Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Genetically Modified Maize (Commercialisation)

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 25 March 2004 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 6 contributions · 2 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

6 contributions
Robin Harper Green Lothians
link
To ask the First Minister what discussions the Scottish Executive has had with Her Majesty's Government and the Welsh Assembly about the commercialisation of genetically modified maize. (S2F-780)

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
Mr Harper will not be surprised to learn that we have had a number of discussions between receipt of the scientific advice and the announcement earlier this month.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link
The Greens have obtained a preliminary legal opinion that says that the Executive has not, in the words of its partnership agreement, "rigorously" applied "the precautionary principle". In fact, we have identified three separate grounds on which the Executive could have been entitled to refuse to allow GM maize on to the seed list but apparently chose not to.

GM maize is not satisfactory for cultivation on the basis of the precautionary principle and on the ground that no independent advice was sought to ensure the avoidance of adverse effects on human health and the environment. Is it not the case that the First Minister has wide discretion in this matter, that the evidence exists that would allow him to use that discretion and that it was lack of political will that held him back? If that is not the case, can the First Minister tell me why, despite the Liberal Democrats' policy, the partnership Government has not used its full powers to oppose GM? Is it because the First Minister does not want to do so?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
The partnership has a united position on the issue. Not only do we accept the precautionary principle, we work carefully with the scientific advice and, of course, we use our position inside the collective decision making of the United Kingdom Government and the devolved Governments to ensure that decisions are in line with policy. That is exactly what we have done in this case. If I were Mr Harper, I would have been embarrassed to publish this morning my legal advice, which says that its own position is "arguable". Any legal opinion is arguable; the law and the legal system in this country are about arguing different positions. However, that is not the point here.

We cannot just accept scientific advice when everybody might want us to agree with it from a predetermined position. If we get independent scientific advice and there is a legal framework throughout the European Union and inside this country that we should stick to, we must go with that. At the same time, we push inside the United Kingdom, and we are determined here in Scotland, to be as precautionary as possible because, currently, there is no public demand, no public requirement and no public desire for GM crops to be grown in Scotland. That is what we are setting out to try to achieve.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link
The First Minister mentioned devolved Governments. He will be aware that the National Assembly for Wales minister Carwyn Jones agreed yesterday that he will not allow GM maize to go on to the UK seed list without the authorisation of the National Assembly for Wales. If the Green party motion that is to be voted on at 5 o' clock is agreed to by Parliament, it would allow the Scottish Parliament the same freedom to decide on whether GM maize should go ahead. Will the First Minister allow the Scottish Parliament to have the same freedom on GM maize as the National Assembly for Wales has?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
The Scottish Parliament has exactly the same freedom as the National Assembly for Wales to have votes in the chamber. We had one last Thursday and the Executive's position was supported.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 25 March 2004 Debate · 1
  2. Zero Waste Debate · 55
  3. Genetically Modified Crops Debate · 103
  4. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  5. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  6. Genetically Modified Maize (Commercialisation) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  7. Scottish Water (Status) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  8. Barker Review First Minister’s Questions · 16
  9. Sustainable Development (Convention of the Highlands and Islands) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  10. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  11. Environmental Court Questions · 4
  12. Angling (Research Findings) Questions · 4
  13. Chardon LL Maize (Cultivation and Use) Questions · 6
  14. Polluted Beaches (Assistance to Local Authorities) Questions · 4
  15. Scottish Water (Efficiencies) Questions · 6
  16. Recycled Materials (Markets) Questions · 6
  17. Shellfish (Polluted Beaches) Questions · 6
  18. Aucheninnes Landfill Site Questions · 4
  19. Health Inequalities Questions · 4
  20. Health Inequalities Questions · 8
  21. Dental Services Questions · 4
  22. Human Tissue (Legislative Plans) Questions · 4
  23. General Practitioner and Consultant Contracts Questions · 8
  24. Under-age Drinking (Highlands) Questions · 4
  25. District Courts (West of Scotland) Questions · 4
  26. Aberdeen City Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
  27. Secure Accommodation Questions · 9
  28. Craft Industries (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 8
  29. Association of Scottish Prisoners Questions · 8
  30. Modern Apprentices Questions · 13
  31. Rural Schools (Support) Questions · 7
  32. Summary Justice Debate · 38
  33. Business Motion Business motions · 4
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 39
  35. School Closures (Borders) Members’ business · 41

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.