Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Barker Review

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 25 March 2004 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 16 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

16 contributions
Murray Tosh Con The Deputy Presiding Officer · West of Scotland
link
To ask the First Minister what steps the Scottish Executive will take to analyse the implications for Scotland of the Barker review's final report on housing supply and implement any necessary action. (S2F-764)

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
We will be looking carefully at those recommendations that affect devolved responsibilities in parallel with our own review of affordable housing.

Murray Tosh Con The Deputy Presiding Officer · West of Scotland
link
The First Minister will be aware of the recent survey that showed that emergent households—mainly the young people whom we so strongly wish to attract and retain—are unable to afford housing in a substantial number of housing markets in Scotland. Indeed, he will know about people queuing up for days to snap up houses in new developments as soon as they go on sale. Does the First Minister accept the Barker analysis that that situation is fundamentally a matter of market failure, that we need better planning guidance and more up-to-date local plans, that we need to identify more land to stabilise house prices and that we need more affordable housing to encourage labour mobility and promote social inclusion?

Members
link
Question.

Murray Tosh Con The Deputy Presiding Officer · West of Scotland
link
It is clearly a question, Presiding Officer.

Murray Tosh Con The Deputy Presiding Officer · West of Scotland
link
Given that we are at least a year away from the planning bill, will the First Minister take that time to commission a review to analyse those issues for the benefit of Scotland and to ensure that his planning bill will deliver a policy and legal framework that is equal to the task of meeting the demands of young households in Scotland?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
I welcome the emerging consensus in the Parliament about the need for affordable housing and I welcome Mr Tosh's support for the review on affordable housing that is already under way, which we hope will report by the summer. Today, Margaret Curran is announcing resources that will be held back to support that review, in addition to the overall 7 per cent increase in the budget for investment in affordable housing throughout Scotland, which includes a 10 per cent increase in the budget for affordable housing projects in the coming year in rural Scotland, where there is a particular problem.

We are investing immediately and, next week, we will announce proposals to improve the planning regime in Scotland. Although we are encouraging further developments and the availability of land throughout Scotland, we also have that review in place. When it reports, we hope that it will produce further recommendations that will ensure the availability of more land and more housing both to rent and to buy, because young families in Scotland have that aspiration and we want to ensure that they can meet it in urban and rural Scotland.

link
With rising house prices outstripping salaries by four to one, 50,000 people faced with homelessness, 200,000 people on council waiting lists and 250,000 dwellings lost because of the right to buy, will the First Minister accept that there is a housing crisis in Scotland at the affordable end of the market? Given that the Barker review was a review of UK housing, will he address directly the recommendations of that review and wrap them into the current review, which he says that the Scottish Executive is conducting?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
I am surprised that the Scottish nationalists want us to implement in Scotland the recommendations of a review that was, in essence, about the English housing market. The purpose of devolution was that we in Scotland could make our own decisions, conduct our own reviews and have the policies that are appropriate for Scotland.

The key difference between the housing markets in England and in Scotland is that, in England, the number of houses being built is outstripped by the demand for those houses whereas, in Scotland, the number of houses being built is greater than the increase in demand. That should not stop us from dealing with the issues of affordable housing because we want to see people moving to Scotland to work and live here.

We know that we have a particular challenge to meet in our rural communities. That is why we are to have our own review and why we will not just accept the findings of a review that is largely about the English housing market. We will also ensure that extra resources are made available. That is why Margaret Curran will announce today a 10 per cent increase in the resources that are to be made available for affordable housing in rural communities. That is a good development and even the nationalists might welcome it.

Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow Kelvin
link
I welcome whole-heartedly the approach of the First Minister and the Scottish Executive to affordable housing. I want to highlight a situation in my constituency of Glasgow Kelvin where an impressive development of 2,500 private houses is to be built. Out of that total, however, not a single house will be in the social rented sector.

