Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Planning (Community Involvement)

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Finance and Public Services and Communities

Thursday 12 May 2005 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 10 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow Kelvin
link
To ask the Scottish Executive how it intends to involve communities in the planning system. (S2O-6712)

Malcolm Chisholm Lab The Minister for Communities · Edinburgh North and Leith
link
Our planning white paper will set out a range of reforms to ensure that local people have better opportunities to participate in the planning system.

Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow Kelvin
link
The minister will be aware of my persistent lobbying for a qualified community right of appeal. Although I do not believe everything that I read in the press, I think that some reassurances are required. Will he make a commitment today to consider all the proposals to redress the imbalance between the rights of developers to challenge planning decisions and communities' lack of rights to do so? If the Executive is not going to support a qualified third-party right of appeal, will he consider removing, reducing or qualifying developers' rights of appeal?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab The Minister for Communities · Edinburgh North and Leith
link
We are giving full consideration to rights of appeal, with regard not only to third parties, but to how the system can operate more effectively and more fairly in relation to developers—Pauline McNeill is right that that is one aspect that we are examining. More generally, it is well known that there are disagreements in society and in the Parliament about the details of the most effective way in which to introduce more community participation into the planning system. However, we are determined to pursue that objective and to create better opportunities for local people to have a say. In many cases, local people feel alienated from the planning system and unable to have the input that they want.

There are disagreements. Some people think that third-party rights of appeal are the key way of achieving greater participation, whereas others think that that is not the most effective way. However, let us be clear about the principles. We are determined to deliver better community participation in the planning system. That is one of the two key pillars; the other is, obviously, the efficiency of the system. For me, community participation is absolutely central to the reforms that we will deliver.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link
The minister will be aware that I have resubmitted my bill on third-party rights of appeal, but is he also aware of the widespread anger in communities about the Executive's complete refusal to consider third-party rights of appeal? He has mentioned clarification, but he must clarify to the people whether he is willing to have third-party rights of appeal. Does he agree with me and others that the consultation process was essentially a sham to get rid of third-party rights of appeal and that the real—

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link
I am asking whether the minister agrees with me. Does he agree that the Executive's real purpose is to centralise the planning process?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab The Minister for Communities · Edinburgh North and Leith
link
Sandra White should wait to see the whole package of reforms that we will bring forward in the near future before she makes sweeping statements that are based on selective quotations from allegedly leaked documents. She makes the charge that we have given no consideration to third-party rights of appeal. If I can exaggerate slightly, I have considered little else for the past seven months. We have given serious—and I mean serious—consideration to the issues and we have examined the underlying problems of the planning system. We want to ensure that we are governed by the principle of greater community involvement in the system.

Sandra White emphasises that aspect of the issue, but I have heard other people say that, if I really want to help their community, I should do other things. One of the key things that we certainly will do—Donald Gorrie introduced the idea in a question this morning—is to ensure that people have a right to be involved early in the process, in respect of not only development control, but development planning. Communities will be more effectively involved at an early stage.

Let us be clear. Some of the details are still being worked out, but I believe that, when we introduce our proposals to the Parliament, they will be broadly and widely welcomed by communities throughout Scotland.

Donald Gorrie LD Central Scotland
link
In addition to the point that the minister kindly referred to, I raise an issue from the same angle as Pauline McNeill did. Does the minister accept that there could be a level playing field between developers and communities in a limited appeal process if we took account of the fact that councils are increasingly involved with developers in joint development and so are not a neutral referee, which is how their role was originally conceived in the planning legislation? The aspect of council involvement must be considered in a right of appeal.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab The Minister for Communities · Edinburgh North and Leith
link
I am not sure that I fully understood the details of what Donald Gorrie said, but we certainly want to involve communities at an early stage. In answer to the charge of centralisation, we also want to ensure that local authorities are at the centre of the planning system. Of course, we fully recognise the crucial role of local authorities in speaking for and being accountable to local communities. However, I think that people should wait until they can see the full range and detail of our planning reforms before making wide-ranging criticisms of them.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 12 May 2005 Debate · 1
  2. Schools-Colleges Review Debate · 72
  3. Child Detentions Questions · 5
  4. Neurology Services Questions · 6
  5. Migrant Workers (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 6
  6. Fife (Economic Regeneration) Questions · 6
  7. Family Mediation Questions · 4
  8. Community Right to Buy Questions · 4
  9. National Health Service (Homoeopathy) Questions · 4
  10. Organ Donor Register Questions · 4
  11. Nuclear Waste Questions · 4
  12. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  13. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  14. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  15. Planning (Community Rights) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  16. Bail (Electronic Tagging) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Nuclear Power First Minister’s Questions · 6
  18. Planning (Community Involvement) Questions · 10
  19. Scottish Executive Staff (Accountants) Questions · 4
  20. Nuclear Power (Planning Applications) Questions · 4
  21. Relocation Policy (Highlands) Questions · 6
  22. Relocation Policy (Guidance) Questions · 6
  23. Fresh Talent Initiative Questions · 6
  24. Civil Service Reform Questions · 4
  25. London Olympic Bid Questions · 6
  26. Sportswomen (Equality) Questions · 4
  27. Autistic Children (Schools) Questions · 14
  28. Outdoor Education Questions · 10
  29. Class Sizes Questions · 4
  30. Scotland's Veterans Debate · 28
  31. Decision Time Decision time · 15
  32. Inclusion Scotland Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.