To ask the Scottish Executive what provision it will make for out-of-hours general practitioner services in rural areas following the introduction of the new GP contracts. (S2O-442)
Official Report · Chamber
General Practitioner Services
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 4
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 2
- David Davidson Con 1
- Chris Ballance Green 1
The record
8 contributionsUnder the terms of the new United Kingdom general medical services contract, by 31 December 2004, the vast majority of GP practices will be able to apply to have responsibility for providing out-of-hours services transferred to their local NHS board. The boards will be required to have in place alternative arrangements that will need to meet mandatory accredited standards.
Planning for the new out-of-hours arrangements is under way. As part of the implementation process, a national working group has been set up to look at the issues around out-of-hours services across Scotland, in both rural and urban settings.
Planning for the new out-of-hours arrangements is under way. As part of the implementation process, a national working group has been set up to look at the issues around out-of-hours services across Scotland, in both rural and urban settings.
The minister will be aware that the funding formula does not contain a specific allocation for the extra costs of out-of-hours services in rural areas, which can be substantially higher than in urban areas. In Dumfries and Galloway and other rural areas, NHS boards are concerned that they will not be able to source GPs to provide out-of-hours services and that, even if they can source them, they will not be able to afford the service. If the minister receives requests for extra funding from Dumfries and Galloway NHS Board or any other health board that covers a rural area, will he undertake to consider such requests sympathetically?
The reality is that, on the back of the new contract, there is a 33 per cent increase in the resources that go into primary care. There is also a minimum practice income guarantee so GP practices in rural areas—like GP practices elsewhere—should be better off than they are now.
Financial arrangements are also in place for the funding of out-of-hours services. We are beginning to see new innovative models of care. For example, when I was in Moray during the summer I saw new arrangements that are already being developed and which involve a new role for paramedics. A lot of work is going on.
One of the key points about the new contract is that the money follows the patient. That principle will apply to the out-of-hours services as it does to everything else.
Financial arrangements are also in place for the funding of out-of-hours services. We are beginning to see new innovative models of care. For example, when I was in Moray during the summer I saw new arrangements that are already being developed and which involve a new role for paramedics. A lot of work is going on.
One of the key points about the new contract is that the money follows the patient. That principle will apply to the out-of-hours services as it does to everything else.
I thank the minister for the response that he gave to Alasdair Morgan, which went some way towards solving the financial problems. My concern is over where the medically qualified people that the health boards will be able to call upon will come from, as that will be a problem in some instances. What about remote and rural practices that are quite a distance away from the usual paramedic services? Where will they get the cover from? If they overextend their hours, they will suffer themselves and will be unable to provide a full-scale service.
It is accepted as part of the contract that in a small minority of cases in the most remote areas it may not be possible for GPs to opt out. I stress that that applies only to a small minority of cases. In the vast majority of cases GPs will be able to opt out if they want to do so, although David Davidson will have heard representatives from the British Medical Association state at the Health Committee that although many GPs might opt out of responsibility for out-of-hours services, they would still wish to provide those services.
One of the other great advantages of the new contract is that it is a practice-based contract. If practices want to employ more GPs and more practice nurses, they can do so. I am sure that David Davidson welcomes last year's unprecedented increase—of about 90—in the number of practice nurses in Scotland. For all the complaining that some people have been doing about the number of people undertaking GP training, there has been an 18 per cent increase in GP registrars since 1997. As David Davidson will know, I assured members at the Health Committee last week that, contrary to what had been reported in some newspapers, the increase that was put in last year would be maintained this year.
One of the other great advantages of the new contract is that it is a practice-based contract. If practices want to employ more GPs and more practice nurses, they can do so. I am sure that David Davidson welcomes last year's unprecedented increase—of about 90—in the number of practice nurses in Scotland. For all the complaining that some people have been doing about the number of people undertaking GP training, there has been an 18 per cent increase in GP registrars since 1997. As David Davidson will know, I assured members at the Health Committee last week that, contrary to what had been reported in some newspapers, the increase that was put in last year would be maintained this year.
Can the minister give a guarantee that, after the new contract has come in, support for the 69 inducement practices throughout Scotland will be continued at existing levels at least? If so, can he say when the doctors involved will be informed of that?
Some details are still to be finalised, but the inducement practices will also be subject to the minimum practice income guarantee, so none of the GPs in those practices will be worse off. They will have the opportunity of being a lot better off if they take on, for example, enhanced services. They will also not have the clawback that sometimes takes place under the current arrangements. Those practitioners can certainly be reassured by that.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Sep 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 18 September 2003 Debate · 1
- Improving Scotland's Health Debate · 90
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Cannabis First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Care Homes First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Lothian and Borders Police (Funding) Questions · 8
- General Practitioner Services Questions · 8
- Scallop Fishing Questions · 8
- Bail Questions · 8
- Cohabitee Rights Questions · 4
- European Structural Funds Questions · 10
- VisitScotland Questions · 6
- MTV Awards Questions · 4
- Scottish Agricultural College Questions · 6
- Central Heating Installation Programme Questions · 4
- Marine Fish Farming Questions · 5
- Glasgow Housing Association Questions · 4
- Community Recycling Groups Questions · 4
- Healthier Lifestyles Questions · 4
- Improving Scotland's Health Debate · 56
- Terrestrial Trunked Radio Masts Members’ business · 33
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.