To ask the First Minister what the Scottish Executive's position is in response to the programme "Stop Chewin' the Fat" and recent reports that Scottish children are among the most obese in the developed world. (S2F-415)
Official Report · Chamber
Obesity
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 5
- Tommy Sheridan SSP 3
- Sarah Boyack Lab 1
- Shona Robison SNP 1
The record
10 contributionsThe latest figures on childhood obesity confirm what we already knew—that health improvement must be a long-term consistent priority for Scotland. Childhood obesity has significant implications for the future health of Scots and for our health services, but we will not tackle the problem overnight. It will take at least a generation of concerted action to turn round the eating and exercise habits of our nation. Flagship programmes in our school classrooms and playgrounds—such as hungry for success and active schools—demonstrate our commitment to improving the situation for Scotland's children.
After four and a half years of the Labour-Liberal Government in Scotland, and two years of the First Minister being in charge, one in five 12-year-olds is defined as being clinically obese. In June, the First Minister rejected the advice of the British Medical Association, One Plus, the Child Poverty Action Group and a range of trade union organisations, which argued that we require a radical solution; namely, free healthy and nutritious school meals. Will he now display the level of courage and political maturity that is required to admit that he was wrong, that we need a step change now, and that every child in Scotland should be guaranteed a healthy and nutritious school meal to tackle the problem?
I am determined to ensure that our schools and councils deliver healthy and nutritious meals for Scotland's school children. That is exactly why we are spending the money that Mr Sheridan would like to spend on the best-off and richest children on improving the quality of school meals, availability of school meals and take-up of school meals. Those priorities—getting nutritional quality right and improving take-up—are exactly the right ones for Scotland, but we must also ensure that children take more exercise and that they are fed better outside their classrooms. More than 100,000 Scottish school children are going to benefit by the end of this year from our free fruit in schools programme. That is the sort of initiative that will make a difference, unlike the tokenism of Mr Sheridan, who wants to benefit the rich but not to help the poor.
It is a bit contradictory to say that it is okay to give rich kids free fruit but not a free meal.
The programme to which I referred quoted 11 of the 12 food experts that were appointed by the First Minister's own food tsar. They said that free school meals would be required to tackle this problem. Why will the First Minister not listen to the experts? He will not listen to the British Medical Association, he will not listen to the trades union movement and he will not listen to the Child Poverty Action Group or to One Plus. Will he at least listen to the food experts who are advising him that free school meals are required to tackle this radical problem?
The programme to which I referred quoted 11 of the 12 food experts that were appointed by the First Minister's own food tsar. They said that free school meals would be required to tackle this problem. Why will the First Minister not listen to the experts? He will not listen to the British Medical Association, he will not listen to the trades union movement and he will not listen to the Child Poverty Action Group or to One Plus. Will he at least listen to the food experts who are advising him that free school meals are required to tackle this radical problem?
I am determined to listen to the evidence, but the programme that Tommy Sheridan quoted got the evidence wrong. One of the claims that it made was that the improvement in diet in Finland was down to the introduction of free school meals. Free school meals were introduced in Finland after the second world war to deal with starvation—not in the 1980s to deal with a poor health record. Finland rightly implemented national action, with all parties and people from all sectors of society working together to improve the diet, eating habits and exercise habits of the population. As a result, the health of the nation was dramatically improved. That is exactly what we are trying to do in Scotland. That is how we should concentrate our resources and that is what we will continue to do. We will back the evidence, back what works and back the international examples that show that Scotland is in shame at the moment, but which will ensure that it is a better place to live in the future.
Does the First Minister agree that, in looking at the evidence on child obesity, it is absolutely vital for the next generation that we do not focus exclusively on what food our young people are eating and which diet they are following? We have to look at physical activity in school and in getting to school. Does the First Minister agree that the historic low rate of children walking to school is a national disgrace? Does he also agree that it is vital that we do everything that we can—for example, the twenty's plenty initiative and encouragement of safer routes to school, as is being done by my local authority—to tackle the appalling rate of obesity among the next generation?
There is no doubt that more walking to school and more walking in our society would make a significant contribution to exercise habits, to our health and to the use of our health service. Initiatives such as twenty's plenty—which ensures that the introduction of 20mph speed limits round schools becomes uniform throughout Scotland—provide a significant opportunity, not just for greater safety around schools and greater walking opportunities. Other initiatives to encourage more youngsters and adults to walk more in Scotland are vital for the health of individuals and for the health of the country.
In the light of the shocking obesity levels in Scotland, does the First Minister now accept that, rather than spend money on setting up healthy-eating phone lines that no one calls, it would be more effective to remove unhealthy fatty foods and fizzy drinks from vending machines in our schools so that we stop giving our children contradictory and mixed messages about what it is healthy and unhealthy to eat?
We have to be more intelligent than that in our response to the situation. The reality in Scottish schools was that the number of children, who instead of eating or drinking in school, were leaving school to eat chocolate and drink rubbish further down the street increased dramatically for at least two decades. It is vital that we maintain in our schools initiatives to sell the right things and that we encourage children to eat and drink the right things, but we must also encourage children to stay in school so that they are not eating and drinking rubbish elsewhere.
The initiatives that have been put in place by the health improvement campaign—which Shona Robison and other members have criticised—take branding off vending machines, ensure that there are drinks other than fizzy drinks in every machine, ensure that water is available for our youngsters in schools throughout Scotland and ensure that they are encouraged to drink it. Those initiatives will make a difference; they will not drive kids back outside schools or encourage them to go to the local newsagent for their preferred alternative.
The initiatives that have been put in place by the health improvement campaign—which Shona Robison and other members have criticised—take branding off vending machines, ensure that there are drinks other than fizzy drinks in every machine, ensure that water is available for our youngsters in schools throughout Scotland and ensure that they are encouraged to drink it. Those initiatives will make a difference; they will not drive kids back outside schools or encourage them to go to the local newsagent for their preferred alternative.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Dec 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 4 December 2003 Debate · 1
- Scottish Parliament (Financial Powers) Debate · 151
- European Parliament (Number of Seats) Members’ business · 28
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Obesity First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Commonwealth Games First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Free Bus Travel (Strathclyde) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Holyrood Inquiry First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Hydro Subsidies Questions · 6
- Destitution Questions · 5
- Schools (Charitable Status) Questions · 12
- Trunk Road Maintenance Questions · 7
- Asset Seizure (Drug Dealers) Questions · 18
- Older People (Financial Security) Questions · 4
- Rented Housing Questions · 12
- Strategic Rail Authority (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Congestion Charging Questions · 6
- Scottish Ambulance Service (Prioritisation of Calls) Questions · 4
- Transportation of Patients (Charging) Questions · 6
- Hydro Schemes Questions · 6
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Bathing Water Quality Debate · 75
- Business Motion Business motions · 9
- Decision Time Decision time · 59
- Unity Enterprise (Glasgow Airport) Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.