To ask the Scottish Executive when it will announce the content of its revised planning guidance on opencast mining. (S2O-6399)
Official Report · Chamber
Opencast Mining
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Finance and Public Services and Communities
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Karen Gillon Lab 2
- Adam Ingram SNP 1
- Patrick Harvie Green 1
- Mary Mulligan Lab 1
The record
10 contributionsThe Executive currently plans to issue finalised guidance in June.
The minister will be aware that the revised guidance will come too late for three applications in my constituency. Will she investigate whether those applications can be considered in relation to the criteria that are set out in the new guidance, which relate to environmental impact, employment and community benefit? Will she consider the applications in that light?
It is not possible for me to comment on the applications to which the member referred because they have been notified to the Executive under the current rules and regulations. However, it should be clear that councils must take account of all relevant material considerations, such as the policies in development plans, national planning guidance and the views of statutory consultees and the public. We are already in a position in which there must be recognition of the environmental consequences of a development, but we must establish whether there is community benefit.
Will the minister confirm that the Executive will not bow to the scaremongering campaign of opencast companies about the introduction of a general presumption against opencasting and a fixing of minimum separation distances between opencast sites and communities that would be affected by them? In addition, will she commit to funding research into the long-term health impacts on communities of airborne particulate matter from opencast sites, given that the independent review of national planning policy guideline 16, which was commissioned by the Executive, recommended just that?
On the question about revised Scottish planning policy guideline 16, and the presumption against opencast mining in particular, there has been some misrepresentation and lack of understanding of the changes. It is understandable that we still recognise the economic benefits and local job opportunities that come with opencast coal mining, but we also recognise that there might be consequences for communities from developments and their cumulative impact.
A major shift has not been proposed; I clarify that there is no presumption against opencast coal mining in toto, but against proposals that are not environmentally acceptable or which would not provide local benefits. I hope that all concerned on both sides recognise that we seek to strike a balance and that even when the proposal is finalised, it will be open to regular scrutiny and review and we will be aware of the consequences for both sides.
I note what the member said about health issues; we are always open in respect of the health consequences to communities of any developments and I will ensure that that is kept on the agenda.
A major shift has not been proposed; I clarify that there is no presumption against opencast coal mining in toto, but against proposals that are not environmentally acceptable or which would not provide local benefits. I hope that all concerned on both sides recognise that we seek to strike a balance and that even when the proposal is finalised, it will be open to regular scrutiny and review and we will be aware of the consequences for both sides.
I note what the member said about health issues; we are always open in respect of the health consequences to communities of any developments and I will ensure that that is kept on the agenda.
link
The minister will be aware that opencast mining is precisely the kind of development that creates deep resentment because of the unfairness that is built into the appeals stage of the planning process, which is why such an overwhelming majority of consultees supported the third-party right of appeal. Does the minister accept that widening of appeal rights will be necessary if the Executive is to take what its advisers have called
"a once in a generation opportunity to effect radical change of the planning system in Scotland."?
If the minister cannot accept that, will she tell us when the Executive expects to reach a view on this matter of environmental justice?
"a once in a generation opportunity to effect radical change of the planning system in Scotland."?
If the minister cannot accept that, will she tell us when the Executive expects to reach a view on this matter of environmental justice?
It is true that some people are frustrated about the opencast coal industry and that some people in the industry are frustrated by some organisations' bad practice in working with communities. It is my view that where there has not been appropriate consultation, and where people have not lived up to the conditions to which they committed themselves, frustration has been created that is sometimes captured in the idea of extending the right of appeal.
The Executive remains committed to maintaining a balance between increasing inclusion of communities in the planning process in order to build confidence, and speeding up the planning process so that it gets to grips with some of the beneficial developments in our communities.
The Executive remains committed to maintaining a balance between increasing inclusion of communities in the planning process in order to build confidence, and speeding up the planning process so that it gets to grips with some of the beneficial developments in our communities.
I am pleased to hear that an announcement will be made in June, but will the minister reassure me and people in communities such as Fauldhouse and Blackridge in my constituency that after the guidance is issued, more emphasis will be given to monitoring planning permission for opencast mining as well as to enforcing any planning conditions that are set?
I commend the people in the industry who have already voluntarily developed compliance projects, who have worked with communities and who have committed themselves to working with them. I am sure that people in the industry who are committed to its success want to separate themselves from some of the more unacceptable practices of the past.
I agree with the member about compliance. It is generally true of planning that people have faith in a system if the conditions that are imposed are seen to be enforced and monitoring is done properly. That is clearly recognised across the board and the Executive is committed to it.
I agree with the member about compliance. It is generally true of planning that people have faith in a system if the conditions that are imposed are seen to be enforced and monitoring is done properly. That is clearly recognised across the board and the Executive is committed to it.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 Apr 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 21 April 2005 Debate · 1
- Business Motion Business motions · 7
- Dental Health Services Debate · 88
- Concessionary Travel (Pensioners and Disabled People) Questions · 6
- Antisocial Behaviour (Aberdeen) Questions · 5
- Community Recycling Questions · 4
- Inverness College Questions · 8
- Zero Waste Questions · 4
- Economy (Families) Questions · 7
- Health Care-acquired Infections Questions · 4
- BBC Scotland (Job Losses) Questions · 4
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- National Health Service (Entrepreneurial Spirit) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- NHS Argyll and Clyde First Minister’s Questions · 10
- G8 Summit (Impact on Edinburgh) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Barnett Formula First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Mainstreaming Questions · 9
- After-school Activities Questions · 6
- Tourism (Independent Retail Sector) Questions · 7
- Teachers Questions · 8
- Pupil Attainment Questions · 6
- Community Schools Questions · 4
- Fresh Talent Initiative Questions · 6
- Pensioner Poverty Questions · 8
- Housing (Dundee) Questions · 4
- Lennoxtown Initiative Questions · 6
- Opencast Mining Questions · 10
- Tenant Rights (Private Sector) Questions · 4
- Gaelic Language (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 119
- Gaelic Language (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 26
- Point of Order Procedure · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 6
- Scotch Whisky (Protected Geographical Indicator) Members’ business · 28
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.