To ask the First Minister how the Scottish Executive intends to respond to the issues raised in the report by Professor Arthur Midwinter and the Scottish Parliament information centre, "Key Trends in the Scottish Budget 1999-2003". (S2F-713)
Official Report · Chamber
Budget
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 3
- Shona Robison SNP 2
- Jim Mather SNP 1
The record
6 contributionsProfessor Midwinter says that his report is
"a background paper with limited information at the beginning of a comprehensive budget review exercise rather than a fully developed assessment of recent performance".
However, I found his report very interesting.
"a background paper with limited information at the beginning of a comprehensive budget review exercise rather than a fully developed assessment of recent performance".
However, I found his report very interesting.
So did I.
Did the First Minister note Professor Midwinter's comments on health? Is the First Minister satisfied with the Scottish Executive's stewardship of the NHS when, according to Professor Midwinter, the NHS received 15 per cent extra funding between 1999 and 2003, yet it gained only a 5.3 per cent increase in staffing? Does the First Minister believe that that represents good value for money, given that we have more people waiting for treatment and fewer people being treated in the NHS and that we therefore desperately require more staff to tackle those problems?
Did the First Minister note Professor Midwinter's comments on health? Is the First Minister satisfied with the Scottish Executive's stewardship of the NHS when, according to Professor Midwinter, the NHS received 15 per cent extra funding between 1999 and 2003, yet it gained only a 5.3 per cent increase in staffing? Does the First Minister believe that that represents good value for money, given that we have more people waiting for treatment and fewer people being treated in the NHS and that we therefore desperately require more staff to tackle those problems?
That is the third different position that the SNP has taken on the subject in the past week.
Consistently during the past year, we have heard perfectly understandable calls from the Scottish nationalist party for increased wages in the national health service for nurses, doctors, consultants, allied health professionals and everybody who works in the health service. Then we heard from Fergus Ewing last Sunday, after the publication of Professor Midwinter's report, that the SNP's finance spokesperson thinks that the way in which the Executive puts together its budget, together with a point that Professor Midwinter made about increased wage costs in the public sector in Scotland, shows that we are spending money on the wrong things. The SNP's finance spokesperson does not agree with the calls for increased wages.
Today, we hear from the health spokesperson that we should not be spending in the way that we are in the health service. The situation is getting absolutely ridiculous. I do not mind if the SNP calls consistently for increased spending and justifies that by advocating increased taxes. However, doing that at the same time as calling for increased spending and lower taxes—or saying, as the finance spokesperson did, that he is in favour of cutting public sector budgets rather than using the tax-and-spend approach, as detailed in Holyrood magazine yesterday—throws the whole SNP policy into tatters. The SNP needs to review its policy.
Consistently during the past year, we have heard perfectly understandable calls from the Scottish nationalist party for increased wages in the national health service for nurses, doctors, consultants, allied health professionals and everybody who works in the health service. Then we heard from Fergus Ewing last Sunday, after the publication of Professor Midwinter's report, that the SNP's finance spokesperson thinks that the way in which the Executive puts together its budget, together with a point that Professor Midwinter made about increased wage costs in the public sector in Scotland, shows that we are spending money on the wrong things. The SNP's finance spokesperson does not agree with the calls for increased wages.
Today, we hear from the health spokesperson that we should not be spending in the way that we are in the health service. The situation is getting absolutely ridiculous. I do not mind if the SNP calls consistently for increased spending and justifies that by advocating increased taxes. However, doing that at the same time as calling for increased spending and lower taxes—or saying, as the finance spokesperson did, that he is in favour of cutting public sector budgets rather than using the tax-and-spend approach, as detailed in Holyrood magazine yesterday—throws the whole SNP policy into tatters. The SNP needs to review its policy.
Will the First Minister consider augmenting future versions of Professor Midwinter's report by adding comprehensive reporting of outcomes for all public functions—for example, clear statements of measurable and tangible public good that has been achieved from Government spending, as suggested by Nicholas Crafts of the London School of Economics in his exceedingly well-received lecture this week?
I am keen that we are not only clear about what we want to spend money on, but that we measure how effective that spending is and we will continue to do that.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Mar 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 11 March 2004 Debate · 1
- Pensioner Poverty Debate · 34
- Winter Cold-related Deaths Debate · 17
- Council Tax Debate · 55
- Nursery Nurses Debate · 45
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Genetically Modified Maize First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Racially Motivated Attacks First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Budget First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Higher Education (Review) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Points of Order Procedure · 10
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- A80 (Upgrade) Questions · 10
- Higher Education (Investment) Questions · 4
- Congestion Questions · 6
- Bottled Water Industry Questions · 6
- Marine Energy (Employment) Questions · 8
- Borders Railway Questions · 6
- Trials in Absence of Accused Questions · 6
- Off-licences Questions · 8
- Corporate Homicide Questions · 6
- Clementi Review Questions · 4
- Offenders (Employability) Questions · 4
- Crime Victims Questions · 9
- Off-licences Questions · 4
- Diabetes Questions · 8
- Single Farm Payment Scheme Questions · 4
- Physical Education (Primary Schools) Questions · 10
- Recycling Questions · 7
- Child Protection Questions · 4
- Agricultural Produce (Promotion) Questions · 4
- Ministerial Group on Tourism Statement · 31
- Historic Environment Debate · 34
- Decision Time Decision time · 75
- Maternity Services (Caithness) Members’ business · 35
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.