Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Subordinate Legislation

Food Protection (Emergency Prohibitions) (Amnesic Shellfish Poisoning) (Orkney) (Scotland) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/260)

Thursday 19 June 2003 Meeting of the Parliament Debate 8 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Motion moved,

That the Parliament agrees that the Food Protection (Emergency Prohibitions) (Amnesic Shellfish Poisoning) (Orkney) (Scotland) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/260) be approved.—[Tavish Scott.]

David Davidson Con North East Scotland
link
In speaking against the motion, I am being consistent with my party's stance on the matter. Two years ago at least, my colleague Jamie McGrigor spoke eloquently in the chamber about a move to an alternative means of testing scallops. Ted Brocklebank, who is another colleague, talked eloquently recently in the Hub about the over-regulation move that the motion proposes. Yesterday, I opposed a similar motion at a Health Committee meeting.

There has never been a case of amnesic shellfish poisoning in Scotland or anywhere in the European Union. That is a matter of fact. The only known death from such poisoning in recent years was that of an unfortunate Canadian, from Labrador, in the late 1990s. However, he did not contract the disease from scallops, but from mussels, and three other Canadians who suffered during the same outbreak made complete recoveries.

The west coast scallop industry is worth £10 million a year. I am uncertain about the value to the local scallop industry of the scallops in the Orkney box to which the Scottish statutory instrument that we are debating refers. Instead of preventing the catching of scallops, why can we not move to the alternative procedure of testing scallops after they are caught? That procedure works well in Ireland and it is legal under European regulations.

That is, after all, a move from Europe to tell us how we should behave in this country. Why should a vital and lucrative Scottish industry be wiped out because of indiscriminate closures of this kind, while other, far more serious, risks to health are ignored? Those are posed either from poorly prepared food or cheap, unlabelled foreign imports.

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link
Would the member agree that even one incident of poisoning in Scotland has the potential to ruin forever this very important industry?

David Davidson Con North East Scotland
link
My point is that an alternative method may be used, which would ensure consumer safety and allow consumer choice. More important, it actually works. The proof of that is in Ireland, and the method has been approved by the European Union. I oppose the motion.

Tom McCabe Lab The Deputy Minister for Health and Community Care · Hamilton South
link
We will hopefully not take up too much time on this. Mr Davidson claims that he is being consistent. He is being consistent—in the irresponsibility in both his and his party's approach to this issue. He is well aware—and this has been explained to him in the past—that work is being carried out with the industry to develop a tiered scheme, which has the potential to offer considerable relief to the industry.

Mr Davidson's comparison with Ireland is completely disingenuous. Our industry is significantly larger than the industry in Ireland, and the percentage of the product that we put to market is considerably larger than is the case in Ireland.

I have previously explained—both in the chamber and in committee—that this is both a public health and a consumer safety issue. We are also protecting the good name of the Scottish industry. It would be disastrous if, through our laxity, we had a serious outbreak of poisoning.

Tom McCabe Lab The Deputy Minister for Health and Community Care · Hamilton South
link
No, not in this kind of debate. Above all, we are complying with our legal obligations under the relevant European directive. People in this country, and in the United Kingdom in general, realised long ago that the Conservatives stand for nothing. It is now clear that they do not even stand for the upholding of the rule of law. More importantly in this instance, they do not stand for the protection of a world-class industry.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 19 June 2003 Debate · 1
  2. Water Industry Debate · 134
  3. Care Homes for the Elderly Debate · 66
  4. Business Motion Business motions · 5
  5. Holyrood Project Statement · 30
  6. Minister for Justice (Visits to Stirling) Questions · 6
  7. Deprived Communities (Cultural Activity) Questions · 4
  8. Less Favoured Areas Support Scheme Questions · 6
  9. National Health Service (Prescription Charges) Questions · 10
  10. Minority Sports Questions · 6
  11. National Health Service (Prescription Charges) Questions · 6
  12. Prison Conditions Questions · 8
  13. Transport Budget Questions · 10
  14. Hepatitis C (Financial Assistance) Questions · 4
  15. High Court (Time Limit for Commencement of Cases) Questions · 6
  16. Fostering (Remuneration) Questions · 6
  17. Landfill Sites (Road Transportation of Waste) Questions · 4
  18. Kerbside Recycling Questions · 5
  19. Solutions RMC Questions · 5
  20. Angus Council (Road Improvement Projects) Questions · 6
  21. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  22. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  23. Sustainable Future First Minister’s Questions · 4
  24. Cabinet Reshuffle (Constitutional Changes) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  25. West Coast Main Line Railway First Minister’s Questions · 4
  26. Police Numbers First Minister’s Questions · 7
  27. Subordinate Legislation Debate · 47
  28. Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill Bill debate · 34
  29. Subordinate Legislation Debate · 1
  30. Subordinate Legislation Debate · 6
  31. Subordinate Legislation Debate · 8
  32. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  33. Motion without Notice Business motions · 4
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 55
  35. Airport Investment (Glasgow and Edinburgh) Members’ business · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.