communities · Glasgow Pollok
link
As I said, we are consulting on how the next stage of the programme should be taken forward. At that level, nothing has been ruled out. A compelling case was made for the extension of the programme to the over-80s with partial or inefficient systems. That has to balanced against a reflection on the extent to which, as the programme develops, it still addresses issues around fuel poverty. I acknowledge Jackie Baillie's point about people with a disability. Indeed, a case can be made for a whole range of people. We will have to make a balanced judgment on the basis of not just what the representative fuel poverty forum says, but what the experiences of MSPs and others bring to the consultation.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 23 June 2005 Debate · 1
  2. Financial Management 2004-05 Debate · 121
  3. Homophobic Bullying Questions · 5
  4. “World Competitiveness Yearbook” Questions · 6
  5. Cancer Treatment Targets Questions · 9
  6. Disclosure Scotland Questions · 6
  7. Cataract Operations (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
  8. Universities (Points System) Questions · 4
  9. Health Priorities Questions · 5
  10. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  11. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
  13. Cultural Commission Report First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. W8 Conference First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Children's Services First Minister’s Questions · 13
  16. Homestake Scheme Questions · 4
  17. Central Heating Programme Questions · 12
  18. Local Authority Services (Equitable Provision) Questions · 5
  19. United Kingdom Presidency of the European Union Questions · 11
  20. Public Sector Jobs (Relocation Policy) Questions · 8
  21. Out-of-hours Facilities Questions · 6
  22. Schools (Mainstreaming) Questions · 6
  23. Schools (Foreign Language Teaching) Questions · 4
  24. Children's Panel System Questions · 4
  25. School Meals Questions · 8
  26. Teacher Numbers Questions · 10
  27. Legal Aid Reform Debate · 56
  28. Business Motions Business motions · 3
  29. Decision Time Decision time · 28
  30. W8 Summit Members’ business · 14

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.