In speaking against the motion, I am being consistent with my party's stance on the matter. Two years ago at least, my colleague Jamie McGrigor spoke eloquently in the chamber about a move to an alternative means of testing scallops. Ted Brocklebank, who is another colleague, talked eloquently recently in the Hub about the over-regulation move that the motion proposes. Yesterday, I opposed a similar motion at a Health Committee meeting.
There has never been a case of amnesic shellfish poisoning in Scotland or anywhere in the European Union. That is a matter of fact. The only known death from such poisoning in recent years was that of an unfortunate Canadian, from Labrador, in the late 1990s. However, he did not contract the disease from scallops, but from mussels, and three other Canadians who suffered during the same outbreak made complete recoveries.
The west coast scallop industry is worth £10 million a year. I am uncertain about the value to the local scallop industry of the scallops in the Orkney box to which the Scottish statutory instrument that we are debating refers. Instead of preventing the catching of scallops, why can we not move to the alternative procedure of testing scallops after they are caught? That procedure works well in Ireland and it is legal under European regulations.
That is, after all, a move from Europe to tell us how we should behave in this country. Why should a vital and lucrative Scottish industry be wiped out because of indiscriminate closures of this kind, while other, far more serious, risks to health are ignored? Those are posed either from poorly prepared food or cheap, unlabelled foreign imports.
There has never been a case of amnesic shellfish poisoning in Scotland or anywhere in the European Union. That is a matter of fact. The only known death from such poisoning in recent years was that of an unfortunate Canadian, from Labrador, in the late 1990s. However, he did not contract the disease from scallops, but from mussels, and three other Canadians who suffered during the same outbreak made complete recoveries.
The west coast scallop industry is worth £10 million a year. I am uncertain about the value to the local scallop industry of the scallops in the Orkney box to which the Scottish statutory instrument that we are debating refers. Instead of preventing the catching of scallops, why can we not move to the alternative procedure of testing scallops after they are caught? That procedure works well in Ireland and it is legal under European regulations.
That is, after all, a move from Europe to tell us how we should behave in this country. Why should a vital and lucrative Scottish industry be wiped out because of indiscriminate closures of this kind, while other, far more serious, risks to health are ignored? Those are posed either from poorly prepared food or cheap, unlabelled foreign imports.