To ask the Scottish Executive whether, following the Minister for Transport's recent visit, there will be a public inquiry into the proposals for the upgrade of the A80. (S2O-1478)
Official Report · Chamber
A80 (Upgrade)
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicol Stephen LD 5
- Donald Gorrie LD 2
- Cathie Craigie Lab 1
- Alex Neil SNP 1
- Margaret Mitchell Con 1
The record
10 contributionsNo decision has yet been taken, but it would be unusual for a scheme of this scale and importance to proceed without a public local inquiry.
The minister's statement is welcome, as was his visit. I am sure that the local people will appreciate the time and interest that he has shown. Would he agree that, particularly in this case, in which there are strong feelings about the two alternative routes for the road—there are strong arguments for and against in each case—a proper inquiry at which all the arguments may be tested would be the best way forward?
If an objector wishes to put forward, and justify, any alternative route, the reporter, assuming that there is an inquiry—as I have said, a decision on that has yet to be taken formally—would be duty-bound to consider it and report back to me as Minister for Transport. We are now some way through the consultation on the first phase of development. There will be three phases of development under the terms of the current proposals. The detailed proposals for stages 2 and 3 will be published later this year. In my view, if a public local inquiry were required, it would be sensible to hold it in relation to the three phases of the scheme.
I welcome the minister's response. He will be aware that there has been uncertainty surrounding the A80 in my constituency for 30 years. I do not suppose that he will have had personal experience of that for many of those years, but the people of Cumbernauld and Kilsyth have been suffering chronic congestion daily. Will he do everything in his power to ensure that the road orders for the next phases of development are published as soon as possible, and that a public local inquiry will examine the three phases along the stretch of the road between Stepps and Haggs?
I am very pleased that work at the Auchenkilns roundabout is now under way. We are spending more than £20 million on introducing a grade-separated junction there, which will improve the situation. However, I believe that the full scheme is required—virtually everyone in the community recognises that some change is urgently required.
I have not had to suffer the daily inconvenience and disruption that are caused by the congestion on the A80. However, I have sat in traffic there for two hours on a journey from Aberdeen to Glasgow, and I know of some of the serious congestion that has occurred in recent weeks, so I realise how topical the subject is. That is why I am very pleased that we are committed to the scheme, that funding has been set aside for it and that we will be investing tens of millions of pounds over the coming years in making a very major improvement.
I have not had to suffer the daily inconvenience and disruption that are caused by the congestion on the A80. However, I have sat in traffic there for two hours on a journey from Aberdeen to Glasgow, and I know of some of the serious congestion that has occurred in recent weeks, so I realise how topical the subject is. That is why I am very pleased that we are committed to the scheme, that funding has been set aside for it and that we will be investing tens of millions of pounds over the coming years in making a very major improvement.
Has the minister ruled out a general public inquiry? If so, will any public inquiry be a local public inquiry? How wide would a local public inquiry's remit be?
The inquiry will be a public local inquiry. I hesitate to describe, off the cuff and in the Parliament, the remit of that public local inquiry, but it will be the normal public local inquiry permitted, to which the normal procedure for major trunk road schemes applies. I give Alex Neil the assurance that I gave Donald Gorrie: any objector has the opportunity to put forward the case for any alternative proposal.
Will the minister confirm that any inquiry will include a full appraisal of both the costs and the benefits of the A80 upgrade and of the Kelvin valley route for the new motorway? Will it include a comparison between the economic and environmental impacts of both options?
The costs and benefits of the proposals will be part of the evidence that is put in front of the public local inquiry—that is only appropriate. I have visited the alternative route and looked at the proposals in that regard, but I should make it clear that the evidence that the Scottish Executive brings forward will be in relation to the scheme that it favours. That is normal; it would be extremely unusual for the Scottish Executive to come forward with multiple proposals or to give evidence on a multiplicity of schemes.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Mar 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 11 March 2004 Debate · 1
- Pensioner Poverty Debate · 34
- Winter Cold-related Deaths Debate · 17
- Council Tax Debate · 55
- Nursery Nurses Debate · 45
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Genetically Modified Maize First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Racially Motivated Attacks First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Budget First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Higher Education (Review) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Points of Order Procedure · 10
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- A80 (Upgrade) Questions · 10
- Higher Education (Investment) Questions · 4
- Congestion Questions · 6
- Bottled Water Industry Questions · 6
- Marine Energy (Employment) Questions · 8
- Borders Railway Questions · 6
- Trials in Absence of Accused Questions · 6
- Off-licences Questions · 8
- Corporate Homicide Questions · 6
- Clementi Review Questions · 4
- Offenders (Employability) Questions · 4
- Crime Victims Questions · 9
- Off-licences Questions · 4
- Diabetes Questions · 8
- Single Farm Payment Scheme Questions · 4
- Physical Education (Primary Schools) Questions · 10
- Recycling Questions · 7
- Child Protection Questions · 4
- Agricultural Produce (Promotion) Questions · 4
- Ministerial Group on Tourism Statement · 31
- Historic Environment Debate · 34
- Decision Time Decision time · 75
- Maternity Services (Caithness) Members’ business · 35
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.