To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will support charitable status for all Scotland's schools. (S2O-865)
Official Report · Chamber
Schools (Charitable Status)
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Peter Peacock Lab 6
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 2
- Fiona Hyslop SNP 1
- Chris Ballance Green 1
- Dennis Canavan Ind 1
The record
12 contributionsAny body whose main purpose is the advancement of education and which provides a public benefit is able, and will continue to be able, to be considered for charitable status.
Can a clear statement be made about what Scottish schools should do to preserve that charitable status?
As Lord James and the chamber know, we are about to consult on changes to charity law generally with a view to legislating. At no point in that process will existing charities automatically lose their charitable status, provided that they meet the new definitions in the bill that we produce and that they can show clearly that a public benefit derives from their work. The regulator will deal with charitable status case by case.
Does the minister agree that it would be unforgivable if negotiations with private sector schools had delayed charity law reform? Will he confirm that he will consider affording charitable status not only to existing private sector schools, but to local authority-run school projects that are for the public benefit of local children and are funded by not-for-profit trusts?
I know that the SNP opposes our public-private partnership proposals, which will provide the single biggest investment ever in Scottish education. The SNP continues to try to create the illusion of an alternative from a spurious charitable route, to which Fiona Hyslop may have referred today.
Members
link
Spurious?
Yes, the suggestion is entirely spurious. What is important is the fact that we are about to review charity law. We will have broad definitions, and we will leave it to the regulator to determine qualification for charitable status case by case. That is the best way to proceed.
Would the minister care to give his Christmas message to employees of the construction company that was forced out of business by the collapse of the East Lothian schools PPP?
I know that I have the correct colour of beard for Christmas messages but, in all seriousness, I say that the situation is difficult and involves many legal complications. Action is under way in relation to the winding-up of that company, so it would be wrong for me to comment in detail. However, such situations are not unusual with any form of contract to build a school, whether under a public-private partnership or in the traditional way. In a past life, I was involved in situations in which companies had gone bust in the middle of building a school. The situation is complex to sort out, but that can be done.
Why should charitable status be given to institutions such as Fettes College, which practise social exclusion by charging fees of up to £19,000 a year to produce uncharitable people such as Tony Blair, who practises further social exclusion by proposing to charge students top-up fees of up to £3,000 a year?
As Dennis Canavan knows, the Executive has done more to tackle social exclusion than any Administration has and it will continue to do so. One feature of our new work on charities is clarity: public benefit must flow from a body that has charitable status. The regulator will test that public benefit case by case, and if it cannot be shown, a body will have difficulty in qualifying for charitable status.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Dec 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 4 December 2003 Debate · 1
- Scottish Parliament (Financial Powers) Debate · 151
- European Parliament (Number of Seats) Members’ business · 28
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Obesity First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Commonwealth Games First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Free Bus Travel (Strathclyde) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Holyrood Inquiry First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Hydro Subsidies Questions · 6
- Destitution Questions · 5
- Schools (Charitable Status) Questions · 12
- Trunk Road Maintenance Questions · 7
- Asset Seizure (Drug Dealers) Questions · 18
- Older People (Financial Security) Questions · 4
- Rented Housing Questions · 12
- Strategic Rail Authority (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Congestion Charging Questions · 6
- Scottish Ambulance Service (Prioritisation of Calls) Questions · 4
- Transportation of Patients (Charging) Questions · 6
- Hydro Schemes Questions · 6
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Bathing Water Quality Debate · 75
- Business Motion Business motions · 9
- Decision Time Decision time · 59
- Unity Enterprise (Glasgow Airport) Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.