To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Executive is aware of any plans to review the operation of the Barnett formula. (S2F-1592)
Official Report · Chamber
Barnett Formula
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- George Reid 4
- Jack McConnell Lab 3
- Margo MacDonald Ind 3
- George Lyon LD 2
- Jim Mather SNP 1
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 1
The record
16 contributionsWe are not aware of any such plans.
I wonder whether the First Minister is thinking what Liberal Democrat members are thinking—that the only thing that a Tory Government at Westminster would deliver for Scotland would be massive cuts to front-line public services. Does the First Minister have any information on why the Scottish National Party has failed to publish detailed costings of its spending plans? Could it be that it is trying to cover up a financial black hole in the plans? Does he welcome the fact that a Liberal Democrat Government at Westminster will deliver not cuts or financial black holes, but an additional £1.8 billion for the Executive to invest in public services?
I am sure that George Lyon and the Liberal Democrats as a whole will be happy to outline their plans to the good voters of Edinburgh, Aberdeen and elsewhere, and that they will also spell out the tax increases that will pay for them. However, at least those plans are accurately thought out, unlike the nonsense that we have heard over recent weeks from the two main Opposition parties in the Parliament. On 20 January, we had a clear promise from the Conservatives that they would publish their plans for savings in the Scottish budget in advance of the Scottish election, but just a few weeks later we had a clear promise that they would not. The Scottish Conservatives have hidden, secret plans for cuts in the Scottish budget that we have yet to see.
However, at least the Conservatives have some plans, unlike the Scottish nationalist party, which cannot even add up what it will spend, never mind what it will save. It is about time that the Scottish National Party published not only the savings that Alex Salmond promised this week, but the costings of all the many promises that are included in its manifesto.
However, at least the Conservatives have some plans, unlike the Scottish nationalist party, which cannot even add up what it will spend, never mind what it will save. It is about time that the Scottish National Party published not only the savings that Alex Salmond promised this week, but the costings of all the many promises that are included in its manifesto.
We will give the First Minister a chance to do some arithmetic of his own. To what extent will the forecast by the United Kingdom Government Actuary's Department that the Scottish population will decline to 3.6 million by 2073 and our having the lowest life expectancy of the 24 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development countries force changes to the Executive's revenue-generating strategies and other Government policies?
On a point of order, Presiding Officer.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Let me get the First Minister's answer out of the way, then I will come to you.
I should live so long.
I was waiting for Mr Mather to get to the point. There has been a bit of talk in the chamber today about people publishing information that they have. Mr Mather published a document on Tuesday, but he did not publish the introductory comment that he was given by those in the Government Actuary's Department who provided him with that document. That comment said:
"the long-term figures should be treated with great caution. Population projections become increasingly uncertain the further they are carried forward, and particularly so for smaller geographic areas."
Mr Mather did it last week and he is doing it again—he is running Scotland down and saying that it is not the kind of country that people want to come to. He described our country as being in recession three years ago when it was not. He described our population as decreasing when it is not. He described young people disappearing and running out of Scotland when they do not and when we have higher net in-migration than out-migration. When will the SNP stand up for Scotland, stand up for our country and promote its many attributes and its great future? [Interruption.] When will it do that for Scotland and stop running Scotland down?
"the long-term figures should be treated with great caution. Population projections become increasingly uncertain the further they are carried forward, and particularly so for smaller geographic areas."
Mr Mather did it last week and he is doing it again—he is running Scotland down and saying that it is not the kind of country that people want to come to. He described our country as being in recession three years ago when it was not. He described our population as decreasing when it is not. He described young people disappearing and running out of Scotland when they do not and when we have higher net in-migration than out-migration. When will the SNP stand up for Scotland, stand up for our country and promote its many attributes and its great future? [Interruption.] When will it do that for Scotland and stop running Scotland down?
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Ms MacDonald, you are still with us.
If I wanted to go to a pantomime, I would book in at the King's.
I think that we might have transgressed our own rules in the previous question. As I recall, the question referred to the Barnett formula. By the time we got to Mr Mather, even though what he contributed might have been interesting, it was not relevant.
I think that we might have transgressed our own rules in the previous question. As I recall, the question referred to the Barnett formula. By the time we got to Mr Mather, even though what he contributed might have been interesting, it was not relevant.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
That is hardly the point. I judged it to be relevant—just.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. Although I am sure that you are aware of this, I tell the chamber that the Barnett formula is based on population.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Indeed, that is why I judged the question to be relevant.
Meeting suspended until 14:15.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 21 Apr 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 21 April 2005 Debate · 1
- Business Motion Business motions · 7
- Dental Health Services Debate · 88
- Concessionary Travel (Pensioners and Disabled People) Questions · 6
- Antisocial Behaviour (Aberdeen) Questions · 5
- Community Recycling Questions · 4
- Inverness College Questions · 8
- Zero Waste Questions · 4
- Economy (Families) Questions · 7
- Health Care-acquired Infections Questions · 4
- BBC Scotland (Job Losses) Questions · 4
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- National Health Service (Entrepreneurial Spirit) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- NHS Argyll and Clyde First Minister’s Questions · 10
- G8 Summit (Impact on Edinburgh) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Barnett Formula First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Mainstreaming Questions · 9
- After-school Activities Questions · 6
- Tourism (Independent Retail Sector) Questions · 7
- Teachers Questions · 8
- Pupil Attainment Questions · 6
- Community Schools Questions · 4
- Fresh Talent Initiative Questions · 6
- Pensioner Poverty Questions · 8
- Housing (Dundee) Questions · 4
- Lennoxtown Initiative Questions · 6
- Opencast Mining Questions · 10
- Tenant Rights (Private Sector) Questions · 4
- Gaelic Language (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 119
- Gaelic Language (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 26
- Point of Order Procedure · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 6
- Scotch Whisky (Protected Geographical Indicator) Members’ business · 28
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.