To ask the First Minister what action the Scottish Executive will take to address inequalities highlighted by the report published in the April edition of the British Medical Journal which concludes that the gap between life expectancy in rich and poorer areas has not been wider since Victorian times. (S2F-1625)
Official Report · Chamber
Life Expectancy
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 5
- Colin Fox SSP 3
- Des McNulty Lab 2
- George Reid 1
- Sandra White SNP 1
The record
12 contributionsIn addition to reducing the number of people in poverty, we have introduced legislation to ban smoking in enclosed public places. That legislation will be the biggest contribution that we can make to improving health in Scotland, as it will reduce the toll of preventable, premature deaths that result from smoking and that affect the poorer parts of our country most.
Does the First Minister agree that it is totally unacceptable that life expectancy for a man in Kensington and Chelsea should be 10 years more than that of his counterpart in Glasgow, which is the widest gap for 100 years? The authors of the British Medical Journal report believe that, if current trends continue, growing inequalities will be transmitted to and magnified among future generations. Does the First Minister agree with the conclusions that the report draws about what needs to be done to turn the current situation around?
In looking at this question, I did a little research and it was interesting to note how difficult it is to compare the situation in Victorian times with the situation today. We have, of course, the figures on life expectancy that were quoted in the report not just for the United Kingdom or Scotland as a whole, but for individual constituencies. Even in the constituency of Shettleston, which has the lowest life expectancy in the UK—63 years—people have a significantly better life expectancy than their counterparts did in Victorian times, when life expectancy was 40 years.
Given that Mr Fox was asking the question, I thought that it might be interesting to check what the life expectancy was when Robin Hood was alive. At that time, life expectancy was 24 years. The figures show that we cannot compare life expectancy and inequality centuries apart, but we can compare the reality in Scotland today with what was happening just eight years ago when the current Government came to power.
The reality in the UK and in Scotland is that there are now significantly fewer people living in poverty. Just here in Scotland, 110,000 children have been lifted from relative—not absolute, but comparative—poverty since 1997, which is a 25 per cent reduction. Some 170,000 pensioners have been lifted from absolute poverty, which is a massive 68 per cent reduction. Right the way through the statistics, we see massive reductions since 1997 in the numbers of people living in poverty in Scotland, in the UK and particularly in the poorer parts of Scotland. That is precisely why people should vote tomorrow not for some Trotskyist sect that promotes wacky ideas about the past, but for a party that is genuinely committed to tackling poverty, is doing so and will make further progress if we go forward and not back in the votes tomorrow night.
Given that Mr Fox was asking the question, I thought that it might be interesting to check what the life expectancy was when Robin Hood was alive. At that time, life expectancy was 24 years. The figures show that we cannot compare life expectancy and inequality centuries apart, but we can compare the reality in Scotland today with what was happening just eight years ago when the current Government came to power.
The reality in the UK and in Scotland is that there are now significantly fewer people living in poverty. Just here in Scotland, 110,000 children have been lifted from relative—not absolute, but comparative—poverty since 1997, which is a 25 per cent reduction. Some 170,000 pensioners have been lifted from absolute poverty, which is a massive 68 per cent reduction. Right the way through the statistics, we see massive reductions since 1997 in the numbers of people living in poverty in Scotland, in the UK and particularly in the poorer parts of Scotland. That is precisely why people should vote tomorrow not for some Trotskyist sect that promotes wacky ideas about the past, but for a party that is genuinely committed to tackling poverty, is doing so and will make further progress if we go forward and not back in the votes tomorrow night.
All that bluster appears to prove that the First Minister does not have a clue about the conclusions that were drawn in the British Medical Journal report. I remind him that the report concluded that, if the situation is to improve, radical action is needed and
"far more potent and redistributive intervention by government".
Either the First Minister agrees with the conclusions of those experts, who are on the front line of the national health service, or, as I suspect, Labour has simply reconciled itself to living with greater inequalities and has effectively abandoned the NHS's founding principles—to have a comprehensive, free health care system—in favour of privatised hospitals and further inequalities.
"far more potent and redistributive intervention by government".
Either the First Minister agrees with the conclusions of those experts, who are on the front line of the national health service, or, as I suspect, Labour has simply reconciled itself to living with greater inequalities and has effectively abandoned the NHS's founding principles—to have a comprehensive, free health care system—in favour of privatised hospitals and further inequalities.
I am always happy to debate the statistics, including the fact that the proportion of children in relative poverty has decreased from one in three to one in four; that the proportion of all Scots in relative poverty has decreased from one in four to one in five; and that the proportion of pensioners in relative poverty has decreased from one in three to one in five. However, I suspect that Colin Fox does not want to debate such statistics, because they clearly prove that our policies are making an impact.