I hope that the First Minister will agree that the need for affordable housing is not just a problem for first-time buyers and that we need a supply of social rented housing. In any review of affordable housing, would he consider placing a duty on those responsible for housing strategies and housing development to ensure that a quota of affordable housing and social rented housing is included in any new development that is built in urban and rural Scotland?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
Those issues will be addressed in the review and in the consultation on planning that we intend to launch before the Easter recess. In many ways, the issues are being addressed currently in Glasgow with the substantial investment—hundreds of millions of pounds—that will result from the Glasgow housing stock transfer. Glasgow City Council will no longer control people's tenancies; people will control their tenancies themselves through their housing associations.

The process will be assisted by our announcement last Saturday of a co-operative development agency for Scotland. The agency will assist people in Scotland to have more control over their lives. The announcement is one that will meet with dismay on the part of the Trotskyists and the nationalists in the chamber, both of which groups oppose housing stock transfer and do not want the investment of hundreds of millions of pounds to take place in Glasgow. The people of Glasgow want to see that investment and we will deliver it.

Colin Fox SSP Lothians
link
Given that tens of thousands of Scottish families are effectively denied access to the housing market because of the astronomical price of housing, is not the figure of 51 council houses, which is the latest figure for the total number of council houses built across Scotland, the clearest possible signal from the First Minister and the Executive that they have given up on affordable social housing in their smart, successful Scotland?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
I am sorry, but we have moved on. In Scotland today, there are many young families who can afford to and want to own their own homes and not just rent them. That is a legitimate choice. I know that it is one to which Colin Fox's party is ideologically opposed, but it is a legitimate choice for families to want to make.

Also, and much more important for the future strength of our communities in Scotland, we want those families who choose to rent, or who have to rent because they cannot afford to buy, to have more control over their housing. That is why we no longer build so many houses for councils to rent. People have more control over their homes and their lives through housing associations, which give them more say and more ownership over the houses and streets in which they live. That is an important social development. I realise that Colin Fox's party is opposed to that, but I think that it is far more in line with the socialist principles that the Labour Party adheres to than his policy is.

Donald Gorrie LD Central Scotland
link
Will the First Minister ensure that the planning system requires that any large development must include a substantial amount of social housing for sale and for rent as well as the commercially priced houses?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
I believe that there are important issues in the planning system in relation to not only the availability of land for housing but the use to which that land is put, the decisions that are made and the approvals that are given in order to guarantee the availability of affordable housing, either to rent or to buy, for local families. The planning consultation that we are about to launch will address that issue in some respects and I am sure that other issues will be addressed in the course of the months ahead.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 25 March 2004 Debate · 1
  2. Zero Waste Debate · 55
  3. Genetically Modified Crops Debate · 103
  4. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  5. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  6. Genetically Modified Maize (Commercialisation) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  7. Scottish Water (Status) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  8. Barker Review First Minister’s Questions · 16
  9. Sustainable Development (Convention of the Highlands and Islands) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  10. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  11. Environmental Court Questions · 4
  12. Angling (Research Findings) Questions · 4
  13. Chardon LL Maize (Cultivation and Use) Questions · 6
  14. Polluted Beaches (Assistance to Local Authorities) Questions · 4
  15. Scottish Water (Efficiencies) Questions · 6
  16. Recycled Materials (Markets) Questions · 6
  17. Shellfish (Polluted Beaches) Questions · 6
  18. Aucheninnes Landfill Site Questions · 4
  19. Health Inequalities Questions · 4
  20. Health Inequalities Questions · 8
  21. Dental Services Questions · 4
  22. Human Tissue (Legislative Plans) Questions · 4
  23. General Practitioner and Consultant Contracts Questions · 8
  24. Under-age Drinking (Highlands) Questions · 4
  25. District Courts (West of Scotland) Questions · 4
  26. Aberdeen City Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
  27. Secure Accommodation Questions · 9
  28. Craft Industries (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 8
  29. Association of Scottish Prisoners Questions · 8
  30. Modern Apprentices Questions · 13
  31. Rural Schools (Support) Questions · 7
  32. Summary Justice Debate · 38
  33. Business Motion Business motions · 4
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 39
  35. School Closures (Borders) Members’ business · 41

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.