To ask the Scottish Executive what progress has been made in ensuring that the same standard of care is available throughout Scotland for people with multiple sclerosis. (S2O-760)
Official Report · Chamber
Multiple Sclerosis
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 3
- Tricia Marwick SNP 2
- David Davidson Con 1
The record
6 contributionsWe are funding the development of a managed care network in Forth valley for people with multiple sclerosis. That work includes developing standards for services in primary care and in hospital that are endorsed by NHS Quality Improvement Scotland. We wish to see those MS networks developed throughout Scotland. The Executive is also pleased to support the risk-sharing scheme, which makes disease-modifying drugs available to patients who are assessed as suitable for treatment. I am glad to report significant progress with that initiative.
In October 2000, the Scottish needs assessment programme report referred to the facilities for people with MS in Scotland. The report stated:
"current care is substantially sub-optimal, inadequately resourced and unacceptably fragmented. … There is an urgent need to develop properly resourced services in MS care."
A recent survey indicated that three quarters of people with MS believed that their standard of care depended on where in Scotland they lived. The minister knows that the National Institute for Clinical Excellence will produce guidelines for England and Wales that will set a national standard for care. Will he give a commitment today that a national standard of care will be developed for people with MS in Scotland?
"current care is substantially sub-optimal, inadequately resourced and unacceptably fragmented. … There is an urgent need to develop properly resourced services in MS care."
A recent survey indicated that three quarters of people with MS believed that their standard of care depended on where in Scotland they lived. The minister knows that the National Institute for Clinical Excellence will produce guidelines for England and Wales that will set a national standard for care. Will he give a commitment today that a national standard of care will be developed for people with MS in Scotland?
There has been some misunderstanding of the NICE guidelines. They are guidelines and are not mandatory in England. They can be used by the managed clinical networks that we want to see develop in Scotland, and I hope that they will.
In reality, we need a vehicle for delivering standards. We believe that managed clinical networks—or, even better, managed care networks, as in Forth valley—are the way in which to do that and I will be very active in promoting them. They must have a quality assurance framework that is endorsed by NHS Quality Improvement Scotland. That is the way in which to proceed towards national standards.
Tricia Marwick referred to a report that was published in 2000. She should also have mentioned the progress that has been made since then, which the Multiple Sclerosis Society has acknowledged. For example, nine extra specialist MS nurses have been appointed in Scotland since the 2000 report was published, including the clinical lead in Forth valley. I am very pleased that that post is held by a nurse specialist.
In reality, we need a vehicle for delivering standards. We believe that managed clinical networks—or, even better, managed care networks, as in Forth valley—are the way in which to do that and I will be very active in promoting them. They must have a quality assurance framework that is endorsed by NHS Quality Improvement Scotland. That is the way in which to proceed towards national standards.
Tricia Marwick referred to a report that was published in 2000. She should also have mentioned the progress that has been made since then, which the Multiple Sclerosis Society has acknowledged. For example, nine extra specialist MS nurses have been appointed in Scotland since the 2000 report was published, including the clinical lead in Forth valley. I am very pleased that that post is held by a nurse specialist.
In a letter that Malcolm Chisholm wrote to the Multiple Sclerosis Society under the auspices of our previous First Minister, he said:
"MS specialist nurses have enormous potential to improve patients' quality of life."
He also said:
"They are probably the quickest way to bring a demonstrable improvement for individual patients."
Given that only nine of the 15 health boards have an MS nurse in place—and many of them must cater for more than 1,000 patients each—what positive action will the Scottish Executive take to improve access to that nursing facility throughout Scotland?
"MS specialist nurses have enormous potential to improve patients' quality of life."
He also said:
"They are probably the quickest way to bring a demonstrable improvement for individual patients."
Given that only nine of the 15 health boards have an MS nurse in place—and many of them must cater for more than 1,000 patients each—what positive action will the Scottish Executive take to improve access to that nursing facility throughout Scotland?
I accept fully that there is much more to do. Equally, we must acknowledge the progress that has been made. I undertake to raise the issue with those boards that do not yet have a specialist MS nurse. However, we must acknowledge the progress that has been made—and not just in the appointment of nurse specialists. Since 1997, the number of neurologists has increased by 40 per cent. The MS Society has acknowledged that as an important reason why services have improved, although there is a long way to go.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Nov 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 20 November 2003 Debate · 1
- Poverty in Scotland Debate · 104
- World Peace Debate · 48
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet Sub-committee on Sustainable Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Further Education (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Fluoridation First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Conference of European Regions with Legislative Power First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Dental Services Statement · 51
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Voting Systems Questions · 6
- Multiple Sclerosis Questions · 6
- Dungavel Questions · 4
- Affordable Homes Questions · 8
- Hospitals (Vending Machines) Questions · 4
- Social Housing Questions · 6
- Fuel Poverty Questions · 6
- Scottish Water Questions · 8
- Speed Restrictions (Kinbrace Primary School) Questions · 4
- Wind Energy Questions · 4
- Compulsory Entitlement Cards Questions · 6
- Textile Industry Questions · 6
- Street Prostitution Questions · 4
- Zero-waste Strategy Questions · 6
- Fuel Poverty Debate · 58
- Planning and Compulsory Purchase Bill Bill debate · 17
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Presiding Officer's Ruling Procedure · 1
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 7
- Decision Time Decision time · 80
- Maternity Services (Glasgow) Members’ business · 49
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.