To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will review the basis on which bail is granted for those charged with murder or culpable homicide. (S2O-6549)
Official Report · Chamber
Bail
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Justice and Law Officers
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Cathy Jamieson Lab 3
- Brian Adam SNP 2
- Margaret Mitchell Con 1
The record
6 contributionsI am very aware of public concern about bail being granted to those who are accused of serious crimes. In its recent report, the Sentencing Commission recommended various ways of tightening up the basis on which bail and remand decisions are taken. We have already made provision for electronic monitoring as a condition of bail in the case of charges of murder and rape.
The minister will be aware that only three people who were charged with murder were granted bail in 1999 whereas 55 such people were granted bail in 2004. Does the minister consider that the repeal of the statutory exclusions to the granting of bail in 2000 for those charged with murder has been a success? If not, will she consider taking further action to increase public protection beyond that which she has described today?
I am sure that the member is aware of the provisions of the European convention on human rights. I am therefore unsure whether he is suggesting that his party is in favour of completely repealing those provisions—perhaps he is; if so, we can have the discussion another time. The important point to make is that far too many offences are committed by people on bail. That is not acceptable.
There are, of course, a number of standard and specific conditions that must be put on bail orders. I believe that we should tighten up some of the conditions. I am looking closely at the recommendations in the Sentencing Commission report and I expect to bring forward proposals in the not-too-distant future.
There are, of course, a number of standard and specific conditions that must be put on bail orders. I believe that we should tighten up some of the conditions. I am looking closely at the recommendations in the Sentencing Commission report and I expect to bring forward proposals in the not-too-distant future.
Is it not the case that the incorporation of the ECHR in Scots law means that there is now a presumption in favour of bail? The proper discretion of the court has been usurped, and that, in turn, has worked to the detriment of both victims and witnesses.
It is certainly the case that people have concerns in some instances about those who have been granted bail. That is why I asked the Sentencing Commission to look at a number of the issues as a priority. Some commentators and other people have chosen to portray the measures that we are taking, including electronic monitoring, as a softening of the approach to bail. I want to be clear that electronic monitoring is not an alternative to remand for those who ought to be remanded. Where there are concerns, the Executive is tightening up bail conditions.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 May 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Wednesday 4 May 2005 Debate · 1
- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 7
- Business Motion Business motions · 48
- Health Questions · 8
- Teachers (Fife) Questions · 6
- Tartan Day Questions · 4
- M74 (Health Hazards) Questions · 4
- Nuclear Waste (Submarines) Questions · 6
- Public Services (Investment) Questions · 8
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Life Expectancy First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Housing (First-time Buyers) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Spending Review First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Children (Detention in Prison) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Police (Recruitment) Questions · 4
- Motoring Offences (Sentencing Guidelines) Questions · 4
- Offending (Young People) Questions · 4
- Sectarianism Questions · 8
- Bail Questions · 6
- Criminal History System (Replacement Project) Questions · 6
- Youth Courts Questions · 7
- Criminal History System (Replacement Project) Questions · 4
- Retraining Questions · 4
- Student Loans (Repayment) Questions · 5
- Scottish Enterprise (Employee Relations) Questions · 7
- Enterprise (Inverclyde) Questions · 10
- State Aid (Reform) Questions · 8
- Transport (Fife) Questions · 8
- Community Enterprises Questions · 4
- Supporting Local Producers Members’ business · 27
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.