So let us debate policies, by which I mean not just the policies that I am sure all parties across the chamber agree on, but the policies on which we have a choice. I am happy to mention not only the provision of free fruit to primary school children; the 500 community food initiatives that are operating across Scotland; the tackling and treatment of cancer and heart disease; and the smoking legislation that I referred to earlier. I am also happy to mention the Scottish Socialist Party's policy of providing free school meals and prescriptions to those who can afford to pay for them, instead of targeting that money on the children and other people in our society who need that assistance the most. That is why we are absolutely right to invest the money that Colin Fox would waste on those who can afford to pay in better, nutritious school meals and why we lead the rest of the UK in ensuring that children in Scotland have a better start in life. It is a shame that the so-called socialists in the chamber cannot back that policy.
So let us debate policies, by which I mean not just the policies that I am sure all parties across the chamber agree on, but the policies on which we have a choice. I am happy to mention not only the provision of free fruit to primary school children; the 500 community food initiatives that are operating across Scotland; the tackling and treatment of cancer and heart disease; and the smoking legislation that I referred to earlier. I am also happy to mention the Scottish Socialist Party's policy of providing free school meals and prescriptions to those who can afford to pay for them, instead of targeting that money on the children and other people in our society who need that assistance the most. That is why we are absolutely right to invest the money that Colin Fox would waste on those who can afford to pay in better, nutritious school meals and why we lead the rest of the UK in ensuring that children in Scotland have a better start in life. It is a shame that the so-called socialists in the chamber cannot back that policy.
I have an advantage over many members in that I have listened to the arguments about how to improve Glasgow's health. As a result, I believe that we should focus not on Glasgow's problems, but on the solutions that we can put forward. For example, Harry Burns and Phil Hanlon, who are the leading experts in the field, say that we need high levels of employment, affordable, safe and high-quality housing—
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
This is a speech, Mr McNulty. A question, please.
We also need improved education. Does the First Minister agree that, in order to change the statistics, we need not only increased investment in health, but the sustained development programme that Labour offers?
I have absolutely no doubt that the best route out of poverty for those who can work is that they should be able to work. I am very proud to be the First Minister of a country that has the second highest employment level in the European Union and the highest employment level in the UK. We will maintain our pressure in driving towards full employment and ensuring that those who are out of work even now have the life chances, health, skills, education, training, encouragement and support to give them opportunities and to close the final gap between the current high level of employment and full employment. That has been the dream of our party for 100 years and it is closer to being a reality now than it has ever been before.
Does the First Minister agree that it is absolutely shameful that Glasgow has the worst levels of deprivation and the worst life expectancy in the UK? After suffering decades of Labour domination in the council, at Westminster and in the Scottish Parliament, thousands of Glaswegians are still living in poverty. Will he give a commitment today to set up a task force and invite all interested parties to examine the very real issues of poverty in the city?
The last thing that the good people of Glasgow need is another committee to look at the matter. They want action and that is what they are getting. They are getting regeneration down the Clyde and in the east end; they are getting new hospitals; and they are getting a massive housing stock transfer, which is leading to the biggest public sector housing modernisation programme in the whole of Europe. Sandra White opposed that. She has the temerity to come to the chamber and say that she represents the people of Glasgow when she was against them getting new houses and getting their houses repaired and renovated. She would rather have no investment than investment that meant that people had more control over their own affairs.
We are all about ensuring that, instead of being run by some centralised Scottish National Party bureaucracy, people in Glasgow and elsewhere in Scotland have a chance to take more control over their own lives. We want to ensure that people in Glasgow lead their own regeneration, that they have their own employment and that they can be proud of their city again.
We are all about ensuring that, instead of being run by some centralised Scottish National Party bureaucracy, people in Glasgow and elsewhere in Scotland have a chance to take more control over their own lives. We want to ensure that people in Glasgow lead their own regeneration, that they have their own employment and that they can be proud of their city again.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 May 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Wednesday 4 May 2005 Debate · 1
- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 7
- Business Motion Business motions · 48
- Health Questions · 8
- Teachers (Fife) Questions · 6
- Tartan Day Questions · 4
- M74 (Health Hazards) Questions · 4
- Nuclear Waste (Submarines) Questions · 6
- Public Services (Investment) Questions · 8
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Life Expectancy First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Housing (First-time Buyers) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Spending Review First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Children (Detention in Prison) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Police (Recruitment) Questions · 4
- Motoring Offences (Sentencing Guidelines) Questions · 4
- Offending (Young People) Questions · 4
- Sectarianism Questions · 8
- Bail Questions · 6
- Criminal History System (Replacement Project) Questions · 6
- Youth Courts Questions · 7
- Criminal History System (Replacement Project) Questions · 4
- Retraining Questions · 4
- Student Loans (Repayment) Questions · 5
- Scottish Enterprise (Employee Relations) Questions · 7
- Enterprise (Inverclyde) Questions · 10
- State Aid (Reform) Questions · 8
- Transport (Fife) Questions · 8
- Community Enterprises Questions · 4
- Supporting Local Producers Members’ business · 27
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.